(Press-News.org) INDIANAPOLIS -- Decision-making by a surrogate for a family member who is unable to make medical decisions is more complicated than decision-making by patients themselves, according to a study from the Regenstrief Institute, Indiana University Center for Aging Research and the Charles Warren Fairbanks Center for Medical Ethics of Indiana University Health.
The researchers found that family decision-makers considered the cognitively impaired patient's wishes and interests. But they also took into account their own needs and preferences.
Factors influencing surrogate decision-makers included:
Respect for the patient's input.
The patient's prior wishes.
Consideration of the patient's best interests.
The surrogate's own wishes as a guide.
The surrogate's religious and spiritual beliefs.
The surrogate's own interests.
Family consensus.
"Family members often say that they wish they knew more about their loved one's views on medical care," said Regenstrief Institute investigator Alexia Torke, M.D., associate professor of medicine at the IU School of Medicine and an IU Center for Aging Research scientist. "And whether or not surrogates know what the patient would have wanted had they been able to make the decision for themselves, we learned that family members may feel compelled to substitute what they themselves want, or to paraphrase the Golden Rule: do to others as you would have them do to you.
"Surrogates also consider the feelings and beliefs of other family members," said Dr. Torke, senior author of the study. "The individuals who are making decisions for those who cannot are the survivors -- they take into account the fact that they have to live with other family members as and after they make surrogate decisions."
"Making Decisions for Hospitalized Older Adults: Ethical Factors Considered by Family Surrogates" is published in the Summer 2013 issue of the Journal of Clinical Ethics.
An estimated four out of 10 hospitalized adults lack decision-making capacity due to cognitive impairment. When patients are unable to make their own decisions, surrogates often are called upon. Dr. Torke notes that the need for surrogate decision-making is growing as life-sustaining medical technology becomes more available, the population ages, and the prevalence of diseases such as Alzheimer's and other forms of dementia increases.
In the study, the investigators interviewed 35 surrogates with a recent decision-making experience for a hospital patient age 65 or older. The group was almost evenly split between white and African-American surrogates. Eighty percent of the respondents were female; 60 percent were the daughters of the cognitively impaired patient.
"Because surrogates also imagine what they would want under the circumstances and consider their own needs and preferences as well as those of the patient for whom they are acting, standard ethical models of surrogate decision-making [in the academic literature] must account for these additional considerations," the paper noted. "Surrogates' desire for more information about patient preferences suggests a need for greater advance care planning."
INFORMATION:
IU School of Medicine student Jenna Fritsch, B.S., is first author of the paper. Co-authors, in addition to Dr. Torke, are Sandra Petronio, Ph.D., of the Department of Communication Studies in the IU School of Liberal Arts at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis; and Paul R. Helft, M.D., of the Department of Medicine at the IU School of Medicine and the IU Melvin and Bren Simon Cancer Center. Drs. Torke, Petronio and Helft are members of the Charles Warren Fairbanks Center for Medical Ethics at IU Health, of which Dr. Helft serves as the director.
Dr. Torke was supported by an award [K23AG031323] from the National Institute on Aging at the National Institutes of Health. Fritch was supported by the Medical Student Training in Aging Research program, administered by the American Federation for Aging Research and the National Institute on Aging. The content of the study is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Study: Making medical decisions for a cognitively impaired family member is complicated
2013-08-15
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Imaging in mental health and improving the diagnostic process
2013-08-15
LONDON, ON – What are some of the most troubling numbers in mental health? Six to 10 -- the number of years it can take to properly diagnose a mental health condition. Dr. Elizabeth Osuch, a Researcher at Lawson Health Research Institute and a Psychiatrist at London Health Sciences Centre and the Department of Psychiatry at Western University, is helping to end misdiagnosis by looking for a 'biomarker' in the brain that will help diagnose and treat two commonly misdiagnosed disorders.
Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), otherwise known as Unipolar Disorder, and Bipolar Disorder ...
Huge owls need huge trees
2013-08-15
NEW YORK -- A study spearheaded by the Wildlife Conservation Society and the University of Minnesota has shown that the world's largest owl -- and one of the rarest -- is also a key indicator of the health of some of the last great primary forests of Russia's Far East.
The study found that Blakiston's fish owl relies on old-growth forests along streams for both breeding and to support healthy populations of their favorite prey: salmon. The large trees provide breeding cavities for the enormous bird, which has a two-meter (six-foot) wingspan. And when these dead, massive ...
Cosmic turbulences result in star and black hole formation
2013-08-15
Just how stars and black holes in the Universe are able to form from rotating matter is one of the big questions of astrophysics. What we do know is that magnetic fields figure prominently into the picture. However, our current understanding is that they only work if matter is electrically well conductive -- but in rotating discs this isn't always the case. Now, a new publication by Helmholtz-Zentrum Dresden-Rossendorf physicists in the scientific journal Physical Review Letters shows how magnetic fields can also cause turbulences within "dead zones," thus making an important ...
Mountaintop mining pollution has distinct chemical signatures
2013-08-15
DURHAM, N.C. -- Three elements commonly found at elevated levels in an Appalachian river polluted by runoff from mountaintop coal mining have distinctive chemistries that can be traced back to their source, according to a Duke University-led study.
The distinctive chemistries of sulfur, carbon and strontium provide scientists with new, more accurate ways to track pollution from mountaintop mining sites and to distinguish it from contamination from other sources.
"Essentially, we found that these elements have unique isotopic fingerprints, meaning we can use them as ...
1 in 5 women don't believe their breast cancer risk
2013-08-15
ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Despite taking a tailored risk assessment tool that factors in family history and personal habits, nearly 20 percent of women did not believe their breast cancer risk, according to a new study from the University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center.
Most of the women who didn't believe their risk numbers said they did not feel it took into account their family history of cancer or their personal health habits. The tool did ask relevant questions about the individual's family and personal history.
"If people don't believe their risk numbers, it ...
A magnetar at the heart of our Milky Way
2013-08-15
This news release is available in German. Astronomers have discovered a magnetar at the centre of our Milky Way. This pulsar has an extremely strong magnetic field and enables researchers to investigate the direct vicinity of the black hole at the heart of the galaxy. An international team of scientists headed by the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn have, for the first time, measured the strength of the magnetic field around this central source and were able to show that the latter is fed by magnetic fields. These control the inflow of mass into the ...
Raising the IQ of smart windows
2013-08-15
Researchers at the U.S. Department of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) have designed a new material to make smart windows even smarter. The material is a thin coating of nanocrystals embedded in glass that can dynamically modify sunlight as it passes through a window. Unlike existing technologies, the coating provides selective control over visible light and heat-producing near-infrared (NIR) light, so windows can maximize both energy savings and occupant comfort in a wide range of climates.
"In the US, we spend about a quarter of our total ...
Extreme weather, climate and the carbon cycle
2013-08-15
Extreme weather and climate events like storms, heavy precipitation and droughts and heat waves prevent the update of 3 giga-tonnes of carbon by the global vegetation. A team of scientists under the lead of Markus Reichstein, Director of the Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry in Jena, Germany, investigated the effect of extremes on the carbon cycle from the terrestrial ecosystem perspective for the first time. In the current issue of Nature (14th of August 2013), they use Earth observation methods and numerical models to show that especially extreme droughts lead ...
Preschoolers inability to estimate quantity relates to later math difficulty
2013-08-15
Preschool children who showed less ability to estimate the number of objects in a group were 2.4 times more likely to have a later mathematical learning disability than other young people, according to a team of University of Missouri psychologists. Parents may be able to help their children develop their skills at approximating group sizes by emphasizing numerals while interacting with young children.
"Lacking skill at estimating group size may impede a child's ability to learn the concept of how numerals symbolize quantities and how those quantities relate to each other," ...
How will crops fare under climate change? Depends on how you ask
2013-08-15
The damage scientists expect climate change to do to crop yields can differ greatly depending on which type of model was used to make those projections, according to research based at Princeton University. The most dire scenarios can loom large in the minds of the public and policymakers, yet neither audience is usually aware of how the model itself influenced the outcome, the researchers said.
The report in the journal Global Change Biology is one of the first to compare the agricultural projections generated by empirical models — which rely largely on field observations ...