(Press-News.org) Contact information: Inga Kiderra
ikiderra@ucsd.edu
858-822-0661
University of California - San Diego
Drinking and driving: Unsafe at any level
Very low blood alcohol content associated with causing car crashes
Even "minimally buzzed" drivers are more often to blame for fatal car crashes than the sober drivers they collide with, reports a University of California, San Diego study of accidents in the United States .
Led by UC San Diego sociologist David Phillips and published in the British Medical Journal group's Injury Prevention, the study examined 570,731 fatal collisions, from 1994 to 2011.
The researchers used the official U.S. Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) database for the study, because it is nationally comprehensive and because it reports on blood alcohol content (BAC) in increments of 0.01 percent. They focus particularly on "buzzed drivers," with BAC of 0.01 to 0.07 percent, and, within this group, the "minimally buzzed" (or BAC 0.01 percent).
Phillips and his co-authors find that drivers with BAC 0.01 percent – well below the U.S. legal limit of 0.08 – are 46 percent more likely to be officially and solely blamed by accident investigators than are the sober drivers they collide with.
The authors also find no "threshold effect" – "no sudden transition from blameless to blamed" at the legal limit for drunk driving. Instead, blame increases steadily and smoothly from BAC 0.01to 0.24 percent.
Despite this evidence, "buzzed" drivers are often not punished more severely than their sober counterparts. In practice, Phillips said, police, judges and the public at large treat BAC 0.08 percent as "a sharp, definitive, meaningful boundary," and do not impose severe penalties on those below the legal limit. That needs to change, Phillips said. "The law should reflect what official accident investigators are seeing."
The researchers measured blame by looking at more than 50 driver factors coded in the FARS database, including such "unambiguous" factors as driving through a red light or driving on the wrong side of the road.
Many of the study's analyses take advantage of what the authors call "a natural experiment": two-vehicle collisions between a sober and a drinking driver. "Because the two drivers collide in exactly the same circumstances and at exactly the same time," they write, "this natural experiment automatically standardizes many potentially confounding variables," including weather and roadway conditions.
The findings are unequivocal, Phillips said. "We find no safe combination of drinking and driving – no point at which it is harmless to consume alcohol and get behind the wheel of a car," Phillips said. "Our data support both the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's campaign that 'Buzzed driving is drunk driving' and the recommendation made by the National Transportation Safety Board, to reduce the legal limit to BAC 0.05 percent. In fact, our data provide support for yet greater reductions in the legal BAC."
Phillips noted that, although federal agencies recommend reducing the legal BAC limit below 0.08 percent, there has been very little research on the dangers of driving at very low levels of BAC. "We appear to be the first researchers to have provided nationwide evidence on traffic accidents caused by minimally buzzed drivers," he said.
More than 100 countries around the world have limits set at BAC 0.05 percent or below.
In calling on all 50 U.S. states to follow suit, NTSB Chairman Deborah A.P. Hersman said in a statement last spring: "Alcohol-impaired crashes are not accidents. They are crimes. They can – and should – be prevented. The tools exist. What is needed is the will."
###
Study coauthors are: Rebecca Moshfegh, an undergraduate student in the UC San Diego Department of Economics, and Ana Luisa Sousa, a recent sociology graduate of UC San Diego, currently at the USC Gould School of Law.
The current study follows up on a paper Phillips published in 2011 showing that buzzed driving is associated with greater accident severity.
Drinking and driving: Unsafe at any level
Very low blood alcohol content associated with causing car crashes
2014-01-17
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Natural 3-D counterpart to graphene discovered
2014-01-17
Natural 3-D counterpart to graphene discovered
Researchers at Berkeley Lab's Advanced Light Source find new form of quantum matter
The discovery of what is essentially a 3D version of graphene – the 2D sheets of carbon through which electrons race at ...
Fighting flies
2014-01-17
Fighting flies
Caltech biologists identify sex-specific brain cells in male flies that promote aggression
When one encounters a group of fruit flies invading their kitchen, it probably appears as if the whole group is vying for a sweet treat. ...
1 step at a time, researchers learning how humans walk
2014-01-17
1 step at a time, researchers learning how humans walk
CORVALLIS, Ore. – Humans and some of our hominid ancestors such as Homo erectus have been walking for more than a million years, and researchers are close to figuring out how we do it.
It's ...
Early warning: Internet surveillance predicts disease outbreak
2014-01-17
Early warning: Internet surveillance predicts disease outbreak
The habit of Googling for an online diagnosis before visiting a GP can provide early warning of an infectious disease epidemic.
In a new study published in Lancet Infectious ...
New insights into facial transplantation
2014-01-17
New insights into facial transplantation
During rejection episodes, donor T cells are significantly involved
Boston, MA—In 2009, the first face transplant was performed at Brigham and Women's Hospital (BWH), and lead surgeon, Dr. Bohdan Pomahac has been pioneering ...
KAIST participates in the 2014 Davos Forum on Jan. 22-25 in Switzerland
2014-01-17
KAIST participates in the 2014 Davos Forum on Jan. 22-25 in Switzerland
Through the sessions of the Global University Leaders Forum, IdeasLab, and Sustainability-Innovation-Growth, KAIST participants will actively engage with global ...
Not just clean but spotless -- Researchers show how cells tidy up
2014-01-17
Not just clean but spotless -- Researchers show how cells tidy up
Autophagy – or how cells tidy up
"Bang and the dirt is gone!" There are many commercials for products that claim to make the unpopular process of cleaning up easier. But it's not only our surroundings ...
Most women undergoing surgery for vulvar cancer maintain healthy body image and sex life
2014-01-17
Most women undergoing surgery for vulvar cancer maintain healthy body image and sex life
A new study finds that most women who undergo conservative surgery for vulvar cancer experience little to no long-term disruption to sexuality and body image. Published early online ...
2 million people eligible for weight loss surgery
2014-01-17
2 million people eligible for weight loss surgery
Two million people in England could be eligible for weight loss surgery according to new research published today by JRSM Open, the open access companion publication of the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. The ...
A new toad from the 'warm valleys' of Peruvian Andes
2014-01-17
A new toad from the 'warm valleys' of Peruvian Andes
A new species of toad was discovered hiding in the leaf litter of the Peruvian Yungas. The word is used widely by the locals to describe ecoregion of montane rainforests, and translates as "warm valley" in English. The ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
The diagnosis and evolving treatment landscape of systemic light chain amyloidosis
Lactylation in gynecological malignancies: a bridge between lactate metabolism and epigenetic therapy
Immune cell phenotypes, inflammatory proteins and epilepsy
Olfaction and coronary heart disease
Consistent adherence to physical activity guidelines and digestive system cancer risk and mortality
Beliefs about the effect of alcohol use on cancer risk in the us adult population
Comprehensive molecular profiling of renal medullary carcinoma identifies TROP2 as a promising therapeutic target
Breast cancer risk varies between different hormonal contraceptives
Immature brain-supporting cells switch fate to restore blood flow after stroke
Making more supply to meet the demands of muscle cell therapy
Americans have widespread misbeliefs about the cancer risks of alcohol, study finds
JMIR Publications’ Journal of Medical Internet Research invites submissions on Digital Health Strategic Planning
New cancer drug shows exceptional tumor-fighting potential
Spectral shaper provides unprecedented control over 10,000 laser frequency comb lines
Global Virus Network welcomes new centers of excellence across the Americas
Africa acacias ‘go for broke’ to grow, use up water to survive drought
An app, an Apple Watch and AI: UMass Amherst creates a new way for researchers to study sleep health
Sharing positive emotions with a partner is good for health
Ergonomic insect headgear and abdominal buckle with surface stimulators manufactured via multimaterial 3D printing snap-and-secure installation of noninvasive sensory stimulators for cyborg insects
Pharmacological insights into Scleromitrion diffusum (Willd.) against gastric cancer: active components and mechanistic pathways
Advanced imaging strategies based on intelligent micro/nanomotors
How climate-damaging nitrous oxide forms in the ocean
N6-methyladenosine methylation emerges as a key target for treating acute lung injury
Distributor-type membrane reactor for carbon dioxide methanation
Mapping the missing green: An AI framework boosts urban greening in Tokyo
Pharmacists help cancer patients manage high blood sugar more effectively
Babies’ gut bacteria may influence future emotional health
Scientists create new type of semiconductor that holds superconducting promise
Genes associated with obesity shared across ancestries, researchers find
Antidepressants improve core depressive symptoms early on
[Press-News.org] Drinking and driving: Unsafe at any levelVery low blood alcohol content associated with causing car crashes