Contact Information:
Findlaw PR

Kredyty mieszkaniowe Kredyty mieszkaniowe

Sprawdź aktualny ranking najlepszych kredytów mieszkaniowych w Polsce - atrakcyjne kredytowanie nieruchomości. - Press Release Distribution
RSS - Press News Release
Add Press Release

Missouri Narrows Tort Reform Caps, Passes on Constitutionality Question

The Missouri Supreme Court recently provided a victory to injured people seeking damages in medical malpractice claims.

August 18, 2010 ( The Missouri Supreme Court recently provided a significant, albeit limited, victory to injured people seeking damages in medical malpractice claims. In Klotz v. St. Anthony's Medical Center, the court concluded that the caps on noneconomic damages enacted by Missouri's 2005 tort reform law should only apply to injuries that occurred after the law took effect. Unfortunately, the court failed to address the larger issues of whether the damages caps themselves are constitutional.

The 2005 Tort Reform Law and Damages Caps

In 2005, then-Gov. Matt Blunt signed a bill into law that sought to put a cap on certain types of damages claims in medical malpractice lawsuits. The cap applied to noneconomic damages, that is, damages for pain and suffering, mental anguish, inconvenience, physical impairment, disfigurement, loss of capacity to enjoy life, and loss of consortium. The caps did not apply to punitive damages or economic damages such as medical bills, and lost income.

The intent of capping these damage awards was to prevent the continued rise of medical malpractice insurance premiums, and in effect, help keep medical care affordable for more people. Previously, Missouri limited the recovery of noneconomic damages to an amount that was periodically adjusted for inflation. Before passage of the 2005 law, the damages limit was $579,000 for each individual involved in a lawsuit.

The new law essentially instituted a hard cap of $350,000 per lawsuit for noneconomic damages. This cap applies to all parties in the suit collectively, not to each individual.

The Missouri Supreme Court's Decision in Klotz

The court's recent decision in Klotz v. Saint Anthony's Medical Center clarifies how these caps are to be applied, but did not go as far as many people, and some Supreme Court justices, would have preferred.

The Klotz case was filed in 2006 alleging that medical malpractice was committed during a 2004 surgery. The injured plaintiff won his case, and he and his wife were awarded $2.5 million by the jury, more than $1 million of which was for noneconomic damages. The trial judge then reduced the noneconomic damages portion to $350,000 in accordance with the limits imposed by the 2005 law.

Upon review by the Missouri Supreme Court, the damage award was reinstated when the court held that the 2005 noneconomic damage cap should only apply to cases in which the injuries took place on or after August 28, 2005 when the tort reform law went into effect.

In practice, this decision narrows the applicability of the damages caps, but since there is a two-year statute of limitations on malpractice cases, this decision will likely affect few, if any, other cases.

The Court's Missed Opportunity in the Klotz Decision

While Klotz was a victory for some injured plaintiffs, the court failed to decide the larger issue of whether the noneconomic damage caps are constitutional in the first place. Recently, two other states, Illinois and Georgia, have ruled that similar caps on damages were unconstitutional. In addition, at least two justices from the Missouri Supreme Court wrote concurring opinions in Klotz that seemed to indicate that they too would have preferred the court declare the caps on noneconomic damages unconstitutional.

In his concurring opinion, Justice Michael A. Wolff argued that the legislature's imposition of caps on noneconomic damage awards was a violation of the right to trial by jury guaranteed by the Missouri Constitution. Justice Wolff reasoned that the constitution gives a jury the right to determine factual issues, including what amount of damages repays someone for suffering a particular injury, and that right cannot be taken away without the consent of the people of Missouri by amending their constitution.

In another concurring opinion, Justice Richard B. Teitelman, reasoned that the damages cap violated the principle of equal protection. He pointed out that, in effect, minor injuries would be compensated more fully than severe injuries because an individual with a minor injury may recover all of their damages without reaching $350,000, while that same amount of money may only be a small percentage of damages to someone that becomes permanently disabled at a young age.

In addition, those that are young or economically disadvantaged will disproportionately suffer because the greater share of their damages will be noneconomic because they do not have the established career or income of an older or wealthier individual. Finally, those injured plaintiffs that cannot prove economic damages may have a hard time pursing claims at all because it might be hard to find attorneys willing to represent them. Since malpractice attorneys typically work on a contingency basis, the limitations on recovery may serve as a disincentive for lawyers to take on the expenses of pursing complex medical malpractice suits.

Illinois and Georgia Courts Find Similar Damages Caps Unconstitutional

While the Missouri Supreme Court has not done so yet, courts in both Illinois and Georgia have recently struck down damages caps using reasoning similar to the two concurring justices in Klotz. In Nestlehutt v. Atlanta Oculoplastic Surgery, the Georgia Supreme Court followed the same reasoning that Justice Wolff advanced in Klotz, that is, that the legislature overstepped its power and violated the right to trial by jury.

Similarly, in Lebron, a Minor v. Gottlieb Memorial Hospital, the Illinois Supreme Court concluded that the imposition of caps on noneconomic damages was a violation of the separation-of-powers clause of the Illinois Constitution. In that case, the court concluded that the caps imposed by the legislature encroached on the powers of the judiciary.

While the Missouri caps on noneconomic damages remain in effect, it may just be a matter of time before the right case comes along to allow for another strong challenge to their constitutionality.

Article provided by Holman Schiavone, LLC
Visit us at


New Bill in Review: Offers Rewards to Ban Distracted Driving

Many drivers realize that talking or texting on their cell phone is dangerous while driving, yet with over 80 million cell phones in use in the U.S., it has become far too common to drive while distracted. The Risks A study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration analyzed a large study group to determine how common and destructive distracted driving has become. The study estimated that drivers on their cell phones caused 955 deaths and 240,000 accidents in 2002. Drivers talking or texting were found to be as likely to crash their vehicle as someone with ...

Battle to Enforce Trademark Wax Seal on Liquor Bottles Finally Ends

Copying a single aspect of another company's packaging - even if the companies are not in direct competition with one another - may violate federal trademark laws. That difficult lesson comes courtesy of a recent court decision (Maker's Mark Distillery Inc., v. Diageo North American, Inc., et. al, 2010 WL 1407325 (W.D.Ky.) from the United States District Court for the Western District of Kentucky. The case arose out of the adoption of the distinctive red wax seal used by Maker's Mark, a distiller of bourbon, by the makers of Cuervo tequila. Although no one is going to ...

Treating Mental Illness: Can a Missed Diagnosis Lead to Jail Time?

Countless crimes are committed everyday in the United States. Some of them, by default, are committed by people with some form of mental illness. Some of these disorders are diagnosed, some are not. In some cases, relatively minor offenses arise as the result of mental illness. An individual may be arrested for trespassing or for being a public nuisance, when the criminal activity is a merely a symptom of a larger problem. In other cases, a criminal act is a cry for help - some know that the only way they will ever receive the medication and treatment they desperately ...

Michigan High Court Considers "Possession" in Child Pornography Cases

In a recent case, the Michigan Supreme Court elucidated the meaning of "possession" within the context of child pornography. The ruling expands the definition of possession to include both actual and constructive possession of child sexually-abusive material, thereby making it more difficult for people accused of possession of child pornography to defend against these allegations. The defendants were identified after federal officials raided a company in Florida that sold child pornography on the Internet. With information from the credit cards used to access and view ...

Manufacturers Try to Swerve Around Off-Road Vehicle Safety Rules

Manufacturers of recreational off-road vehicles are attempting to head off regulators by incorporating some safety features into their products. The chairperson of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says these belated efforts won't deter the government from pursuing safety standards. The Commission is writing mandatory rules for the two- to four-passenger recreational off-road vehicles also known as ROVs. Bloomberg News reports that U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission chair Inez Tannenbaum told a meeting of ROV manufacturers that "it concerned me then, ...

FMCSA Defends CSA 2010 Model, Schedule

The trucking industry's primary regulator, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), has proposed Comprehensive Safety Analysis 2010, a new measurement, enforcement and compliance program designed to measure drivers' safety habits and training. The program's goals are to improve federal and state enforcement of safety and regulatory laws, identify and address behavior that increases risk and encourage the use of technology to track safety and performance data. The data will be compared among carriers to pinpoint at-risk companies. Hearings on Capitol ...

Radiation Overdoses Coming To Light Following Brain Perfusion CT Scans

Imagine suddenly losing your hair in a narrow ring around your head (right about where a hat would sit) but have no idea why. That dilemma was the start of a very troubling discovery for hundreds of people across the country who had been the victims of radiation overdoses during CT scans. In the summer of 2009, reports of the telltale hair loss and other symptoms began surfacing, as medical experts and the victims themselves began putting the pieces together. All signs pointed toward radiation overdoses during CT perfusion scans -- tests for blood flow in the brain, ...

Does Massachusetts' "Charitable Immunity" Law Affect Patient Safety?

Everyone agrees that well-trained, devoted nurses are a crucial component of quality health care. Not everyone agrees on what nurse staffing levels are needed to maintain high-quality care or on how to create and sustain a sizable pool of good nurses. Some Massachusetts health care advocates are now focusing on the state's "charitable immunity" law as an overlooked contributing factor to substandard care. What is the "Charitable Immunity Law"? Massachusetts is one of the few remaining states to recognize the doctrine of "charitable immunity." In short, this legal ...

Superior Atlanta Airport Hotel Offers Convenient Accommodations to International Woodworking Fair 2010 Attendees

The Hilton Garden Inn Atlanta Airport Hotel North offers convenient lodging to guests attending the International Woodworking Fair (IWF) 2010 at the Georgia World Congress Center. The event is being held on August 25-28, 2010 from 8:00am to 5:00pm. Expected to generate 53,000 attendees, IWF is where the industry comes together to solve problems and find solutions. The International Woodworking Fair will include: - A Technology Session where attendees can learn from their peers and industry experts - Over 950 exhibiting companies - New product showcase and a green ...

Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Reports Busy Summer Season, Hiring Additional Atlanta Movers

Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Reports Busy Summer Season, Hiring Additional Atlanta Movers
Although the troubled economy has led many businesses to downsize recently, Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage is pleased to announce that this is not the case with their Atlanta moving company, and that they are actually in the process of hiring additional Atlanta movers. Summer is typically the busiest time of the year for the Atlanta moving industry, and Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage has seen peak demand over the last few months for their Atlanta moving and storage services. As business thrives for the Atlanta moving company, Coast 2 Coast is hiring additional Atlanta ...


How your brain decides blame and punishment -- and how it can be changed

Uniquely human brain region enables punishment decisions

Pinpointing punishment

Chapman University publishes research on attractiveness and mating

E-cigarettes: Special issue from Nicotine & Tobacco Research

Placental problems in early pregnancy associated with 5-fold increased risk of OB & fetal disorders

UT study: Invasive brood parasites a threat to native bird species

Criminals acquire guns through social connections

Restoring ocean health

Report: Cancer remains leading cause of death in US Hispanics

Twin study suggests genetic factors contribute to insomnia in adults

To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?

International team discovers natural defense against HIV

Bolivian biodiversity observatory takes its first steps

Choice of college major influences lifetime earnings more than simply getting a degree

Dominant strain of drug-resistant MRSA decreases in hospitals, but persists in community

Synthetic biology needs robust safety mechanisms before real world application

US defense agencies increase investment in federal synthetic biology research

Robots help to map England's only deep-water Marine Conservation Zone

Mayo researchers identify protein -- may predict who will respond to PD-1 immunotherapy for melanoma

How much water do US fracking operations really use?

New approach to mammograms could improve reliability

The influence of citizen science grows despite some resistance

Unlocking secrets of how fossils form

What happens on the molecular level when smog gets into the lungs?

Using ultrasound to clean medical instruments

Platinum and iron oxide working together get the job done

Tiny silica particles could be used to repair damaged teeth, research shows

A quantum lab for everyone

No way? Charity's logo may influence perception of food in package

[] Missouri Narrows Tort Reform Caps, Passes on Constitutionality Question
The Missouri Supreme Court recently provided a victory to injured people seeking damages in medical malpractice claims. is a service of DragonFly Company. All Rights Reserved.
Issuers of news releases are solely responsible for the accuracy of their content.