PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Deciding when 'not' to maximize profits

How and why some corporations sabotage their own subsidiaries

2013-10-24
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Sean Hennessey
sean.hennessey@bc.edu
617-552-3630
Boston College
Deciding when 'not' to maximize profits How and why some corporations sabotage their own subsidiaries CHESTNUT HILL, MA (October 23, 2013) - Corporate America may have a reputation for maximizing profits whenever possible, but a new study shows that's not always the case; companies sometimes deliberately leave money on the table in an effort to "get along" with and not upset their competitors. For the first time, we're learning how a company's top bosses are doing it.

Titled "Constrained Delegation: Limiting Subsidiaries' Decision Rights and Resources in Firms That Compete across Multiple Industries," (published in Administrative Science Quarterly), the research paper finds corporate heads "selectively intervene" in the everyday business of a subsidiary to deliberately sabotage decisions that could positively shift the balance of power in the marketplace.

"We showed how large multi-unit firms manage competition across markets which no study before has showed," says Boston College Carroll School of Management Assistant Professor Metin Sengul, the study's co-author. "There are two ways a corporation head can ensure a subsidiary plays nice. One is to watch over its subsidiary's shoulder everyday, which is very difficult for headquarters, especially if it has lots of different units. It's very costly and impractical.

"The other option is what we are arguing and that is to delegate decisions that will not trigger competitive aggressiveness to your units," says Professor Sengul, who argues corporations want subsidiaries to succeed – to a point. "A corporate head might say to a subsidiary, 'I don't want you to anger my multimarket rivals so that we are hurt overall. Other than that, I want you to make money. Go, do good business. But whenever you are making big investment decisions - increasing your capacity by 30%, for example – stop. Come and ask me. Let's talk. And then I will tell you to do it or not. Don't decide on your own.' Corporations don't want to centralize everything, they just want to centralize big decisions."

To curtail any potential problems, Sengul says corporations not only limit a subsidiary's decision-making capacity, but also financially handcuff them.

"If you're one of those units that I want to behave," says Professor Sengul. "I don't leave lots of cash to your discretion because I don't want to come back next year and see that you created new factories because you had the cash and you had the autonomy. It's not good for the corporation if we are competing with the same rivals in multiple different businesses."

To be clear, a company that is a standalone entity will typically go after its competitors in an aggressive way when there is an attractive market opportunity; Professor Sengul argues it's the corporations competing with the same rivals in multiple businesses who aren't as aggressive. He argues this approach to decision making is part of a larger issue where corporations tacitly agree amongst themselves not to upset the collective apple cart; instead, the goal is to get along across all industries within a corporation's market place and avoid "competitive spillovers."

"Our study shows this happens across all industries, especially in industries where large firms dominate," says Professor Sengul, who goes on to describe a hypothetical scenario where General Electric decides to cut its light bulb prices by 10% and increase production by 20% in a bid to gain market share. That move might hurt Siemens, also in the light bulb market. Professor Sengul says instead of matching the price drop and hurting its own bottom line in the light bulb industry, Siemens might instead go after GE in the MRI market, a space both companies compete in.

"Let's say that Siemens' MRI unit is relatively small compared to their light bulb unit," hypothesizes Professor Sengul. "Siemens' headquarters tells the MRI unit 'Cut your prices' because the moment the MRI unit of Siemens cuts its prices, then it increases competition in the MRI business. So now GE is hurt because as the competition escalates in the MRI market, GE starts losing money in that business and healthcare business is important for the entire GE portfolio. Note that although it all started with GE light bulb cutting its prices, the unit that is losing money is not GE light bulb but GE healthcare. In that way, the initial competitive action of one unit hurt another unit. That is what we call competitive spillover.

"Whenever corporate heads realize, 'OK my unit competes with other firms that can respond in other markets, then they tell those units, don't be too aggressive. You are part of my corporate umbrella, my corporate empire. Behave. Don't focus on market share, don't cut prices. Be nice. Focus on profits, focus on increasing the margins.'"

Professor Sengul calls this a "go along to get along" cooperative attitude.

"Live and let live," says Professor Sengul. "You step back, I step back. If you don't step back, I don't step back. That is called 'mutual forbearance.' We both forbear. We both take a step back."

Inside the corporate umbrella, this cooperative attitude toward multimarket rivals can lead to a restricted growth in certain businesses of the corporation, businesses that compete with units of other multimarket firms.

"I'm intervening not to push my units to grow, I'm intervening basically to reduce their competitive aggressiveness. That is the objective. Because that is the objective and my units are getting less aggressive, that's why they are growing relatively less."

Professor Sengul argues in the end, it's the consumers that are taking a backseat.

"Collusive behavior rarely helps consumers. Profits go up usually at their expense. Mutual forbearance reduces competitive aggressiveness in the market place and less competition usually hurts consumers."

Data collection on this report began in 2005 and focused solely on French companies.

"We have data on every single subsidiary from every single firm in France," says Professor Sengul. "You can't get that kind of data in the United States – the laws are more restrictive here. Mutual forbearance happens in the U.S. every day, no doubt about it."

INFORMATION:

Javier Gimeno of INSEAD, France was the co-researcher of this study.

If you would like to speak with Professor Sengul, please contact:
Sean Hennessey, Boston College Office of News and Public Affairs
(617) 552-3630; sean.hennessey@bc.edu

END



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

TopoChip reveals the Braille code of cells

2013-10-24
TopoChip reveals the Braille code of cells Cells in the human body change shape as they crawl, split, or cling to other surfaces, but while the scientific literature is filled with examples of how cell shapes shift in response to things they touch, little ...

Uncovering the tricks of nature's ice-seeding bacteria

2013-10-24
Uncovering the tricks of nature's ice-seeding bacteria Like the Marvel Comics superhero Iceman, some bacteria have harnessed frozen water as a weapon. Species such as Pseudomonas syringae have special proteins embedded in their outer membranes that help ice ...

First-ever Information Systems Job Index shows healthy market for college students

2013-10-24
First-ever Information Systems Job Index shows healthy market for college students Despite a 7.2 percent national unemployment rate, the job market is a healthy one for college students majoring in information systems, with nearly three quarters of students receiving ...

Berkeley Lab researchers get a detailed look at a DNA repair protein in action

2013-10-24
Berkeley Lab researchers get a detailed look at a DNA repair protein in action Provides new insight into genome integrity and biological detection of mismatched DNA Errors in the human genetic code that arise from mismatched nucleotide base pairs in ...

Induced pluripotent stem cells reveal differences between humans and great apes

2013-10-24
Induced pluripotent stem cells reveal differences between humans and great apes Key differences in the regulation of jumping genes may have arisen relatively recently in evolution LA JOLLA, CA---- Researchers at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies have, for the first time, ...

Birthing a new breed of materials

2013-10-24
Birthing a new breed of materials Where two different materials meet on the atomic level, a new material can be born that is neither one nor the other. The two parent materials do not mix – they remain distinct from one another – but their marriage begets ...

Vacuums provide solid ground for new definition of kilogram

2013-10-24
Vacuums provide solid ground for new definition of kilogram Of all the standard units currently in use around the world, the kilogram – the official unit of mass in the International System of Units (SI) – is the only one that still relies on a physical object ...

Ignorance is sometimes bliss

2013-10-24
Ignorance is sometimes bliss A range of examples suggests a lack of information about their fellows can favor cooperation and prevent conflict among animals -- and even among genes For the Oct. 16 issue of Biology Letters, a special issue commemorating the 50th ...

Researchers capture images of open channel that moves proteins across cell membranes

2013-10-24
Researchers capture images of open channel that moves proteins across cell membranes (Boston) – Similar to passengers on an urban transit system, every protein made in the cell has a specific destination and function. Channels in cell membranes ...

A protein safeguards against cataracts

2013-10-24
A protein safeguards against cataracts Activation mechanism of a protective protein in the ocular lens resolved This news release is available in German. The lens of the human eye is made up of a highly concentrated protein solution ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Scientists trace origins of now extinct plant population from volcanically active Nishinoshima

AI algorithm based on routine mammogram + age can predict women’s major cardiovascular disease risk

New hurdle seen to prostate screening: primary-care docs

MSU researchers explore how virtual sports aid mental health

Working together, cells extend their senses

Cheese fungi help unlock secrets of evolution

Researchers find brain region that fuels compulsive drinking

Mental health effects of exposure to firearm violence persist long after direct exposure

Research identifies immune response that controls Oropouche infection and prevents neurological damage

University of Cincinnati, Kent State University awarded $3M by NSF to share research resources

Ancient DNA reveals deeply complex Mastodon family and repeated migrations driven by climate change

Measuring the quantum W state

Researchers find a way to use antibodies to direct T cells to kill Cytomegalovirus-infected cells

Engineers create mini microscope for real-time brain imaging

Funding for training and research in biological complexity

The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: September 12, 2025

ISSCR statement on the scientific and therapeutic value of human fetal tissue research

Novel PET tracer detects synaptic changes in spinal cord and brain after spinal cord injury

Wiley advances Knowitall Solutions with new trendfinder application for user-friendly chemometric analysis and additional enhancements to analytical workflows

Benchmark study tracks trends in dog behavior

OpenAI, DeepSeek, and Google vary widely in identifying hate speech

Research spotlight: Study identifies a surprising new treatment target for chronic limb threatening ischemia

Childhood loneliness and cognitive decline and dementia risk in middle-aged and older adults

Parental diseases of despair and suicidal events in their children

Acupuncture for chronic low back pain in older adults

Acupuncture treatment improves disabling effects of chronic low back pain in older adults

How interstellar objects similar to 3I/ATLAS could jump-start planet formation around infant stars

Rented e-bicycles more dangerous than e-scooters in cities

Ditches as waterways: Managing ‘ditch-scapes’ to strengthen communities and the environment

In-situ molecular passivation enables pure-blue perovskite LEDs via vacuum thermal evaporation

[Press-News.org] Deciding when 'not' to maximize profits
How and why some corporations sabotage their own subsidiaries