When looking at species declines, nuances and long-term data are important
(Press-News.org) The scientific process is an iterative and collaborative journey. Research is published, others can weigh in on results, and hypotheses can be corroborated, refuted, or further refined and tested. Though it may seem like second guessing or perhaps become contentious in some cases, this often overlooked aspect of the scientific method makes science better by continuing to challenge scientific assertions, thereby expanding and deepening our understanding.
An example of this process has been published today in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, in a collaboration between researchers from Louisiana State University, the University of Puerto Rico, and UConn. This new paper is a follow-up to an earlier response published in the same journal in 2018 that told of a collapsing food web and insect declines that were taking place in Puerto Rico, specifically as a result of global warming.
UConn Board of Trustees Distinguished Professor of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology and Executive Director of the Institute of the Environment, Mike Willig, and collaborators, have been working in Puerto Rico on long-term ecological research projects for decades, so when the paper came out, they took notice. The team includes lead author Timothy Schowalter and Manoj Pandey of LSU, Steven Presley also of UConn and Jess Zimmerman of the University of Puerto Rico.
"When we saw the initial paper and the claims of food web collapse we said, 'Well that is news to us!' but perhaps we weren't looking in the right places, or considering all of the possibilities. So we tried to, as science requires, see if the results were replicable or repeatable."
Willig explains that as insect populations appear to be on the decline in other areas of the world, the original paper on insect decline in Puerto Rico was among the first to claim declines due to global warming in a tropical setting. Willig and his collaborators decided to take a second look to see if they could corroborate the claims.
"We were not able to arrive at the same conclusions for a variety of reasons. The world is complex and there were a lot of problematic issues with the original research," Willig says the data that the authors of the initial paper selected and analytical approaches that they used were at the root of the problem. Critically, the original paper did not consider the complexities of the system, notably that Puerto Rico endures frequent hurricanes and tropical storms.
Nuances and long-term data changed the picture when looking at the original paper's hypothesis, says Willig,
"Many studies are like that first study in which part of the analyses involved two datasets, in this case taken 30 years apart. In contrast, our data looked at 29 years of annual research. Data can be consistent with one hypothesis but that doesn't make it right. Additionally, ecological research projects are often snapshots in time that correspond to the length of a grant, 3-5 years," says Willig. "That's why we're fortunate to have long-term data to disentangle the effects of warming from hurricane impacts and subsequent ecological succession."
Noting the flaws from the first study, the team used this long-term exploration as springboard to look deeper into their data to uncover trends of insect abundance.
"Puerto Rico is a disturbance-mediated environment where there are frequent hurricanes. Ecosystems in these disturbance-mediated environments are predisposed from an evolutionary perspective to be resistant to these storms," says Willig.
After a storm has blown through and brought down trees, the canopy is gone, temperatures on the ground increase, and leaves and other detritus becomes food for opportunists. Though a disaster for some species, these post-disturbance conditions lead to the perfect circumstances for a population boom in other species.
"The prediction is that due to global warming there will be an increase in the frequency of these high energy storms in the Caribbean. Storms will happen more often so that resident species will be evolving in a world dominated by more frequent hurricanes where habitats will represent early successional stages. The climatic environment and associated plant communities may move outside of tolerance limits of constituent animal species," says Willig.
"We see no species extinction on the site yet," but Willig notes that perhaps the original paper was right for the wrong reasons. Insect declines may not happen directly due to global warming but an increased hurricane frequency and intensity due to climate change could eventually push species beyond their limits.
"One of the cool things that came out of our study is that the hypothesis from the original food web collapse paper lead us to reanalyze our data in a way that we may not have done as quickly. It jarred us, it accelerated our desire to look at the data from multiple perspectives to try to disentangle the relative importance of warming, hurricanes and subsequent succession on the abundances of animal species, which is part of the self-correcting process of science. It also forces you to look outside the box and to examine your data to see how you can use it to distinguish between alternative hypotheses," says Willig.
The length of time over which data are collected adds value to those data. Long-term experiments are important for capturing the full story and nuances within a system. Willig likens the situation to regular medical checkups:
"The regular collection of data is important, like having annual checkups with your doctor. You may not be diabetic yet but your sugar levels may have been gradually increasing over the past 10 years, suggesting that there may be a problem. If you aren't doing regular checkups of the environment we will not have that early warning that environmental problems are on the horizon. It is the same with consistency, you can't fairly examine trends if you don't have comparable data at the same locations over a long term to assess ecosystem health."
Willig stresses that this new paper is not denying climate change is impacting insects around the world, but he emphasizes the need for more long-term monitoring of species abundances, and associated climatic and habitat data everywhere, to better understand what is going on in this time of rapid changes:
"What we are saying is that data are inadequate to show that global warming in Puerto Rico had an effect on the flora and fauna on the island, and in fact, we show that other climate change effects related to increasing hurricane frequency and intensity play a dominate role. Without long-term data from throughout the world, we don't know how general our result is compared to that other sites. It is necessary to have a network of sites collecting similar data in similar ways to see if a pattern is general regardless of geographic context."
All authors are part of the National Science Foundation's Long-term Ecological Research Program located at the Luquillo Experimental Forest (LUQ-LTER) in Puerto Rico.
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Hydrogen is an important factor in a sustainable energy system. The gas stores energy in chemical form and can be used in many ways: as a fuel, a feedstock for other fuels and chemicals or even to generate electricity in fuel cells. One solution to produce hydrogen in a climate-neutral way is the electrochemical splitting of water with the help of sunlight. This requires photoelectrodes that provide a photovoltage and photocurrent when exposed to light and at the same time do not corrode in water. Metal oxide compounds have promising prerequisites for this. For example, solar water splitting devices using bismuth ...
In a study of 500 sourdough starters spanning four continents, scientists have garnered new insights into the environmental factors that contribute to each sourdough starter's microbial ecosystem, and how different types of microbes influence both a sourdough's aroma and how quickly the sourdough rises. The results may surprise sourdough enthusiasts.
"We didn't just look at which microbes were growing in each starter," says Erin McKenney, co-author of the paper and an assistant professor of applied ecology at North Carolina State University. "We looked at what those microbes are doing, and how those microbes coexist with each other."
"There have been quite a few small studies on microbial ecosystems in sourdough," says Benjamin Wolfe, co-author of the study and ...
In the next years, increasing use of electronic devices in consumables and new technologies for the internet of things will increase the amount of electronic scrap. To save resources and minimize waste volumes, an eco-friendlier production and more sustainable lifecycle will be needed. Scientists of Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) have now been the first to produce displays, whose biodegradability has been checked and certified by an independent office. The results are reported in the Journal of Materials Chemistry. (DOI: 10.1039/d0tc04627b)
"For the first time, we have demonstrated that it is possible to produce sustainable displays that are largely based on natural ...
DALLAS (SMU) - A new study suggests children on the autism spectrum may be more likely to misinterpret healthy arguments between their parents as being negative, compared to children who aren't on the autism spectrum.
That means they may be missing out on an opportunity to learn from their parents how to handle conflict constructively, researchers Naomi Ekas and Chrystyna Kouros said.
"Children can learn how to best handle conflict from watching their parents," said Kouros, associate professor of psychology at SMU (Southern Methodist University). "Seeing parents ...
Manipulating individual electrons with the goal of employing quantum effects offers new possibilities and greater precision in electronics. However, these single-electron circuits are governed by the laws of quantum mechanics, meaning that deviations from error-free operation still occur - albeit (in the best possible scenario) only very rarely. Thus, insights into both the physical origin the and metrological aspects of this fundamental uncertainty are crucial for the further development of quantum circuitry. To this end, scientists from PTB and the University of Latvia have collaborated to develop a statistical testing methodology. Their results have been published in the journal Nature Communications.
Single-electron circuits are already used as electric-current quantum standards and ...
A study performed by the Universitat Oberta de Catalunya (UOC) provided eight recommendations for improving the online technology to help with the treatment and diagnosis of neglected tropical diseases (NTDs). The analysis, presented in a recent open-access publication, was performed by UOC researchers Carme Carrion and Marta Aymerich from the eHealth Lab and Noemí Robles from the eHealth Center, together with José Antonio Ruiz Postigo from the World Health Organization and Oriol Solà de Morales from the Health Innovation Technology Transfer Foundation. In the study, the authors looked at the context of the existing ...
For mice, the earliest social memories can form at three days old and last into adulthood, scientists report on January 26 in the journal Cell Reports. They show that mouse pups prefer their mothers to unfamiliar mouse mothers as newborns and remember them after up to 100 days apart--although they prefer unfamiliar mouse mothers as adults.
"I'm really interested in studying the development of social memory," says first author Blake J. Laham of Princeton University, "which is the memory we have for other individuals including certain facts and features about them." These early ...
Representatives from a network of women deans, chairs and distinguished faculty in biomedical engineering are calling upon the National Institutes of Health and other funding agencies to address disparities in allocating support to Black researchers. The group made the call to action in the Jan. 26, 2021, issue of the journal Cell.
In examining the racial inequities and injustices that prevent Black faculty from equitably contributing to science and achieving their full potential, insufficient federal funding for research by Black scientists rose to the top as a key issue.
According to studies of National Institutes ...
WASHINGTON, January 26, 2021 -- As the pandemic has continued to spread globally, studies indicate the COVID-19 virus may be contained in aerosols that can be generated and spread through breathing, coughing, sneezing, or talking by infected individuals. Researchers are increasingly focused on developing tools and methods to assist in decontaminating surfaces and spaces.
While scientists have previously explored the use of electromagnetic energy to deactivate flu virus in bulk fluids, less work has been done to understand the role of nonionizing radiation, ...
What The Study Did: Survey data from school-age children and adolescents in Guangdong province, China, were used to assess self-reported psychological distress associated with the COVID-19 pandemic.
Authors: Chichen Zhang, M.D., and Ruibin Zhang, Ph.D., of Southern Medical University in Guangzhou, and Xuefeng Yi, M.D., of the Health Publicity and Education Center of Guangdong Province, all in China, are the corresponding authors.
To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website at this link https://media.jamanetwork.com/
Editor's Note: The article includes funding/support disclosures. ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] When looking at species declines, nuances and long-term data are important