(Press-News.org) Contact information: Bettye Miller
bettye.miller@ucr.edu
951-827-7847
University of California - Riverside
News that is better or worse than expected influences health decisions
UCR psychologist finds that unrealistic pessimists less likely to take preventive action after receiving good news
RIVERSIDE, Calif. — Patients who are unrealistically optimistic about their personal health risks are more likely to take preventive action when confronted with news that is worse than expected, while unrealistic pessimists are less likely to change their behavior after receiving feedback that is better than expected, according to researchers at the University of California, Riverside and Grand Valley State University in Allendale, Mich.
This poses a serious dilemma for health care professionals, said study authors Kate Sweeny, assistant professor of psychology at UC Riverside, and co-author Amanda Dillard, assistant professor of psychology at Grand Valley State University: Should they withhold accurate risk information from unrealistic pessimists to avoid undermining their perceptions of the severity of their potential consequences and ultimately their motivation for preventive behavior?
"The question reveals a tension between the goals of health-behavior promotion and informed patient decision-making that has plagued researchers in several health domains, most notably with regard to women's often overly pessimistic perceptions of their breast cancer risk," Sweeny and Dillard wrote in "The Effects of Expectation Disconfirmation on Appraisal, Affect, and Behavioral Intentions," published this month in the online edition of Risk Analysis: An International Journal. The journal is an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis, a multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary, scholarly, international society based in McLean, Va.
"Our findings cannot resolve this tension, but rather point to the need for further consideration of the potential consequences of risk communication," the researchers said.
Sweeny and Dillard are the first to demonstrate that how an individual reacts and responds to objective risk feedback may depend on initial expectations prior to the feedback.
The psychologists conducted a series of experiments in which participants were told they would be tested for exposure to toxins found in everyday products. The researchers found that people who received risk feedback that was worse than expected expressed stronger intentions to prevent the threat in the future than did people who received risk feedback that was better than expected. All study participants received the same health feedback; only the expectations of the participants differed.
"Our findings add critical pieces to the previously incomplete picture of the consequences of expectation disconfirmation," they wrote. "Ours is the first experimental investigation of the relationship between expectation disconfirmation and behavioral intentions in the context of personal risk perceptions, and the first study to examine the process by which intentions might rise or fall in response to unexpected risk feedback."
Contrary to findings in other recent studies, Sweeny and Dillard determined that when people are faced with objective feedback that differs from their perceptions of health risks, they may adapt their behavior to fit the new risk information.
"In our studies, participants who learned that their risk was higher than they expected … formed relative strong intentions to take preventive action," they said. They also found that people who learned that their risk was lower than expected felt relatively good in the face of feedback and formed relatively weak intentions to take preventive action. All of the study participants received the same health risk feedback.
"Our findings point to an important tradeoff people face when managing their expectations as they await feedback: maintaining optimism leaves people open to disappointment, but bracing for the worst may undermine future motivation to improve," they said. "… It seems that people find the emotional consequences of being caught off-guard more compelling than the potential for elation to undermine their motivation to change their behavior in response to feedback."
INFORMATION:
News that is better or worse than expected influences health decisions
UCR psychologist finds that unrealistic pessimists less likely to take preventive action after receiving good news
2013-10-30
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Mechanisms of wound healing are clarified in MBL zebrafish study
2013-10-30
Mechanisms of wound healing are clarified in MBL zebrafish study
WOODS HOLE, Mass.— A crucial component of wound healing in many animals, including humans, is the migration of nearby skin cells toward the center of the wound. These cells fill the wound in and help ...
Results of the SAFE-PCI trial presented at TCT 2013
2013-10-30
Results of the SAFE-PCI trial presented at TCT 2013
Novel study finds using radial versus femoral access during cardiac catheterization may have benefits in women
SAN FRANCISCO, CA – October 29, 2013 – A clinical trial conducted exclusively in women suggests that an initial ...
Dinner rituals that correlate with child and adult BMI
2013-10-30
Dinner rituals that correlate with child and adult BMI
All in the family: Dinner tables linked to less fat
Beyond plate size and calorie count, the war against obesity may have a new leader – the dinner table. Families that eat together without the television ...
Knowledge about incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse lower among women of color
2013-10-30
Knowledge about incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse lower among women of color
Knowing what symptoms to look for may help women with pelvic floor disorders improve their chances of successful treatment. But knowledge of these disorders is lacking among most women, ...
Results of the COREVALVE EXTREME RISK trial presented at TCT 2013
2013-10-30
Results of the COREVALVE EXTREME RISK trial presented at TCT 2013
Clinical trial finds that COREVALVE reduces rate of death and stroke in sickest patients with aortic stenosis
SAN FRANCISCO, CA – October 29, 2013 – In a clinical trial, a self-expanding transcatheter aortic ...
Exercise programs could help to prevent fall injuries in older people
2013-10-30
Exercise programs could help to prevent fall injuries in older people
Could reduce rate of severe falls leading to medical care
Exercise programmes designed to prevent falls in older adults also appear to prevent injuries caused by falls, suggests a paper ...
Unpublished trial data 'violates an ethical obligation' to study participants, say researchers
2013-10-30
Unpublished trial data 'violates an ethical obligation' to study participants, say researchers
Study finds almost 1 in 3 large clinical trials still not published 5 years after completion
Almost one in three (29%) large clinical trials remain unpublished ...
Autism and language impairment genetically linked
2013-10-30
Autism and language impairment genetically linked
Rutgers University scientists also find strong evidence of a genetic connection in areas of social skills and repetitive behaviors
Lorenzo Miodus-Santini an 11-year-old sixth-grader from Princeton, who was classified ...
Warm winters let trees sleep longer
2013-10-30
Warm winters let trees sleep longer
Climate change alters timing of spring growth in forests
In the temperate zones, vegetation follows the change of the seasons. After a winter pause, plants put out new growth in spring. Research has now brought ...
New substance effectively combats multi-resistant bacteria
2013-10-30
New substance effectively combats multi-resistant bacteria
MULTI-RESISTANCE: In Europe alone, more than 25,000 people die each year from infections caused by multi-resistant bacteria. Researchers from University of Copenhagen have now developed and characterized ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Transnational electoral participation of undocumented Mexican immigrants in the US
A new method to build more energy-efficient memory devices for a sustainable data future
Freely levitating rotor spins out ultraprecise sensors for classical and quantum physics
‘Chinese lantern’ structure shifts into more than a dozen shapes for various applications
Towards light-controlled electronic components
Tiny architects, titanic climate impact: scientists call for October 10 to become International Coccolithophore Day
Stress sensitivity makes suicidal thoughts more extreme and persistent among the university population
Lessons from Ascension’s shark troubles could help boost conservation
Fire provides long-lasting benefits to bird populations in Sierra Nevada National Parks
Menstrual cycle affects women’s reaction time but not as much as being active
Housing associations more effective than government in supporting unemployed in deprived areas
Biochar helps composting go greener by cutting greenhouse gas emissions
Ulrich named president-elect of the AACI
Multitasking makes you more likely to fall for phishing emails
Researchers solve model that can improve sustainable design, groundwater management, nuclear waste storage, and more
Parched soils can spark hot drought a nation away
Uncovering new physics in metals manufacturing
Sped-up evolution may help bacteria take hold in gut microbiome, UCLA-led research team finds
The dose-dependent effects of dissolved biochar on C. elegans: Insights into the physiological and transcriptomic responses
New research reveals genetic link to most common pediatric bone cancer
Research conducted during 2024 eclipse reveals importance of light on bird behavior
Why does female fertility decline so fast? The key is the ovary
Total solar eclipse triggers dawn behavior in birds
Europe’s largest bats hunt and eat migrating birds on the wing, high in the sky
China’s emerging AI regulation could foster an open and safe future for AI
The secret to naked mole-rat’s longevity: Enhanced DNA repair
Acidic tumor environment promotes survival and growth of cancer cells
New biosensor tracks plants’ immune hormone in real time
New study finds gaps in REDD+ forest carbon offsets with most overstating climate impacts
Mystery solved: How Europe’s largest bat catches and eats passerines mid-air
[Press-News.org] News that is better or worse than expected influences health decisionsUCR psychologist finds that unrealistic pessimists less likely to take preventive action after receiving good news