Academic institutions receive lower financial returns from biotechnology licenses than commercial firms

Bentley University study shows disparity between returns from public and private sector investment in biomedical science

2023-03-31

(Press-News.org) BENTLEY UNIVERSITY

The financial terms of biotechnology licenses from academic institutions are significantly less favorable than those of comparable licenses between commercial firms according to a new study from Bentley University’s Center for Integration of Science and Industry. The study, published in the journal PLOS ONE, shows that the royalties and payments to academic institutions are significantly lower than those to commercial firms for similar licenses and products at the same stages of development.

The article, titled “Comparing the economic terms of biotechnology licenses from academic institutions with those between commercial firms,” is the first to make an explicit comparison of academic and commercial licenses. Licenses of biotechnologies from academic institutions provide a mechanism by which scientific discoveries made with government-funded research grants are transferred to companies to develop commercial products. These licenses provide financial returns to the public sector, which universities can use to support research or education, and enable industry to develop innovative products, create jobs, and generate economic growth.

“Our previous work has shown that the U.S. government invests more than a billion dollars for the early-stage basic or applied research underlying each innovative, first-in-class drug. Here, we examined how much of the profit from such products is returned to the public.” said Fred Ledley, Director of the Center for Integration of Science and Industry, and the senior author on this study. “The results suggest that the public sector is not getting the same returns that a company would expect from similar licenses.”

The Bentley University study compared the economic terms of 239 biotechnology licenses from academic institutions to biotechnology companies with 916 comparable licenses between commercial firms. Academic licenses had lower royalty rates (3% versus 8%), lower total payments (deal size) ($900 thousand versus $31 million), and lower payments before product launch (precommercial payments) ($1.1 million versus $25 million). While academic licenses, on average, involved products at less advanced stages of development than corporate licenses, differences in the stage of development accounted for less than half of the disparity between academic and corporate licenses. Considering differences in stage of development together with differences in research payments, co-development, co-commercialization, exclusivity, or grants of stock, academic licenses had royalty rates that were 3-3.6% lower than corporate licenses, deal sizes that were $11.4-$12.2 million lower than corporate licenses, and precommercial payments that were $7.6-$9.4 million lower than corporate licenses.

Prateet Shah was the lead author of this work along with Dr. Gregory Vaughan and Dr. Ledley. Mr. Shah conducted this research as an undergraduate researcher at Bentley University.

This analysis used the BioSciDB database provided by Mark Edwards and BioScience Advisors, now part of Evaluate Ltd.

This work was supported by a grant from the National Biomedical Research Foundation.

THE CENTER FOR INTEGRATION OF SCIENCE AND INDUSTRY at Bentley University focuses on advancing the translation of scientific discoveries to create public value. The Center is an environment for interdisciplinary scholarship spanning basic science, data analytics, business and public policy. For more information, visit www.bentley.edu/sciindustry and follow us on Twitter @sciindustry and LinkedIn.

BENTLEY UNIVERSITY is more than just one of the nation's top business schools. It is a lifelong-learning community that creates successful leaders who make business a force for positive change. With a combination of business and the arts and sciences and a flexible, personalized approach to education, Bentley provides students with critical thinking and practical skills that prepare them to lead successful, rewarding careers. Founded in 1917, the university enrolls 4,100 undergraduate and 1,000 graduate and PhD students and is set on 163 acres in Waltham, Massachusetts, 10 miles west of Boston. For more information, visit bentley.edu. For more information, visit bentley.edu. Follow us on Twitter @BentleyU #BentleyUResearch.

END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Harnessing nature to promote planetary sustainability

2023-03-31

As Earth’s population grows, the demands of modern lifestyles place mounting strain on the global environment. Proposed solutions to preserve and promote planetary sustainability can sometimes prove more harmful than helpful. However, technologies that harness natural processes could be more successful. Such technologies are the focus of the latest issue of the open access journal PLOS Biology, which features a special collection publishing March 31st of papers highlighting biology-based solutions that could be applied to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, eliminate non-degradable plastics, produce food or energy ...

Study examines how social rank affects response to stress

2023-03-31

Can an individual’s social status have an impact on their level of stress? Researchers at Tulane University put that question to the test and believe that social rank, particularly in females, does indeed affect the stress response. In a study published in Current Biology, Tulane psychology professor Jonathan Fadok, PhD, and postdoctoral researcher Lydia Smith-Osborne looked at two forms of psychosocial stress — social isolation and social instability — and how they manifest themselves based on social rank. They conducted their research on adult female mice, putting them in pairs and allowing them to form a stable ...

The stars in the brain may be information regulators

2023-03-31

Long thought of as “brain glue,” the star-shaped cells called astrocytes—members of a family of cells found in the central nervous system called glial that help regulate blood flow, synaptic activity, keep neurons healthy, and play an important role in breathing. Despite this growing appreciation for astrocytes, much remains unknown about the role these cells play in helping neurons and the brain process information. “We believe astrocytes can add a new dimension to our understanding of how external and internal information is merged in the ...

The Institut Pasteur and the University of São Paulo sign articles of association to establish the Institut Pasteur in São Paulo

2023-03-31

On Friday March 31st, 2023 at a ceremony in Paris, the Institut Pasteur President, Professor Stewart Cole, and the University of São Paulo (USP) Rector, Carlos Gilberto Carlotti Junior, signed articles of association for the Institut Pasteur in São Paulo, a private non-profit organization under Brazilian law. The mission of the institute, an associate member of the Pasteur Network, is to conduct research in the field of biology that contributes to the development of human health, and to promote outreach, education, innovation and knowledge transfer activities and public health measures. The Institut Pasteur ...

Mathematical model provides bolt of understanding for lightning-produced X-rays

2023-03-31

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — In the early 2000s, scientists observed lightning discharge producing X-rays comprising high energy photons — the same type used for medical imaging. Researchers could recreate this phenomenon in the lab, but they could not fully explain how and why lightning produced X-rays. Now, two decades later, a Penn State-led team has discovered a new physical mechanism explaining naturally occurring X-rays associated with lightning activity in the Earth’s atmosphere. They published their ...

nTIDE March 2023 Deeper Dive: Intersection of race and disability perpetuate inequalities in employment impacting Black/African American people with disabilities

2023-03-31

East Hanover, NJ – March 31, 2023 – Since the pandemic, gains in the labor market have been slower to materialize for black/African American people with disabilities compared to their white counterparts, according to experts speaking last Friday during the nTIDE Deeper Dive Lunch & Learn Webinar. They discussed potential factors underlying why the disability employment gap is wider among members of the black/African American population when compared to the white population and how to integrate measures to effect change. Using data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) for persons ages 16-64, the monthly employment-to-population ratio averaged ...

Researchers uncover the first steps driving antibiotic resistance

2023-03-31

Antibiotic resistance is a global health threat. In 2019 alone, an estimated 1.3 million deaths were attributed to antibiotic resistant bacterial infections worldwide. Looking to contribute a solution to this growing problem, researchers at Baylor College of Medicine have been studying the process that drives antibiotic resistance at the molecular level. They report in the journal Molecular Cell crucial and surprising first steps that promote resistance to ciprofloxacin, or cipro for short, one of the most commonly prescribed antibiotics. The findings point at potential ...

Study reveals new insights into body salt handling

2023-03-31

HUNTINGTON, W.Va. – A new study led by Marshall University researchers focuses on a novel mechanism of the body’s regulation of salt balance. The kidney plays a central role in the body’s ability to maintain an appropriate sodium balance, which is critical for the determination of blood pressure. Disorders of sodium balance contribute to the development and progression of many common diseases, including hypertension, heart disease and stroke. Na/K-ATPase (NKA) is the enzymatic machinery that drives absorption of sodium along the renal proximal tubule. As ...

A tighter core stabilizes SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in new emergent variants

2023-03-31

UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Just as a tight core is a component of good physical fitness for humans, helping to stabilize our bodies, mutations that tightened the core of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in new variants may have increased the virus’s fitness. New research led by Penn State reveals that the stem region of the spike protein became progressively tighter over time, and the team thinks this likely improved the virus’s ability to transmit through nasal droplets and infect host cells once in the body. The team said the stem region of the protein that emerged in the most recent Omicron variants is as rigid as it can get, which could ...

Status epilepticus: New inflammatory markers to improve patient care

2023-03-31

A rare and nevertheless formidable event in the landscape of epilepsies, New-Onset Refractory Status Epilepticus (NORSE) is a form of prolonged seizure in which the neurons of the epileptic focus endure a continuous discharge of neurotransmitters. It is a medical emergency requiring intensive care management. Indeed, it can cause significant long-term neurological sequelae and is associated with an average mortality rate of 12% in children and 16 to 27% in adults. NORSE can occur in response to an infection or tumor development. However, its origin remains unknown in half of the affected patients despite extensive clinical and biological ...