PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

School violence lowers test scores, not grades

2013-11-07
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Daniel Fowler
pubinfo@asanet.org
202-527-7885
American Sociological Association
School violence lowers test scores, not grades WASHINGTON, DC, November 6, 2013 — It's hard to go a day without seeing news of violence in some form occurring in schools around the country, and Chicago is often cited as a city where crime rates in schools are particularly high. In a new study in the current issue of Sociology of Education, Brown University sociologist Julia Burdick-Will looked at the effect such violence has on school achievement among Chicago high school students. She found that while violent crime has a negative impact on standardized test scores, it doesn't have the same effect on grades.

"It seems obvious that having fights in schools is not a good thing for achievement, but it's a really difficult thing to show," said Burdick-Will, a post-doctoral research associate in the Population Studies and Training Center at Brown University, whose study is titled "School Violent Crime and Academic Achievement in Chicago."

Employing detailed crime data from the Chicago Police Department, administrative records from Chicago Public Schools, and school climate surveys conducted by the Consortium on Chicago School Research from 2002 to 2010, Burdick-Will compared fluctuations in year-to-year violent crime rates with changes in both student standardized test scores and annual grade point averages.

She found that violent crime in schools adversely affects reading and math scores on standardized tests, but has no influence on GPAs.

Burdick-Will said the results suggest that violent crime rates affect the amount of material learned by the entire student body, but not the study skills or effort of individual students. GPAs, she points out, not only reflect learning, but also student behavior and standing within the classroom. Test scores are a more objective measure of content knowledge and performance on a given day.

"So you would expect that if what's really going on is students are distracted and not learning as much and also not able to perform as well on the day of the test that it would affect their test scores," Burdick-Will said. "But it wouldn't necessarily affect how much homework they've turned in over the course of the year. You're still going to have that kid who is really eager; he or she is just not going to know as much."

The study also reveals that students' perceptions of safety go relatively unchanged, even in years when violent crime rates are low. One explanation may be that the research only looks at reported crimes that involved police intervention. There could be many more incidents, such as shoving in the hallway and verbal altercations, that go unreported but still have an effect on students' sense of well-being.

While annual violent crime rates generally fluctuated significantly at individual schools during the eight-year study period, Burdick-Will found that the average violent crime rate for all high schools in the district combined changed very little over the study period. The paper also notes that a few high schools each year accounted for the large majority of violent crimes in the whole district.

Burdick-Will thinks her research demonstrates the need for policy changes that consider education and crime rates together and take into account the "collateral damage" that crime and violence have on multiple sectors of society.

"In an age of increasing school accountability and shrinking public budgets, it is important to understand how policies that on the surface only affect one social sphere, such as policing strategies, have larger consequences for other social institutions, including schools, in ways that have lasting impacts on individual life chances and national levels of inequality," Burdick-Will said.

###

About the American Sociological Association and the Sociology of Education

The American Sociological Association (http://www.asanet.org), founded in 1905, is a non-profit membership association dedicated to serving sociologists in their work, advancing sociology as a science and profession, and promoting the contributions to and use of sociology by society. Sociology of Education is a quarterly, peer-reviewed journal of the ASA.

The research article described above is available by request for members of the media. For a copy of the full study, contact Daniel Fowler, ASA's Media Relations and Public Affairs Officer, at (202) 527-7885 or pubinfo@asanet.org.

For more information about the study, members of the media can also contact Courtney Coelho, News Officer, Brown University's Office of Media Relations, at (401) 863-7287 or courtney_coelho@brown.edu.

END



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

In dual-career couples, mothers still do the most child care

2013-11-07
In dual-career couples, mothers still do the most child care Moms spend 70 percent of free time on parenting activities COLUMBUS, Ohio – Even in couples most likely to believe in sharing parenting responsibilities, mothers still bear significantly ...

Hospitals with neurology residency programs more likely to administer life-saving clot-busting drugs

2013-11-07
Hospitals with neurology residency programs more likely to administer life-saving clot-busting drugs tPA found underused; getting it depends on where patients are treated Stroke patients treated at hospitals with neurology residency programs are significantly ...

Stanford researchers surprised to find how neural circuits identify information needed for decisions

2013-11-07
Stanford researchers surprised to find how neural circuits identify information needed for decisions Multitasking neurons filter and decide, confounding the conventional wisdom While eating lunch you notice an insect buzzing around your plate. Its color and ...

Researchers and clinicians unite to answer what will it take to achieve an AIDS-free world?

2013-11-07
Researchers and clinicians unite to answer what will it take to achieve an AIDS-free world? November 5, 2013, San Francisco, CA—Since the onset of the AIDS pandemic more than three decades ago, researchers from the lab and physicians in the clinic have been working toward one ...

Hormone levels in women using contraception affect nerve activity involved in vessel constriction

2013-11-07
Hormone levels in women using contraception affect nerve activity involved in vessel constriction Bethesda, Md. (Nov. 6, 2013)—After menopause, women's levels of estrogen and progesterone fall. Their formerly lower risk for heart disease equals, even surpasses, men's risk. ...

'Please feed me': The power of putting a human face on social causes

2013-11-07
'Please feed me': The power of putting a human face on social causes Companies often put a personal face on products in an attempt to reach a deeper connection with consumers. New research suggests the same idea can be applied to social ...

CWRU study finds mending ruptures in client-therapist relationship has positive benefits

2013-11-07
CWRU study finds mending ruptures in client-therapist relationship has positive benefits In order for prolonged exposure therapy, an evidence-based psychotherapy for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), to reach its full potential, any misperceptions ...

Mothers' relationships can influence adolescent children's relationships, MU study finds

2013-11-07
Mothers' relationships can influence adolescent children's relationships, MU study finds COLUMBIA, Mo. – Until now, little research has been conducted on the association between parents' friendships and the emotional well-being of their adolescent ...

UC's SmartLight more than a bright idea, it's a revolution in interior lighting ready to shine

2013-11-07
UC's SmartLight more than a bright idea, it's a revolution in interior lighting ready to shine The innovative solar technology 'would change the equation for energy,' according to UC researchers A pair of University of Cincinnati researchers has seen the light ...

Georgia Tech warns of threats to cloud data storage, mobile devices in latest 'emerging cyber threat'

2013-11-07
Georgia Tech warns of threats to cloud data storage, mobile devices in latest 'emerging cyber threat' As more businesses find their way into the cloud, few engage in security measures beyond those provided by the associated cloud storage firm, a new report ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Robotic space rovers keep getting stuck. UW engineers have figured out why

New research shows how immigration status can become a death sentence during public health crisis

University of Toronto Engineering researchers develop safer alternative non-stick coating

Good vibrations: Scientists use imaging technology to visualize heat

More ecological diversity means better nutritional resources in Fiji’s agroforests

New global study shows freshwater is disappearing at alarming rates

Scientists create an artificial cell capable of navigating its environment using chemistry alone

A little salt is good for battery health

Deep-sea fish confirmed as a significant source of ocean carbonate

How to keep kids with eating disorders home after hospital stay? Therapy

Sex differences affect efficacy of opioid overdose treatment

Aligning AI with Human Values and Well-Being

Engineering the next generation of experimental physics

The scuba diving industry is funding marine ecosystem conservation and employing locals

BATMAN brings TCR therapy out of the shadows

Surrogates more likely to be diagnosed with mental illness, study finds

Columbia Engineering researchers turn dairy byproduct into tissue repair gel

Global estimates of lives and life-years saved by COVID-19 vaccination during 2020-2024

Potential trade-offs of proposed cuts to the NIH

New research simulates cancer cell behavior

COVID, over 2.5 million deaths prevented worldwide thanks to vaccines. One life saved for every 5,400 doses administered

Scuba diving generates up to $20 billion annually

Scientists advance efforts to create ‘virtual cell lab’ as testing ground for future research with live cells

How DNA packaging controls the “genome’s guardian”

Simplified models, deeper insights: Coarse-grained models unlock new potential for ionic liquid simulations

Gorillas’ personal circumstances shape their aggression towards groupmates

Which signalling pathways in the cell lead to possible therapies for Parkinson's disease

Identifying landslide threats using hydrological predictors

First graders who use more educational media spend more time reading

Exploring the meaning in life through phenomenology and philosophy

[Press-News.org] School violence lowers test scores, not grades