(Press-News.org) If a scientist has a good reputation among his colleagues, other scientists are more likely to cite his publications. According to a study, reputation is crucial for the impact of publications.
Author reputation is key in driving a paper's citation count early in its life cycle, before a tipping point, after which reputation has much less influence compared to the paper's citation count, says Aalto University Professor Santo Fortunato, pointing out that this is a key finding of the study.
Quality – not quantity – of publications build authors' reputation
As the quality of science is more and more linked to citation counts, understanding the mechanisms that underlie the life spans of scientists' careers becomes increasingly essential.
The result encourages publishing quality, not quantity. Just a single widely cited high-impact article is very likely to cause what the group calls "a reputation boost".
The number of journals increases rapidly and so do opportunities for publication. The reputation boost effect speaks in favour of aiming for quality instead of quantity in publishing. This reinforces a research strategy beneficial for science and scientists alike, asserts Fortunato.
The life cycle of heavily cited articles is long in mathematics, where some publications even seem to "live forever". The papers in other sciences studied – biology and physics – display a "half-life" of roughly five years. The group puts this down to the fast pace of ideation in these fields.
Effects of reputation on the impact analysed with quantitative methods
The effects of researchers' reputation on their scientific impact can now be analysed with quantitative methods. Statistical physicists at Aalto University Department of Biomedical Engineering and Computational Science (BECS) are collaborating in a study that studies how the value of individual scientists' reputation emerges and how scientific knowledge advances.
The group clarifies how an author's reputation influences the impact of a published article. They have analysed the citation patterns of over 80 000 articles and 7,5 million citations.
A researcher produces many comparable products – publications – over her career. We use the citations that the publications receive as a measure of scientific impact, explains group leader Professor Alexander Petersen from IMT Lucca.
The relation between the reputation and the career growth of an individual researcher still remains poorly understood. We wish to provide methods to better evaluate not only scientific output but also the scientists themselves, says Fortunato.
The career evolution of a scientist is a complex process. Understanding the role of social ingredients – reputation, cooperation, competition, creativity – which underlie it, is an emerging interdisciplinary research front, says Petersen.
INFORMATION:
The results are now published in the esteemed journal PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences). The study is led by Professors Alexander Petersen and H. Eugene Stanley from IMT Lucca and Boston University, respectively. Other authors are Professors Fabio Pammolli and Massimo Riccaboni (IMT Lucca) and Dr Armando Rungi (IMT Lucca). Collaborating from Aalto University are Professors Kimmo Kaski and Santo Fortunato and Postdoctoral Researcher Raj Kumar Pan.
The study is part of on-going work in the Aalto University Department of Biomedical Engineering and Computational Science research groups Complex Networks and Complex Systems. They model complex social networks in an upcoming field called computational social science.
Alexander M. Petersen, Santo Fortunato, Raj K. Pan, Kimmo Kaski, Orion Penner, Armando Rungi, Massimo Riccaboni, H. Eugene Stanley, Fabio Pammolli: Reputation and Impact in Academic Careers. PNAS doi: 10.1073/pnas.1323111111
Link to article: http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/10/03/1323111111.abstract?sid=bc1519d9-82c1-426a-b279-3e8e4b9524ee
Further information:
Santo Fortunato, Professor
santo.fortunato@aalto.fi
tel. +358 50 460 5511
Twitter @santo_fortunato
Aalto University School of Science
Department of Biomedical Engineering and Computational Science BECS
http://becs.aalto.fi/en/
Researchers prefer citing researchers of good reputation
2014-10-07
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Results of study of the human mind and consciousness at the time of death available
2014-10-07
The results of a four-year international study of 2060 cardiac arrest cases across 15 hospitals published and available now on ScienceDirect. The study concludes:
The themes relating to the experience of death appear far broader than what has been understood so far, or what has been described as so called near-death experiences.
In some cases of cardiac arrest, memories of visual awareness compatible with so called out-of-body experiences may correspond with actual events.
A higher proportion of people may have vivid death experiences, but do not recall them due ...
Small spills at gas stations could cause significant public health risks over time
2014-10-07
A new study suggests that drops of fuel spilled at gas stations — which occur frequently with fill-ups — could cumulatively be causing long-term environmental damage to soil and groundwater in residential areas in close proximity to the stations.
Few studies have considered the potential environmental impact of routine gasoline spills and instead have focused on problems associated with large-scale leaks. Researchers with the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, publishing online Sept. 19 in the Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, developed a mathematical ...
Testosterone promotes prostate cancer in rats
2014-10-07
Washington, DC—A researcher who found that testosterone raised the risk of prostate tumors and exacerbated the effects of carcinogenic chemical exposure in rats is urging caution in prescribing testosterone therapy to men who have not been diagnosed with hypogonadism, according to a new study published in the Endocrine Society's journal Endocrinology.
Testosterone use has soared in the last decade among older men seeking to boost energy and feel younger. One study published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism found that the number of American men ...
Printing in the hobby room: Paper-thin and touch-sensitive displays on various materials
2014-10-07
Until now, if you want to print a greeting card for a loved one, you can use colorful graphics, fancy typefaces or special paper to enhance it. But what if you could integrate paper-thin displays into the cards, which could be printed at home and which would be able to depict self-created symbols or even react to touch? Those only some of the options computer scientists in Saarbrücken can offer.
They developed an approach that in the future will enable laypeople to print displays in any desired shape on various materials and therefore could change everyday life completely.
For ...
World's first child born after uterus transplantation
2014-10-07
In a ground-breaking research project at the University of Gothenburg, seven Swedish women have had embryos reintroduced after receiving wombs from living donors. Now the first transplanted woman has delivered a baby – a healthy and normally developed boy. The world-unique birth was acknowledged in The Lancet on 5 October.
The uterus transplantation research project at the University of Gothenburg started in 1999 and has been evaluated in over 40 scientific articles. The goal of the Gothenburg project is to enable women who were born without a womb or who have lost ...
Fundamentals of physics confirmed
2014-10-07
To explore any possible limits of the two theories, they have been experimentally verified many times already and both have passed all the tests so far. Hence, scientists look for deviations in experiments with increasing precision or under extreme conditions.
For this purpose, Nörtershäuser's team has now accelerated ions to velocities near the speed of light and illuminated them with a laser.
The results, which are presented in two new publications, confirm the time dilation predicted for high velocities in the theory of relativity with an accuracy that ...
New study finds nearly 6 million more dengue cases in India than official annual tally
2014-10-07
Deerfield, Ill. (October 8, 2014) — The annual number of dengue fever cases in India is 282 times higher than officially reported, and the disease inflicts an economic burden on the country of at least US$1.11 billion each year in medical and other expenses, according to a new study published online today in the American Journal of Tropical Medicine & Hygiene.
The study, led by researchers at Brandeis University's Schneider Institute for Health Policy in Waltham, Massachusetts, the INCLEN Trust International in New Delhi, and the Indian Council of Medical Research's ...
Researchers turn computers into powerful allies in the fight against AIDS
2014-10-07
The battle against AIDS cannot be won in the laboratory alone. To fight the potentially deadly virus that 34 million people are suffering from we need help from computers. Now research fron University of Southern Denmark turns computers into powerful allies in the battle.
Effective treatment of HIV-virus is a race against time: Many of the drugs that have been potent killers of HIV-virus, have today lost their power, because the virus has become resistant to them. As a result science must constantly develop new drugs that can attack the virus in new ways.
Now researchers ...
Easy recipe to make bone and cartilage
2014-10-07
Scientists at The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston (UTHealth), Monash University and RIKEN Centre for Developmental Biology have used a combination of small molecules to generate mouse cells that can form bone and cartilage. This new method is easily scalable, and hence is a promising approach for the repair of human bone and cartilage defects. The research has just been published at http://dev.biologists.org/ in the scientific journal Development.
Current strategies to regenerate bone and cartilage use adult stem cells that are committed to forming ...
A new pathway discovered regulating autoimmune diseases
2014-10-07
Boston, MA – The main function of the immune system is to protect against diseases and infections. For unknown reasons our immune system attacks healthy cells, tissues and organs in a process called autoimmunity, which can result in diseases such as multiple sclerosis, type 1 diabetes, lupus or rheumatoid arthritis. There are currently no existing cures for these diseases.
Now, in a new study by researchers at Brigham and Women's Hospital (BWH), a potential treatment maybe on the horizon. Researchers found that NAD+, a natural molecule found in living cells, plants ...