PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Animal welfare scientists reveal infrequent and inconsistent acceptance of existing data by EPA to satisfy endocrine disruptor testing requirements

2013-11-01
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Tasgola Bruner
TasgolaB@peta.org
770-518-1675
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals
Animal welfare scientists reveal infrequent and inconsistent acceptance of existing data by EPA to satisfy endocrine disruptor testing requirements Norfolk, Va. – An original article by scientists at People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) and the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) evaluated acceptance of Other Scientifically Relevant Information (OSRI) by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the agency's Endocrine Disruptor Screening Program (EDSP) in lieu of requiring new testing on animals and found it to be low and at times inconsistent. The findings are published online in an "early view" edition of the journal Birth Defects Research Part B: Developmental and Reproductive Toxicology.

"The analysis we performed clearly suggests that the EPA did not utilize OSRI to the greatest extent possible to avoid duplicative data collection and reduce the number of animals," said Patricia Bishop, one of the authors and a research scientist at PETA's Regulatory Testing Division. "As there is extensive information available for the first chemicals to be tested—and for many that will be slated for future testing—the EPA must support and develop explicit guidance for the use of OSRI and standardize and clearly articulate its own evaluation procedures to avoid duplicative testing and the loss of thousands of animal lives."

The EDSP is a two-tiered testing program. Tier 1 consists of five in vitro and six in vivo tests that explore the potential of a chemical to interact with the estrogen, androgen, and thyroid hormone systems and uses 595 animals—at minimum—per chemical if the entire battery is performed. Positive chemicals from Tier 1 presumably proceed to Tier 2, consisting of multi-generation reproductive and developmental toxicity studies in mammals, fish, birds, and amphibians, for further testing. Tier 2 assays are extremely animal-intensive. For example, the bird assay requires hatching of a minimum of 800 birds while the fish and amphibian assays each use thousands of animals per test. The EPA indicated that, prior to requiring new Tier 1 testing, it would consider OSRI submitted by test order recipients and third parties and determine whether it satisfied data requirements of the EDSP. OSRI is existing data that is either functionally equivalent to information obtained from the Tier 1 assays (i.e., data from assays that perform the same function as EDSP Tier 1 assays) or provides evidence of a potential effect on the endocrine system.

Most of the 52 chemicals in the first round of Tier 1 testing under the EDSP were pesticides for which there is a wealth of existing toxicity data. This data includes results of guideline animal tests conducted under 40 CFR Part 158 data requirements to support pesticide registration as well as research studies published in the peer-reviewed literature. Guideline studies generally include two-generation reproduction toxicity studies in rodents; 28-day, 90-day, and 1-year chronic exposure studies in rodents and dogs; and reproduction and life-cycle studies in fish and birds. With so many of these chemicals already being extensively tested, acceptance of OSRI is a primary means for avoiding duplicative data collection and minimizing further animal use.

The authors found that, due to a lack of clear guidance from the EPA, OSRI submissions by test order recipients were quite variable in their length and content. Some respondents requested waivers based on OSRI for all Tier 1 tests while others did not seek any waivers at all. Of the 412 waivers sought, the EPA granted only 93—an overall OSRI acceptance rate of 23 percent. The 49 waivers for in vivo tests and 20 waivers for in vitro assays that use tissues collected from animals spared 3325 animals. However, at least 27,731 animals were estimated to have been used to perform the Tier 1 tests eventually required by the EPA after rejecting OSRI, with additional animals being used by laboratories in preparation for conducting the Tier 1 tests.

Despite language in the laws creating the EDSP that provides for the use of OSRI and direction by the Office of Management and Budget in approving the EPA's request to collect Tier 1 data that the agency accepts OSRI to the greatest extent possible, the study found that the EPA applied a rather narrow and limited approach to acceptance of OSRI. Most OSRI accepted in lieu of new testing either indicated a positive result or was produced using a study method that was identical or very similar to a Tier 1 or Tier 2 assay, even though the EPA said functionally equivalent studies would be considered. The OSRI analysis shows that results from Part 158 studies were accepted infrequently and that there were cases where literature studies were accepted for one chemical when the results were positive but rejected for another chemical evaluated in the study when the results were negative.

"Even with the EPA's planned integration of 21st -century toxicity-testing tools, such as computational toxicology methods and high throughput in vitro assays, into the EDSP for prioritization and screening purposes, OSRI will continue to play an important role in reducing the number of animals used in testing and in pretesting until such time when we can do away with animal testing completely," Bishop added.

###

The article is part of an entire journal issue devoted to the EDSP and may be read here. For more information about PETA's scientific papers and presentations, please click (here.

END



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Mid-level health workers as effective as physicians

2013-11-01
Mid-level health workers as effective as physicians This news release is available in Spanish, French, Portuguese and Arabic. Countries facing severe shortages and poor distribution of health workers could benefit from training and deploying more ...

A new weapon in the fight against superbugs

2013-11-01
A new weapon in the fight against superbugs The ever-increasing threat from "superbugs" -- strains of pathogenic bacteria that are impervious to the antibiotics that subdued their predecessor generations -- has forced the medical community to look for bactericidal ...

Patients' 'immune fingerprints' may help diagnose bacterial infections and guide treatment

2013-11-01
Patients' 'immune fingerprints' may help diagnose bacterial infections and guide treatment Body's immune response indicates type of infection and which antibiotics to use Washington, DC (October 31, 2013) — A patient's immune response may provide better and more ...

New techniques produce cleanest graphene yet

2013-11-01
New techniques produce cleanest graphene yet Columbia Engineers develop new device architecture for 2D materials, making electrical contact from the 1D edge New York, NY—October 31, 2013—Columbia Engineering researchers have experimentally demonstrated for the ...

Global warming as viewed from the deep ocean

2013-11-01
Global warming as viewed from the deep ocean The intermediate waters of the Pacific Ocean are absorbing heat 15 times faster over the past 60 years than in the past 10,000 Some climate change skeptics have pointed out that global atmospheric temperatures ...

Is global heating hiding out in the oceans?

2013-11-01
Is global heating hiding out in the oceans? Parts of pacific warming 15 times faster than in past 10,000 years A recent slowdown in global warming has led some skeptics to renew their claims that industrial carbon emissions are not ...

Making electrical contact along 1-D edge of 2-D materials

2013-11-01
Making electrical contact along 1-D edge of 2-D materials As postdoc at Columbia, CCNY physicist Cory Dean and colleagues devised new method that addresses graphene's contamination problem Dr. Cory Dean, assistant professor of physics at The City College of New ...

Researchers identify molecule that orients neurons for high definition sensing

2013-11-01
Researchers identify molecule that orients neurons for high definition sensing Many animals have highly developed senses, such as vision in carnivores, touch in mice, and hearing in bats. New research from the RIKEN Brain Science Institute has uncovered a brain molecule that can explain ...

A 20 percent sugary drink tax would cut number of UK obese adults by 180,000

2013-11-01
A 20 percent sugary drink tax would cut number of UK obese adults by 180,000 As biggest consumers, under 30s likely to be most affected A 20% tax on sugar sweetened drinks would reduce the number of UK adults who are obese by 180,000 (1.3%) and who are overweight ...

Important breakthrough in identifying effect of epilepsy treatment

2013-11-01
Important breakthrough in identifying effect of epilepsy treatment 50 years after valproate was first discovered, research published today in the journal Neurobiology of Disease, reports how the drug works to block seizure progression. Valproate (variously ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Tiny fish open new horizons for autism research.

How eye-less corals see the light

Storing breast milk for specific times of day could support babies’ circadian rhythm

Growing a new, pencil-shaped structure of gold named “quantum needles”

Transparent mesoporous WO₃ film enhances solar water splitting efficiency and stability

Protostellar jet detection in Milky Way’s outer region reveals universal star formation

New research uncovers a ‘ghost’ of the Australian bush

Study establishes link between rugby and dementia

Can courts safeguard fairness in an AI age?

Less than half of England has access to Mounjaro on the NHS months after roll-out

Study highlights cultural differences in parenting and reveals that how babies are soothed matters more than how fast

Claims on baby food fail to stack up

Potential molecular link between air pollutants and increased risk of Lewy body dementia revealed

Deaths from high blood pressure-related kidney disease up nearly 50% in the past 25 years

U.S. survey finds salt substitutes rarely used by people with high blood pressure

Researchers map key human proteins that power coronavirus replication, pointing to new treatment strategies

Single hair strand could provide biomarker for ALS, Mount Sinai study finds

Bio-oil made with corn stalks, wood debris could plug orphaned fossil fuel wells

Can the 'good' bacteria in your mouth act as probiotic cavity fighters?

This common fish has an uncommon feature: Forehead teeth, used for mating

UI Health performs first islet cell transplant with Lantidra

Study shows not all dietary proteins are digested the same way

MSU study finds accessible wireless ultrasounds are accurate

Scientists review breakthrough methods to disrupt toxic “forever chemicals” in water

Ghost sharks grow forehead teeth to help them have sex

How stress and social struggles fuel America’s obesity crisis

Researchers uncover similarities between human and AI learning

Researchers achieve light-induced heterolytic hydrogen dissociation at ambient temperature

Intestinal surface cells pull rather than push

Game-changing biotech for engineering pathogen-resistant crops

[Press-News.org] Animal welfare scientists reveal infrequent and inconsistent acceptance of existing data by EPA to satisfy endocrine disruptor testing requirements