PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Even or odd: No easy feat for the mind

2013-12-21
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Gary Lupyan
lupyan@wisc.edu
917-843-4868
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Even or odd: No easy feat for the mind MADISON — Even scientists are fond of thinking of the human brain as a computer, following sets of rules to communicate, make decisions and find a meal.

But if the brain is like a computer, why do brains make mistakes that computers don't?

Research by Gary Lupyan, a cognitive scientist and psychology professor at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, shows that our brains stumble on even the simplest rule-based calculations. Instead, humans get caught up in contextual information, even when the rules are as clear-cut as separating even numbers from odd.

Almost all adults understand that it's the last digit — and only the last digit —that determines whether a number is even, including participants in Lupyan's study. But that didn't keep them from mistaking a number like 798 for odd.

A significant minority of people, regardless of their formal education, believe 400 is a better even number than 798, according to Lupyan, and also systematically mistake numbers like 798 for odd. After all, it is mostly odd, right?

"Most of us would attribute an error like that to carelessness, or not paying attention," says Lupyan, whose work was published recently in the journal Cognition. "But some errors may appear more often because our brains are not as well equipped to solve purely rule-based problems."

Asked in experiments to sort numbers, shapes, and people into simple categories like evens, triangles, and grandmothers, study subjects often broke simple rules in favor of context.

For example, when asked to consider a contest open only to grandmothers and in which every eligible contestant had an equal chance of victory, people tended to think that a 68-year old woman with 6 grandchildren was more likely to win than a 39-year old woman with a newborn grandkid.

"Even though people can articulate the rules, they can't help but be influenced by perceptual details," Lupyan says. "Thinking of triangles tends to involve thinking of typical, equilateral sorts of triangles. It is difficult to focus on just the rules that make a shape a triangle, regardless of what it looks like exactly."

In many cases, eschewing rules is no big deal. In fact, it can be an advantage in assessing the unfamiliar.

"This serves us quite well," Lupyan says. "If something looks and walks like a duck, chances are it's a duck."

Unless it's a math test, where rules are absolutely necessary for success. Thankfully, humans have learned to transcend their reliance on similarity.

"After all, although some people may mistakenly think that 798 is an odd number, not only can people follow such rules — though not always perfectly — we are capable of building computers that can execute such rules perfectly," Lupyan says. "That itself required very precise, mathematical cognition. A big question is where this ability comes from and why some people are better at formal rules than other people."

That question may be important to educators, who spend a great deal of time teaching rules-based systems of math and science.

"Students approach learning with biases shaped both by evolution and day-to-day experience," Lupyan says. "Rather than treating errors as reflecting lack of knowledge or as inattention, trying to understand their source may lead to new ways of teaching rule-based systems while making use of the flexibility and creative problem solving at which humans excel."

### Chris Barncard
608-890-0465
barncard@wisc.edu


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Van Allen Probes shed light on decades-old mystery

2013-12-21
Van Allen Probes shed light on decades-old mystery New research using data from NASA's Van Allen Probes mission helps resolve decades of scientific uncertainty over the origin of ultra-relativistic electrons in Earth's near space environment, and is likely to ...

Virginia Tech research overturns assumption about mercury in the Arctic

2013-12-21
Virginia Tech research overturns assumption about mercury in the Arctic Mercury concentrations in fish much lower than expected For years, scientists have assumed that if mercury is high and increasing in fish in the North American and European Arctic, the same is true of fish ...

Ohio State study shows 2 drugs help adolescents with ADHD, aggression

2013-12-21
Ohio State study shows 2 drugs help adolescents with ADHD, aggression COLUMBUS, Ohio – Prescribing both a stimulant and an antipsychotic drug to children with physical aggression and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), ...

Adult stem cells found to suppress cancer while dormant

2013-12-21
Adult stem cells found to suppress cancer while dormant Researchers at UCLA's Eli and Edythe Broad Center of Regenerative Medicine and Stem Cell Research have discovered a mechanism by which certain adult stem cells suppress their ability to initiate ...

Concussion tests' marketing outpaces scientific evidence, new review says

2013-12-20
Concussion tests' marketing outpaces scientific evidence, new review says Computerized neurocognitive testing for concussions is widely used in amateur and professional sports, but little research over the past decade proves its effectiveness, a paper ...

Classic signaling pathway holds the key to prostate cancer progression

2013-12-20
Classic signaling pathway holds the key to prostate cancer progression Approximately 1 out of every 6 American men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer, and this year alone there are expected to be nearly a quarter of a million new cases diagnosed, making prostate ...

Helping good genes win in brain cancer cells

2013-12-20
Helping good genes win in brain cancer cells Porto Alegre, Brazil - Researchers at the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), the university hospital (Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, HCPA) and the Children's Cancer Institute (Instituto ...

Stanford and Google team up to simulate key drug receptor

2013-12-20
Stanford and Google team up to simulate key drug receptor Roughly 40 percent of all medications act on cells' G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). One of these receptors, beta 2 adrenergic receptor site (B2AR), naturally transforms between two base configurations; knowing ...

UT Southwestern neuroscience researchers identify gene involved in response to cocaine

2013-12-20
UT Southwestern neuroscience researchers identify gene involved in response to cocaine DALLAS – Dec. 19, 2013 – UT Southwestern neuroscience researchers have identified a gene that controls the response to cocaine by comparing closely related ...

ASU researchers develop new device to help image key proteins at room temperature

2013-12-20
ASU researchers develop new device to help image key proteins at room temperature TEMPE, Ariz. – A group of researchers from Arizona State University are part of a larger team reporting a major advance in the study of human proteins that could open up new avenues ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Circulating tumor DNA may guide immunotherapy use in limited-stage SCLC, new study shows

Novel immunotherapy strategy shows promising long-term survival in advanced NSCLC patients with inadequate response to immune checkpoint inhibitors

Surgery after EGFR TKI shows promise in prolonging progression-free survival in metastatic NSCLC

Lung Cancer Europe study highlights communication gaps and need for shared decision-making

FANSS study demonstrates feasibility of U.S.-based lung cancer screening in Asian female nonsmokers

Well-publicized polar geoengineering ideas will not help and could harm, warn experts

Racial stereotypes can make us see weapons where they don’t exist

“Bottlebrush” particles deliver big chemotherapy payloads directly to cancer cells

New AI tool pinpoints genes, drug combos to restore health in diseased cells

Predicting where deadly brain cancer may spread next

First ever measure of boron in individual cancer cells could revolutionise drug understanding

Graz researchers discover what stiffens the aorta

Breakthrough in atomic-level etching of hafnium oxide, a promising material for advanced semiconductors

How evolution explains autism rates in humans

Swedish psychologist transforms mental health access through digital therapy revolution

Centenarian neuroscientist inspires blueprint for vibrant longevity through mentorship and connection

King’s College London researcher advances psychiatric genomics through pioneering polygenic scoring innovations

Study questions ocean origin of organics in Enceladus’s plumes

Look out for the keyhole: How to find the safest spots to deflect a hazardous asteroid

The older we get, the fewer favorite songs we have

Face‑/edge‑shared 3D perovskitoid single crystals with suppressed ion migration for stable X‑ray detector

Multiple solutions help fly embryos overcome the fundamental problem of ‘tissue tectonic collision’

GLP-1 weight-loss drugs pose hidden risks for young women

Strategies for enhancing energy‑level matching in perovskite solar cells: An energy flow perspective

3D‑printed boron‑nitrogen doped carbon electrodes for sustainable wastewater treatment via MPECVD

Screening anionic groups within zwitterionic additives for eliminating hydrogen evolution and dendrites in aqueous zinc ion batteries

New tectonic geodynamics textbook bridges scientific disciplines

Tiny and powerful – metamaterial lenses for your phones and drones

Study used AI models to improve prediction of chronic kidney disease progression to end stage renal disease

Peanut shell biochar composite shows promise for removing antibiotic-resistant bacteria from aquaculture wastewater

[Press-News.org] Even or odd: No easy feat for the mind