PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

HIV medications dialogue differs by race, ethnicity

2014-01-27
(Press-News.org) Contact information: David Orenstein
david_orenstein@brown.edu
401-863-1862
Brown University
HIV medications dialogue differs by race, ethnicity PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — A lot of evidence shows that a patients' race or ethnicity is associated with differences in how health care providers communicate with them, the health care they receive, and their health outcomes. In HIV care, a key to those outcomes is whether people take their medications as prescribed. A new study of the doctor-patient dialogue about HIV drug adherence found several specific differences in those conversations depending on patients' race and ethnicity.

The study, which appears online Jan. 25 in the journal AIDS and Behavior, is based on a highly structured analysis of recorded office visits between 45 health care providers and 404 patients, 245 of whom were black and 59 of whom were Hispanic. Researchers used the Generalized Medical Interaction Analysis, which divides the dialogue into units called "utterances" based on speech acts such as asking questions, giving information, giving instructions, making requests, or expressing desires. It also classifies the topic or subject matter of each utterance.

Lead author M. Barton Laws, assistant professor (research) of health services policy and practice in the Brown University School of Public Health, and his colleagues produced three main findings:

Different speech patterns: Because black patients spoke less to their providers than either white or Hispanic patients, they experienced significantly greater provider dominance in their discussions. Black patients and their providers exchanged fewer expressions of goals or values than did Hispanics and whites. Meanwhile, providers asked Hispanic patients fewer open-ended questions and their discussions involved less humor. More dialogue about HIV drug adherence with minorities: Providers and either black or Hispanic patients exchanged a higher volume of dialogue — more utterances — about adherence than did providers and white patients. This difference occurred regardless of how adherent patients were to their medication regimens or whether lab tests showed that their disease was under control. Directives, not problem solving: In those more extensive dialogues between black and Hispanic patients with their providers, there were not any more utterances about problem-solving than for whites. Instead there were more provider directives (e.g. "Take your medicine or you'll get sick") said to the minority patients than to whites.

New hypotheses

Laws said that the research does not reveal why providers – 34 of whom were doctors and 30 of whom were white, with most of the rest of Asian ancestry — talked more with minority patients than with whites about adherence. One hypothesis – yet to be tested – is that the providers may be attempting to compensate for what they read in studies about lower adherence among minorities.

"The possibility that seems most compelling to me is the doctors don't trust their black and Hispanic patients as much to be adherent," Laws said. "It has been epidemiologically observed that they do tend to be less adherent, but it's not because they are black or Hispanic."

Other factors likely cause a lack of adherence, he said, but how the providers spoke to minority patients didn't correlate with whether they were adherent. Doctors also didn't spend much time trying to find out whether patients faced barriers to staying on their medications and helping find solutions.

In previous research analyzing office visits, Laws and colleagues found that physicians generally tended to use more directives than engage in problem solving when addressing HIV adherence. But research in behavioral counseling shows that simply exhorting people again and again does not make them more likely to engage in a desired behavior.

The emphasis on directives, rather than problem solving, is likely a product of how providers relate to all patients, he said, regardless of race. However, the other differences in the overall visits are suggestive of ways in which differences in culture and background may affect communication.

Laws cautioned that the current study does not examine whether the racial differences in the dialogue lead to different clinical outcomes, but that question can now be investigated.

"We've found there is something going on and it would be good to understand it better," Laws said. Ongoing work with collaborators is assessing whether provider communication styles can be changed, and how communication patterns are associated with outcomes.

### In addition to Laws, other authors on the paper are Yoojin Lee and Dr. Ira Wilson at Brown, William Rogers at Tufts Medical Center, Mary Catherine Beach and Richard Moore at Johns Hopkins University, Somnath Saha and P. Todd Korthuis at Oregon Health and Science University, Victoria Sharp at St. Lukes-Roosevelt in New York, and Jonathan Cohn at Wayne State University.

The research was supported by the National Institute of Mental Health (grants R34MH089279 and RO1MH083595) and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (grant: 290-01-0012).


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Study identifies high level of 'food insecurity' among college students

2014-01-27
CORVALLIS, Ore. – One of the few studies of its type has found that a startling 59 percent of college students at one Oregon university were "food insecure" at ...

Graphene-like material made of boron a possibility, experiments suggest

2014-01-27
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — Researchers from Brown University have shown experimentally that a boron-based competitor to graphene is a very real possibility. Graphene has been heralded ...

Drug to reverse breast cancer spread in development

2014-01-27
Researchers at Cardiff University are developing a novel compound known to reverse the spread of malignant breast cancer ...

Blue eyes and dark skin, that's how the European hunter-gatherer looked

2014-01-27
La Braña 1, name used to baptize a 7,000 years ...

Engineers teach old chemical new tricks to make cleaner fuels, fertilizers

2014-01-27
University researchers from two continents ...

Sensitivity of carbon cycle to tropical temperature variations has doubled, research shows

2014-01-27
The tropical carbon cycle has become ...

Cleveland Clinic researchers discover process that turns 'good cholesterol' bad

2014-01-27
Cleveland: Cleveland Clinic researchers have discovered the process by ...

Shortening guide RNA markedly improves specificity of CRISPR-Cas nucleases

2014-01-27
A simple adjustment to a powerful gene-editing tool may be able to improve its specificity. In a report receiving advance online publication in Nature Biotechnology, Massachusetts ...

How does the brain create sequences?

2014-01-27
When you learn how to play the piano, first you have to learn notes, scales and chords and only then will you be able to play a piece of music. The same ...

Long-lived breast stem cells could retain cancer legacy

2014-01-27
Researchers from Melbourne's Walter and Eliza Hall Institute have discovered that breast stem cells and their 'daughters' have a much longer lifespan than previously thought, and are active in puberty ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Process for dealing with sexual misconduct by doctors requires major reform

Severe pregnancy sickness raises risk of mental health conditions by over 50%

Early humans may have walked from Türkiye to mainland Europe, new groundbreaking research suggests

New study shows biochar’s electrical properties can influence rice field methane emissions

Guangdong faces largest chikungunya outbreak on record

Tirzepatide improves blood sugar control in children aged 10-17 years with type 2 diabetes inadequately controlled on existing therapies (SURPASS-PEDS trial)

An old drug, in a low dose, shown to be safe and effective in preventing progression of type 1 diabetes in children and young people (MELD-ATG trial)

Study reports potential effects of verapamil in slowing progression of type 1 diabetes

Fresh hope for type 1 diabetes as daily pill that slows onset confirms promise at 2-year follow-up

New estimates predict over 4 million missing people who would be alive in 2025 if not for inadequate type 1 diabetes care

So what should we call this – a grue jay?

Chicago Quantum Exchange-led coalition advances to final round in NSF Engine competition

Study identifies candidates for therapeutic targets in pediatric germ cell tumors

Media alert: The global burden of CVD

Study illuminates contributing factors to blood vessel leakage

What nations around the world can learn from Ukraine

Mixing tree species does not always make forests more drought-resilient

Public confidence in U.S. health agencies slides, fueled by declines among Democrats

“Quantum squeezing” a nanoscale particle for the first time

El Niño spurs extreme daily rain events despite drier monsoons in India

Two studies explore the genomic diversity of deadly mosquito vectors

Zebra finches categorize their vocal calls by meaning

Analysis challenges conventional wisdom about partisan support for US science funding

New model can accurately predict a forest’s future

‘Like talking on the telephone’: Quantum computing engineers get atoms chatting long distance

Genomic evolution of major malaria-transmitting mosquito species uncovered

Overcoming the barriers of hydrogen storage with a low-temperature hydrogen battery

Tuberculosis vulnerability of people with HIV: a viral protein implicated

Partnership with Kenya's Turkana community helps scientists discover genes involved in adaptation to desert living

Decoding the selfish gene, from evolutionary cheaters to disease control

[Press-News.org] HIV medications dialogue differs by race, ethnicity