(Press-News.org) Contact information: Robert Sanders
rlsanders@berkeley.edu
510-643-6998
University of California - Berkeley
Study dispels theories of Y chromosome's demise
Stripped-down chromosome retains key genes for fertility
A comparison of Y chromosomes in eight African and eight European men dispels the common notion that the Y's genes are mostly unimportant and that the chromosome is destined to dwindle and disappear.
"The Y chromosome has lost 90 percent of the genes it once shared with the X chromosome, and some scientists have speculated that the Y chromosome will disappear in less than 5 million years," said evolutionary biologist Melissa A. Wilson Sayres, a Miller Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of Integrative Biology at the University of California, Berkeley, and lead author of the new analysis.
Some mammals have already lost their Y chromosome, though they still have males and females and reproduce normally. And last month, researchers reported shuffling some genes in mice to create Y-less males that could produce normal offspring, leading some commentators to wonder whether the chromosome is superfluous.
"Our study demonstrates that the genes that have been maintained, and those that migrated from the X to the Y, are important, and the human Y is going to stick around for a long while," she said.
Wilson Sayres and coauthor Rasmus Nielsen, UC Berkeley professor of integrative biology, show in a paper published online today (Jan. 9, 2014) in PLOS Genetics that patterns of variation on the Y chromosome among the 16 men are consistent with natural selection acting to maintain the gene content there, much of which has been shown to play a role in male fertility. The Y chromosome's puny size – it contains 27 unique genes versus thousands on the other chromosomes – is a sign it is lean and stripped down to essentials.
"Melissa's results are quite stunning. They show that because there is so much natural selection working on the Y chromosome, there has to be a lot more function on the chromosome than people previously thought," Nielsen said.
Variations in Y chromosomes are used to track how human populations moved around the globe, and according to Nielsen, the new research will help improve estimates of humans' evolutionary history.
"Melissa has shown that this strong negative selection – natural selection to remove deleterious genes – tends to make us think the dates are older than they actually are, which gives quite different estimates of our ancestors' history," Nielsen said.
Y has degraded over past 200 million
Before about 200 million years ago, when mammals were relatively new on Earth, early versions of the sex chromosomes, X and Y, were just like other pairs of chromosomes: with each generation, they swapped a few genes so that offspring were a mix of their parents' genes. Fertilized eggs that got two proto-Xs became females and eggs with a proto-X and proto-Y became males.
But for some reason, Wilson Sayres said, the gene that triggers the cascade of events that result in male features became fixed on the Y chromosome and attracted other male-specific genes, such as those that control development of the testes, sperm and semen. Many of these turned out to be harmful for females, so the X and Y stopped swapping genes and the two chromosomes began to evolve separately.
"Now the X and Y do not swap DNA over most of their lengths, which means that the Y cannot efficiently fix mistakes, so it has degraded over time," she said. "In XX females, the X still has a partner to swap with and fix mistakes, which is why we think the X hasn't also degraded."
Wilson Sayres was fascinated by the strange history of the sex chromosomes and in particular the lack of genetic variation worldwide on the Y chromosome compared to the variety seen in DNA on the non-sex chromosomes. This variation, though used to chart human history, was poorly characterized across the entire Y chromosome.
"Y chromosomes are more similar to each other than we expect," said Wilson Sayres. "There has been some debate about whether this is because there are fewer males contributing to the next generation, or whether natural selection is acting to remove variation."
Did fewer males contribute genes to Y chromosome?
The UC Berkeley researchers demonstrated that if fewer males were the only cause of the low variability, it would mean that fewer than 1 in 4 males throughout history had passed on their Y chromosome each generation. Variations in other human chromosomes, including the X chromosome, make this an unlikely scenario. Instead, they showed that the low variation can be explained by intense natural selection, that is, a strong evolutionary pressure to weed out bad mutations that ended up trimming the chromosome down to its essentials.
"We show that a model of purifying selection acting on the Y chromosome to remove harmful mutations, in combination with a moderate reduction in the number of males that are passing on their Y chromosomes, can explain low Y diversity," Wilson Sayres said.
The researchers also found that all 27 genes on the Y chromosome – the 17 that humans retain after 200 million years, and 10 more recently acquired but poorly understood genes – are likely affected by natural selection. Most of the newer genes, called ampliconic genes, are present in multiple copies on the chromosome and loss of one or more copies has been linked to male infertility.
"These ampliconic regions that we haven't really understood until now are evidently very important and probably should be investigated and studied for fertility," she said.
Wilson Sayres was able to precisely measure Y variability because for the first time she compared variation on a person's Y chromosome with variation on that person's other 22 chromosomes (called autosomes), the X chromosome and the mitochondrial DNA. She used whole genome data from 16 men whose DNA had been sequenced by the Mountain View-based company Complete Genomics Inc., which has the most accurate sequences of the Y chromosome. The company was recently acquired by BGI, the Bejing Genome Institute.
Cross-population studies of variation in the Y chromosome are in their infancy, she said, noting that of the more than 36 mammalian genomes sequenced to date, complete Y chromosomes are only available for three. Most of the 1,000+ human genomes already sequenced do not have sufficiently accurate coverage of the Y to make this type of comparison among individuals, but advances in technology to better characterize DNA will facilitate future analyses of the Y chromosome, she said.
###
The work was funded by UC Berkeley's Miller Institute. Kirk Lohmueller of UCLA is a coauthor of the paper.
Study dispels theories of Y chromosome's demise
Stripped-down chromosome retains key genes for fertility
2014-01-10
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Penn research helps lay out theory for metamaterials that act as an analog computer
2014-01-10
Penn research helps lay out theory for metamaterials that act as an analog computer
The field of metamaterials has produced structures with unprecedented abilities, including flat lenses, invisibility cloaks and even optical "metatronic" devices that can manipulate ...
Moderate coffee consumption does not lead to dehydration
2014-01-10
Moderate coffee consumption does not lead to dehydration
Researchers dispel the myth that coffee consumption can cause dehydration
New research(1), published today in the PLOS ONE, has found no evidence for a link between moderate coffee consumption and dehydration. The ...
Ahoy! First ocean vesicles spotted
2014-01-10
Ahoy! First ocean vesicles spotted
Scientists discover extracellular vesicles produced by ocean microbes
CAMBRIDGE, Mass-- Marine cyanobacteria — tiny ocean plants that produce oxygen and make organic carbon using sunlight and CO2 — are primary engines of ...
UNC research demonstrates 'guided missile' strategy to kill hidden HIV
2014-01-10
UNC research demonstrates 'guided missile' strategy to kill hidden HIV
The finding provides a new route to killing persistent HIV-infected cells -- a major roadblock to a cure
CHAPEL HILL, NC – Researchers at the UNC School of Medicine have ...
Marine tubeworms need nudge to transition from larvae state
2014-01-10
Marine tubeworms need nudge to transition from larvae state
Intriguing bacterium-animal interaction may have implications for boat owners and the mariculture industry, UH Manoa researchers say
A common problem at Pearl Harbor, biofouling affects harbors ...
Target canine 'superspreaders' to halt killer disease and cull fewer dogs, study suggests
2014-01-10
Target canine 'superspreaders' to halt killer disease and cull fewer dogs, study suggests
A new way to test for the parasite which causes the fatal disease leishmaniasis could help control its spread to humans and stop dogs being needlessly killed in parts ...
New clues to how bacteria evade antibiotics
2014-01-10
New clues to how bacteria evade antibiotics
Scientists have made an important advance in understanding how a subset of bacterial cells escape being killed by many antibiotics.
Cells become "persisters" by entering a state in which they stop replicating and ...
Prediction of the future flu virus
2014-01-10
Prediction of the future flu virus
Every year, influenza outbreaks claim hundreds of thousands of human lives. Though vaccination against flu is fairly efficient, the disease is difficult to exterminate because of the high evolutionary rate of the flu virus. ...
Researchers develop test to predict early onset of heart attacks
2014-01-10
Researchers develop test to predict early onset of heart attacks
LA JOLLA, CA – A new "fluid biopsy" technique that could identify patients at high risk of a heart attack by identifying specific cells as markers in the bloodstream has been developed by a group of ...
Spinal cord findings could help explain origins of limb control
2014-01-10
Spinal cord findings could help explain origins of limb control
Zebrafish study connects data between fish and mammalian locomotion
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Revised diagnostic criteria for vascular cognitive impairment and dementia—The VasCog-2-WSO criteria
The ATREIDES program in search of lost exo-Neptunes
Ancient crop discovered in the Canary Islands thanks to archaeological DNA
Placental research may transform our understanding of autism and human brain evolution
Mapping the Universe, faster and with the same accuracy
Study isolates population aging as primary driver of musculoskeletal disorders
Designing a sulfur vacancy redox disruptor for photothermoelectric and cascade‑catalytic‑driven cuproptosis–ferroptosis–apoptosis therapy
Recent advances in dynamic biomacromolecular modifications and chemical interventions: Perspective from a Chinese chemical biology consortium
CRF and the Jon DeHaan Foundation to launch TCT AI Lab at TCT 2025
Canada’s fastest academic supercomputer is now online at SFU after $80m upgrades
Architecture’s past holds the key to sustainable future
Laser correction for short-sightedness is safe and effective for older teenagers
About one in five people taking Ozempic, Wegovy or Mounjaro say food tastes saltier or sweeter than before
Taking semaglutide turns down food noise, research suggests
Type 2 diabetes may double risk of sepsis, large community-based study suggests
New quantum sensors can withstand extreme pressure
Tirzepatide more cost-effective than semaglutide in patients with knee osteoarthritis and obesity
GLP-1 drugs shown cost-effective for knee osteoarthritis and obesity
Interactive apps, AI chatbots promote playfulness, reduce privacy concerns
How NIL boosts college football’s competitive balance
Moffitt researchers develop machine learning model to predict urgent care visits for lung cancer patients
Construction secrets of honeybees: Study reveals how bees build hives in tricky spots
Wheat disease losses total $2.9 billion across the United States and Canada between 2018 and 2021
New funding fuels development of first potentially regenerative treatment for multiple sclerosis
NJIT student–faculty team wins best presentation award for ant swarm simulation
Ants defend plants from herbivores but can hinder pollination
When the wireless data runs dry
Inquiry into the history of science shows an early “inherence” bias
Picky eaters endure: Ecologists use DNA to explore diet breadth of wild herbivores
Study suggests most Americans would be healthier without daylight saving time
[Press-News.org] Study dispels theories of Y chromosome's demiseStripped-down chromosome retains key genes for fertility