(Press-News.org) Contact information: Diana Kenney
dkenney@mbl.edu
508-289-7139
Marine Biological Laboratory
Blind cavefish offer evidence for alternative mechanism of evolutionary change
WOODS HOLE, Mass.—In a blind fish that dwells in deep, dark Mexican caves, scientists have found evidence for a long-debated mechanism of evolutionary change that is distinct from natural selection of spontaneously arising mutations, as reported this week in the journal Science.
The eyeless cavefish Astyanas mexicanus is "a special system in which we can look at evolution in action," says article co-author William Jeffery, a senior adjunct scientist at the Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL) in Woods Hole, Mass., and a professor at the University of Maryland. The Science study was led by Nicolas Rohner and Clifford J. Tabin at Harvard Medical School's Department of Genetics.
Using the cavefish, the team demonstrated for the first time in nature how "standing" or "cryptic" genetic variations in an animal, which have been inherited from prior generations without causing any physical changes in the animal, can be "unmasked" by the shock of entering a new environment. Gene variants that improve the animal's ability to adapt to that new environment can then be selected for, and passed on to its progeny. This is distinct from the established evolutionary mechanism of "de novo" genetic mutations that arise by chance after the animal has entered the new environment, which also provide a substrate upon which natural selection can act.
The environmental shock that prompted the loss of eyes in the cavefish, the scientists propose, occurred about 2 or 3 million years ago when its surface-dwelling ancestors, which have eyes, "either colonized these caves or were trapped in them," Jeffery says. The fish's transition from swimming outside the cave to swimming inside the cave, where the water is purer and less conductive of electricity, inhibited the activity of a "heat shock" protein called HSP90. (Prior studies in the fruit fly of this protein, which is critical in regulating protein folding, had suggested that it may play a role in masking cryptic genetic variation.) In the case of the cavefish, the present study finds, HSP90 inhibition due to environmental shock unmasked cryptic genetic variations, allowing smaller or bigger eyes to be expressed in different individuals.
"On the surface, in an environment of light, bigger eyes are more helpful than tiny eyes. But once the fish gets into the cave, if that (genetic variation) is unmasked, it doesn't matter if you have small eyes or big eyes because it is completely dark," Jeffery says. The paper suggests that fish that expressed smaller eyes, and eventually no eyes, were selected for because it provided an adaptive advantage.
"That is controversial," Jeffery says, noting that it is difficult even for scientists in the field to conceive of the purpose of losing eyes. The paper proposes several possible advantages of eyelessness, such as allowing the animal to conserve the large amount of energy it takes to maintain an eye and to expend it, instead, on traits that are useful in a dark environment.
The descent of the surface-dwelling Astyanas mexicanus into the cave a few million years ago "is a very, very recent event, in evolutionary terms," Jeffery says. "We are talking about a rapid evolutionary process here, as opposed to the 500 million years of natural selection that have unfolded since most animal [groups] appeared during the Cambrian Period. The fact that these eyeless cavefish are so young makes them very attractive to understand evolutionary processes at their beginning."
INFORMATION:
Citation:
Rohner H, Jarosz DF, Kowalko JE, Yoshizawa M, Jeffery WR, Borowsky RL, Lindquist S, and Tabin CJ (2013) Cryptic variation in morphological evolution: HSP90 as a capacitor for loss of eyes in a cavefish. Science: 10.1126/science.1240276
The Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL) is dedicated to scientific discovery and improving the human condition through research and education in biology, biomedicine, and environmental science. Founded in Woods Hole, Massachusetts, in 1888, the MBL is a private, nonprofit institution and an affiliate of the University of Chicago.
Blind cavefish offer evidence for alternative mechanism of evolutionary change
2013-12-13
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Sniffing out danger: Rutgers scientists say fearful memories can trigger heightened sense of smell
2013-12-13
Sniffing out danger: Rutgers scientists say fearful memories can trigger heightened sense of smell
Findings could provide better understanding of anxiety disorders like PTSD
Most people – including scientists – assumed we can't just sniff out danger.
It was ...
NIH study links family structure to high blood pressure in African-American men
2013-12-13
NIH study links family structure to high blood pressure in African-American men
Children of 2-parent homes grow up to have lower rates of adult hypertension
In a study of African-American men, researchers from the National Institutes ...
Bureau of Reclamation & Santa Ana Watershed Project Authority complete Santa Ana Watershed study
2013-12-13
Bureau of Reclamation & Santa Ana Watershed Project Authority complete Santa Ana Watershed study
Collaborative Report helps address impacts of climate change on the Basin's water resources
WASHINGTON - Bureau of Reclamation Commissioner Michael L. Connor released the Santa ...
Researchers at Penn help develop a dynamic model of tissue failure
2013-12-13
Researchers at Penn help develop a dynamic model of tissue failure
The idea of growing replacement tissue to repair an organ, or to swap it out for an entirely new one, is rapidly transitioning from science fiction to fact. Tissue engineering techniques are improving ...
Graphene-based nano-antennas may enable networks of tiny machines
2013-12-13
Graphene-based nano-antennas may enable networks of tiny machines
Networks of nanometer-scale machines offer exciting potential applications in medicine, industry, environmental protection and defense, but until now there's been one very small problem: the limited ...
Dec. 2013 Lithosphere now available online
2013-12-13
Dec. 2013 Lithosphere now available online
Boulder, Colo., USA - In the latest issue of The Geological Society of America journal Lithosphere: Learn more about the Great Slave Lake shear zone in northwest Canada (open access article); the tectonic development of the ...
Helping cancer researchers make sense of the deluge of genetic data
2013-12-13
Helping cancer researchers make sense of the deluge of genetic data
Gene Expression Barcode 3.0 sifts genetic data from 100,000 patients, 50,000 mice
MAYWOOD, IL. – A newly improved internet research tool is helping cancer researchers and physicians make sense ...
Bioethics Commission on incidental findings: Anticipate and communicate
2013-12-13
Bioethics Commission on incidental findings: Anticipate and communicate
Bioethics Commission releases ethical analysis and recommendations for clinicians, researchers, and direct-to-consumer testing companies on how ...
Bonefish spawning behavior in the Bahamas surprises researchers, should aid conservation
2013-12-13
Bonefish spawning behavior in the Bahamas surprises researchers, should aid conservation
A report to the Bahamas Ministry of Environment this week documents rarely seen pre-spawning behavior in bonefish, which should aid future conservation efforts
AMHERST, ...
Keeping the lights on
2013-12-13
Keeping the lights on
UCSB mechanical engineer Igor Mezic finds a way to predict cascading power outages
(Santa Barbara, Calif.) — A method of assessing the stability of large-scale power grids in real time could bring the world closer ...