Patients have a right to know -- not a duty to know -- their diagnosis says new research

Defensive mechanisms protect patients from fully engaging with bad news say healthcare professionals from the University of Leicester

2014-03-06

(Press-News.org) The experiences of doctors, patients and carers of initial cancer consultations have informed new guidelines developed at the University of Leicester, in collaboration with University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust and Imperial College London, to help patients better understand their cancer consultations.

The research, published today (6 March 2014) in the British Journal of Health Psychology, found patients' experiences of being given their diagnosis differed both between participants and within the same participant. This means a doctor's role in communicating information in a patient-centred way can be very difficult.

A variety of defensive mechanisms were found to be employed by patients in order to protect themselves from fully engaging with the knowledge they had been given within an oncology consultation.

Semi-structured interviews were carried out with 36 patients and interpretive phenomenological analysis (IPA) was used to understand participants' meanings of their experiences in their initial consultation. They found patients had a 'right to know' but not a 'duty to know' their diagnosis and prognosis, and as such doctors face a difficult task in ascertaining how much detail the individual patient wants at any one time.

Research lead Professor Anne Thomas, from the University of Leicester's Department of Cancer Studies and Molecular Medicine, said: "The accounts from patients of what they wished to know in the consultation could be affected by a desire to protect themselves and/or family members from the distress of bad news.

"With this in mind, the complexity of patients' needs and preferences regarding information means that the doctor's role in communicating that information in a patient-centric way is difficult, especially as we also found that patients' needs varied over time.

Additionally, it is also difficult for doctors to know whether or not the information they disclosed about diagnosis, prognosis and treatments was wanted or understood."

Using information from this analysis and data from a larger study, the researchers have developed a consultation aid for doctors and patients to refer to that will identify the patients' preferences with regard to 'knowing and not knowing'.

Dr Lynn Furber, Senior Nurse Researcher from University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust, added: "It was imperative to us to be able to use our research findings to develop a tool based on what patients and doctors told us was important to improve their experiences and provide them with information in a timely and efficient manner.

"This should provide the doctors with better information so that they are able to conduct consultations in a more patient-centred manner. Whilst an oncology consultation that involves giving bad news to patients is likely to be a difficult experience for both doctor and patient, it is hoped that the consultation aid will lead to an increase in patient satisfaction, and help inform doctors on how to meet the individual patients' needs."

The researchers now hope to expand on this pilot study to explore the acceptability and usability of their consultation support tool.

Once they have proved its effectiveness in practice, it is hoped that it will be adopted into current patient pathways.

INFORMATION: END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Working pressures increase children attending nursery with respiratory tract infections

2014-03-06

Working parents are often caught between the needs of their sick child and their job, which can lead to continued day care use even when their child is ill. New research has found children going to nursery when they are unwell with respiratory tract infections (RTIs) may be an important factor in the spread of these illnesses in the community. The findings, to be presented today [Thursday 6 March] at the South West Society for Academic Primary Care (SW SPAC) meeting, explored why parents send their children to nursery when they are unwell. The Parents' Choices About ...

How the internet is transforming our experience of being ill

2014-03-06

The last decade has seen a remarkable shift in how people use the internet in relation to their health and it is now talked of as a routine feature of being ill. Professor Sue Ziebland, Director of the Health Experiences Research Group, based in the Nuffield Department of Primary Health Care at the University of Oxford, will share these findings with health practitioners and researchers at the South West Society for Academic Primary Care (SW SAPC) meeting hosted by the Centre for Academic Primary Care at the University of Bristol, today [Thursday 6 March]. This study ...

Low saturated fat diets don't curb heart disease risk or help you live longer

2014-03-06

Diets low in saturated fat don't curb heart disease risk or help you live longer, says a leading US cardiovascular research scientist and doctor of pharmacy in an editorial in the open access journal Open Heart. And current dietary advice to replace saturated fats with carbohydrates or omega 6-rich polyunsaturated fats is based on flawed and incomplete data from the 1950s, argues Dr James DiNicolantonio. Dietary guidelines should be urgently reviewed and the vilification of saturated fats stopped to save lives, he insists. DiNicolantonio points out that the demonisation ...

New 'willful neglect' offense needed for healthcare sector, say lawyers

2014-03-06

A new criminal offence of "wilful neglect" is needed for individuals and organisations in the healthcare sector, to send out a clear message that appalling care warrants public censure and sanction, say leading lawyers in the journal BMJ Quality & Safety. Existing regulation is not up to the job, argue Professors Karen Yeung of The Dickson Poon School of Law, King's College London, and Jeremy Horder of the Department of Law at the London School of Economics. Many patients are just as vulnerable as those who are mentally incapacitated, they point out, yet they do not ...

New terms used for trainee doctors stump nurses and patients

2014-03-06

Nurses and patients are struggling to identify qualified doctors or to grade their seniority from their generic name badges, finds a survey of one hospital in England, published online in BMJ Quality & Safety. The findings prompt the researchers to call for a review of currently used terminology, deployed since the Modernisation of Medical Careers initiative in 2009, which revamped the length of training and introduced a range of new job titles. Staff and patients must be able to correctly identify professional status and communicate effectively, if optimal care is ...

Long-lasting device protects against HIV and pregnancy

2014-03-06

EVANSTON, Ill. --- Women's reproductive health may never be the same, thanks to Northwestern University biomedical engineer Patrick Kiser and his first-of-its-kind intravaginal ring that reliably delivers an antiretroviral drug and a contraceptive for months. Kiser's one ring delivers two drugs that do three important things: the device is designed to protect against HIV and herpes as well as unwanted pregnancy. It will be the first device with the potential to offer this protection to be tested in women. The easy-to-use ring delivers controlled doses of tenofovir (a ...

Gene therapy locks out HIV, paving the way to control virus without antiretroviral drug

2014-03-06

PHILADELPHIA—University of Pennsylvania researchers have successfully genetically engineered the immune cells of 12 HIV positive patients to resist infection, and decreased the viral loads of some patients taken off antiretroviral drug therapy (ADT) entirely—including one patient whose levels became undetectable. The study, appearing today in the New England Journal of Medicine, is the first published report of any gene editing approach in humans. The phase I study was co-authored by researchers at Penn Medicine, the Albert Einstein College of Medicine and scientists ...

Human activity influences beach bacterial diversity

2014-03-06

Human activity influences ocean beach bacterial communities, and bacterial diversity may indicate greater ecological health and resiliency to sewage contamination, according to results published March 5, 2014, in the open access journal PLOS ONE by Elizabeth Halliday from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution and colleagues. Beaches all contain bacteria, but some bacteria are usually from sewage and may contaminate the water, posing a public health risk. In this study, scientists studied bacterial community composition at two distant beaches (Avalon, California, and Provincetown, ...

New dinosaur found in Portugal, largest terrestrial predator from Europe

2014-03-06

A new dinosaur species found in Portugal may be the largest land predator discovered in Europe, as well as one of the largest carnivorous dinosaurs from the Jurassic, according to a paper published in PLOS ONE on March 5, 2014 by co-authors Christophe Hendrickx and Octavio Mateus from Universidade Nova de Lisboa and Museu da Lourinhã. Scientists discovered bones belonging to this dinosaur north of Lisbon. They were originally believed to be Torvosaurus tanneri, a dinosaur species from North America. Closer comparison of the shin bone, upper jawbone, teeth, and partial ...

Younger men benefit most from surgery for localized prostate cancer

2014-03-06

Boston, MA -- More than 230,000 men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer this year in the United States, but determining their course of treatment remains a source of considerable debate. A new study by researchers from Uppsala University Hospital, Sweden, Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) and colleagues—which draws from one of the few randomized trials conducted to directly address this issue—finds a substantial long-term reduction in mortality for men with localized cancer who undergo a radical prostatectomy. While the benefit on mortality appears to be limited ...

Patients have a right to know -- not a duty to know -- their diagnosis says new research

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: