U.S. Supreme Court Considers Warrantless Blood Draws for DWI Arrests

The U.S. Supreme Court is considering whether the Constitution requires police to obtain warrants prior to drawing a DWI suspect's blood.

2013-01-23

January 23, 2013 (Press-News.org) On January 9, 2012 the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Missouri v. McNeely, a case addressing the issue of the constitutionality of police obtaining blood samples from those arrested for suspicion of driving while intoxicated and are refusing chemical testing when police have not gotten warrants to draw blood. Drivers in New York should be aware of the facts of the case before the Court, as well as the arguments each side advanced.

DWI arrest

The case stems from an arrest of a Missouri man police say was swerving and travelling 11 m.p.h. over the speed limit at 2 a.m. Police suspected the man was intoxicated and administered field sobriety tests, which the driver failed. Police arrested the driver and he refused to allow police to administer a Breathalyzer test or draw his blood to test his blood alcohol concentration. Police took the driver to the local hospital and ordered a phlebotomist to draw the man's blood while he was handcuffed.

The driver was later convicted of DWI charges, but appealed arguing that police should have gotten a warrant before drawing his blood because drawing blood constitutes a search for the purposes of the Fourth Amendment. The Missouri Supreme Court threw out the blood test, reasoning that there was nothing that would have prevented the police officer from obtaining a warrant rapidly. The Court noted that the officer himself had admitted that he has easily gotten warrants in similar situations in the past.

Warrants required for blood draws?

Missouri appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, urging the Court to issue a new exception to the warrant requirement saying that police never need warrants for blood draws in DWI cases because of the nature of the evidence they are trying to gather -- alcohol dissipates quickly, and the accuracy of the test may be compromised if police spend time getting a warrant.

The driver argued that there is no need to create a blanket exception to the protections of the Fourth Amendment preventing unreasonable searches and seizures. In many cases, police have no trouble obtaining such warrants and getting a warrant causes only a short delay. Police can now apply for warrants with cell phones and laptop computers from their cars.

Furthermore, 25 states already require warrants for blood draws, barring exigent circumstances -- showing the prevalence of the idea that the state sticking a needle in a person's arm is precisely the type of situation to which the Fourth Amendment applies.

Talk to a lawyer

DWI charges are serious matters, and convictions on such charges can carry severe penalties. If you have been charged with an alcohol-related driving offense, speak with an experienced DWI defense attorney who can help ensure your rights are protected.

Article provided by Larkin, Axelrod, Ingrassia & Tetenbaum, LLP
Visit us at www.law5141.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Massachusetts Motorists Need to Stay Off Their Cellphones While Driving

2013-01-23

Many drivers sadly continue to make the mistake of concentrating too much on their cellphones instead of keeping their eyes on the road - which is a mistake that can have deadly consequences. Here in Massachusetts, and throughout the country, lawmakers and police are doing their best to curb this epidemic, but tragically distracted driving and texting-while-driving accidents continue to occur. Fatal consequences of distracted driving According to statistics reported by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), there were 3092 deaths and 416,000 ...

Checklists and Communication Trainings: Improving Postoperative Care

2013-01-23

Patients put their lives in the hands of medical professionals. With this in mind, it is important for health care providers to exercise due care in the execution of medical tasks and procedures. For example, to ensure safe and rapid recoveries, medical personnel should practice postoperative care in accordance with current medical standards. This can help reduce the chance of health risks and complications. In the effort to discover techniques that help make medical procedures safer, scholars explore various methods of practice. For instance, a new study performed by ...

Domestic Violence Charges in Michigan: What You Need to Know

2013-01-23

Domestic violence is a crime under Michigan law. Yet, every family has the occasional spat, and it can be challenging for police to determine when a heated disagreement has crossed the line. If you've been accused of domestic violence, you're likely awash with questions. A domestic violence defense attorney is the best resource to answer your questions and help fight charges, but even a brief overview of Michigan domestic violence law can be beneficial. Anatomy of a domestic violence charge Domestic violence is defined by Michigan law as abusive behavior used by ...

Drunk Drivers on New Jersey Roads Cause Havoc, Injuries

2013-01-23

Even with the state's tough DUI/DWI laws serving as a deterrent, there are still people who drive on New Jersey's roads while intoxicated. Unfortunately, when drunk drivers hit the highways, injury-causing crashes often result. Recent multi-car accidents on I-80 caused by drunk drivers have shined a spotlight on the problem, putting the issue "front and center" for discussion. Is the state doing enough? New Jersey - like most other states - considers someone to be driving while impaired or intoxicated by the effects of alcohol if he or she has a blood alcohol ...

Study Reveals Over 4,000 Preventable Surgical Errors Occur in US Annually

2013-01-23

It can be a surgical patient's worst nightmare -- upon awakening in an anesthetized haze, he or she slowly realizes the wrong operation was performed or the operation was performed on the wrong side of the body. Under such circumstances, depending on the overall health of the patient and other factors, the surgical error can lead to additional, otherwise unnecessary surgeries. In the most severe cases, patients have died as a result of such preventable surgical errors. While most of us assume that such incidents are incredibly rare and therefore not a cause for concern, ...

NLRB Weighs in on Facebook Posts and Employee Discrimination

2013-01-23

Many laws, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964, have been passed throughout the years to protect workers against discrimination or retaliation on the basis of race, religion, sex, age, religion or political affiliation, among many others. As technology expands into our 21st century, doors have opened for new ways for employers, in particular, to discrimination against employees. Facebook is one such example. The most popular social media site known as Facebook is everywhere; in America and all across the globe and is likely here to stay. Facebook, Twitter and various ...

Wisconsin Police Agencies Wrapping Up Another Season of Extended Holiday Patrols

2013-01-23

The time between Labor Day and New Year's Day is a busy one for Wisconsin police agencies. The extended holiday season brings joy, merriment, festive gatherings and holiday "cheer" in the form of alcoholic beverages, so law enforcement agencies around the state regularly increase OWI/DWI/DUI patrols in an effort to keep drunk drivers off the street. A dubious distinction According to data compiled by the U.S. Department of Transportation, Wisconsin has the highest rate of drinking and driving in the nation, something which has led state lawmakers to propose ...

Attend the 2013 Atlanta Camping & RV Show and Stay at Nearby Hampton Inn & Suites Atlanta Airport Hotel

2013-01-23

The Hampton Inn & Suites Atlanta Airport Hotel (North, I-85) offers nearby lodging to guests attending the 2013 Atlanta Camping and RV Show. The event will take place at Atlanta Exposition Center South from January 25-27, 2013 and is the largest RV show in Georgia. The show will include: - Fun and informative seminars - Millions of dollars of RVs on sale - Model RVs available to tour including Motor Homes, Fifth Wheels, and Travel Trailers This event is produced by the Metro Atlanta Recreational Vehicle Dealers Association. For admission details and hours visit ...

Attend the 2013 Super Region One Wrestling Duals at Newberry College and Stay at Nearby Holiday Inn Express & Suites Newberry SC Hotel

2013-01-23

The Holiday Inn Express & Suites Newberry SC Hotel offers convenient lodging to students, parents, and guests attending the 2013 Super Region One Wrestling Duals, presented by Sonic Drive-In of Newberry. The event will be held in Newberry's Eleazer Arena and historic MacLean Gymnasium on Friday, January 25, and Saturday, January 26, 2013. For details, visit newberrywolves.com. Joining Newberry in the event are Super Region I teams Anderson University, Belmont Abbey (N.C.) College, East Stroudsburg (Pa.) University, Kutztown (Pa.) University, Limestone College, Mercyhurst ...

Comfort Inn North Atlanta Hotel Provides Affordable Lodging to Guests Attending The Great American Motorcycle Show at North Atlanta Trade Center

2013-01-23

The Comfort Inn & Conference Center Northeast, a leading hotel in north Atlanta, offers nearby affordable accommodations to guests attending The Great American Motorcycle Show at the North Atlanta Trade Center. The show takes place January 25-27, 2013. With over 100,000 square feet of vendor space, The Great American Motorcycle Show is Georgia's largest and only indoor motorcycle show. It's a great place to purchase a new motorcycle and all kinds of accessories. Show hours are 3-8pm Friday, 9am-8pm Saturday, and 10am-5pm Sunday. Single and multi day passes are available. ...