(Press-News.org) How has online sleuthing successfully replaced wanted posters?
Researchers within the Virginia Tech Department of Computer Science answered this question by studying the crowdsourced online investigation that followed the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection at the U.S. Capitol.
“These online communities can provide real value, if they’re organized in the right way,” said Kurt Luther, associate professor of computer science and history. “These aren’t just digital witch hunts now that make false identifications. They can really make solid contributions to ongoing investigations by getting images in front of people, which is ultimately what law enforcement has been trying to do since those wanted posters 200 years ago.”
Led by Tianjiao "Joey" Yu, a Ph.D. student Luther co-advises, the group analyzed the online community Sedition Hunters to understand how the group successfully used Twitter to help law enforcement and prosecutors — including the FBI and Department of Justice — identify suspects who took part in the insurrection. Their work has been cited in multiple arrests and legal proceedings.
Yu is scheduled to present the resulting paper, “Sedition Hunters: A Quantitative Study of the Crowdsourced Investigation into the 2021 U.S. Capitol Attack,” at an annual international gathering, the ACM Web Conference, May 2 in Austin, Texas.
“Oftentimes I don’t see clearly the real-life applications of my research,” said Yu, whose research interests include crowd intelligence, natural language processing, and linguistics. “But with this, I feel like I’m really solving a problem and I’m really making a contribution.”
Yu and Luther collaborated on the project with Ismini Lourentzou, assistant professor of computer science, and Sukrit Venkatagiri, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Washington. Venkatagiri is a double Hokie, having earned a master's degree and a Ph.D. in computer science in 2020 and 2022, respectively. Luther was his Ph.D advisee when part of this project was completed.
The research team found the Sedition Hunters generally adhered to ethical investigative guidelines, successfully mined large troves of data to create multi-angle composite images, and used creative nicknames as hashtags to collectively refer to unidentified people of interest and reach a broader audience on Twitter.
“They really focused on what they could do that was helpful and not harmful, and I think that’s one of the reasons they’ve been able to sustain it for more than two years,” Luther said.
Crowdsourcing information as a crime-solving tactic is far from a new concept, according to Luther, who directs Virginia Tech’s Crowd Intelligence Lab in Arlington.
“Arguably, the first manhunt followed the Abraham Lincoln assassination because it was the first time photos were actually used to try to identify some of the conspirators,” he said.
More recently, unsuccessful attempts to use online crowdsourcing after the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing cast a negative light on the method.
Supported by a National Science Foundation grant, Luther and the Crowd Intelligence Lab began to study the use of crowdsourcing in active investigations in 2017. He said the events of Jan. 6, 2021, provided a unique situation to study.
“It was the most heavily documented crime in history, according to Time magazine,” Luther said. “It’s kind of this perfect storm of this significant event happening and this massive amount of documented evidence in photos and videos online that’s being publicly shared, so it creates this opportunity for people who want to help law enforcement to be able to contribute.”
Luther said a key element of the community’s success was law enforcement’s interest in its discoveries, despite the mistakes that online sleuths made following the Boston Marathon bombing. “They seem to be very receptive of what the community can offer,” Luther said.
According to the team’s research, the Sedition Hunters account has more than 66,000 followers who produced more than 320,000 tweets with more than 1 million retweets between Jan. 12, 2021 and Jan. 12, 2022. Despite the large audience, the community’s content is dominated by a small number of highly influential accounts. The majority of tweets requested other users to share content or shared information related to news or recent events.
The research team found that, early on, the Sedition Hunters ran into an issue when some Twitter users falsely identified an individual in a tweet. Luther said was he impressed how quickly a few influential users were able to largely change that behavior.
“They said, 'Hey, no more naming suspects publicly. If you think you know who it is, send it to the FBI,'” Luther said. “And to a large extent, that’s what the community did. The community evolved.”
The Sedition Hunters went on to develop pseudonyms for unidentified suspects, which they used as searchable hashtags. Luther credits the community’s creativity, using humor to developing names such as #LittleRedRioter and #SlimMcTreason, as part of the reason the effort was successful.
He also said he was surprised at the community’s ability to locate and use open-source camera footage to create composite pictures of suspects. This helped to overcome barriers in the first images collected, such as wanted individuals wearing masks or being captured at useable angles.
Yu said he was impressed at the Sedition Hunters’ collective ability to take the content being generated on Twitter and develop other websites with high-tech features. He specifically pointed to the development of a timeline and map that connected to different video sources as an impressive investigative tool.
“That was really surprising,” Yu said. “They built several websites and it was really interesting to see people interact with all these fancy tools.”
Though overwhelmingly positive, Yu said he did see areas for future improvements. They include being more centralized, finding a better way to track the progress of each investigation, and more behavioral oversight within the group.
Overall, Luther said the Sedition Hunters have shown they have the potential to greatly benefit law enforcement and society in general.
“This paper offers a lot of promise for how law enforcement and the public can work together,” Luther said. “Officials are getting a more diverse section of the population to see suspects and ultimately help solve crimes in an ethical and more effective way.”
END
Virginia Tech researchers study the crowdsourced investigation of Jan. 6, 2021
2023-05-03
[Attachments] See images for this press release:
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Survey: Half of parents believe their children’s mental health suffered due to social media during the past year
2023-05-03
COLUMBUS, Ohio (May 3, 2023) — Concerns continue to grow about the impact social media use has on the mental health and well-being of children and adolescents. According to a new national survey conducted online by The Harris Poll on behalf of The On Our Sleeves Movement For Children’s Mental Health, half (50%) of parents of children younger than 18 feel their child(ren)’s mental health has suffered during the past 12 months because of social media use.
To best understand how social media is impacting their children’s mental health, On Our Sleeves encourages parents and caregivers to sit down and have ...
Engineers tap into good vibrations to power the Internet of Things
2023-05-03
In a world hungry for clean energy, engineers have created a new material that converts the simple mechanical vibrations all around us into electricity to power sensors in everything from pacemakers to spacecraft.
The first of its kind and the product of a decade of work by researchers at the University of Waterloo and the University of Toronto, the novel generating system is compact, reliable, low-cost and very, very green.
“Our breakthrough will have a significant social and economic impact by reducing our reliance on non-renewable power sources,” said Asif Khan, a ...
Texas A&M researcher receives $3M National Science Foundation manufacturing grant
2023-05-02
Dr. Zhijian “Z.J.” Pei and his intercollegiate team recently received the Future Manufacturing Research Grant from the National Science Foundation’s Future Manufacturing program, which funds researchers to develop new manufacturing capability that does not exist today. The focus of this research grant is to substitute products made from petroleum-based plastics or natural wood with biomass.
“Our idea is to use living matter, including fungi, algae, bacteria, plus agriculturally derived biomass and use 3D printing to make products,” said Pei, professor in the Wm Michael Barnes ’64 ...
Crossroads: The role of biomarkers in the management of lumps in the breast
2023-05-02
“A biomarker or set of biomarkers to inform on the individual progression risk would be beneficial to the patient and cost-effective for the healthcare system."
BUFFALO, NY- May 2, 2023 – A new research perspective was published in Oncotarget's Volume 14 on April 24, 2023, entitled, “Crossroads: the role of biomarkers in the management of lumps in the breast.”
Here, Dr. Georg F. Weber from the University of Cincinnati Academic Health Center discusses a long-standing issue in women’s health: ...
Openseize: A novel open-source software to analyze large-scale digital signals
2023-05-02
Electroencephalography (EEG) is an indispensable tool used by clinicians to diagnose neurological diseases and by researchers to study and discover brain circuit mechanisms that support sensory, mnemonic, and cognitive processing. A new software - Openseize - created by Dr. Matthew Caudill, an investigator at the Jan and Dan Duncan Neurological Research Institute at Texas Children’s Hospital and assistant professor at Baylor College of Medicine, can now analyze massive amounts of one-dimensional digital ...
JSA Awards $558K for Initiatives Fund Program for FY2023
2023-05-02
WASHINGTON, DC – Jefferson Sciences Associates (JSA) has announced the award of $558,060 through its JSA Initiatives Fund Program. The program supports projects by staff and scientific users at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility. The FY23 program awards leveraged over $800,000 in matching funds, and taken together, the program and matching awards total over $1.3 million. Project awards include scientific meeting support, education and career development, and outreach activities, ...
Deep neural network provides robust detection of disease biomarkers in real time
2023-05-02
Sophisticated systems for the detection of biomarkers — molecules such as DNA or proteins that indicate the presence of a disease — are crucial for real-time diagnostic and disease-monitoring devices.
Holger Schmidt, distinguished professor of electrical and computer engineering at UC Santa Cruz, and his group have long been focused on developing unique, highly sensitive devices called optofluidic chips to detect biomarkers.
Schmidt’s graduate student Vahid Ganjalizadeh led an effort to use machine learning to enhance ...
How the brain's dopamine circuitry helps regulate cognitive flexibility and reward-seeking
2023-05-02
The Brain & Behavior Research Foundation (BBRF) is hosting a free webinar, “How the Brain's Dopamine Circuitry Helps Regulate Cognitive Flexibility and Reward-Seeking” on Tuesday, May 9, 2023, at 2:00 pm EST. The presenter will be Nikhil Urs, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Pharmacology and Therapeutics at the University of Florida and a recipient of a 2018 BBRF Young Investigator Grant. The webinar will be hosted by Jeffrey Borenstein, M.D., President & CEO of the Brain & Behavior Research Foundation, and host of the public television series Healthy Minds.
Register today at BBRFoundation.org
Dopamine ...
AI in medical imaging could magnify health inequities, study finds
2023-05-02
Artificial intelligence (AI) technology in the medical field has the possibility to automate diagnoses, decrease physician workload, and even to bring specialized healthcare to people in rural areas or developing countries. However, with possibility comes potential pitfalls.
Analyzing crowd-sourced sets of data used to create AI algorithms from medical images, University of Maryland School of Medicine (UMSOM) researchers found that most did not include patient demographics. In the study published April 3 in Nature Medicine, the researchers also found that the algorithms did not evaluate for inherent biases either. That means they have ...
Cybersickness more likely to affect women, ongoing research to understand why
2023-05-02
AMES, IA — Iowa State researchers in psychology and engineering found women experience cybersickness with virtual reality headsets more often than men. Their ongoing work, supported by a new $600,000 grant from the National Science Foundation, explores why this difference exists and options to help individuals adapt.
Psychology professor Jonathan Kelly studies human computer interaction, spatial cognition and virtual reality. He says gender discrepancies in cybersickness may not seem that important when it’s related to video games and other forms of entertainment.
"But it’s still a problem, and when VR gets to the point ...