INFORMATION:
The research was conducted by Vattikuti Urology Institute, Center for Outcomes Research Analytics & Evaluation, Henry Ford Health System and the Center for Surgery and Public Health and Division of Urologic Surgery, Brigham & Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School.
The study is available at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/bju.13111/pdf
'Pay-for-performance' may lead to higher risk for robotic prostate surgery patients
2015-03-30
(Press-News.org) DETROIT - A "perverse disincentive" for hospitals that have invested in expensive technology for robotic surgery may be jeopardizing prostate cancer patients who seek out the procedure, concluded a new study led by Henry Ford Hospital researchers.
The study, which compared complication rates in hospitals with low volumes of robot-assisted radical prostatectomies (RARPs) to institutions with high volumes of the procedure, suggested that current pay-for-performance healthcare models are to blame.
The new study was published online this month by BJU International.
"Patients pursue robotic surgery based on perceived benefit, including its minimally invasive nature and faster recovery time compared to conventional open surgery," says Jesse Sammon, D.O., a researcher at Henry Ford's Vattikuti Urology Institute and lead author of the study. "But they fail to take into account the importance of hospital and surgeon experience on outcomes."
Now the most common surgical method for treating prostate cancer in the U.S., RARP allows a surgeon to remove the diseased prostate by manipulating robotic arms holding undersized instruments through tiny incisions in the patient's skin.
Besides avoiding the higher risk of infection and blood loss posed by open surgery, successful RARP reduces patient hospital stay and recovery time.
Researchers at Henry Ford Hospital, a pioneer in robotic surgery that has now performed more than 10,000 RARPs, saw a rapid increase in U.S. hospitals investing in the technology and performing the procedure during the past decade.
Building on earlier research that showed higher-volume hospitals had more success with the procedure than smaller institutions, the new study focused on all patients listed in the National Inpatient Sample (NIS) who underwent RARP between 2009 and 2011. The NIS collects and provides data on all patients discharged from a 20 percent sample of non-federal hospitals in the U.S.
Researchers also collected the number of RARPs performed at the hospitals where the patients were treated, categorized the hospitals according to that volume and recorded the complication rates for each.
They found:
The number of hospitals performing RARP remained stable over the study period - 802 in 2009, 792 in 2010 and 808 in 2011.
The overall complication rate after surgery was "significantly" related to the volume of RARPs performed at a hospital.
14.7 percent of patients treated at very-low volume institutions experienced complications while those treated at very-high volume institutions experienced a complication rate of 5.7 percent.
Patients treated at very-high volume hospitals were less than half as likely to experience a complication as those treated at very-low volume hospitals.
In presenting the study, researchers noted that during the 1990s when centralizing surgical treatment for cancers of the bladder and kidney resulted in a greater percentage of cases being sent to high-volume hospitals, the same was not true for prostate cancers during that decade.
"But between 2000 and 2008," Dr. Sammon explains, "there was a 74 percent increase in the number of radical prostatectomies performed, and a 19 percent decrease in the number of hospitals performing radical prostatectomy.
"By 2009, the median hospital volume for open radical prostate surgery was 32 cases per year compared to 137 cases per year using the robotic approach."
What this suggests, Sammon says, is that "market forces" behind the adoption of robotic surgery may have unintentionally had the salutary effect of centralizing prostate cancer care.
Yet the new study suggests that, with the boom in robotic surgery, fewer patients are seeking care at very-high volume hospitals, instead choosing low-volume institutions that have invested in the technology but have less experience in using it - and may be placing themselves at higher risk of complications.
"This migration of patients away from very-high volume hospitals is likely the result of the current pay-for-performance models in U.S. healthcare," Dr. Sammon says. "For institutions that have invested millions in robotic technology, this removes the incentive to refer patients to other, higher volume hospitals.
"This perverse disincentive is probably jeopardizing patients, and calls for a renewed focus on the benefits of centralized care at larger providers."
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Fat grafting technique improves results of breast augmentation
2015-03-30
March 30, 2015 - In women undergoing breast augmentation, a technique using transplantation of a small amount of the patient's own fat cells can produce better cosmetic outcomes, reports a study in the April issue of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery®, the official medical journal of the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS).
In particular, the fat grafting technique can achieve a more natural-appearing cleavage--avoiding the "separated breasts" appearance that can occur after breast augmentation, according to the report by Dr. Francisco G. Bravo of Clinica ...
Compound from soil microbe inhibits biofilm formation
2015-03-30
Researchers have shown that a known antibiotic and antifungal compound produced by a soil microbe can inhibit another species of microbe from forming biofilms--microbial mats that frequently are medically harmful--without killing that microbe. The findings may apply to other microbial species, and can herald a plethora of scientific and societal benefits. The research is published online ahead of print on March 30, 2015, in the Journal of Bacteriology, a publication of the American Society for Microbiology. The study will be printed in a special section of the journal ...
Roll up your screen and stow it away?
2015-03-30
From smartphones and tablets to computer monitors and interactive TV screens, electronic displays are everywhere. As the demand for instant, constant communication grows, so too does the urgency for more convenient portable devices -- especially devices, like computer displays, that can be easily rolled up and put away, rather than requiring a flat surface for storage and transportation.
A new Tel Aviv University study, published recently in Nature Nanotechnology, suggests that a novel DNA-peptide structure can be used to produce thin, transparent, and flexible screens. ...
Princess Margaret scientists convert microbubbles to nanoparticles
2015-03-30
(TORONTO, Canada - March 30, 2015) - Biomedical researchers led by Dr. Gang Zheng at Princess Margaret Cancer Centre have successfully converted microbubble technology already used in diagnostic imaging into nanoparticles that stay trapped in tumours to potentially deliver targeted, therapeutic payloads.
The discovery, published online today in Nature Nanotechnology, details how Dr. Zheng and his research team created a new type of microbubble using a compound called porphyrin - a naturally occurring pigment in nature that harvests light.
In the lab in pre-clinical ...
Mother's diet influences weight-control neurocircuits in offspring
2015-03-30
Maternal diet during pregnancy and lactation may prime offspring for weight gain and obesity later in life, according to Penn State College of Medicine researchers, who looked at rats whose mothers consumed a high-fat diet and found that the offsprings' feeding controls and feelings of fullness did not function normally.
Previous research shows that obesity compromises the neurocircuits that control how the stomach and intestine work to regulate how much we eat, and that the time around pregnancy and lactation is important in the development of these circuits. In both ...
Study: Worked-based wellness programs reduce weight
2015-03-30
A new study shows that workplace wellness programs can be effective in helping people lose weight by providing healthier food choices and increasing opportunities for physical activity, particularly if these efforts are designed with the input and active participation of employees. The two-year project - the results of which appear in the American Journal of Public Health - successfully reduced the number or people considered overweight or obese by almost 9 percent.
"Worksites are self-contained environments with established communication systems where interventions ...
Reviewing online homework at scale
2015-03-30
In computer-science classes, homework assignments consist of writing programs. It's easy to create automated tests that determine whether a given program yields the right outputs to a series of inputs. But those tests say nothing about whether the program code is clear or confusing, whether it includes unnecessary computation, and whether it meets the terms of the assignment.
Professors and teaching assistants review students' code to try to flag obvious mistakes, but even in undergraduate lecture courses, they usually don't have time for exhaustive analysis. And that ...
LiDAR studies of the Sept. 2013 Colorado Front Range flooding and debris flows
2015-03-30
Boulder, Colo., USA - Scott W. Anderson and colleagues use repeat aerial LiDAR to quantify the erosional impact of the heavy rains that inundated the Colorado Front Range in September 2013. The five-day storm triggered more than 1,100 landslides and debris flows in a 3,430-square-kilometer area due to 200-450 mm of heavy, steady rainfall. This number of hillslope failures in a single event represents unprecedented activity for the region in its ~150 years of written history.
This study for Geology addresses the role of such large, rare events in shaping landscapes by ...
Promoting maternal interaction improves growth, weight gain in preemies
2015-03-30
An intervention to teach mothers of preterm infants how to interact with their babies more effectively results in better weight gain and growth for the infants, according to a study funded in part by the National Institutes of Health.
A subsequent study showed that infants who had the benefit of a major component of this intervention more rapidly developed the muscle control needed for feeding successfully from a bottle. The initial findings were published on line in the Journal of Perinatology and the subsequent study in Advances in Neonatal Care.
Briefly, the intervention ...
Short bouts of high-intensity exercise before a fatty meal best for vascular health
2015-03-30
A short burst of intensive exercise before eating a high fat meal is better for blood vessel function in young people than the currently recommended moderate-intensity exercise, according to a new study from the University of Exeter.
Cardiovascular diseases including heart attacks and stroke are the leading cause of death in the UK, and the process underlying these diseases start in youth. An impairment in the function of blood vessels is thought to be the earliest event in this process, and this is known to occur in the hours after consuming a high fat meal.
Performing ...