(Press-News.org) Researchers say there should be an international database containing the very latest information about organ donations and transplants, so policy makers can make informed decisions on whether to adopt an opt-out or opt-in system.
The call comes after a study, carried out by The University of Nottingham, the University of Stirling and Northumbria University, showed that overall an opt-out system might provide a greater number of organs for transplant but many factors can influence the success of either system and a repository of accessible information would help individual countries decide which one would be better for them.
The research published, today Wednesday 24 September 2014, in the online academic journal BioMed Central Medicine (BMC Medicine), is the first international comparison that examines both deceased as well as living organ/transplant rates in opt-in and opt-out systems.
Professor Eamonn Ferguson, an expert in personality theory and human altruism in the School of Psychology at The University of Nottingham, said: "Until now decisions have been based on limited evidence. This important health policy question generates strong opinions but the evidence is weak and the subject is complex. Our main aim is to increase the number of organs available for donation and transplantation but this research has revealed subtleties that weren't known before concerning the effects of consent of both deceased and living organ donations, with previous work focusing primarily on deceased donations."
No Easy Answers
There are many organisations that favour the opt-out system because it targets deceased donors, which on face value allows more organs to be harvested. But this new research has shown that the opt-in system can increase the number of living donors for kidneys and liver.
Professor Ferguson said: "We wanted to find out if opt-out versus opt-in policies influence not just deceased donations but also living donations - which are a major source of kidneys. We also wanted to extend previous work by examining the effects of these policies for different types of organs. The aim is to develop a more comprehensive dataset on organ donation by combining sources of data from 48 counties over a 13 year period."
The research looked at the number of organ donations in 48 countries world-wide. Twenty-three of these countries use the opt-in system, twenty-five of them have an opt-out system. Using statistics going back 13 years the study found that for every million people in the population:
There were more deceased donors in countries using the opt-out system than those using the opt-in system.
There were more living donations in countries using the opt-in system than those with an opt-out.
Taking the overall number of kidney and liver donations - from both living and deceased donors – the figure was higher in countries using the opt-out system.
So Is Opt-Out the Best Way Forward?
With advances in medical treatments the demand for organ transplantation is growing. In Wales they have moved to an opt-out system while England has kept the opt-in system. The Spanish Model which has an opt-out system has resulted in a notable increase in donors but the whole health system underwent a transformation to achieve that.
Eamonn Ferguson said: "Although we support previous research in demonstrating greater deceased donor rates in opt-out countries compared with countries using the opt-in system it isn't as simple as that."
The researchers point to other factors that can influence the donation rates other than the type of consent system. For instance:
The critical care systems: how many critical hospital beds are there?
The gross domestic product.
Professor Fergusson argues that it is imperative for transplant organisations to routinely collect data on important organ donation indices - consent type, procurement procedure, number of intensive care beds and trained surgeons - and make this publically available to inform future research and policy recommendations.
INFORMATION:
Organ donation: Do we opt-in or opt-out?
2014-09-24
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Recreational activity a major pollutant on Canadian coast of Pacific Ocean
2014-09-24
From recreational boats and fishing vessels to commercial cruise ships and private marinas, a newly published study shows that oil discharges related to human maritime activity on the Canadian coast is posing a major threat to marine ecosystems in the Pacific Ocean.
The study – published in the August edition of the journal Applied Geography, with University of Calgary associate professor in geography Stefania Bertazzon as lead author – provides a geospatial analysis of oil discharges in the Canadian Pacific Ocean.
The findings show that a large portion of oil discharge ...
New study finds university health schools' use of holistic admissions has positive impact
2014-09-24
On September 30, 2014, in Washington, DC, higher education and health leaders will release a report that is the first to examine nationwide the impact and use of holistic review—a university admissions process that assesses an applicant's unique experiences alongside traditional measures of academic achievement such as grades and test scores—for students pursuing careers in the health professions.
Many colleges and universities use a holistic admission process to select students. The practice has become more popular in health fields such as medicine, because it enables ...
Tonsil stem cells could someday help repair liver damage without surgery
2014-09-24
The liver provides critical functions, such as ridding the body of toxins. Its failure can be deadly, and there are few options for fixing it. But scientists now report in the journal ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces a way to potentially inject stem cells from tonsils, a body part we don't need, to repair damaged livers — all without surgery.
Byeongmoon Jeong and colleagues point out that currently, the only established method for treating liver failure or severe cases of liver disease is complete or partial transplantation. But the need is much greater than the number ...
New linguistic tools can predict your dialect characteristics
2014-09-24
A new linguistic study may make it possible to more accurately predict the dialect features people use based on their demographic characteristics and where they live. In a new article published in the September 2014 issue of Language, Martijn Wieling (University of Groningen) and colleagues used statistical modeling techniques to predict whether speakers in Tuscany use words from standard Italian or words unique to local dialects.
The article, "Lexical differences between Tuscan dialects and standard Italian: Accounting for geographic and socio-demographic variation using ...
Are weak values quantum? Don't bet on it
2014-09-24
Over the past 20 years, a strange idea called a "weak value" has taken root in quantum information science.
Many of the things you can do with quantum technologies entail being able to gain information from quantum systems. But there is a quantum conundrum: we can't say what a particle is doing when we're not looking at it, but when we do look at it, we change its behaviour.
But what if we could look "a little"? Well, that's a weak measurement, a concept which is central to the notion of a weak value. The basic idea of weak measurement is to gain a little bit of information ...
Buffet pricing surprise
2014-09-24
In the study, conducted by researchers David Just PhD., Ozge Sigirci, and Brian Wansink PhD. author of the forthcoming book, Slim by Design: Mindless Eating Solutions for Everyday Life, 139 diners in an Italian all-you-can-eat buffet restaurant were either charged $4 or $8 for the lunch buffet. The buffet offered pizza, salad, breadsticks, pasta, and soup. After finishing, diners were asked to rate the taste of the pizza and how much they enjoyed the dining experience on a 9 point scale.
"People set their expectation of taste partially based on the price—and it becomes ...
Enzyme discovery paves way to tackling deadly parasite diseases
2014-09-24
An enzyme found in all living things could hold the key to combatting deadly diseases such as sleeping sickness, a study suggests.
Research into the enzyme, which helps cells convert nutrients into energy, has shown that it is activated in different ways in various species.
Researchers say this discovery creates an opportunity to design drugs that block activity of the enzyme – known as pyruvate kinase – in species that cause infection. Blocking the enzyme would effectively kill the parasite, without affecting the same enzyme in the patient.
Findings from the study ...
Cyber Week 2014: Netanyahu, Kaspersky, and Gold tackle cyber 'game-changers'
2014-09-24
Tel Aviv — "I don't think it's an exaggeration to say that cyber defense solutions will serve as the essential basis for human development and economic growth in this century — I think it's happening before our very eyes," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told leading policymakers and cybersecurity experts at the 4th Annual International Cybersecurity Conference, held at Tel Aviv University on September 14-15, 2014.
The signature event of Cyber Week 2014, one of the most important annual cyber events in the world, the TAU conference series presented the full spectrum ...
Good news for young patients with a leukemia subtype associated with a poor prognosis
2014-09-24
(MEMPHIS, Tenn. – September 24, 2014) St. Jude Children's Research Hospital investigators found that adjusting treatment based on early response to chemotherapy made a life-saving difference to young patients with an acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) subtype associated with a poor outcome. The study appeared in the September 20 edition of the Journal of Clinical Oncology.
The results are good news for children and adolescents with Philadelphia chromosome-like ALL (Ph-like ALL), a subtype that until now was associated with a poor prognosis. Ph-like ALL accounts for as ...
Cardiorespiratory fitness is often misdiagnosed
2014-09-24
A recent study by the University of Eastern Finland shows that scaling maximal oxygen uptake and maximal workload by body weight confounds measures of cardiorespiratory fitness. It has been a common practice in exercise testing to scale the results by body weight and, according to researchers, this practice should be abandoned. More reliable data on cardiorespiratory fitness can be observed by using lean mass proportional measures. The results were published recently in Clinical Physiology and Functional Imaging.
Exercise tests, such as the maximal cycle ergometer exercise ...