(Press-News.org) DURHAM, N.C -- When students repeat a grade, it can spell trouble for their classmates, according to a new Duke University-led study of nearly 80,000 middle-schoolers.
In schools with high numbers of grade repeaters , suspensions were more likely to occur across the school community. Discipline problems were also more common among other students, including substance abuse, fighting and classroom disruption.
Public debate typically focuses on how retention affects an individual student's academic performance, said lead author Clara Muschkin. So she and her colleagues decided to take a wider view and consider how holding students back may affect the school as a whole.
"The decision to retain students has consequences for the whole school community," said Muschkin, an associate director of the Duke Center for Child and Family Policy. "That wider effect is an issue worth considering as we debate this policy."
The study by Muschkin, Elizabeth Glennie and Audrey Beck looked at 79,314 seventh-graders in 334 North Carolina middle schools.
For information on retention and discipline problems, the authors turned to administrative data from the state's public school system. The authors found that different schools have greatly varying numbers of older and retained students, with significant consequences.
The authors took pains to account for a range of factors that might offer alternative explanations for their findings, including schools' socioeconomic composition and parents' educational status. Even after controlling for such factors, the presence of older and retained students was still strongly linked with more discipline problems in the entire group.
For instance, if 20 percent of children in seventh grade were older than their peers, the chance that other students would commit an infraction or be suspended increased by 200 percent.
"There's a strong relationship here that we think is likely to be causal," Muschkin said.
The study focused on two groups in particular: students who repeated a grade, and students who were a year older than their classmates, on average. When there were more older and retained students present, discipline problems increased for all subgroups in the study, including black and white students and boys and girls. Two groups saw a particularly large jump in discipline problems: white students and girls of all races.
"This finding took us by surprise," Muschkin said. "These two groups appear to be a bit more affected than others by the influence of older peers."
In early adolescence, a time of major physical and psychological change, students are particularly vulnerable to peer influence, Muschkin noted. However, more research is needed to understand why some subgroups appear to respond more strongly than others to the influence of their classmates, she said.
Holding students back became a popular educational option as criticism of "social promotion" mounted. The study suggests that since retention has school-wide ramifications, educators should do more to assist older and retained students with their academic struggles; for instance, through tutoring, summer school and peer mentoring.
"Support for older and retained students is an investment in the achievement and climate of the entire school," Muschkin said.
The paper appears online Feb. 28 in Teachers College Record.
Research funding was provided by the National Institute on Drug Abuse, through the Duke University Transdisciplinary Prevention Research Center. Data was provided by the North Carolina Education Research Data Center at Duke University, with assistance from the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction and financial support from the Spencer Foundation.
CITATION: "Peer Contexts: Do Old for Grade and Retained Peers Influence Student Behavior and Suspensions in Middle School?," Clara G. Muschkin, Elizabeth J. Glennie and Audrey N. Beck. Teachers College Record, February 2014.
Retention leads to discipline problems in other kids
Kids who are 'held back' may contribute to disruptive middle school environment
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Dangerous mistaken identity
This news release is available in German. Proteins like the so-called heat shock protein Hsp90 play an important role in almost all processes within human cells. They help other proteins fold into their three-dimensional structure or return damaged proteins back into their proper shape. Recently, there has been increasing evidence indicating that the heat shock protein HSP90 may also be involved in the folding processes of the tau protein. Deposits of tau proteins in brain cells are typical for Alzheimer's disease and are held responsible for decaying nerve ...
Diabetes and obesity more common in socioeconomically deprived regions
Living in a socioeconomically deprived region is a risk factor for being affected by diabetes mellitus and obesity. This holds true regardless of the individual social status of the inhabitants. This is the conclusion reached by scientists from the Institute of Health Economics and Health Care Management (IGM) at the Helmholtz Zentrum München (HMGU) and the Department of Epidemiology and Health Monitoring at the Robert Koch Institute (RKI) in Berlin. "Regional factors, such as the population's average income, unemployment or quality of the living environment can affect ...
Unearthing key function of plant hormone
This news release is available in German. Plants, like animals, employ hormones as messengers, which coordinate growth and regulate how they react to the environment. One of these plant hormones, auxin, regulates nearly all aspects of plant behavior and development, for example phototropism, root growth and fruit growth. Depending on the context, auxin elicits a range of responses such as cell polarization or division. In this week's edition of Science (DOI:10.1126/science.1245125), a team of researchers including Jiri Friml from IST Austria and led by Zhenbiao ...
Scientists discover the specific types of macrophages that affect Crohn's disease severity
For those coping with Crohn's disease, a new research report published in the Journal of Leukocyte Biology offers hope for the development of new and more effective drugs. In the report, scientists show for the first time, precisely what type of immune cells are involved in driving the inflammation process in the disease. With this knowledge, new compounds can be identified which reduce the activity of these cells or lessen their inflammatory effects. "By increasing the knowledge on the different macrophage subsets in the intestine and their blood counterparts, we hope ...
York physicists pave the way for more energy efficient technology
An international team of scientists led by physicists from the University of York has paved the way for a new class of magnetic materials and devices with improved performance and power efficiency. Magnetic materials are currently used to store almost all digital information. However, with information processing and storage now making up a significant fraction of the world's energy consumption, continuing improvements in energy efficiency will require new technologies and materials. A promising development is all-optical thermally induced magnetic switching (TIMS), which ...
Emergency alert in the cell
When an organism is exposed to life-threatening conditions, it sounds the alarm and a cellular emergency program, the heat shock response, is initiated. However, the name "heat shock response" is misleading. In the beginning of the 1960s, this form of stress response was first observed. Scientists exposed fruit flies to high temperatures and discovered a complex emergency program designated to save single cells and thus the organism itself. Today researchers know that this program is also triggered by other dangers such as radiation or toxic substances. The terminology, ...
Twitter 'big data' can be used to monitor HIV and drug-related behavior, UCLA study shows
Real-time social media like Twitter could be used to track HIV incidence and drug-related behaviors with the aim of detecting and potentially preventing outbreaks, a new UCLA-led study shows. The study, published in the peer-reviewed journal Preventive Medicine, suggests it may be possible to predict sexual risk and drug use behaviors by monitoring tweets, mapping where those messages come from and linking them with data on the geographical distribution of HIV cases. The use of various drugs had been associated in previous studies with HIV sexual risk behaviors and ...
Competition breeds new fish species, study finds
Competition may play an important role during the evolution of new species, but empirical evidence for this is scarce, despite being implicit in Charles Darwin's work and support from theoretical studies. Dr Martin Genner from Bristol's School of Biological Sciences and colleagues used population genetics and experimental evidence to demonstrate a role for competition that leads to the differentiation of new species within the highly diverse cichlid fishes of Lake Tanganyika in East Africa. They found that the cichlid fish Telmatochromis temporalis shows two genetically ...
Rise in New York foreclosures means many could benefit from bankruptcy
Rise in New York foreclosures means many could benefit from bankruptcy Article provided by Michael A. Fakhoury, Esq., P.C. Visit us at http://www.fakhourylaw.com According to a report from the chief administrator of courts in New York, the number of foreclosurefilings in 2013 exceeded the totals for 2012 and 2011 combined. In some areas, the problem has been particularly pronounced. A report from the Times Herald-Record indicated that foreclosure filings approximately doubled in Orange and Ulster counties from 2012 to 2013. RealtyTrac, a company that tracks foreclosures, ...
Divorce and tax audits an unfortunately common combination
Divorce and tax audits an unfortunately common combination Article provided by Kenney & Kenney Visit us at http://www.kenney-law.com Two dreaded legal actions often occur in the early months of the year; winter is a popular time to divorce and most people are required to file a tax return before April. Unfortunately, certain actions that take place during divorce proceedings may also make it more likely to receive a tax audit. In addition, many divorcing couples have questions about how their divorce will affect their taxes. When do they file as single? Who ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
UC Irvine receives $15 million NSF grant for integrative movement research
University of Houston engineer Metin Akay featured in study highlighting 50 scientists' contributions to biomedical engineering advancements
JWST captures the end of planet formation
Good news—MS drugs taken while breastfeeding may not affect child development
Programs intended to reduce health insurance premiums may make coverage less affordable for the middle class
PrEP discontinuation in a US national cohort of sexual and gender minority populations, 2017–22
USC Study: Medicare Part D plans increased restrictions on drug coverage
Sacituzumab govitecan plus platinum-based chemotherapy in breast, bladder, and lung carcinomas
Global study unveils "problematic" use of porn
Newly discovered protein prevents DNA triplication
Less ice in the arctic ocean has complex effects on marine ecosystems and ocean productivity
Antarctica’s coasts are becoming less icy
New research shows migrating animals learn by experience
Modeling the origins of life: New evidence for an “RNA World”
Scientists put forth a smarter way to protect a smarter grid
An evolutionary mystery 125 million years in the making
Data science approach to identifying thermal conductivity-related structural factors in amorphous materials
Deciphering the male breast cancer genome
Detection of suicide-related emergencies among children using real-world clinical data: A free webinar from the Brain & Behavior Research Foundation
Editor-in-Chief of Sustainability and Climate Change Madhavi Venkatesan named USA TODAY Woman of the Year for Massachusetts for leading plastic bottle ban efforts
Tests show high-temperature superconducting magnets are ready for fusion
Zika vaccine safe, effective when administered during pregnancy
Firearm ownership is correlated with elevated lead levels in children, study finds
Role of African women and young people in agricultural service provision investigated in new CABI-led study
26th International Conference of the Redox Medicine Society Set for June 2024 in Paris, France
Geologists explore the hidden history of Colorado’s Spanish Peaks
Webb unlocks secrets of one of the most distant galaxies ever seen
3D-printed skin closes wounds and contains hair follicle precursors
Discovered a RNA molecule that helps prevent DNA replication errors
Small and overlooked: Amount of repetitive DNA in blood hints at cancer early[Press-News.org] Retention leads to discipline problems in other kids
Kids who are 'held back' may contribute to disruptive middle school environment