PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

BMJ investigation raises concerns about the post-approval surveillance of medical devices

Feature: Why the FDA can't protect the public

2010-11-03
(Press-News.org) The report by Jeanne Lenzer, a medical investigative journalist in New York, and Shannon Brownlee from the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice in New Hampshire, looks at the FDA's approval of a device to prevent or reduce seizures in patients with epilepsy who do not respond to drug treatment.

The device, manufactured by Cyberonics, is implanted under the skin and sends electrical impulses to stimulate the vagus nerve in the neck. It was approved by the FDA in 1997 on the condition that Cyberonics carried out a post-approval study to examine the safety of the device.

"However, in the 13 years since the device was approved in the US, more than 900 deaths have been reported to the FDA, and it is still not clear what impact, if any, the device has had on patient mortality," say Lenzer and Brownlee. They point out that, although Cyberonics conducted the requisite post-approval study, the FDA did not specifically require the company to submit mortality data.

Lenzer and Brownlee argue that the FDA's failure to request and rigorously monitor mortality data related to the vagus nerve stimulator "is but one example of the gap in post-approval surveillance of medical devices." A recent review showed that less than one third of devices approved under FDA's premarket approval process had been evaluated in a randomised study.

They also question the FDA's ability to detect potentially unsafe devices through its harms database and cite a finding that many post-approval studies "are not conducted or conducted so poorly as to be meaningless."

The FDA gave the BMJ references to five additional post-approval studies as evidence of the device's safety. But Lenzer and Brownlee say that these studies do not establish that the device wasn't responsible for deaths because none of them reported mortality data.

In 2005, the FDA approved the vagus nerve stimulator for the treatment of depression, despite the recommendation against approval by its own scientists. The company has also suggested that the stimulator might have a role in treating obesity, stroke, traumatic brain injury, and other conditions, and has taken out patents for these potential therapies.

The gaps in post-approval monitoring of the vagus nerve stimulator are emblematic of the FDA's surveillance of all devices, say the authors. Yet they believe many of the problems have relatively easy fixes. For example, the FDA could make better use of the FDA's database to detect potential safety issues by requiring manufacturers to regularly submit data on the number of active devices.

An independent review panel could also be appointed to decide whether certain adverse outcomes could be excluded from reporting, instead of allowing the manufacturer to make those decisions. And, as the FDA has suggested, mechanisms to limit widespread uptake of new devices could be put in place so that fewer patients are harmed if it ultimately turns out that newly approved devices are flawed, they conclude.

In an accompanying editorial, Professor Jerry Avorn from Harvard Medical School argues that "the standards for device approval and surveillance have fallen far below those for drugs, and even those that would be dictated by common sense."

He points to a "notoriously inadequate approach" in the vital area of postmarketing safety surveillance, and calls for surveillance activities to be placed at a higher and more independent position within regulatory bodies.

Important lessons can be learnt from drug regulation, he says, including mandatory recording of all installed devices on clinical databases and better systems to review new products.

INFORMATION:

END



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Hidden costs of applying to medical school will deter poorer students

2010-11-03
In the UK, medical students are 4.5 to 7.2 times more likely to come from the wealthier socio-economic groups 1-3 than 4-7, write Professor Terence Stephenson, president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, and Lucy Stephenson, a medical student. Selection to a medical course should not depend on the applicants' financial status. However, with "grade inflation" at A level, choosing between applicants can involve other criteria that may depend on ability to pay, they say. They calculate that the activities required as part of the selection process ...

U-M's concept of value-based insurance design featured in major health policy journal

2010-11-03
Ann Arbor, Mich. — Value-Based Insurance Design — a concept created at the University of Michigan and incorporated in the nation's new health care reform law — is the focus of an upcoming national policy journal. Health Affairs, the nation's premier health policy journal, is featuring a cluster of papers in its November issue about growing interest in and adoption of Value-Based Insurance Design (V-BID). The concept was first developed and named by U-M faculty A. Mark Fendrick, M.D., and Dean Smith, Ph.D., along with Michael Chernew, Ph.D., formerly of U-M and now at ...

Strengthening routine flu vaccination and health programs may improve pandemic vaccinations

Strengthening routine flu vaccination and health programs may improve pandemic vaccinations
2010-11-03
Strengthening routine influenza vaccination and health programs may help states improve their vaccination coverage against future pandemics or other health emergencies, a new study suggests. The study -- conducted by researchers at the Georgia Institute of Technology in collaboration with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) -- examined factors that may have contributed to the striking state-by-state variation in U.S. H1N1 flu vaccination rates. The results of the study were revealed on Oct. 26 at the 32nd Annual Meeting of the Society for Medical Decision ...

GOES-13 catches Tropical Storm Tomas' early morning strengthening

GOES-13 catches Tropical Storm Tomas early morning strengthening
2010-11-03
The GOES-13 satellite keeps a continuous eye on the eastern half of the U.S. and Atlantic Ocean basin, and has provided meteorologists with an infrared look at a strengthening Tropical Storm Tomas this morning. The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellites like GOES-13 are managed by NOAA. The NASA GOES Project at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md. creates images and animations from the GOES satellite data. When GOES-13 provided an infrared image (because it was taken at night) today, Nov. 2 at 0845 UTC (4:45 a.m. EDT), Tropical Storm Tomas ...

NJIT math professor illuminates cellular basis of neural impulse transmission

2010-11-03
NJIT Associate Professor Victor Matveev, PhD, in the department of mathematical sciences, was part of a research team that published "N-type Ca2+ channels carry the largest current: Implications for nanodomains and transmitter release," in Nature Neuroscience on Oct. 17, 2010. http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v13/n11/abs/nn.2657.html Leading the project, Elise Stanley, PhD, a senior scientist at the Toronto Western Research Institute, said that Matveev's mathematical modeling showed that calcium influx through a single N-type calcium channel is sufficient to trigger ...

Improving health care in the Internet age

2010-11-03
Faster and more widely available internet access has improved our lives in many ways but healthcare is lagging behind, according to researchers writing in the International Journal of Medical Engineering and Informatics. The US team suggests that there is immense potential for the utilization of digitized personal health records (PHR) in chronic disease management. They have reviewed the state of the art in healthcare portals, assessed the standardization and the legality of health record s and point to a need to improve interoperability, which still represents a major ...

New study re-examines bacterial vaccine studies conducted during 1918 influenza pandemic

2010-11-03
WHAT: Secondary infections with bacteria such as Streptococcus pneumoniae, which causes pneumonia, were a major cause of death during the 1918 flu pandemic and may be important in modern pandemics as well, according to a new article in the Journal of Infectious Diseases co-authored by David M. Morens, M.D., senior advisor to the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, part of the National Institutes of Health. The researchers examined 13 studies published between 1918 and 1920. During this time, many scientists erroneously believed that ...

Gastric bypass alters sweet taste function

2010-11-03
Gastric bypass surgery decreases the preference for sweet-tasting substances in obese rats, a study finding that could help in developing safer treatments for the morbidly obese, according to Penn State College of Medicine researchers. "Roux-en-Y gastric bypass surgery is the most common effective treatment for morbid obesity," said Andras Hajnal, M.D., Ph.D., associate professor, Department of Neural and Behavioral Science and Surgery. "Many patients report altered taste preferences after having the procedure." This surgery involves the creation of a small gastric ...

The Scientist's Life Science Salary Survey 2010 -- results announced

2010-11-03
This year's Salary Survey saw drops in salaries across the board with almost every speciality suffering a setback, some with dips as large as $20,000 (ecology) and $28,000 (virology). However, a few select fields, namely bioinformatics, biophysics, biotechnology, and neuroscience, bucked the trend and actually posted salary increases this year. Whilst it is not easy to determine why these specialities saw salaries rise and others saw salaries cut, Mark Musen, head of the Stanford Center for Biomedical Informatics Research at Stanford University commented: "I've noticed ...

Antibody locks up West Nile's infection mechanism

2010-11-03
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. - Researchers have learned the structure that results when an antibody binds to the West Nile virus, neutralizing the virus by locking up its infection mechanism. The information could help scientists develop a vaccine against the mosquito-borne disease. The findings show precisely how a key part of the antibody, called the antigen binding fragment, or Fab, attaches to two adjacent protein molecules that make up the virus's outer shell. This "crosslinking" attachment between molecules is repeated over the entire shell, interlocking the 30 molecular ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Pioneering neuroendocrinologist's century of discovery launches major scientific tribute series

Gendered bilingualism in post-colonial Korea

Structural safety monitoring of buildings with color variations

Bio-based fibers could pose greater threat to the environment than conventional plastics

Bacteria breakthrough could accelerate mosquito control schemes

Argonne to help drive AI revolution in astronomy with new institute led by Northwestern University

Medicaid funding for addiction treatment hasn’t curbed overdose deaths

UVA co-leads $2.9 million NIH investigation into where systems may fail people with disabilities

With the help of AI, UC Berkeley researchers confirm Hollywood is getting more diverse

Weight loss interventions associated with improvements in several symptoms of PCOS

Federal government may be overpaying for veterans’ health care in Medicare Advantage plans

Researchers awarded $2.5 million grant to increase lung cancer screenings in underserved communities

New trigger proposed for record-smashing 2022 Tonga eruption

Lupus Research Alliance announces Lupus Research Highlights at ACR Convergence 2024

Satellite imagery may help protect coastal forests from climate change

The secrets of baseball's magic mud

Toddlers understand concept of possibility

Small reductions to meat production in wealthier countries may help fight climate change, new analysis concludes

Scientists determine why some patients don’t respond well to wet macular degeneration treatment, show how new experimental drug can bridge gap

Did the world's best-preserved dinosaurs really die in 'Pompeii-type' events?

Not the usual suspects: Novel genetic basis of pest resistance to biotech crops

Jill Tarter to receive Inaugural Tarter Award for Innovation in the search for life beyond earth

Survey finds continued declines in HIV clinician workforce

Researchers home in on tumor vulnerabilities to improve odds of treating glioblastoma

Awareness of lung cancer screening remains low

Hospital COVID-19 burden and adverse event rates

NSF NOIRLab astronomers discover the fastest-feeding black hole in the early universe

Translational science reviews—a new JAMA review

How the keto diet could one day treat autoimmune disorders

Influence of tool corner radius on chip geometrical characteristics of machining Zr-based bulk metallic glass

[Press-News.org] BMJ investigation raises concerns about the post-approval surveillance of medical devices
Feature: Why the FDA can't protect the public