Supreme Court to Issue Decision in DUI Case

The United States Supreme Court recently heard arguments in a case that may have serious implications for drivers' Fourth Amendment rights.

2013-02-07

February 07, 2013 (Press-News.org) Supreme Court to Issue Decision in DUI Case

Article provided by Bird & Van Dyke, Inc. - A Professional Law Corporation Visit us at http://www.centralvalleycriminallaw.com

The United States Supreme Court recently heard arguments in a case that may have serious implications for drivers' Fourth Amendment rights. The specific issue in contention in Missouri v. McNeely is whether law enforcement can order a blood alcohol test without first obtaining a warrant.

The Facts ofMcNeely

On October 3, 2010, a Missouri highway patrolman stopped Tyler McNeely for speeding in Cape Girardeau, Missouri. In the course of the stop, the officer developed the suspicion that McNeely had been drinking and he requested that he perform a series of standard field sobriety tests, all of which McNeely failed. After McNeely refused the officer's repeated requests to submit to a Breathalyzer test, he was transported to a local hospital, where the officer asked whether he would submit to a blood test. Once again, McNeely refused. The officer then ordered staff to take McNeely's blood without his consent, even though the officer had not obtained a warrant for the test. The test indicated that McNeely's blood alcohol concentration (BAC) was .154, nearly twice the .08 legal limit. McNeely was charged with driving under the influence (DUI).

Before trial, McNeely's attorney argued that the blood test results should be excluded from evidence because the sample was taken without his client's consent and without a warrant. Although the trial court agreed, the objection was overturned on appeal. The Missouri supreme court unanimously upheld the trial court and ruled that the blood evidence was inadmissible at trial without a warrant. The state of Missouri then brought the issue to the Supreme Court.

Although the Fourth Amendment generally requires police to obtain a warrant before a search, there are, of course, many exceptions to the rule. In its initial ruling, the Missouri appeals court relied on the Supreme Court's 1966 decision in Schmerber v. California, which upheld the admissibility of a blood sample without consent and without a warrant. In Schmerber, the Court ruled that a warrant was not always necessary to administer a BAC test because alcohol in the blood stream diminishes over time. If police are unable to collect a sample immediately after an accident, there is a chance that the evidence may be destroyed as the suspect's body metabolizes the alcohol in his bloodstream.

The Supreme Court recently heard oral arguments in the McNeely case and is expected to release its decision later this year.

A Criminal Defense Attorney Can Help

If you or someone you love is facing charges for driving under the influence or any other offense, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney. A knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer can assess your case, counsel you on the possible effects of a conviction or plea agreement, and help you protect your rights. For more information about what a criminal defense attorney can do for you, contact a lawyer today.

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Tennessee can compel blood sampling for DUI suspects

2013-02-07

Tennessee can compel blood sampling for DUI suspects Article provided by Law Office of Edward E. DeWerff Visit us at http://www.dewerfflaw.com Tennessee has implemented a new law governing blood sampling from people suspected of drunk driving. Under the previous implied consent law, drivers stopped by a law enforcement officer could refuse to give a blood sample for a blood alcohol contest test, but could lose their driver's licenses as a result of the refusal. Tennessee's "No Refusal" law takes effect The current law, known as a "no refusal" ...

Debt settlement companies promise big, deliver little

2013-02-07

Debt settlement companies promise big, deliver little Article provided by Marlatt Law Office Visit us at http://www.marlattbankruptcylaw.com With a full recovery from the recession still elusive, many Americans find themselves behind on their bills. It is no coincidence that debt settlement companies have recent sprung up, almost overnight it seems. Such companies claim to help people with their financial problems, but in reality operate in an unregulated environment, putting them in a prime position to take advantage of people. You may have seen the commercials ...

NJ and federal law may not sufficiently protect working pregnant women

2013-02-07

NJ and federal law may not sufficiently protect working pregnant women Article provided by Piro, Zinna, Cifelli, Paris & Genitempo, P.C. Visit us at http://www.pirozinnalaw.com Over the past 50 years, the composition of the American workforce has changed dramatically. As the years have gone by, an increasing number of women have joined the labor force. Despite the length of time that has passed since women began working in larger numbers, many feel laws protecting women in the workforce have not kept pace. While some safeguards exist at the federal and state ...

Organizations use of non-compete agreements are on the rise

2013-02-07

Organizations use of non-compete agreements are on the rise Article provided by The Roberts Law Firm, P.C. Visit us at http://www.mobusinesslawyers.com A non-compete agreement is often drafted by organizations in an effort to protect their business interests. Non-compete agreements prohibit employees from starting a competing business, or working for a competitor, within a certain period of time after their employment has ended. But in order to be valid, the agreement must also be fair. Timing is everything An employer cannot keep a former employee from pursuing ...

Study: Workers' compensation does not cover majority cost of injuries

2013-02-07

Study: Workers' compensation does not cover majority cost of injuries The workers' compensation system in California, like all workers' compensation systems, is designed to ensure that employees who suffer injury on the job or suffer a work-related illness receive fixed compensation without having to sue their employer for the injury. In this sense, filing a workers' compensation claim is similar to filing an insurance claim and is considered a substitute for a lawsuit against an employer. The benefits a worker receives comes from a state workers' compensation fund. ...

Worker's Compensation wage loss benefits

2013-02-07

Worker's Compensation wage loss benefits Article provided by Vellner Law Visit us at http://www.vellnerlaw.com Most Pennsylvania workers who become injured or ill on the job are fortunately covered under the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act. The Act requires every employer to have worker's compensation insurance for every employee, even those who work only part-time or seasonally. Even when an employer fails to have worker's compensation insurance, an injured Pennsylvania worker might still be able to obtain benefits through the Uninsured Employer Guaranty ...

Suntell Japan Commence Installation Project of Solar Panels

2013-02-07

Suntell Japan has announced that it will commence the installation of a photovoltaic system on the roof of the headquarters as a benchmark in efficient utilization of solar energy for a corporate structure. "We are committed to leading by example when we discuss the advantages of using solar power as a viable means of energy supply when engaging with our clients and associates" announced Yoshihiko Wakadu the Chairman of the Board at SunTell Japan. "In order to remain a company that differentiates itself from a reseller, and to ensure that our target ...

Halfpricesoft.com Has Made W-2 1099 Reporting Easy For Users For Almost a Decade

2013-02-07

Service companies that need to file both W2 and 1099 return can save time and money this 2013 tax season. Halfpriceosft.com, the payroll tax software provider, has updates ezW2 software with new forms for 2013 tax season. The new edition can print both W2 and 1099 forms which is ideal for service firms that usually hire both employees and contractors. EzW2 2012 can fill and print tax forms W-2, W-3, 1099-misc and 1096. Users who want to save time and money on tax forms can try the blank paper printing feature. EzW2 software is approved by SSA to print black and white ...

Never Mind the Weather, Tourists Prize Friendly Scottish Welcome

2013-02-07

Travellers taking a holiday in Scotland prize our famous friendly Scottish welcome above anything else, according to research. A survey carried out by bookings website Private House Stays (www.privatehousestays.com) revealed an overwhelming 85% of people planning to visit Scotland consider a warm reception key to their overall holiday experience. Travellers also want their hosts to offer local knowledge, and to feel they are discovering Scotland away from the tourist traps. By contrast, unfriendly or unhelpful service was revealed to be the biggest holiday downer, ...

Supertramp's Roger Hodgson "Gives a Little Bit" at Super Bowl Before Kicking Off 2013 World Tour

2013-02-07

In the wake of Super Bowl XLVII, some will remember which commercials were the best as much as the game itself. With this year's ads prompting emotions ranging from laughter to tears, prime among them was a 30-second spot for Coca-Cola utilizing the song "Give a Little Bit" as its soundtrack - a song written and composed by Roger Hodgson and originally released in 1977 by Supertramp, the iconic rock band he co-founded. This new recording is Hodgson's latest version of his classic hit, which is now available on iTunes. His latest release Classics Live can be found ...