PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
FREE PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Hunters and busybodies: Researchers use Wikipedia to measure different types of curiosity

The study from Penn and American University draws on psychology, philosophy and network science to better understand the different ways curiosity is actually practiced


Hunters and busybodies: Researchers use Wikipedia to measure different types of curiosity
2021-01-12
(Press-News.org) Curiosity has been found to play a role in our learning and emotional well-being, but due to the open-ended nature of how curiosity is actually practiced, measuring it is challenging. Psychological studies have attempted to gauge participants' curiosity through their engagement in specific activities, such as asking questions, playing trivia games, and gossiping. However, such methods focus on quantifying a person's curiosity rather than understanding the different ways it can be expressed.

Efforts to better understand what curiosity actually looks like for different people have underappreciated roots in the field of philosophy. Varying styles have been described with loose archetypes, like "hunter" and "busybody" -- evocative, but hard to objectively measure when it comes to studying how people collect new information.

A new study led by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania's School of Engineering and Applied Science, the Annenberg School for Communication, and the Department of Philosophy and Religion at American University, uses Wikipedia browsing as a method for describing curiosity styles. Using a branch of mathematics known as graph theory, their analysis of curiosity opens doors for using it as a tool to improve learning and life satisfaction.

The interdisciplinary study, published in Nature Human Behavior, was undertaken by Danielle Bassett, J. Peter Skirkanich Professor in Penn Engineering's Departments of Bioengineering and Electrical and Systems Engineering, David Lydon-Staley, then a postdoctoral fellow in her lab and now an assistant professor in the Annenberg School of Communication, two members of Bassett's Complex Systems Lab: graduate student Dale Zhou and postdoctoral fellow Ann Sizemore Blevins, and Perry Zurn, assistant professor from American University's Department of Philosophy.

"The reason this paper exists is because of the participation of many people from different fields," says Lydon-Staley. "Perry has been researching curiosity in novel ways that show the spectrum of curious practice and Dani has been using networks to describe form and function in many different systems. My background in human behavior allowed me to design and conduct a study linking the styles of curiosity to a measurable activity: Wikipedia searches."

Zurn's research on how different people express curiosity provided a framework for the study.

"Each curiosity style has its own 'kinesthetic signature' that describes how a person naturally searches for information," says Zurn. "For example, the 'hunter' style is characterized by the seeking of closely related information, aiming to dive deeply into a certain topic, while the 'busybody' jumps from topic to topic, collecting loosely connected information."

The study was comprised of 149 participants, who were instructed to browse Wikipedia for 15 minutes a day over the course of 21 days. With no further instructions on what pages to visit, the participants' paths through the site revealed the kinesthetic signatures of their curiosity styles.

"Wikipedia allowed both introverts and extroverts to have equal opportunity in curious practice, a limitation in other studies of curiosity, while the ad-free search engine allowed individuals to truly be captains of their own curiosity ships," says Bassett.

While browsing, data was recorded as knowledge networks where each unique Wikipedia page visited became a node and the relatedness between Wikipedia pages, determined by text similarity between two pages, created the thickness of the edges between the nodes.

Participants with the hunter curiosity style exhibited a tight network with relatively high clustering of nodes, thick edges, and short overall path lengths. Those with the busybody curiosity style exhibited a looser network with nodes further separated by thin connecting edges and longer path lengths.

The signatures of a participant's curiosity style were not written in stone, however.

"We found that people are curious in their own ways and fall in and out of different styles, shown by changes in the knowledge network structures over time. We then wanted to understand the drivers of these changes," says Bassett.

To better understand the factors that influence which curiosity style a person might use, the researchers surveyed the participants on indicators of well-being in a laboratory visit before their Wikipedia browsing began. These indicators included "deprivation sensitivity," or the tendency to seek information in order to fill knowledge gaps, and "sensation seeking," or the tendency to seek novel and exciting information. Other factors recorded participants' tendencies to browse topics for fun, seek out social interaction, and tolerate stress. The information from these surveys was incorporated in the models of the knowledge networks, allowing the team to assess the mechanisms behind curiosity styles.

"We hypothesize that a switch from hunter to busybody style might arise due to sensation seeking, or the craving for novelty and new information during the day," says Bassett.

"By measuring a person's level of sensation seeking before each Wikipedia browsing session, we found that people tended to take larger steps between nodes when the tendency to seek new information was high," says Lydon-Staley, creating a loose knowledge network.

The participants who originally scored higher in deprivation sensitivity tended to form tighter networks as they sought information to fill knowledge gaps. This network structure indicated the hunter style of information seeking. For example, one participant searched for "History of the Jews in Germany," "Hep-Hep riots," "Zionism," "Nathan Birnbaum," and "Theodor Herzl," all centralized around Jewish history.

On the other end of the spectrum, participants who reported lower deprivation sensitivity exhibited a knowledge network characterized by thinner links, more loosely connected topics, and longer overall network paths. An example of this style is a Wikipedia search for "Physical chemistry," "Me Too movement," "The Partridge Family," "Harborne Primary School," "HIP 79431," and "Tom Bigelow."

"With this method, we can now quantify the kind of information or resources we store. Resources affect well-being, and this research complicates, in a good way, how resources affect well-being," says Lydon-Staley.

Bassett adds that, "while there may be different motivators behind each curiosity style, each style has a purpose."

In addition to the importance of each style, our ability to learn and our emotional well-being may be more related to the connection of information rather than the information itself.

"Curiosity is edgework. It is more about building structures of information than about acquiring separate informational units. This can motivate us, as educators, to ask how we can help students not only understand existing knowledge connections but get excited about building new ones," says Zurn.

As to whether we should be directing curiosity to improve education, Lydon-Staley says, "We need more data to know how to use this information in the classroom, but I hope it discourages the idea that there are curious and incurious people."

"Curiosity should be encouraged and expectations of certain types of curiosity to be exhibited by certain types of students is limiting. We should value and respect each style of curious practice while being less prescriptive for how to accomplish a task," says Bassett.

Some real-world applications that align with this understanding of curiosity are using projects that students can tune to their own curiosity, supporting quieter students to express their curiosity in less boisterous ways, and realizing that students may be able to solve problems in ways unimaginable to the teacher.

"By visualizing these networks, we can begin to see not only the spectrum of hunter and busybody styles, but the incredible flexibility that characterizes curiosity and the knowledge networks it builds. Appreciating the diversity of curious practice can be really empowering for students, especially those who are otherwise socially marginalized or underserved. Rather than asking 'am I curious or not?,' they can ask 'which style or styles do I have?' and 'what can I do with it?'," says Zurn.

It is clear that curiosity is important for our well-being and the visualization of these knowledge networks may help to pinpoint where curiosity reflects emotional state and vice versa. Recent research from the same team showed that when we maintain a consistent level of curiosity throughout the day, we are more likely to experience increased feelings of life satisfaction and decreased symptoms of depression. Their work suggests that engaging in curiosity more often and having an open mind about what curiosity looks like may improve well-being, a link the team plans to test using interventions in future work.

In a time when human interaction is stinted and our natural curiosity is interrupted by ads and algorithms, curiosity examined through a network perspective helps us see how we can use curiosity to increase life satisfaction and communication with others. While a clear benefit of this study is its potential future applications in education and emotional well-being, its network approach and interdisciplinary research design also promotes collaborative scientific studies. This interdisciplinary approach allows us to learn from many perspectives and propose many applications for knowledge networks as tools to enhance our well-being beyond education.

INFORMATION:


[Attachments] See images for this press release:
Hunters and busybodies: Researchers use Wikipedia to measure different types of curiosity

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Beating the 'billion-dollar bug' is a shared burden

Beating the billion-dollar bug is a shared burden
2021-01-12
A lurking threat that has stymied US corn growers for decades is now returning to the forefront: western corn rootworm. Sometimes referred to as the "billion-dollar bug," the species' tiny larvae chew through the roots of corn plants, causing devastating yield losses. In 2003, farmers began planting a genetically engineered variety of corn known as "Bt," which produces a protein toxic to the pest species - but by 2009, the billion-dollar bug had already evolved adaptations for resistance to the toxin. A new study suggests that slowing the resurgence of western corn rootworm may require a larger-scale strategy than previously thought. The findings, ...

Mechanisms in the kidney that control magnesium and calcium levels discovered

2021-01-12
BOSTON - While investigating the underlying causes of a rare skin disorder, a researcher at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) discovered a previously unknown mechanism in the kidneys that is important for regulating levels of magnesium and calcium in the blood. The discovery, described in the journal Cell Reports, highlights the role of a previously little-studied gene called KCTD1. The gene directs production of a protein that regulates the kidney's ability to reabsorb magnesium and calcium from urine and return it to the bloodstream. A genetic mutation causing the loss of KCTD1 results in defects in nephrons, ...

'Old Faithful' cosmic eruption shows black hole ripping at star

2021-01-12
You've heard of Old Faithful, the Yellowstone National Park geyser that erupts every hour or two, a geological phenomenon on a nearly predictable schedule. Now, an international group of scientists who study space have discovered an astronomical "Old Faithful" - an eruption of light flashing about once every 114 days on a nearly predictable schedule. The researchers believe it is a tidal disruption event, a phenomenon that happens when a star gets so close to a black hole that the black hole "rips" away pieces of the star, causing the flare. The team made the discovery using data from NASA and from a network of telescopes operated by The Ohio State University. Their findings, presented today at the Astronomical Society's annual meeting and accepted for publication ...

New method helps pocket-sized DNA sequencer achieve near-perfect accuracy 

2021-01-12
Researchers have found a simple way to eliminate almost all sequencing errors produced by a widely used portable DNA sequencer, potentially enabling scientists working outside the lab to study and track microorganisms like the SARS-CoV-2 virus more efficiently.   Using special molecular tags, the team was able to reduce the five-to-15 per cent error rate of Oxford Nanopore Technologies' MinION device to less than 0.005 per cent -- even when sequencing many long stretches of DNA at a time.     "The MinION has revolutionized the field of genomics by freeing DNA sequencing from the confines of large laboratories," says Ryan Ziels, an ...

Gene-editing produces tenfold increase in superbug slaying antibiotics

Gene-editing produces tenfold increase in superbug slaying antibiotics
2021-01-12
Scientists have used gene-editing advances to achieve a tenfold increase in the production of super-bug targeting formicamycin antibiotics. The John Innes Centre researchers used the technology to create a new strain of Streptomyces formicae bacteria which over-produces the medically promising molecules. Discovered within the last ten years, formicamycins have great potential because, under laboratory conditions, superbugs like MRSA do not become resistant to them. However, Streptomyces formicae only produce the antibiotics in small quantities. This has made it difficult to scale up ...

DNA in water used to uncover genes of invasive fish

2021-01-12
ITHACA, NY - Invasive round goby fish have impacted fisheries in the Great Lakes and the Finger Lakes by competing with native species and eating the eggs of some species of game fish. But the camouflaged bottom dwellers can be difficult to find and collect - especially when they first enter a new body of water and their numbers are low and they might be easier to remove. In a proof-of-principle study, Cornell researchers describe a new technique in which they analyzed environmental DNA - or eDNA - from water samples in Cayuga Lake to gather nuanced information about the presence of these invasive fish. The study, "Nuclear eDNA Estimates Population Allele Frequencies and Abundance in Experimental Mesocosms and Field Samples," was ...

First-degree relative with kidney disease increases disease risk by three-fold

2021-01-12
In a large population-based family study, family history of kidney disease was strongly associated with increased risk of chronic kidney disease. In this large population-based family study recently published in the American Journal of Kidney Diseases, researchers investigated the familial aggregation of CKD by comparing the risk of chronic kidney disease (CKD) in individuals with an affected first-degree relative to that in the general population. Participants with an affected first-degree relative were observed to have a threefold higher risk of CKD compared to that in the general population, independent of BMI, hypertension, diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, history of cardiovascular disease (CVD), and smoking status. ...

Is the COVID-19 vaccine safe for nursing mothers?

Is the COVID-19 vaccine safe for nursing mothers?
2021-01-12
New Rochelle, NY, January 12, 2021--The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine (ABM) does not recommend cessation of breastfeeding for individuals who are vaccinated against COVID-19. In a new statement, the ABM suggests that lactating women discuss the risks and benefits of vaccination with their health care provider, within the context of their risk of contracting COVID-19 and of developing severe disease, according to the peer-reviewed journal Breastfeeding Medicine. Click here to read the ABM statement now. This is a challenging topic because the vaccine trials excluded lactating women. Thus, there are no clinical data regarding the safety ...

Killing cancer by unleashing the body's own immune system

Killing cancer by unleashing the bodys own immune system
2021-01-12
The body's immune system is the first line of defense against infections like bacteria, viruses or cancers. Some cancers, however, have developed the art of molecular deception to avoid destruction by the body's immune system. However, a University of Missouri researcher might have found a new way to help the body's immune system get past that deception and destroy the cancer. "Normally, your body's immune cells are constantly on patrol to identify and destroy foreign entities in the body," said Yves Chabu, an assistant professor in the Division of Biological Sciences. "Normal cells put up a 'don't-eat-me' molecular ...

New process evaluates patients for elective surgeries following COVID-19

2021-01-12
Acknowledging that COVID-19 may be here to stay, Oregon Health & Science University has laid out a series of steps to prepare patients for elective surgery following their illness. The evaluation, outlined in a commentary published in the journal Perioperative Medicine, is believed to be the first published protocol laying out a COVID-era path forward in American medicine. "We think this is groundbreaking," said senior author Avital O'Glasser, M.D., associate professor of medicine (hospital medicine) in the OHSU School of Medicine. "We are hoping other clinics and surgical centers can use this to keep their patients safe." The work started around Memorial Day, when OHSU clinicians began to see an increasing number of patients ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Where COVID-19 hit hardest, sudden deaths outside the hospital increased

Many parents say teens with anxiety, depression may benefit from peer confidants at school

Vermont's BIPOC drivers are most likely to have a run-in with police, study shows

Students returning home may have caused 9,400 secondary COVID-19 infections across UK

Changing diets -- not less physical activity -- may best explain childhood obesity crisis

Scientists shed light on how and why some people report "hearing the dead"

Better diet and glucose uptake in the brain lead to longer life in fruit flies

The COVID-19 pandemic in brazil has overwhelmed its health systems

New study connects religiosity in US South Asians to cardiovascular disease

Rapid blood test identifies COVID-19 patients at high risk of severe disease

Scientists offer road map to improve environmental observations in the Indian Ocean

USask study finds COVID isolation worsens student diets, inactivity, and alcohol intake

45% of adults over 65 lack online medical accounts, which could affect COVID vaccination

COVID-19 deaths really are different. But best practices for ICU care should still apply

T cells linked to myelin implicated in MS-like disease in monkeys

Conductive nature in crystal structures revealed at magnification of 10 million times

Nanodiamonds feel the heat

Glass frogs living near roaring waterfalls wave hello to attract mates

New study compiles four years of corn loss data from 26 states and Ontario, Canada

US fishing and seafood industries saw broad declines last summer due to COVID-19

Controlling chemical catalysts with sculpted light

Special interests can be assets for youth with autism

New videos show RNA as it's never been seen

USC study measures brain volume differences in people with HIV

Large mammals make soil more fertile in tropical forests

Principles of care established for young adults with substance use disorders

Physicists propose a new theory to explain one dimensional quantum liquids formation

Is your skin thirsty? Optoacoustic sensor measures water content in living tissue

Want a hot stock tip? Avoid this type of investment fund

Biodistribution of AAV gene transfer vectors in nonhuman primate

[Press-News.org] Hunters and busybodies: Researchers use Wikipedia to measure different types of curiosity
The study from Penn and American University draws on psychology, philosophy and network science to better understand the different ways curiosity is actually practiced