Who gets a transplant organ
People tend to spread scarce resources across groups, but allocation to individuals is more medically efficient, Rutgers study shows
(Press-News.org) Imagine 12 patients who need new kidneys, and six kidneys available. How would you allocate them? New research by Rutgers social psychologists suggests your answer would depend on how the patients and their situations are presented to you.
In research recently published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, Gretchen Chapman and Jeff DeWitt of Rutgers and Helen Colby of the University of California-Los Angeles found that people make dramatically different decisions about who should receive a transplant depending on whether the potential recipients are presented as individuals or as part of two separate groups.
"The most efficient way to allocate those kidneys is to give all six to the people with the best chance of a successful transplant," says Chapman, a professor of psychology in the School of Arts and Sciences at Rutgers. "But that's not always how it works. It depends on how you frame the choices."
The study might have been done using any scarce resource, but transplant organs make a particularly pressing example. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services says there are 123,000 people waiting for organs nationwide, and 21 die waiting each day.
In their first study, researchers showed half the participants two groups of six fictional patients. Each patient had a picture and a first name, but one group was collectively labeled as having a poor chance of transplant success, while the other one was labeled as having a good chance. The other half of the participants also saw the two groups of six fictional patients, but there was an individual prognosis attached to each patient's name and picture. Almost two thirds (65 percent) of the people who saw the individual-level prognosis information chose the most efficient option - giving the kidneys to the people most likely to benefit from them. But less than half the people (46 percent) who saw the group-level prognosis information did so.
In second and third studies, participants saw the patients either in two groups or as a unified whole. Participants were less efficient when allocating across two groups than when allocating to 12 individuals.
"It's as if people said, 'Ooooh, groups! We should spread the resources around,'" Chapman said.
In Study 2, half the participants saw patients with identifying information in addition to prognosis - names, pictures, ages - and half saw them with no identifying information but the prognosis and a number (Patient 1, Patient 2, etc.). In the third study, participants had a chance to explain their allocations. Whenever there were groups, most participants wanted to distribute kidneys to both groups.
The more information beyond the prognosis presented about each patient, the less efficient participants were in allocating kidneys.
In their explanations for their allocation decisions, participants in the third study often said they were trying to be efficient, but cited information other than the patients' prognoses. For example, participants often cited a patient's age as more important than his or her prognosis. They might reject an older person with a good prognosis in favor of a younger person with a poor one. "People might say, 'Well, I know the young guy has a poor prognosis, but he's young, so if the transplant works, he'll get years of use out of the kidney, so I'm giving him a kidney,'" Chapman said.
When potential recipients were considered in groups, participants tended to allocate organs across the groups, ignoring information about the patients' chances of success. Also, Chapman says these findings suggest people have a strong bias toward equality when it comes to divvying up limited resources, even if equality doesn't ultimately lead to the most logical or effective decisions. There are some contexts, however, in which the grouping effect could be helpful.
"Think about managers deciding on whom to hire or promote," Chapman says. "If they grouped candidates by gender instead of presenting them as individuals, they might be prompted to spread jobs across the groups more evenly, which would lead to the hiring or promotion of more women."
The researchers plan on exploring the potential positive outcomes of grouping in future studies.
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
As animal architects go, the average termite doesn't have many tools at their disposal - just their bodies, soil and saliva. And as guidance, variations in wind speed and direction and daily fluctuations in temperature as the sun rises and sets.
Despite such limitations, the tiny insects have managed build structures that are efficiently ventilated - a challenge that human architects still struggle with.
Led by L. Mahadevan, Lola England de Valpine Professor of Applied Mathematics, of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology, and of Physics, a team of researchers that ...
RIVERSIDE, Calif. -- Advance supply signals, such as financial health and production viability, contain rich information on supplier conditions. When and how these signals should be used is critical for improving firms' forecast and profitability.
A recent paper, "Dynamic Supply Risk Management with Signal-Based Forecast, Multi-Sourcing, and Discretionary Selling," provides mathematical tools and management principles on this issue.
The authors, Long Gao (from University of California, Riverside School of Business Administration), Nan Yang and Renyu Zhang (both from ...
Scientists have pinpointed a population of neurons in the brain that influences whether one drink leads to two, which could ultimately lead to a cure for alcoholism and other addictions.
A study, published in the Journal of Neuroscience by researchers at the Texas A&M Health Science Center College of Medicine, finds that alcohol consumption alters the structure and function of neurons in the dorsomedial striatum, a part of the brain known to be important in goal-driven behaviors. The findings could be an important step toward creation of a drug to combat alcoholism. ...
New research indicates that household food insecurity dramatically increases the likelihood of metabolic diseases in children, with many showing chronic disease markers before they graduate from high school. The study published today in the Journal of the American Osteopathic Association.
Food insecurity, defined as lacking access to food for an active, healthy life, is a preventable health threat. Yet, lack of basic access to food affects 14.3 percent of all U.S.
households and 19.5 percent of households with children.
"This is a looming health issue for the nation. ...
Brooklyn, NY - Xian-Cheng Jiang, PhD, professor of cell biology at SUNY Downstate Medical Center, has led a study identifying a new approach for lowering "bad" lipids in blood circulation, a critical means to combat devastating cardiovascular diseases such as atherosclerosis. The research was published in the online edition of Gastroenterology.
The team established that an enzyme called LPCAT3 (Lysophosphatidylcholine acyltransferase 3) is involved in the biosynthesis of phosphatidylcholine (PC), a type of compound lipid that is a major component of cell membranes. ...
Northridge, CA (September 2, 2015) - A study published Monday in the Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved (JHCPU) concludes that ethnicity is associated with nutrient shortfalls of important nutrients. This study compared usual intake for essential nutrients between Non-Hispanic Black and Non-Hispanic White Americans using data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), 2007-2010. This new analysis is consistent with previous research and confirms a continuing diet-related health disparity in the American population.
Nutrient shortfalls ...
LA JOLLA, Calif., September 2, 2015 - A new Sanford Burnham Prebys Medical Discovery Institute (SBP) study takes a step forward in understanding how similar, yet genetically unrelated neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's disease, frontal temporal dementia, and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) are caused by the protein tau. The findings, published today in Neuron, create new opportunities to target this key protein that leads to the brain lesions found in patients with impaired motor functions and dementia.
"Our research shows how the abundance of a protein ...
Intentional burning in tropical forests has accounted for nearly 20% of all greenhouse-gas emissions since preindustrial times and will have major implications for Earth's climate and biodiversity in years to come. To better understand the complex dynamics surrounding these fires, a team of researchers led by Jennifer K. Balch, of the University of Colorado-Boulder, conducted a six-year controlled burn experiment in an Amazonian rainforest block located in Mato Grasso, Brazil. The results are described in an article that is part of BioScience's just-released Special Section ...
LA JOLLA--When you're taking a walk around the block, your body is mostly on autopilot--you don't have to consciously think about alternating which leg you step with or which muscles it takes to lift a foot and put it back down. That's thanks to a set of cells in your spinal cord that help translate messages between your brain and your motor neurons, which control muscles.
Now, for the first time, researchers have created a method to watch--in real time--the activity of those motor neurons. The new technology, developed by Salk scientists and published in Neuron, is ...
Georgia Institute of Technology researchers have developed a new artificially intelligent system that crowdsources plots for interactive stories, which are popular in video games and let players choose different branching story options.
With potentially limitless crowdsourced plot points, the system could allow for more creative stories and an easier method for interactive narrative generation. Current AI models for games have a limited number of scenarios, no matter what a player chooses. They depend on a dataset already programmed into a model by experts.
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: