(Press-News.org) Contact information: Dr. Anna-Sabine Ernst
presse@iqwig.de
49-022-135-6850
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care
Dabrafenib in melanoma: Added benefit not proven
No differences could be shown for mortality, symptoms and quality of life / concerning side effects, data too uncertain
Dabrafenib (trade name: Tafinlar) has been approved in Germany since August 2013 for the treatment of advanced melanoma.In an early benefit assessment pursuant to the Act on the Reform of the Market for Medicinal Products (AMNOG), the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) examined whether this new drug offers an added benefit over the appropriate comparator therapy.
According to the findings, an added benefit of dabrafenib is not proven: Regarding mortality, symptoms, health-related quality of life and treatment discontinuation due to side effects, no advantage can be derived from the dossier. Concerning other side effects, the data were too uncertain to allow drawing any conclusions.
G-BA specified dacarbazine as appropriate comparator therapy
Dabrafenib is an option for adult patients with melanoma that has a certain abnormal protein (BRAF V600 mutation) and that is unresectable or has already formed metastases.
The Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) has specified the drug dacarbazine as the appropriate comparator therapy.
Study allowed treatment switching
One study (BREAK-3), which directly compared dabrafenib and dacarbazine, was included in the assessment. It was envisaged from the beginning of the study that patients could switch from the dacarbazine to the dabrafenib group as soon as the x-ray showed progression of the disease (radiological progression).
Because of the treatment switching it remained unclear which treatment caused the results observed – this was the case for mortality as well as for symptoms, quality of life and side effects. Hence the reliability of the conclusions of the study results was very limited from the outset.
No survival advantage
The data on overall survival showed no statistically significant difference between the treatment groups. However, the manufacturer claimed an advantage for survival in its dossier, and particularly cited the measured time that patients survived without a progression of the disease becoming visible in the x-ray (PFS = progression-free survival).
This is a so-called surrogate outcome, however. It is only reasonable to use such a surrogate parameter if the effect of the treatment on the surrogate (PFS) predicts the effect the treatment has on the patient-relevant outcome (overall survival). However, since this relationship between PFS and overall survival was not shown in the dossier following the necessary scientific criteria, IQWiG could not use the data on PFS for the assessment.
Data on quality of life were partly not evaluable
Health-related quality of life was recorded in the study using two different questionnaires. In the case of the instrument particularly developed for cancer diseases (EORTC QLQ-C30), there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups. In case of the questionnaire EQ-5D, a comprehensive instrument for various indications, no evaluable results were available.
There were also no relevant differences between the two treatment arms regarding symptoms.
Side effects: data uncertainty because of different treatment lengths
The available data hardly allow any conclusions on side effects. The main reason is that the length of treatment and observation was different for the patients in the two study arms – with an average length of 4.9 months for dabrafenib and of 2.8 months for dacarbazine. However, the longer a treatment lasts, the more likely it becomes that side effects occur. Hence the results are biased to the disadvantage of dabrafenib and not informative for most aspects concerning side effects.
The only exception is the outcome "treatment discontinuation due to side effects". However, there were no statistically significant group differences.
Because there were no positive effects regarding mortality, symptoms and quality of life, and the data on side effects were too uncertain, overall, IQWiG sees no proof of added benefit of dabrafenib compared with dacarbazine.
G-BA decides on the extent of added benefit
The dossier assessment is part of the overall procedure for early benefit assessments supervised by the G-BA. After publication of the manufacturer's dossier and IQWiG's assessment, the G-BA conducts a commenting procedure, which may provide further information and result in a change to the benefit assessment. The G‑BA then decides on the extent of the added benefit, thus completing the early benefit assessment.
An overview of the results of IQWiG's benefit assessment is given by a German-language executive summary. In addition, the website gesundheitsinformation.de, published by IQWiG, provides easily understandable and brief German-language information on dabrafenib.
The G-BA website contains both general English-language information on benefit assessment pursuant to §35a Social Code Book (SGB) V and specific German-language information on the assessment of dabrafenib.
### END
Dabrafenib in melanoma: Added benefit not proven
No differences could be shown for mortality, symptoms and quality of life / concerning side effects, data too uncertain
2014-01-07
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Aflibercept in macular oedema: Added benefit not proven
2014-01-07
Aflibercept in macular oedema: Added benefit not proven
Neither the new drug nor the comparator therapy was used in accordance with their approvals in the studies
For the third time in one year, the German Institute for Quality ...
Increased risk of prostate cancer in African American men; implications for PSA screening
2014-01-07
Increased risk of prostate cancer in African American men; implications for PSA screening
New Rochelle, NY, January 7, 2014—African American men have an increased risk of prostate cancer and are two times more likely than Caucasian American ...
Sugar-burning in the adult human brain is associated with continued growth, and remodeling
2014-01-07
Sugar-burning in the adult human brain is associated with continued growth, and remodeling
Research published in the journal Cell Metabolism shows that hotspots of fuel consumption in the adult brain also show key characteristics of developing brain regions
SEATTLE, ...
A CNIO research team discovers new regulators of the most prevalent liver disease
2014-01-07
A CNIO research team discovers new regulators of the most prevalent liver disease
AP-1 proteins modulate fat accumulation in the liver, a disease termed fatty liver disease (FLD); the pharmacological manipulation of these proteins might help treating ...
Teriflunomide in multiple sclerosis: Added benefit not proven
2014-01-07
Teriflunomide in multiple sclerosis: Added benefit not proven
Regarding side effects, there are both positive and negative effects in comparison with beta interferon 1a
Teriflunomide (trade name: Aubagio) has been approved in Germany ...
NREL finds a new cellulose digestion mechanism by a fast-eating enzyme
2014-01-07
NREL finds a new cellulose digestion mechanism by a fast-eating enzyme
CelA digests cellulose faster than enzymes from commercial preparations
Researchers at the Energy Department's National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) have discovered ...
MU researcher's study of African forest elephants helps guide research efforts in the US
2014-01-07
MU researcher's study of African forest elephants helps guide research efforts in the US
Study finds that human occupation of an area may not contribute to population decline of an endangered species
COLUMBIA, Mo. – Conservation of a protected or endangered ...
Story tips from the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory, January 2014
2014-01-07
Story tips from the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory, January 2014
To arrange for an interview with a researcher, please contact the Communications staff member identified at the end of each tip. For more information on ORNL and its research ...
Might more ravens -- aided by humans -- mean 'nevermore' for sage-grouse?
2014-01-07
Might more ravens -- aided by humans -- mean 'nevermore' for sage-grouse?
BOZEMAN (January 7, 2014) – A new study by the Wildlife Conservation Society, Idaho State University and the U.S. Geological Survey suggests that habitat fragmentation and the addition of ...
On-demand vaccines possible with engineered nanoparticles
2014-01-07
On-demand vaccines possible with engineered nanoparticles
Vaccines combat diseases and protect populations from outbreaks, but the life-saving technology leaves room for improvement. Vaccines usually are made en masse in centralized locations far removed from where they ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Study unexpectedly finds living in rural, rather than urban environments in first five years of life could be a risk factor for developing type 1 diabetes
Editorial urges deeper focus on heart-lung interactions in pulmonary vascular disease
Five University of Tennessee faculty receive Fulbright Awards
5 advances to protect water sources, availability
OU Scholar awarded Fulbright for Soviet cinema research
Brain might become target of new type 1 diabetes treatments
‘Shore Wars:’ New research aims to resolve coastal conflict between oysters and mangroves, aiding restoration efforts
Why do symptoms linger in some people after an infection? A conversation on post-acute infection syndromes
Study reveals hidden drivers of asthma flare-ups in children
Physicists decode mysterious membrane behavior
New insights about brain receptor may pave way for next-gen mental health drugs
Melanoma ‘sat-nav’ discovery could help curb metastasis
When immune commanders misfire: new insights into rheumatoid arthritis inflammation
SFU researchers develop a new tool that brings blender-like lighting control to any photograph
Pups in tow, Yellowstone-area wolves trek long distances to stay near prey
AI breakthrough unlocks 'new' materials to replace lithium-ion batteries
Making molecules make sense: A regional explanation method reveals structure–property relationships
Partisan hostility, not just policy, drives U.S. protests
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: August 1, 2025
Young human blood serum factors show potential to rejuvenate skin through bone marrow
Large language models reshape the future of task planning
Narrower coverage of MS drugs tied to higher relapse risk
Researchers harness AI-powered protein design to enhance T-cell based immunotherapies
Smartphone engagement during school hours among US youths
Online reviews of health care facilities
MS may begin far earlier than previously thought
New AI tool learns to read medical images with far less data
Announcing XPRIZE Healthspan as Tier 5 Sponsor of ARDD 2025
Announcing Immortal Dragons as Tier 4 Sponsor of ARDD 2025
Reporting guideline for chatbot health advice studies
[Press-News.org] Dabrafenib in melanoma: Added benefit not provenNo differences could be shown for mortality, symptoms and quality of life / concerning side effects, data too uncertain