(Press-News.org) If skin is the body's fortress against germ invaders, shouldn't minimally invasive surgeries – operations guided by camera probes, conducted entirely within the abdomen – carry less risk for serious infection than procedures that slice the same cavity wide open?
New research published in the December Annals of Surgery is challenging that assumption – at least for a subset of patients. Researchers from theUniversity of Rochester Medical Center (URMC) analyzed thousands of appendectomies (appendix removals) and found that, for a small group, the danger of deep abdominal infections was markedly less if the old-fashioned, open surgical approach was used.
"Our study corroborates a common theme in medicine: one size does not fit all," said study author John Monson, M.D., F.A.C.S., chief of the Division of Colorectal Surgery at URMC. "While the data suggest that the laparoscopic approach is still best for most patients, it might not be best for all."
U.S. surgeons perform more than a quarter million appendectomies annually, most of them laparoscopically – that is, inflating the abdomen with air, and using a popcorn-kernel-sized camera to pilot surgical instruments through tiny, centimeter-long holes in the skin.
"Since laparoscopy first came into vogue the early 90s, it's gone mainstream – mostly because its advantages are so obvious to the patient," Monson said. "The cuts through the skin are extremely small. There's less visible scarring and postoperative pain; patients have short hospital stays and return to work sooner."
But for a small group of patients underoing appendix removal, the study found that these perks come with a cost – greater risk for serious infection. But why? Why would a laparoscopic approach – which seems closed-off and sterile by design – carry a bigger risk for deep infection?
"We think it comes down to balance. It's not just about how much a procedure exposes the body to potential infection – it's also about how easily that procedure allows you to mitigate infection risk," Monson said. "Consider the open approach. Admittedly there's more chance of exposure to microbes – the wound is wide open. But there's also more opportunity to sterilize, since you can meticulously clean the operating space before closing it."
The laparoscopic approach, on the other hand, is much more ginger.
"There's less exposure to the outside environment, but there's also less opportunity to disinfect the organ space," he said. "The philosophy is to be delicate as possible, perform the surgery, then get out."
If a deep infection takes root, it's expensive to treat – to the tune of $50,000, and that figure doesn't begin to account for unrealized income due to missed work (potentially three to six months) while hospitalized, not to mention incalculable costs like distress to families.
"Compare this to an uncomplicated laparoscopic appendectomy – after which patients return to work in a week and a half – you see how devastating a deep infection can be," Monson said.
Some earlier analyses have implicated a connection between laparoscopic surgery and risk for infection in the organ space, but even meta-analyses (studies of studies) had relatively small sample sizes – too small for surgeons to draw definitive recommendations.
"This larger study afforded us that opportunity," Monson said. "By tapping the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program database, we were able to analyze almost 40,000 appendectomies performed between 2005 and 2008."
The study also begins to paint a picture of the type of patients who might fare better with an open procedure. Poring over the data, the team noticed trends – factors that might pre-dispose some patients to being at higher risk for a serious infection. For instance, presenting at the hospital with a high white blood cell count (which signals that the body is already fighting infection); being male (perhaps because men "stomach" pain longer, and wait to go to the Emergency Department until their condition is more advanced); having diabetes; simply being older; or being a smoker (chemicals in cigarettes have a detrimental impact on wound healing – and, smoking tends to be a marker for other unhealthy habits, such as excessive alcohol consumption).
"We found that, for a small group 'high-risk' patients – those who have several risk-elevating factors working against them at the same time – the risk of a deep infection is about 8.9 percent with an open surgery. But that risk jumped to 12.3 percent when the appendix was removed laparoscopically."
For most other (low-risk) patients, the type of surgery had little bearing on their chance of developing a deep infection (though risk did rise slightly – from 0.3 to 0.4 percent – when choosing a laparoscopy over an open procedure).
"I think the data is pretty clear: for a select cohort of folks needing their appendix removed, we would be wise to consider an open procedure," Monson said. "This is what good medicine is about – tailoring our approach based on the patient. It's about being willing to adapt."
INFORMATION:
In addition to Monson, paper co-authors from URMC's Division of Colorectal Surgery included Fergal Fleming, M.D.; Michael Kim, M.D.; Rabih Salloum, M.D.; together with Susan Messing and Doug Gunzler from the Department of Biostatistics and Computational Biology.
END
Researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology in Bremen, Germany and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.) in Cambridge, Massachusetts have found a remarkable effect while studying how marine particles sink, which could affect the way scientists assess global carbon fluxes. Their question - How fast does organic material and debris clumped together forming porous particles settle to the sea floor? Microbes colonizing these particles degrade the organic matter and release carbon dioxide back to the water. The downward velocity of the particles ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio – One of the world's foremost experts on climate change is warning that if humans don't moderate their use of fossil fuels, there is a real possibility that we will face the environmental, societal and economic consequences of climate change faster than we can adapt to them.
Lonnie Thompson, distinguished university professor in the School of Earth Sciences at Ohio State University, posed that possibility in a just-released special climate-change edition of the journal The Behavior Analyst.
He also discussed how the rapid and accelerating retreat of the ...
ROCHESTER, Minn. -- Mayo Clinic (http://www.mayoclinic.org/) researchers found that the part of the brain generating seizures in individuals with epilepsy is functionally isolated from surrounding brain regions. The researchers hope this finding could be a clinical biomarker to help identify individuals with abnormal brain function. This study was presented at the American Epilepsy Society's (http://www.aesnet.org/) annual meeting in San Antonio on Dec. 4.
Epilepsy (http://www.mayoclinic.org/epilepsy/) is a disorder characterized by the occurrence of two or more seizures. ...
Milan, Italy, 8 December 2010 – Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and developmental reading disability (RD) are complex childhood disorders that frequently occur together; if a child is experiencing trouble with reading, symptoms of ADHD are often also present. However, the reason for this correlation remains unknown. A new study reported in the latest special issue of Cortex (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/00109452), dedicated to "Developmental Dyslexia and Dysgraphia", has suggested that the disorders have common genetic influences, which may ...
A new study by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Center for Injury Research and Policy finds that youth generally perceive community street outreach workers positively, regardless of whether they have personally worked with one. Street outreach workers are typically members of the community who intervene to prevent conflict and retaliation, and in some programs, also connect individuals with needed services, such as housing, health care and job training. While communities across the United States are increasingly using street workers as a strategy to connect at-risk youth ...
Milan, Italy, 8 December 2010 – Learning to read and write are complex processes, which can be disrupted in various ways, leading to disorders known as dyslexia and dysgraphia. Two new studies, published in a recent special issue of Elsevier's Cortex (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/00109452) provide evidence of this variety, suggesting that effective treatment needs to take it into account.
A group of researchers from the Universities of Bari and Rome in Italy studied the reading and writing abilities of 33 Italian dyslexic children, comparing their performance ...
Catnip, the plant that attracts domestic cats like an irresistible force, has proven 99 percent effective in repelling the blood-sucking flies that attack horses and cows, causing $2 billion in annual loses to the cattle industry. That's the word from a report published in ACS' biweekly Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry.
Junwei Zhu and colleagues note that stable flies not only inflict painful bites, but also transmit multiple diseases. Cattle harried by these bloodsuckers may produce less meat and milk, have trouble reproducing, and develop diseases that can ...
Contrary to popular belief, birth control pills account for less than 1 percent of the estrogens found in the nation's drinking water supplies, scientists have concluded in an analysis of studies published on the topic. Their report suggests that most of the sex hormone — source of concern as an endocrine disruptor with possible adverse effects on people and wildlife — enters drinking water supplies from other sources. The report appears in ACS' biweekly journal Environmental Science & Technology.
Amber Wise, Kacie O'Brien and Tracey Woodruff note ongoing concern about ...
ANN ARBOR, Mich.---Under just the right conditions---which involve an ultra-high-intensity laser beam and a two-mile-long particle accelerator---it could be possible to create something out of nothing, according to University of Michigan researchers.
The scientists and engineers have developed new equations that show how a high-energy electron beam combined with an intense laser pulse could rip apart a vacuum into its fundamental matter and antimatter components, and set off a cascade of events that generates additional pairs of particles and antiparticles.
"We can ...
The enzyme that makes fireflies glow is lighting up the scientific path toward a long-sought new medical imaging agent to better monitor treatment with heparin, the blood thinner that millions of people take to prevent or treat blood clots, scientists are reporting. Their study appears in the ACS' monthly journal Bioconjugate Chemistry.
Bruce Branchini and colleagues describe a need for new medical imaging agents that emit near-infrared light — the light rays that "night vision" technology detects, enabling soldiers to see in the dark. Those rays penetrate deeper into ...
