(Press-News.org) Lots of potentially useful medical information is getting lost. McGill researchers discovered this when they looked into the lack of reporting of information from "stalled drug" trials in cancer, cardiovascular and neurological diseases.
"Stalled drugs" are drugs that fail to make it to the market either because they prove to be ineffective or unsafe or both. Because only one in ten of the drugs that goes into human testing actually gets licensed, most of the information collected in developing new drugs is currently being lost. This is despite the fact that this information is critical for effective care, protecting patients, and discovering better drugs.
"We focused on drug trials in these three areas because they are a major focus for drug development," says Prof. Jonathan Kimmelman who is Associate Professor of Biomedical Ethics at McGill University and is the lead author on the study that was published today in the British Medical Journal. "We expected to see that many of these trials are never published. What surprised us was the magnitude of the data withholding."
Indeed, between 2005 and 2009, the period that the researchers studied, only about 37 per cent of registered trials for "stalled" drug trials were actually published. For the approved drugs developed in the same period, 75 per cent of the trials were published.
The researchers believe information sharing - even for drugs that stall in development -offers clues about how to deliver care or develop drugs more effectively. Findings from trials of stalled drugs:
1. Allow drug developers to discover what didn't work, and then adjust the compound or method of delivery so that it might work for other conditions. For example, the drug Viagra failed initially as a drug for treatment of angina. We now know it to be a very effective drug for erectile dysfunction.
2. Help us learn about the safety of other approved drugs. Often, trials of experimental drugs generate valuable evidence about the safety of approved drugs - especially if the approved drugs are in the same chemical family.
3. Help drug discoverers learn about the limits of animal models and other experimental techniques. "When a drug works in animal models but not in patients, we have an opportunity to study why our model fell short and to improve it," says Amanda Hakala, a Master's student who is first author on the study.
4. Contain safety and efficacy information that might be useful in other parts of the world. Often, drugs that are considered unsafe and ineffective in one part of the world are approved in another. "Failure to publish these trials deprives patients in those other jurisdictions of state of the art evidence of safety and efficacy," says Kimmelman.
A further reason to share the information about "stalled" drugs is that many patients who take part in these trials are given either placebos or ineffective or unsafe drugs. "The failure of the drug developers to share their findings runs contrary to the Declaration of Helsinki which lays out clear ethical guidelines for medical research involving human subjects," says Kimmelman. "In our study, we found that over 20,000 patients were involved in "stalled" drug trials that were never reported. That's a lot of people whose altruism is not being honoured."
"There are many reasons that drug developers do not report findings in 'stalled' drug trials. One is an unwillingness to share information with competitors," says Amanda Hakala, the Master's student who is the first author on the study. "However, the value of this lost information is starting to be recognized." The European Parliament recently passed legislation that requires sponsors to report on "stalled" trials. And the U.S. is considering policies that would encourage limited transparency about stalled drug trials. "Policies like these are no substitute for full publication, but they go a long way to redeeming the sacrifices of the research subjects and advancing the cause of more effective healthcare and better drug development."
INFORMATION:
The research was funded by: Canadian Institutes of Health Research.
To read the full paper in the British Medical Journal: http://www.bmj.com/content/350/bmj.h1116.full
To reach the researchers:
Jonathan Kimmelman (English only)
Amanda Hakala (English & French)
In a study published in the current online issue of JAMA Psychiatry, an international team of scientists, led by researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine, report finding a highly accurate blood-based measure that could lead to development of a clinical test for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) risk in males as young as one to two years old. The test could be done in community pediatric settings. The degree of accuracy, they said, out performs other behavioral and genetic screens for infants and toddlers with ASD described in literature.
The ...
Eating a vegetarian diet was associated with a lower risk of colorectal cancers compared with nonvegetarians in a study of Seventh-Day Adventist men and women, according to an article published online by JAMA Internal Medicine.
Colorectal cancer is the second leading cause of cancer death in the United States. Although great attention has been paid to screening, primary prevention through lowering risk factors remains an important objective. Dietary factors have been identified as a modifiable risk factor for colorectal cancer, including red meat which is linked to increased ...
Rural suicide rates were nearly double those of urban areas for both males and females in a study of suicide deaths in young people ages 10 to 24, according to an article published online by JAMA Pediatrics.
Suicide is a public health problem and in 2010 suicide was the third leading cause of death in young people behind only unintentional injuries and homicides, according to the study background.
Cynthia A. Fontanella, Ph.D., of Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, and coauthors provide an updated comparison of rural and urban youth suicides by analyzing ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio - The adolescent and young-adult suicide rate in the United States was almost twice as high in rural settings than in urban areas between 1996 and 2010, and new research suggests that the gap appears to be widening.
Of the nearly 67,000 suicides analyzed, the rate of suicide for both males and females living in rural areas was about double the rate in cities.
The research, published in JAMA Pediatrics, also showed that gun use has decreased and that hanging has become a more common method of youth suicide for both males and females. Suicide rates by ...
Middle-aged Americans who show high levels of societal involvement and mental health are especially likely to construe their lives as stories of personal redemption, according to new research published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.
Previous research has shown that adults who are inclined toward generativity - the concern for and commitment to promoting the growth and well-being of future generations - are more likely to engage in a wide range of prosocial behaviors, including positive parenting styles, political participation, ...
Just a weeks' worth of training can improve vision in older adults, according to new research in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. The findings show that training boosted older adults' sensitivity to contrast and also their ability to see things clearly at close distances.
"Our research indicates that the visual system of older adults maintains a high degree of plasticity and demonstrates that training methods can be used to improve visual function," explains psychological scientist G. John Andersen of the University of California, ...
Case Western Reserve University nurse scientist Amy Zhang, who has long examined quality-of-life issues in cancer patients, wondered whether depression in African-American cancer patients has been under-recognized for treatment.
Accurately assessing depression in cancer patients is difficult in general because the physical symptoms of cancer and depression--low energy, lack of sleep and loss of appetite--are so similar.
"African-American cancer patients are often sicker and have more severe physical symptoms," said Zhang, PhD, an associate professor at Case Western ...
Future outbreaks of measles can only be prevented by vaccination.
An article published in Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health examined reasons people are hesitant to vaccinate.
In 2012, an imported case from Thailand led to a large measles outbreak in New South Wales, with 168 identified cases.
Ninety-five of the cases had not been vaccinated appropriately and 32 of these cases reported vaccine refusal as the reason for not being vaccinated.
"Active vaccine refusal is a significant issue and leaves a large group of children at unnecessary risk of measles ...
Australian health websites are too difficult for many people to read.
This is the finding from a study published in Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health.
Matthew Dunn and Christina Cheng from Deakin University evaluated Australian online health information to see if it matched the reading level of Australians.
"Limited availability of 'easy-to-read' health materials suggests that many Australians may not be benefiting from the convenience of the internet," Dr Dunn said.
"For example, more than 12 million Australians were overweight or obese in 2007, yet ...
If you want to know what a man's true attitude towards the female sex is, carefully watch how he smiles and chats to her. This advice is gleaned from a study by Jin Goh and Judith Hall of Northeastern University in the US, published in Springer's journal Sex Roles. It sheds light on how sexism subtly influences social interaction between men and woman.
Even though discrimination against women is thought to have decreased over the past six decades in the United States, instances of sexism are not difficult to find. Experts believe that such gender discrimination can be ...
