March 06, 2013 (Press-News.org) Recently, the Colorado Supreme Court reversed a centuries-old rule governing the use of confessions as evidence in criminal cases. The standard for admitting confessions as evidence in such cases has been the corpus delicti rule.
"Corpus delicti" literally translates to the "body of the crime." In other words, the rule requires the admission of evidence -- besides the confession -- to prove that a crime actually occurred. The confession alone is not sufficient to show a crime was committed.
In overturning the rule, the Colorado Supreme Court elaborated on the possible reasons that the rule was originally adopted. For instance, the high court explained that the rule protected people from being convicted of crimes they imagined, but did not actually commit -- an important safeguard for the accused who suffer from mental illness. In addition, the corpus delicti rule was meant to prevent dependence on confessions alone, to avoid issues with coerced confessions given under pressure from law enforcement officials.
People v. LaRosa
The case before the Colorado Supreme Court arose when a man called a Douglas County emergency operator to report that he had initiated improper sexual contact with his young daughter. The man confessed his actions to the emergency operator, and had previously given similar confessions to members of his family and a pastor.
Due to the confessions, the man was charged with aggravated incest and sexual assault on a child. Prior to the trial, he argued that the charges should be dropped, as no evidence of the crime -- apart from his confessions -- existed. The trial court disagreed and the man was convicted on all charges.
Subsequently, the court of appeals reversed his conviction, relying on the corpus delicti rule.
Colorado Supreme Court imposes trustworthiness standard
In the majority decision, the Colorado Supreme Court abandoned the corpus delicti rule in favor of the trustworthiness standard. The trustworthiness standard was established by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1954. The U.S. Supreme Court explained the standard required the prosecution to "introduce substantial independent evidence which would tend to establish the trustworthiness of the statement." In other words, the prosecution had to prove that the confession was trustworthy.
The Colorado Supreme Court explained that corroborating evidence showing the trustworthiness of the confession can be obtained from a variety of sources, including:
- Facts corroborating those admitted in the confession
- Facts establishing the crime that corroborate facts in the confession
- Facts "under which the confession was made" that show it was "trustworthy or reliable"
The high court did not apply its decision retroactively, though, which means the individual in the case was acquitted of all charges.
If you are facing criminal charges, it is best to consult with a skilled, Colorado defense attorney to ensure a strong defense is established on your behalf.
Article provided by Anaya, Foley & McKedy, P.C.
Visit us at www.davidfoley.net
Colorado Supreme Court abandons corpus delicti rule
Colorado has changed its standard for when confessions can be used to convict.
2013-03-06
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Tampa sinkhole causes water scare at local university
2013-03-06
Given the frequency of sinkholes in the Sunshine State, many Florida residents are well aware of the damage these craters can cause - everything from ruined landscaping to entire homes being swallowed up. However, a recent sinkhole scare at a local Tampa university demonstrated yet another potential hazard that may be linked to Florida sinkholes; namely, possible water contamination.
USF boil water order
According to the University of South Florida's (USF) newspaper - The Oracle - a boil water notice was recently issued after university officials received several ...
Distracted driving is primary cause of Missouri auto accidents
2013-03-06
Despite a nationwide focus on decreasing the number of accidents caused by distracted drivers -- including public awareness campaigns with slogans such as "Stop the Texts, Stop the Wrecks," -- statistics show the frequency of distracted driving collisions is on the rise. According to a Missouri State Highway Patrol sergeant, distracted drivers are now the primary cause of motor vehicle accidents in the state.
In 2011, the Missouri State Highway Patrol reported that distracted driving accidents led to 153 fatalities and approximately 10,000 personal injuries. ...
Breast cancer misdiagnoses often lead to malpractice suits
2013-03-06
As new reports have revealed that a rising number of younger women are being diagnosed with breast cancer, the role of radiologists in ensuring the health of women in Ohio and across the country is as important as ever.
According to a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, the number of women under 40 with breast cancer has increased by approximately 2 percent every year since the 1970s. In 2009, 2.9 out of every 100,000 women in the U.S. between the ages of 25 to 39 were diagnosed with advanced stages of breast cancer.
This study was ...
Increasing use of DNA evidence both convicts and exonerates in Texas
2013-03-06
One of the more recent technological advancements in the criminal justice world is DNA analysis. More and more frequently, especially in Texas, DNA evidence gathered from a crime scene is used to identify someone who may have been present. It is also used to exclude someone from consideration as a suspect or to save him or her from a wrongful conviction.
DNA evidence in criminal cases
DNA stands for deoxyribonucleic acid, and DNA is present in almost every cell of the human body. An individual's DNA is the same in many types of cells, such as saliva, blood, skin tissue, ...
When Can a Bill Collector Call You?
2013-03-06
For most people, it's not convenient to get a call from a debt collector. That's why federal law places restrictions on when a collections agent may contact a debtor regarding a call, prohibits debt collector harassment, and regulates other aspects of the debt collection industry.
The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act
The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) is the primary piece of legislation that regulates debt collection in the U.S. The FDCPA is Title VIII of the Consumer Credit Protection Act, which was added in 1978.
The FDCPA has the following objectives:
- ...
How Safe Are New York Pedestrians?
2013-03-06
According to an end-of-year report from the New York City Police Department, 1,306 pedestrians were hurt or killed in motor vehicle crashes in 2012, with 16 deaths. It turns out that this is actually positive news for the city.
According to a January 2013 Department of Transportation report, the number of pedestrian fatalities and serious injuries was down significantly since 2001 - by 28 percent. And the reduction becomes more significant if one looks at earlier numbers.
For example, the worst years for pedestrian fatalities were between 1920 and 1940. In the decade ...
Use of Social Media in Pennsylvania Car Accident Cases
2013-03-06
Social media has become a central part of our lives. It is much more than a way to connect with friends or potential jobs. Twitter "tweets" now make appearances on newscasts and Facebook "likes" sprinkle across the Web. It shouldn't be a surprise, then, that Facebook, Twitter, Google+ and other social media outlets are also showing up in the courtroom.
Take, for example, a young adult who admitted to drunk driving in a Facebook post by saying: "Drivin drunk.... Classic. ;-) but to whoever's vehicle I hit, I am sorry :P" (published in the ...
Knoxville Bankruptcy Lawyers, Clark & Washington, Address Zsa Zsa Gabor's Bankruptcy Case
2013-03-06
The Knoxville bankruptcy professionals at Clark & Washington recognize that even the rich and fabulous can fall from grace at one point or another. Zsa Zsa Gabor, a famous socialite and actress, found the unfortunate truth in this.
War of Words
Even though she was married nine times, divorced seven and had one marriage annulled, it was a libel lawsuit that made the renowned actress declare bankruptcy, not one of her famous divorces. Her prolonged feud with German-born actress, Elke Sommer, which began in 1984, finally spiraled into a very costly libel suit when ...
Playboy TV Crowns 'The Man of Men'
2013-03-06
On February 2, 2013 Michael Ian Vargo won Playboy TV's newest reality show "The Man" Tournament of Champions Finale! A Playboy TV provocative reality dating show: The Man, where self-proclaimed Casanovas who are convinced they are Gods gift to even the most insatiable women, are put to the real test to prove that they, indeed, should be crowned, The Man. The show consist of three rounds: An introduction kiss, stimulating game, and spending alone time in the bedroom with two gorgeous female judges. After the intimate and final round in the bedroom "the close", ...
Adventure Travels Launches River Cruise Division
2013-03-06
Adventure Travels of Pompano Beach announced today the launch of a new River Cruise Division and website; CheapRiverCruises.net to better serve the river cruising market with certified River Cruise Experts and a dedicated website.
"The River Cruise market has matured and needs specialized agents. We have created a separate division, and have trained and certified our most experienced agents in the art of river cruising," said Glenda Clark, Vice President of Sales & Marketing.
River cruises, a new favorite among seasoned travelers, are a great way to ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Slow, silent ‘scream’ of epithelial cells detected for first time
How big brains and flexible skulls led to the evolution of modern birds
Iguanas floated one-fifth of the way around the world to colonize Fiji
‘Audible enclaves’ could enable private listening without headphones
Twisting atomically thin materials could advance quantum computers
Impaired gastric myoelectrical rhythms associated with altered autonomic functions in patients with severe ischemic stroke
American College of Cardiology issues concise clinical guidance on evaluation and management of cardiogenic shock
Psychological prehabilitation improves surgical recovery, study finds
Neighborhood dispute among cells: Whichever successfully exerts force wins
Deadline extended for the fifth edition of the SWIM Award for Science Journalism
Unique dove species is the dodo of the Caribbean and in similar danger of dying out
Free University Brussels (VUB) opens its doors to censored American researchers
Neuroanatomy that sets humans apart from other primates
Stress and sex influence traumatic brain injury outcomes
Study: suppressing key protein may unlock immunotherapy for Glioblastoma
Early surgical intervention in children with sleep-disordered breathing reduces need for doctor visits, prescriptions
Statin use and risk of hepatocellular carcinoma and liver fibrosis in chronic liver disease
Gender-affirming hormone therapy and depressive symptoms among transgender adults
Surgery in kids with mild sleep-disordered breathing tied to fewer doctor visits, meds
Magnetic microalgae on a mission to become robots
Impact journals to participate at the AACR Annual Meeting 2025
Webb telescope captures its first direct images of carbon dioxide outside solar system
NIH-sponsored trial of Lassa vaccine opens
Pro-life people partly motivated to prevent casual sex, study finds
Top locations for ocean energy production worldwide revealed
New AI model analyzes full night of sleep with high accuracy in largest study of its kind
Combination of cosmic processes shapes the size and location of sub-Neptunes
New study shows regular exercise pre-hospitalization is linked to better outcomes in heart failure
New discovery in plant–pest warfare could lead to sustainable farming solutions
Make Indian sign language an official language and open more schools for deaf and hard-of-hearing students, Cambridge study advises Indian government
[Press-News.org] Colorado Supreme Court abandons corpus delicti ruleColorado has changed its standard for when confessions can be used to convict.