(Press-News.org) Athens, Ga. – When asked who is going to win an election, people tend to predict their own candidate will come out on top. When that doesn't happen, according to a new study from the University of Georgia, these "surprised losers" often have less trust in government and democracy.
And the news media may be partly to blame, according to Barry Hollander, author of the study and UGA professor in the Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication.
"You need the trust of those in a democracy for democracy to be successful," said Hollander. "We have become more fragmented in our media diet and that leads to hearing what we want to hear and believing what we want to believe despite all evidence to the contrary, such as polls. Our surprise in the election outcome makes us angry, disappointed and erodes our trust in the basic concept of democracy—the election. And that can threaten our trust in government."
Based on the theory of wishful thinking—the idea that people tend to predict their own favorite sports team or candidate will win—Hollander analyzed 5,914 survey responses conducted by the American National Election Study before and after the 2012 presidential election. He examined people's pre-election predictions, their news media consumption habits, and ultimately their trust in government and democracy. The results were published in the Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly on July 24.
He found that "surprised losers," those who predicted their candidate would win but who eventually lost, are more skeptical of government, democracy and the election process than are expected losers, or those who favored the same candidate but expected to lose. Despite all evidence to the contrary, 78 percent of Mitt Romney supporters during the 2012 election believed he would win. Nearly all polls showed President Barack Obama leading throughout the campaign.
"When predicting an election outcome, people sample themselves, friends, family and Facebook friends," Hollander said. "You draw a sample of those people like yourself, and we are drawing a very biased sample. In this way our own preferences have enormous weight."
In addition to sampling people much like themselves, the media that people draw from can influence their perception. Previous research from Hollander studied the effect of news consumption on political knowledge.
"In theory, greater news consumption should lead to greater political knowledge," he said. "Therefore, you should become aware of who is winning or losing, and this should reduce wishful thinking. That worked for those who read newspapers, but not for other news media. Also, the stronger you care about the outcome, or feel about a candidate, the more likely you are to think that candidate is going to win, regardless of the polls."
Among Romney supporters, watching Fox News Channel had a unique effect. Controlling for factors such as age, education, race, gender, party identification and exposure to other news, in the current study those who watched Fox News Channel were even more likely to predict Romney would win, and this in turn had an effect on whether or not they thought government posed a threat. In this election, the results suggested if you watched Fox News Channel you were less trusting of the government.
"The more fragmented our media have become the more people are hearing what they want to out of their news and the more surprised they are when the outcome doesn't turn out as they've expected, which could further erode trust in elections, democracy and government," said Hollander. "As a journalist, I didn't give any thought to my effect on people. The danger is if our media continue to become more fragmented, the more and more we tend to hear only what we want to hear and believe what we want to believe, but when the outcome surprises us that can have very real consequences not only in people's own perception but also in the stability of democracy and government."
The full journal article is available at http://jmq.sagepub.com/content/early/recent.
Note to editors: An image of Hollander is available at http://multimedia.uga.edu/media/images/barry_hollander_27029-013.jpg.
Contact: Barry Hollander, 706-542-5027 (office), 706-201-5722 (cell), firstname.lastname@example.org
Election surprises tend to erode trust in government
Media fragmentation plays role in election wishful thinking
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Link between ritual circumcision procedure and herpes infection in infants examined
PHILADELPHA—A rare procedure occasionally performed during Jewish circumcisions that involves direct oral suction is a likely source of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) transmissions documented in infants between 1988 and 2012, a literature review conducted by Penn Medicine researchers and published online in the Journal of the Pediatric Infectious Disease Society found. The reviewers, from Penn's Center for Evidence-based Practice, identified 30 reported cases in New York, Canada and Israel. The practice—known as metzitzah b'peh—and its link to HSV-1 infections ...
Penn study: Incisionless transcatheter aortic valve replacement surgery cuts hospital length of stay
PHILADELPHIA – New research from Penn Medicine shows that incisionless transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) surgery cuts length of hospital stay by 30 percent and has no impact on post-operative vascular complication rates when compared with conventional transfemoral TAVR, which requires an incision in the groin. The complete study is available in the current issue of Circulation: Cardiovascular Interventions. TAVR involves the replacement of the aortic valve without a traditional open-heart surgical approach. It is a treatment for aortic stenosis, a narrowing ...
Piggy-backing cells hold clue to skin cancer growth
Skin Cancer cells work together to spread further and faster, according to a new study published in Cell Reports. The discovery could lead to new drugs to tackle melanoma, the most deadly form of skin cancer. Cancer Research UK scientists at The University of Manchester found that some melanoma cells are particularly fast growing, but not very good at invading the surrounding tissue, while other melanoma cells are the opposite – highly invasive but slow-growing. In a tumour, the faster growing cells 'piggy-back' along with the more invasive cells, so together they ...
Rutgers study explores attitudes, preferences toward post-Sandy rebuilding
NEW BRUNSWICK, N.J. – A yearlong study funded by the New Jersey Recovery Fund and conducted by researchers at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy at Rutgers University has found that individual property owners in Sandy-affected towns are skeptical about the likelihood of community-based rebuilding solutions. Of the more than 400 online survey respondents, 45 percent indicated they were "pessimistic" or "very pessimistic" that the parts of their town affected by Superstorm Sandy would be rebuilt better than they were before the storm; another 24 ...
Joblessness could kill you, but recessions could be good for your health
Being unemployed increases your risk of death, but recessions decrease it. Sound paradoxical? Researchers thought so too. While previous studies of individuals have shown that employees who lose their jobs have a higher mortality rate, more comprehensive studies have shown, unexpectedly, that population mortality actually declines as unemployment rates increase. Researchers from Drexel University and the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor set out to better understand these seemingly contradictory findings. Using a nationally representative panel of individuals across ...
Artificial intelligence identifies the musical progression of the Beatles
Music fans and critics know that the music of the Beatles underwent a dramatic transformation in just a few years, but until now there hasn't been a scientific way to measure the progression. That could change now that computer scientists at Lawrence Technological University have developed an artificial intelligence algorithm that can analyze and compare musical styles, enabling research into the musical progression of the Beatles. Assistant Professor Lior Shamir and graduate student Joe George had previously developed audio analysis technology to study the vocal communication ...
Early warning sign for babies at risk of autism
CORAL GABLES, Fla. (July 24, 2014) -- Some babies are at risk for autism because they have an older sibling that has the disorder. To find new ways to detect Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) earlier in life, researchers are exploring the subtleties of babies' interactions with others and how they relate to the possibility and severity of future symptoms. A new study helps us to understand the connection between early joint attention before one year and later ASD symptoms. Joint attention is an early form of communication that develops toward the end of the first year. ...
Narcissistic CEOs and financial performance
Narcissism, considered by some as the "dark side of the executive personality," may actually be a good thing when it comes to certain financial measures, with companies led by narcissistic CEOs outperforming those helmed by non-narcissistic executives, according to recent research co-authored by faculty at the USC Marshall School of Business. The study, "CEO Narcissism and Accounting: A Picture of Profits," published in The Journal of Management Accounting Research, by Professor of Accounting Mark Young, who holds the George Bozanic and Holman G. Hurt Chair in Sports ...
A protein couple controls flow of information into the brain's memory center
These molecules, which have similar counterparts in humans, affect the connections between nerve cells and influence the transmission of nerve signals into the hippocampus, an area of the brain that plays a significant role in learning processes and the creation of memories. The results of the study have been published in the journal Neuron. Brain function depends on the active communication between nerve cells, known as neurons. For this purpose, neurons are woven together into a dense network where they constantly relay signals to one another. However, neurons do not ...
Immune response may cause harm in brain injuries, disorders
July 17, 2014, Cleveland: Could the body's own immune system play a role in memory impairment and cognitive dysfunction associated with conditions like chronic epilepsy, Alzheimer's dementia and concussions? Cleveland Clinic researchers believe so, based on a study published online by PLOS ONE. The study focuses on the role of a protein known as S100B, which serves as a biomarker for brain damage. Normally, S100B is found only in the brain and spinal column. However, following a brain injury, it can leak through the blood-brain barrier into the blood. Once S100B enters ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
American Academy of Arts and Sciences to induct UVA's Garcia-Blanco
Illinois-led team puts cows and microbes to work to reduce greenhouse gases
DOE announces $264 million for basic research in support of Energy Earthshots™
New drug a breakthrough for brain tumor that strikes young people: NEJM editorial
Genome study reveals 30 years of Darwin’s finch evolution
Ghent University’s research team envisions a bright future with active machine learning in chemical engineering
Climate change and carnivores: shifts in the distribution and effectiveness of protected areas in the Amazon
Can ChatGPT help us form personal narratives?
An intelligent control method reduces carbon emissions in energy-intensive equipment
Groundbreaking control method reduces carbon emissions from zinc oxide rotary kilns, boosting profits for zinc smelting industry
Small but mighty new gene editor
Study finds SARS-CoV-2-associated sepsis was more common, deadly than previously thought
Use of electronic clinical data to track incidence and mortality for SARS-CoV-2–associated sepsis
Misinformation, trust, and use of ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19
Neighborhood factors, individual stressors, and cardiovascular health among Black and white adults
New research reveals link between childhood mental health problems and quality of life for young adults
New insights into how the human brain organises language
Visual search: Context facilitates more effective strategies
Malaria: Treatment of Plasmodium falciparum malaria patients under threat in the Horn of Africa
New post-translational modification of the glycolytic enzyme enolase
New frontier in biomedical engineering: Protein coacervates engineered into adhesive for unprecedented skin repair speed
New study unveils insights into ethylene copolymerization with linear and end-cyclized olefins using a metallocene catalyst
Study identifies new pathway to suppressing autoimmunity
Diabetes may accelerate blood cancer growth, yet survival outcomes differ by race
Groundbreaking mathematical proof: new insights into typhoon dynamics unveiled
Teams invent a new metallization method of modified tannic acid photoresist patterning
MoMFs could be central to liver regeneration
A lethal parasite’s secret weapon: Infecting non-immune cells
Ball milling provides high pressure benefits to battery materials
Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society (CHSS) and fourteen professional organizations announce recommendations for performing pediatric heart surgery in US[Press-News.org] Election surprises tend to erode trust in government
Media fragmentation plays role in election wishful thinking