(Press-News.org) Contact information: Will Fitzgerald
wbfitzgerald@mdanderson.org
713-792-9518
University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center
Study finds more targeted form of radiation improves survival in patients with head and neck cancers
IMRT reduces side effects, also improves outcomes
HOUSTON — Patients with cancers of the head and neck who received intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) - a technology designed to more precisely target cancer cells and spare nearby tissue - experienced improved outcomes, as well as reduced toxicities, compared to patients receiving conventional radiation therapy, according to new research from The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center.
The study, published in the journal Cancer, is the first to document this finding in a large population-based group, as well as the first to suggest IMRT could improve outcomes in head and neck cancer patients.
"Previous studies indicated that patients treated with IMRT did better when it came to treatment-related side effects, however these studies were not designed to examine survival," said Beth Beadle, M.D., Ph.D., assistant professor in MD Anderson's Radiation Oncology. "The survival data was not well-known because IMRT is intended to spare normal tissues but still deliver radiation to the tumor so previous models assumed it was equivalent survival at best."
IMRT employs multiple beams of radiation that allows oncologists to provide a dosage that conforms to the tumor, often at varying intensities, while limiting exposure to surrounding tissue.
Since being approved in 1999 for the treatment of head and neck cancer, IMRT use has substantially increased due to its advantages in being able to target complicated tumors while minimizing patient side effects such as xerostomia (chronic dry mouth), dental complications, fibrosis and range of motion impairments.
Researchers on the population-based retrospective study used the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) Medicare database, compiled by the National Cancer Institute, to identify 3,172 patients treated for head and neck cancer between 1999—2007 who received either conventional radiation therapy or IMRT.
In total, 1,056 patients were treated with IMRT and 2,116 were treated with conventional therapy. All head and neck cancer subtypes were included, with the most common, squamous cell carcinoma, accounting for 91.2 percent. The primary outcome was cause-specific survival (CSS), which reflects the chances of dying from head and neck cancer after 40 months of follow-up.
To account for differences in the patient population with those being treated with IMRT possibly representing a different cohort due to the evolution of treatments, researchers used propensity scoring to create a matched comparison. This scoring model takes into account age at diagnosis, gender, race/ethnicity, income and education, among other factors.
Results Show Outcomes Improved
Beadle and colleagues found that patients treated with IMRT had a statistically significant improvement in CSS compared to those treated with conventional therapy, 38.9 percent vs. 18.9 percent, respectively.
Although propensity scoring matched patients for known variables, the researchers noted there was still a possibility for bias in the two treatment groups as a result of unmeasured variables. To account for this, an instrumental variable model was used that also demonstrated IMRT increased survival.
"From a scientific perspective, the findings support the use of IMRT and suggests we can provide excellent care while optimizing cancer outcomes and reducing toxicities," Beadle said. "At a more global level, with concerns about health care financing and resource allocation, IMRT is more expensive than conventional radiation therapy, but the data suggest it's worth it."
The authors note a separate and recent study (Yong et al.) that examined the cost effectiveness of IMRT in the treatment of oropharynx cancer found reason to support its use. Despite increased upfront costs, the study found IMRT could avoid a case of xerostomia with an incremental cost of $4,532.
Beadle said additional work is required to more closely examine the cost-effectiveness of IMRT. However, she noted that if the therapy can reduce or eliminate subsequent disease recurrences, or treatment-related side effects, the cost impact could be favorable.
With observational studies, the authors said limitations do exist including the uncertainty of Medicare claims data and the absence of data for younger patients. Additionally, the authors note there was an absence of human papillomavirus (HPV) status, which may affect tumor control.
###
None of the authors have conflicts to declare.
In addition to Beadle, other authors on the all-MD Anderson study include: Thomas Buchholz, M.D., division head Department of Radiation Oncology, B. Ashleigh Guadagnolo, M.D., associate professor, Department of Radiation Oncology, Adam Garden, M.D., professor, Department of Radiation Oncology, K. Kian Ang, M.D., Ph.D., professor, Department of Radiation Oncology, Linda Elting, Dr.P.H., professor and Kai-Ping Liao, Ph.D., both of the Department of Health Services Research.
Study finds more targeted form of radiation improves survival in patients with head and neck cancers
IMRT reduces side effects, also improves outcomes
2014-01-13
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
White parents more likely to use age-appropriate car seats than non-whites
2014-01-13
White parents more likely to use age-appropriate car seats than non-whites
Race of parents remains a key predictor of whether children will be placed in the right safety seat, according to new U-M study
Ann Arbor, Mich. — White parents reported higher ...
Fear of being too skinny may put teen boys at risk for depression, steroid use
2014-01-13
Fear of being too skinny may put teen boys at risk for depression, steroid use
Steroid use more likely among depressed and bullying victims, study finds
WASHINGTON – Teenage boys who think they're too skinny when they are actually a healthy weight are ...
'Superlens' extends range of wireless power transfer
2014-01-11
'Superlens' extends range of wireless power transfer
Engineers accomplish the first relatively long-range wireless power transfer by 'beaming' electromagnetic fields
DURHAM, N.C. -- Inventor Nikola Tesla imagined the technology to transmit energy through thin air almost ...
Social media helps users embrace differences and provide support to one another, MU study finds
2014-01-11
Social media helps users embrace differences and provide support to one another, MU study finds
Lady Gaga enables followers to embrace their awkwardness while deepening the perceived relationship they feel they have with the celebrity
COLUMBIA, Mo. ...
Study: Autophagy predicts which cancer cells live and die when faced with anti-cancer drugs
2014-01-11
Study: Autophagy predicts which cancer cells live and die when faced with anti-cancer drugs
When a tumor is treated with an anti-cancer drug, some cells die and, unfortunately, some cells tend to live. A University of Colorado Cancer Center study published in the ...
Text messaging boosts flu vaccine rates in pregnant women
2014-01-11
Text messaging boosts flu vaccine rates in pregnant women
January 10, 2014 --A study by researchers at the Mailman School of Public Health evaluated the impact of text messaging reminders for influenza vaccine in a low-income obstetric ...
Complementary medicine in wide use to treat children with autism, developmental delay
2014-01-11
Complementary medicine in wide use to treat children with autism, developmental delay
Study shows large carnivore numbers and range declining worldwide
2014-01-10
Study shows large carnivore numbers and range declining worldwide
MISSOULA – New research co-written by University of Montana scientists finds steep declines in the worldwide populations and habitat range of 31 large carnivore species. The analysis, ...
Harvard scientists control cells following transplantation, from the inside out
2014-01-10
Harvard scientists control cells following transplantation, from the inside out
New work by Jeffrey Karp, Ph.D., has potential to make cell therapies more functional and efficient
Harvard stem cells scientists at Brigham and Women's Hospital and MIT can now engineer ...
Indigenous groups more vulnerable in the fight against flu
2014-01-10
Indigenous groups more vulnerable in the fight against flu
Research indicated that some Indigenous people such as in Alaska and Australia displayed limited immunity response to the effects of influenza.
Published in the Journal Proceedings of the National ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
US oil and gas air pollution causes unequal health impacts
Scientists reveal how microbes collaborate to consume potent greenhouse gas
UMass Amherst kinesiologist receives $2 million ‘outstanding researcher’ award from NIH
Wildfire peer review report for land Brandenburg, Germany, is now online
Wired by nature: Precision molecules for tomorrow's electronics
New study finds hidden body fat is linked to faster heart ageing
How a gift card could help speed up Alzheimer’s clinical research
Depression and anxiety symptoms in adults displaced by natural disasters
Cardiovascular health at the intersection of race and gender in Medicare fee for service
World’s first observation of the transverse Thomson effect
Powerful nodes for quantum networks
Mapping fat: How microfluidics and mass spectrometry reveal lipid landscapes in tiny worms
ATOX1 promotes hepatocellular carcinoma carcinogenesis via activation of the c-Myb/PI3K/AKT signaling pathway
Colibactin-producing E. coli linked to higher colorectal cancer risk in FAP patients
Animal protein not linked to higher mortality risk, study finds
Satellite insights into eutrophication trends on the Qinghai–Tibet plateau
Researchers develop an innovative method for large-scale analysis of metabolites in biological samples
Asteroid Bennu is a time capsule of materials bearing witness to its origin and transformation over billions of years
New AI model can help extend life and increase safety of electric vehicle batteries
Wildfires can raise local death rate by 67%, shows study on 2023 Hawaiʻi fires
Yogurt and hot spring bathing show a promising combination for gut health
Study explains how lymphoma rewires human genome
New Durham University study counters idea that Jupiter’s mysterious core was formed by a giant impact
Global study shows racialized, Indigenous communities face higher burden of heart disease made worse by data gaps
Hemoglobin reimagined: A breakthrough in brain disease treatment
Fresh twist to mystery of Jupiter's core
Data-driven designs to improve prosthetic legs
Under or over? The twists and turns of genetic research
Moisture changes the rules of atmospheric traffic jams
Stevens INI advances global Alzheimer’s research with support from the Simon family
[Press-News.org] Study finds more targeted form of radiation improves survival in patients with head and neck cancersIMRT reduces side effects, also improves outcomes