Barking up the wrong tree: Florida drug-sniffing dogs given free rein

The U.S. Supreme Court recently overturned a Florida decision. Alerts from drug-sniffing dogs are now considered probable cause for searches in the nation.

2013-03-13

March 13, 2013 (Press-News.org) Barking up the wrong tree: Florida drug-sniffing dogs given free rein

Article provided by The Law Office of Gustavo E. Frances, P.A.
Visit us at http://www.lauderdaledefense.com

The Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures took a big hit recently when the U.S. Supreme Court overturned a decision issued by Florida's highest state court. The U.S. court ruled that any court in the nation can presume that a search is valid if law enforcement officials state it was based on an alert by a drug detection dog.

The underlying case stems from a routine traffic stop in Florida. When the police officer's drug-sniffing dog alerted, the officer searched the vehicle and found ingredients for making methamphetamine, substances a dog would not have been able to detect.

An appeal of the driver's drug conviction went before the Florida Supreme Court that ruled that the dog's alert did not create "probable cause" for the search, an essential element to a lawful search. The U.S. Supreme Court disagreed with the lower court and overturned the ruling.

Concerns raised by the decision

The high court's decision raises a number of criminal defense concerns regarding violations of privacy and regarding proper searches. Based on the decision, drug detection dogs are now, for purposes of establishing a legal reason for a search, treated as expert witnesses without having to provide their success records.

Most states do not have uniform standards for training or certifying drug-sniffing dogs. Nor is there any type of standard procedure verifying that such dogs are continuing to perform accurately. However, police no longer have to demonstrate that a particular drug detection dog is reliable. If a defendant questions the accuracy of a dog, he or she must prove with expert witnesses that the dog's alert was faulty or wrong.

Questioning drug detection dogs

The capabilities of drug-sniffing dogs have long been in dispute. A 2006 study of the usefulness of such dogs concluded that they have proven to be ineffective and unreliable. The researchers further reported that alerts by drug-sniffing dogs led to a high number of public searches during which no drugs were found on those searched.

The U.S. Supreme Court has yet to rule on a case involving another drug-sniffing dog who alerted to marijuana after spending a few minutes sniffing around the front door of a person's home. An adverse ruling in that case can further infringe on the lives of Americans.

Seek legal help

If you have been questioned about or arrested for a crime, seek the help of an experienced criminal defense lawyer to ensure that your rights are protected to the full extent of the law.

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Medical errors can lead to cerebral palsy

2013-03-13

Medical errors can lead to cerebral palsy Article provided by Joseph Chaiken & Associates Visit us at http://www.jchaikenlaw.com According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about 1 out of 303 children in America are born with cerebral palsy. Additionally, according to the United Cerebral Palsy Association, more than 500,000 Americans have the disorder. Although there are many causes, medical errors made before or during birth cause a significant number of cases. What is cerebral palsy? Cerebral palsy is a group of neurological disorders ...

Damage caused by TBI can linger for years

2013-03-13

Damage caused by TBI can linger for years Article provided by The Hirsch Law Firm, PLLC Visit us at http://www.jonhirschlaw.com Traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) are a common problem across the nation. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about 1.7 million Americans suffer a TBI each year. The medical community has long known about the short-term brain damage that TBIs can cause. However, a recent study suggests that the brain injury caused by TBIs can last much longer than previously thought. Researchers at the University of South Florida ...

Proposal may affect Nebraska child custody determinations

2013-03-13

Proposal may affect Nebraska child custody determinations Article provided by Vacanti Shattuck Visit us at http://www.cvhslaw.com In February, a Nebraska lawmaker introduced two bills to the Judicial Committee that could change how courts award child custody. The proposed changes are meant to equalize the amount of time that separated parents spend with their children. In a divorce, child custody is one of the most contentious issues. Often one parent receives a greater share of the time with the child or sole physical custody. This parent's home is usually where ...

Financial pitfalls faced by women post-divorce

2013-03-13

Financial pitfalls faced by women post-divorce Article provided by The Law Office of Thomas V. Sassone, P.C. Visit us at http://www.tvslawpc.com Statistically, women have the harder time financially after a divorce than men. A study conducted by the National Marriage Project at Rutgers University has found that on average, a man will see an approximate 10 percent increase in his standard of living post-divorce, but a woman will experience a 27 percent decrease. Experts attribute the disparity to the possibility that many women are not involved with finances during ...

Iowa Legislature mulls tougher distracted driver law

2013-03-13

Iowa Legislature mulls tougher distracted driver law Article provided by Shanks Law Firm Visit us at http://www.shankslaw.net The dangers that distracted drivers pose to other motorists on our nation's roadways has received a lot of attention in the press lately, and for good reason. After all, common sense tells us that taking our eyes off the road is a dangerous behavior that dramatically increases the risk of a car accident. Unfortunately, Iowa drivers are not immune to such behavior. As a result, the Iowa legislature has proposed toughening its laws against ...

2013 tax changes may spell confusion for small business owners

2013-03-13

2013 tax changes may spell confusion for small business owners Article provided by The Gartzman Law Firm, P.C. Visit us at http://www.gartzmantaxlaw.com After a no small amount of last-minute scrambling to avert the so-called fiscal cliff, Congress recently passed a number of changes to the federal tax code. Some of these changes, both good and bad, could have a significant impact on small business owners. While the potential for increased tax liability under the new plan is a major concern for many small business owners, some say the real challenge will be keeping ...

Tax payment plan vs. tax settlement: What's the difference?

2013-03-13

Tax payment plan vs. tax settlement: What's the difference? Article provided by The Gartzman Law Firm, P.C. Visit us at http://www.gartzmantaxlaw.com Many serious tax problems stem from a simple and relatively common situation: being unable to pay the amount due to the IRS. What many people who find themselves in this situation do not realize, however, is that being unable to afford a tax payment is not necessarily what lands a person in hot water with the IRS. Instead, it is how these individuals choose to deal with the situation -- or not deal with it -- that ...

Personal bankruptcy options: liquidation vs. reorganization

2013-03-13

Personal bankruptcy options: liquidation vs. reorganization Article provided by Purrazzella & Purrazzella, P.A. Visit us at http://www.purrlaw.com When financial difficulties turn from bad to worse and people fear they may never be able to catch up on their overdue bills, many turn to bankruptcy as a way to make a fresh financial start. While most people have heard of bankruptcy, many are unaware of how the process works and how it can benefit people who are struggling with unmanageable debt. What is bankruptcy? Bankruptcy is a legal procedure that helps ...

New technologies lead to new dangers on our nation's highways

2013-03-13

New technologies lead to new dangers on our nation's highways Article provided by Noel M. Ferris Visit us at http://www.noelmferris.net Over the past decade, cell phones have become an essential tool for people in nearly every walk of life. While these devices definitely have their benefits, they are also responsible for the emergence of a significant threat on our nation's highways: distracted driving. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 3,092 people were killed and an additional 419,000 people were injured in motor vehicle accidents ...

Rhode Island divorce: basic family law considerations

2013-03-13

Rhode Island divorce: basic family law considerations Article provided by Law Office of Hoopis & Hoopis Visit us at http://www.hoopisandhoopis.com When a couple plans to divorce in Rhode Island, the parties must address several legal topics that go beyond the relationship, itself. For example, litigants must assess property division, child custody and visitation, child support and other similar issues if they are applicable to the end of the marriage. Jurisdiction The first step in the process concerns jurisdiction. In Rhode Island, divorce proceedings ...