November 04, 2010 (Press-News.org) Every week there is seemingly a new product recall of some sort in the news. Whether it's automobiles or baby toys, a product is being removed from market shelves across the country. Many people may fail to realize, however, that when it comes to pulling defective food and drugs off market shelves, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has no authority to order companies to recall their products. In light of two recent recalls, Congress is proposing bills to reconsider this.
Eggs and Motrin
This past summer, news of eggs tainted with salmonella erupted nationwide. This brought renewed attention to various bills Congress introduced at the start of the 2009 legislative session. The bills, currently still in committee in both the House and Senate, are proposing to allow the FDA to issue recalls of food.
In the spring of 2010, reports surfaced about a "phantom recall" of some versions of the prescription drug Motrin by McNeil Consumer Healthcare, a division of Johnson & Johnson.
In 2009, rather than issuing an official recall of the drugs (which were found to be dissolving incorrectly and thus were not as effective), McNeil hired a private inventory company to purchase the defective Motrin right off of store shelves without telling the store owners or the general public.
When word of the phantom recall reached Congress nearly a year later, the House Oversight Committee held a hearing.
The head of Johnson & Johnson's Consumer Products division said that the plan to buy back the faulty Motrin was merely an "audit" to determine where the faulty pills were shipped. But at a second hearing, the CEO of Johnson & Johnson admitted that the phantom recall was the wrong approach for the company to take in dealing with the defective drugs.
Congressional Examination
Following the first hearing on the Motrin mishap, committee chair Edolphus Towns (D-NY) introduced a bill, HR 5740, which would give the FDA authority to order drug recalls. The bill was referred to the House Committee on Energy and Commerce. However, with the end of the present congressional term approaching, it is unlikely to be passed by the current Congress.
The hearings were not without condemnation and commentary from both Democrats and Republicans. Both members of the committee criticized McNeil's phantom recall approach but also laid blame on the apparent lack of oversight by the FDA. Republicans focused their attention on the FDA being too lax with the companies involved. Democrats blamed the private companies.
Representative Kucinich, one of three co-sponsors of the bill, characterized the committee's role as "not just oversight of the government. It's [also] oversight of misconduct in the private sector."
Kucinich went on to say that if a company knowingly avoided telling the public about a serious health problem, that company's corporate charter should be cancelled--in other words, put out of business.
State Remedies
For the nation's drug companies, neither the FDA nor the federal government currently has the power to revoke a company's corporate charter; that power is held by the state in which it is incorporated.
Fortunately for the public, states across the country have implemented laws that protect consumers against harmful products. Although the defective Motrin example involved a product that was simply less effective than it should have been, when a product causes actual harm, individuals may sue the manufacturer under product liability law.
Specifically, in Ohio, liability may be established under either traditional common-law theories of negligence, or under strict liability laws established under Ohio's Products Liability Act.
Federal Pre-emption
In some cases, however, federal law pre-empts state law. For example, in Ohio, a user of a diet drug claimed that the drug was unreasonably dangerous and sued the drug's manufacturer under both Ohio strict liability law and negligence law. But both of these causes of action were pre-empted, or blocked by federal law, because the FDA, not a state's law, has the authority to determine which drugs are safe and effective enough to be marketed.
As these examples indicate, pursuing legal recourse against a defective product can be complex. Anyone injured as a result of a product improperly labeled or did not do what the manufacturer claimed should discuss the matter with an attorney experienced in product liability cases.
Article provided by Seaman Garson, LLC
Visit us at www.garson.com
Product Scares Bring Attention to FDA's Lack of Recall Power
Recent product recalls have brought congressional scrutiny to the FDA's lack of authority to recall harmful food or drugs. State laws, however, may offer consumers protection.
2010-11-04
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Americans and Debt: The Downward Spiral of Default
2010-11-04
Easy access to credit through the past decade is now catching up with many Americans. In prosperous times, Americans were borrowing enormous amount of money but still getting by making their monthly car, student loan, and mortgage payments. But since the economic downturn, millions of Americans are now defaulting on these loans and finding out the dangers that go along with evading their loan obligations.
Money Judgments and Home Equity Loans
Some housing experts say the number of shoddy home equity loans issued during the housing boom is incalculable. The housing ...
Florida's HTO Amnesty Program
2010-11-04
In Florida, a person designated as a Habitual Traffic Offender (HTO) loses their license to drive for a period of five years. You may be given that designation by the Department of Highway Safety Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) by having three convictions for any of the following offenses within a five year period:
- Voluntary or involuntary manslaughter resulting from the operation of a motor vehicle
- Any violation of 316.193 (driving under the influence or DUI)
- Any felony in the commission of which a motor vehicle is used
- Driving a motor vehicle while your license is ...
Avoiding Potential Pitfalls in Nursing Home Admissions Paperwork
2010-11-04
Be on the Lookout for Arbitration Agreements That Could Jeopardize Your Rights
The decision to admit yourself or a vulnerable loved one to a nursing home, residential care center or assisted living facility is a difficult one. Admission may be precipitated by a sudden downturn in health, the loss of a trusted at-home caregiver or other emotion-laden situations. Nursing home admissions come not only with a multitude of stresses to be felt and decisions to be made; they also come with a lot of paperwork.
Hidden deep within admission forms is likely to be a provision ...
Nursing Home Bed Rails Pose a Danger to Vulnerable Patients
2010-11-04
Harry Griph Sr. was expected to die. The 75-year-old retired phone company worker was in an assisted living facility as a hospice patient. The prognosis was grim: his chronic diseases and functional impairments indicated he was very near the end of life.
The New York Times reports that a staff member found him dead on Christmas morning. But Griph hadn't died of natural causes. His neck was trapped between the bed rail and the mattress. He had died of suffocation.
Griph's three children and his estate sued the nursing home where he died, the hospice provider, the maker ...
Domestic Violence Issues in a Child Custody Context
2010-11-04
As another National Domestic Violence Awareness Month comes to a close, there are millions of people around the country who are suffering in silence. Domestic abuse is one of the most underreported crimes in the nation, due in part because there is no clear-cut definition of what it is. California's laws governing domestic violence are very broad, something that victim advocates applaud and anyone who has been falsely accused laments.
Contrary to popular belief, "abuse" does not have to result in physical injury to be considered as contributing to an environment of violence ...
Schillings Hails Radmacher Ruling as More Than Just Financial Opportunity
2010-11-04
Schillings has revealed that a landmark legal ruling made by the Supreme Court has given significant strength to the rights of couples ahead of marriage to divide their assets in the event that the marriage breaks down.
The Supreme Court decided that prenuptial agreements should be given 'decisive weight' in divorce proceedings, rather than merely being taken into account alongside a number of other factors such as the standard of life enjoyed during the marriage and the earning capacity of the parties.
Commenting on the ruling, Keith Schilling, founder and senior ...
NH Hotels Reveals EBITDA More Than Doubled in the First 9 Months of 2010
2010-11-04
NH Hotels has revealed that the adverse situation of the industry in 2009 underwent a major turnaround during the first 9 months of 2010 leading to a significant improvement towards recovery in the Group's basic activity. NH Hotels' revenues totalled EUR980.5M, a 9.4% rise, and its Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) reflected both the strong recovery in the market and the remarkable increase in productivity. The company generated an EBITDA totalling EUR102.2M, more than double the figure for the same period in 2009, due mainly to an ...
npower and The Football League Announce GBP2m Community Investment
2010-11-04
npower and The Football League have announced the launch of 'Home Town Heroes', a new community initiative that aims to put the power into the hands of the fans.
The GBP2m Home Team Heroes initiative - which will be run over the course of the three year sponsorship - will ask communities around the UK's 72 Football League grounds to vote on how this money should be spent, in order to make the most impact in their local area.
Communities can choose from one of three projects for children:
- A 'respect' training workshop for ten year-olds run in schools with a focus ...
Marks & Spencer Unveils Christmas Marketing Campaign
2010-11-04
Marks & Spencer (M&S) has unveiled its marketing campaign for Christmas. Peter Kay joins the line-up of M&S models - including Dannii Minogue, Twiggy, and Jamie Redknapp - for a dance-themed clothing ad. This year's M&S Christmas strap line: "Don't put a foot wrong this Christmas."
The campaign kicked off at the beginning of November with the first TV airing of the clothing ad and the launch of the microsite.
The much anticipated clothing Christmas TV ad stars one of the nation's favourite comedians, Peter Kay, alongside M&S models Ana Beatriz Barros, Dannii Minogue, ...
LV= Reveals Boom in Holidaymakers Flying Solo
2010-11-04
LV=, the travel insurer, has announced that the number of Brits holidaying alone has doubled in the past two years* according to its research. The trend which was first identified by ABTA** last year is set to see more than two million Brits jet off on holiday on their own over the coming three months*** and a further 3.5 million people over the next year****.
According to the research by LV= travel insurance, a third of all British adults have holidayed alone at some point. Out of these solo holidaymakers 41% were in a relationship when they went, with one in four (27%) ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Deaf male mosquitoes don’t mate
Recognizing traumatic brain injury as a chronic condition fosters better care over the survivor’s lifetime
SwRI’s Dr. James Walker receives Distinguished Scientist Award from Hypervelocity Impact Society
A mother’s health problems pose a risk to her children
Ensuring a bright future for diamond electronics and sensors
The American Pediatric Society selects Dr. Maria Trent as the Recipient of the 2025 David G. Nichols Health Equity Award
The first 3D view of the formation and evolution of globular clusters
Towards a hydrogen-powered future: highly sensitive hydrogen detection system
Scanning synaptic receptors: A game-changer for understanding psychiatric disorders
High-quality nanomechanical resonators with built-in piezoelectricity
ERC Synergy Grants for 57 teams tackling major scientific challenges
Nordic research team receives €13 million to explore medieval book culture
The origin of writing in Mesopotamia is tied to designs engraved on ancient cylinder seals
Explaining science through dance
Pioneering neuroendocrinologist's century of discovery launches major scientific tribute series
Gendered bilingualism in post-colonial Korea
Structural safety monitoring of buildings with color variations
Bio-based fibers could pose greater threat to the environment than conventional plastics
Bacteria breakthrough could accelerate mosquito control schemes
Argonne to help drive AI revolution in astronomy with new institute led by Northwestern University
Medicaid funding for addiction treatment hasn’t curbed overdose deaths
UVA co-leads $2.9 million NIH investigation into where systems may fail people with disabilities
With the help of AI, UC Berkeley researchers confirm Hollywood is getting more diverse
Weight loss interventions associated with improvements in several symptoms of PCOS
Federal government may be overpaying for veterans’ health care in Medicare Advantage plans
Researchers awarded $2.5 million grant to increase lung cancer screenings in underserved communities
New trigger proposed for record-smashing 2022 Tonga eruption
Lupus Research Alliance announces Lupus Research Highlights at ACR Convergence 2024
Satellite imagery may help protect coastal forests from climate change
The secrets of baseball's magic mud
[Press-News.org] Product Scares Bring Attention to FDA's Lack of Recall PowerRecent product recalls have brought congressional scrutiny to the FDA's lack of authority to recall harmful food or drugs. State laws, however, may offer consumers protection.