(Press-News.org) In a Yale School of Medicine analysis of 96 research trial results published in top journals, almost all had at least one discrepancy between what was reported on the public clinical trial registry clinicaltrials.gov and what was posted in the journal article.
"This study raises serious questions about the accuracy of results reporting in both clinical trial registries and publications, and the importance of consistent presentation of accurate results," said Joseph Ross, M.D., assistant professor of medicine and public health at Yale School of Medicine and senior author of the research letter published in the March 12 Journal of the American Medical Association.
In 2007, the Food and Drug Administration mandated that all clinical trial results must be registered within one year of completion through clinicaltrials.gov, a National Institutes of Health online registry and database of clinical trials.
Ross and his colleagues compared the results of 96 trials reported through clinicaltrials.gov and those published in high-profile, peer-reviewed journals between 2010 and 2011. They compared the reported and published results regarding the patients, trial interventions, efficacy, and other results of the studies.
Of the 96 trials examined in this study, 93 of them had at least one discrepancy between the two reported results. "We focused only on reports in top journals such as the New England Journal of Medicine and Lancet, which tend to go through the most scrutiny before being published," explained Ross. "We believe that the results from this study represent the best-case scenario with respect to reporting accuracy in published clinical trials."
According to the analysis, discrepancies found between the clinicaltrials.gov database and published results could result from clerical or typographical errors, failure to report results online, or intentional changes to share more favorable results.
"Fortunately, of the 96 trials studied, only six of the discordant results altered the interpretation of the trial," said Ross. "But there still needs to be greater efforts to ensure accurate reporting in the future."
INFORMATION:
Other authors on this study include first author Jessica E. Becker, Harlan M. Krumholz, M.D., and Gal Ben-Josef.
The study was funded in part by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Cardiovascular Outcomes Center Award (1U01HL105270-02), the National Institute on Aging (K08 AG032886), and by the American Federation for Aging Research through the Paul B. Beeson Career Development Award Program.
Citation: JAMA doi:10.1001/jama.2013.285634; Available pre-embargo to the media at http://media.jamanetwork.com
Discrepancies in clinical trial reporting raise questions of accuracy
2014-03-12
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Promoting love can punish sales
2014-03-12
Valentine's Day has come and gone. But those images of romance are still everywhere : a happy couple holding hands in an eharmony ad, two lovebirds sharing a tender kiss in a Nikon camera commercial.
Advertising filled with romantic images, featuring "happy togetherness" in magazines and stores as well as on television and websites might resonate with you if you have a special someone. But if you're single, a new study shows you're not buying.
New research from consumer psychologist Lisa Cavanaugh, assistant professor at the USC Marshall School of Business, reveals ...
A tailor-made molecule against malaria
2014-03-12
The malaria parasite is particularly pernicious since it is built to develop resistance to treatments. The lack of new therapeutic approaches also contributes to the persistence of this global scourge. A study led by Didier Picard, professor at the Faculty of Sciences of the University of Geneva (UNIGE), Switzerland, describes a new class of molecules targeting the two problems at the same time. Using ultra sophisticated computerised modelling tools, the researchers were successful in identifying a type of candidate molecules toxic for the pathogen, but not for the infected ...
Bucking conventional wisdom, researchers find black sea bass tougher than expected
2014-03-12
In a new study, fisheries researchers from North Carolina State University found that black sea bass (Centropristis striata) can usually survive the physical trauma that results from being hauled up from deep water then released at the surface. The finding is part of a larger study of the fish's mortality rate, which will inform stock assessments designed to help ensure that the black sea bass fishery is sustainable.
Black sea bass are bottom-dwelling fish, and are often caught at depths of greater than 60 feet. When the fish are brought to the surface, the rapid change ...
Type 1 diabetes: Gut microbiota networks may influence autoimmune processes
2014-03-12
As part of the BABYDIET study, the scientists compared the composition and interaction of the gut microbiota in children who went on to develop diabetes-specific autoantibodies in their blood with data from children who were autoantibody negative. The BABYDIET study examines the nutritional factors that may influence the risk of diabetes.
Similar bacteria – different interactions
In the course of the study, the team headed by PD Dr. Peter Achenbach and Professor Anette-Gabriele Ziegler from the Institute of Diabetes Research as well as Dr. David Endesfelder and Dr. ...
VLT spots largest yellow hypergiant star
2014-03-12
Using ESO's Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI), Olivier Chesneau (Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur, Nice, France) and an international team of collaborators have found that the yellow hypergiant star HR 5171 A [1] is absolutely huge — 1300 times the diameter of the Sun and much bigger than was expected [2]. This makes it the largest yellow star known. It is also in the top ten of the largest stars known — 50% larger than the famous red supergiant Betelgeuse — and about one million times brighter than the Sun.
"The new observations also showed that this star has ...
Play it again, Sam: How the brain recognizes familiar music
2014-03-12
Research from McGill University reveals that the brain's motor network helps people remember and recognize music that they have performed in the past better than music they have only heard. A recent study by Prof. Caroline Palmer of the Department of Psychology sheds new light on how humans perceive and produce sounds, and may pave the way for investigations into whether motor learning could improve or protect memory or cognitive impairment in aging populations. The research is published in the journal Cerebral Cortex.
"The memory benefit that comes from performing a ...
First thin films of spin ice reveal cold secrets
2014-03-12
Thin films of spin ice have been shown to demonstrate surprising properties which could help in the development of applications of magnetricity, the magnetic equivalent of electricity.
Published today in Nature Communications, a team of researchers based at the London Centre for Nanotechnology (LCN), in collaboration with scientists from Oxford and Cambridge, found that, against expectations, the Third Law of Thermodynamics could be restored in thin films of the magnetic material spin ice.
In the familiar world around us it is always possible to make things colder, ...
International dispute involving California company finds resolution
2014-03-12
International dispute involving California company finds resolution
Article provided by Dorazio Law Office
Visit us at http://www.doraziolawoffice.com/
Business entities often have specific legal needs that are much different from those that most individuals require. When a business is international, or does business with foreign companies, disputes can produce complicated legal issues.
According to a report by the San Diego Business Journal, Accelrys, Inc., a company based out of San Diego, and Borealis AG, a company headquartered in Vienna, Austria, recently ...
How bankruptcy can help you with your overdue taxes
2014-03-12
How bankruptcy can help you with your overdue taxes
Article provided by The Law Offices of W. Robert Montgomery
Visit us at http://www.wrobertmontgomery.com
It is that time of year again: tax season. Although this time of year is often considered to be among the more unpleasant, if you have fallen behind on your income taxes, it can be even more miserable. If you are in this situation, you may be considering bankruptcy as a means to get back on your feet. Although bankruptcy can help with certain back taxes, it is not always a complete solution for this type of ...
Credit Suisse hearings focus attention on foreign bank accounts
2014-03-12
Credit Suisse hearings focus attention on foreign bank accounts
Article provided by Frost & Associates
Visit us at http://www.districtofcolumbiataxattorney.com/
The chief executive of Credit Suisse recently appeared in front of a Senate subcommittee to answer questions related to the bank's role in aiding tax evasion. A similar hearing in 2008 resulted in a $780 million fine for Swiss bank UBS after the bank admitted helping U.S. taxpayers shield assets to avoid taxes. In conjunction with the record fine, UBS was required to turn over names linked to 4,700 of ...