(Press-News.org) Contact information: Itzhak Ben-David
Bendavid@fisher.osu.edu
Ohio State University
1 'villain' of the housing crisis played only a small role
Mortgage defaults still high after predatory lenders forced out
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- One of the major factors blamed for the subprime mortgage crisis may have actually played only a minor role in the housing meltdown, new research reveals.
Some people claim that high mortgage default rates which helped crash the economy in 2008 were the fault of predatory lenders who approved risky housing loans to unqualified buyers.
But a study of an anti-predatory lending program in Chicago found that the program brought down default rates only modestly, while causing major disruptions in the market.
"Our results suggest that even without any predatory lending during the housing boom period, we still would have had a subprime crisis," said Itzhak Ben-David, co-author of the study and associate professor of finance at Ohio State University's Fisher College of Business.
"Predatory lending was responsible for only about a quarter of the default rate, suggesting it wasn't the most important driver of the subprime crisis."
The study will appear in the Journal of Financial Economics.
Ben-David and his colleagues analyzed the effects of a pilot anti-predatory lending program, passed by the Illinois legislature, which was implemented in Chicago in 2006, near the peak of the housing boom.
Under the program, certain mortgage applicants with low credit scores, as well as those who applied for risky loans, were required to submit their loan offers for review by financial counselors. The counselors identified loans that had above-market interest rates, loans that appeared to be unaffordable based on the borrowers' financial situations and loans that had indications of fraud.
The belief was that these counselors could steer applicants away from unsuitable loans, although applicants did not have to follow the advice they received.
The program was implemented in 10 zip codes in the Chicago area. The researchers compared loan applications in those areas to those that originated in 10 zip codes which had similar demographic characteristics, but where the program was not in effect.
The program had a huge impact on mortgage loans in the affected areas, Ben-David said.
The number of mortgage loans that originated in the program area dropped by nearly half, mainly because lenders specializing in risky loans left the area.
"Many lenders decided they just didn't want to deal with the new regulations and exited the market," Ben-David said. "Many of these lenders had some characteristics that could be tied to predatory lending."
The loans that were issued in the program area were less likely to feature "risky" characteristics, as defined by the legislation, and tended to go to borrowers with higher credit ratings.
But the key finding of the study was that default rates declined only modestly as a result of this program. The default rate in the communities served by the new program fell from 27 percent to about 20 to 21 percent.
"A default rate of 20 percent is still quite high. Our findings suggest that predatory lending was responsible for only about a quarter of mortgage defaults in the targeted area," Ben-David said.
The problem, Ben-David said, was that the program helped drive out bad lenders, but not bad loans.
"They eliminated predatory loans, but not reckless loans," he said. "People still bought homes that they couldn't afford and lenders were still willing to approve their mortgages."
The pilot program was supposed to last four years, but was ended after just four months because of strong opposition, not only from people in the real estate industry, but also from local residents and community leaders who were supposed to be helped from the law.
Many people saw the law as infringing on their right to pursue the American dream of homeownership, Ben-David said.
"In the end, the program had good intentions but came at a very high cost for the limited benefits it provided," Ben-David said.
###
Other co-authors of the study were Sumit Agarwal of the National University of Singapore; Gene Amromin of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago; Souphala Chomsisengphet and Douglas Evanhoff of the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.
1 'villain' of the housing crisis played only a small role
Mortgage defaults still high after predatory lenders forced out
2014-01-06
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Marriage promotion has failed to stem poverty among single moms
2014-01-06
Marriage promotion has failed to stem poverty among single moms
On 50th anniversary of War on Poverty, expert says new approach needed
COLUMBUS, Ohio – As the United States marks the 50th anniversary of the War on Poverty this month, a new report suggests one ...
Researchers find that computer components can be damaged by key manufacturing processes
2014-01-06
Researchers find that computer components can be damaged by key manufacturing processes
Manufacturers of increasingly minute computer chips, transistors and other products will have to take special note of research findings at the University of Huddersfield. The ...
New discovery of biomarker to improve diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of ESCC
2014-01-06
New discovery of biomarker to improve diagnosis, prognosis and treatment of ESCC
Latest study by NUS researchers first to demonstrate that editing of protein-making sequences promotes development of Esophageal Squamous Cell Carcinoma
Esophageal Squamous Cell ...
Technology 1 step ahead of war laws
2014-01-06
Technology 1 step ahead of war laws
Los Angeles, London (January 06, 2013). Today's emerging military technologies—including unmanned aerial vehicles, directed-energy weapons, lethal autonomous robots, and cyber weapons like Stuxnet—raise the prospect of upheavals ...
The loving touch is critical for premature infants
2014-01-06
The loving touch is critical for premature infants
Philadelphia, PA, January 6, 2014 – The benefit that premature infants gain from skin-to-skin contact with their mothers is measurable even 10 years after birth, reports a new study in Biological Psychiatry.
Physical ...
CWRU researcher finds released inmates need programs to meet basic and mental health needs
2014-01-06
CWRU researcher finds released inmates need programs to meet basic and mental health needs
When inmates with severe mental illness are released from jail, their priority is finding shelter, food, money and clothes. Even needs as basic as soap and a ...
Suicide risk doesn't differ in children taking 2 types of commonly prescribed antidepressants
2014-01-06
Suicide risk doesn't differ in children taking 2 types of commonly prescribed antidepressants
A Vanderbilt University Medical Center study released today shows there is no evidence that the risk of suicide differs with two commonly prescribed ...
Laying money on the line leads to healthier food choices over time
2014-01-06
Laying money on the line leads to healthier food choices over time
People are more likely to choose healthy options at the grocery store if they use the risk of losing their monthly healthy food discount as a motivational tool, according ...
MRSA infection rates drop in Veterans Affairs long-term care facilities
2014-01-06
MRSA infection rates drop in Veterans Affairs long-term care facilities
Washington, DC, January 6, 2014 – Four years after implementing a national initiative to reduce methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) rates in Veterans Affairs (VA) long-term care facilities, ...
Stimulating brain cells stops binge drinking, animal study finds
2014-01-06
Stimulating brain cells stops binge drinking, animal study finds
Results suggest it may be possible to use gene therapy in the brain to treat substance abuse, neurological diseases and mental illnesses
BUFFALO, N.Y. – Researchers at the University at Buffalo have ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Treetop Tutorials: Orangutans learn how to build their beds by peering at others and a lot of practice!
Scientists uncover key protein in cellular fat storage
Study finds significant health benefits from gut bugs transfer
UC Riverside pioneers way to remove private data from AI models
Total-body PET imaging takes a look at long COVID
Surgery to treat chronic sinus disease more effective than antibiotics
New online tool could revolutionize how high blood pressure is treated
Around 90% of middle-aged and older autistic adults are undiagnosed in the UK, new review finds
Robot regret: New research helps robots make safer decisions around humans
Cells ‘vomit’ waste to promote healing, mouse study reveals
Wildfire mitigation strategies can cut destruction by half, study finds
Sniffing out how neurons are made
New AI tool identifies 1,000 ‘questionable’ scientific journals
Exploring the promise of human iPSC-heart cells in understanding fentanyl abuse
Raina Biosciences unveils breakthrough generative AI platform for mRNA therapeutics featured in Science
Yellowstone’s free roaming bison drive grassland resilience
Turbulent flow in heavily polluted Tijuana River drives regional air quality risks
Revealed: Genetic shifts that helped tame horses and made them rideable
Mars’ mantle is a preserved relic of its ancient past, seismic data reveals
Variation inside and out: cell types in fruit fly metamorphosis
Mount Sinai researchers use AI and lab tests to predict genetic disease risk
When bison are room to roam, they reawaken the Yellowstone ecosystem
Mars’s interior more like Rocky Road than Millionaire’s Shortbread, scientists find
Tijuana River’s toxic water pollutes the air
Penn engineers send quantum signals with standard internet protocol
Placebo pain relief works differently across human body, study finds
New method could monitor corrosion and cracking in a nuclear reactor
Pennington Biomedical researchers find metabolic health of pregnant women may matter more than weight gain
World’s first custom anterior cervical spine surgery
Quantum Research Sciences developing AI platform to help Air Force more efficiently connect with industry
[Press-News.org] 1 'villain' of the housing crisis played only a small roleMortgage defaults still high after predatory lenders forced out