(Press-News.org) Researchers from Mansoura University and University of Guelph published a new Journal of Marketing study that examines how misaligned contracts can erode innovation outcomes of high-tech firms.
The study, forthcoming in the Journal of Marketing, is titled “Collaborating to Innovate: Balancing Strategy Dividend and Transactional Efficiencies” and is authored by Nehal Elhelaly and Sourav Ray.
When a giant multinational like Unilever partners with one of its major suppliers, such as the industrial enzyme-producer Novozyme, the collaboration can fast-track innovation and improve business performance. Such a partnership between a firm and a supplier brings together knowledge, technologies, and other resources to create a product, service, or solution—and industry reports indicate that up to 85% of firms believe these collaborations are an effective means of innovation.
This broader impact of product co-development collaboration is aptly captured in the following public statement by the multinational pharmaceutical company Bristol-Myers Squibb:
“As critical drivers of our strategy, external innovation and partnering have brought significant commercial success and pipeline growth. Twelve of our company’s twenty blockbuster medicines are derived from collaborations. In addition, more than sixty percent of our current development pipeline is externally sourced bringing significant external innovation to complement our internal capabilities and innovation.”
However, such collaborations also expose the firm to various transactional hazards such as knowledge spillovers and opportunism. The danger looms large when a firm fails to consider its positioning strategy and functional capabilities when crafting innovation collaboration contracts with its suppliers. This creates a barrier to a firm’s ability to generate sustained dividends from its broader marketing strategy.
Strategic decisions taken by firms are based on the presumed value generated from the implementation of the decisions and the presumed costs incurred in the process. Elhelaly explains that, “as important as innovation co-developments are to a firm’s broader marketing strategy, managers should ask themselves an important question: Will such contracts help sustain any strategy dividend? The strategy dividend can be whittled away if there is no fit between a firm’s strategic positioning, functional capabilities, and the governance modes of co-development.”
The Downsides of Joint Venture Partnerships
Consider, for example, industry observations that Joint Venture (JV) partnerships can help firms navigate economic downturns. Economic downturns impose a need for cost efficiencies, and JVs can be useful because of presumed close coordination between the two entities. Yet, as the study’s hypotheses and results show, this economic dividend can only be realized when firms have high technological capabilities. The researchers estimate that for firms with similar efficiency orientations, their technological capabilities are associated with an increase of 5.2% in innovation performance for JVs, but not for technology licensing contracts and joint development agreements.
On the other hand, estimates show that strong marketing capabilities in the same situation are associated with a decrease of 17.9% in innovation performance for JVs. Additionally, marketing capabilities seem to be more benign for joint development agreements in high differentiation-oriented firms. For such firms, marketing capabilities are associated with an increase of 7.8% in innovation performance for joint development agreements.
One of the study’s central themes is that the idea of fit in co-development collaborations comes with underlying notions of misalignment costs that need to be recognized. “While mapping the bases of misalignment,” says Ray, “we highlight the keystone role of the firm’s positioning strategy in innovation collaborations. Strategy frames how a firm deploys its resources and focuses its energies. So, a misalignment will naturally manifest in inefficiency, perhaps one that will emerge over time. As our empirical results bear out, misalignment between collaboration contracts, capabilities, and strategy significantly erodes innovation outcomes.”
Lessons for Chief Marketing Officers
The study offers three key takeaways:
For better innovation outcomes, firms need to select the collaboration form that motivates their partners to share know-how and expertise and facilitate efficient knowledge transfers. At the same time, firms must also pay attention to protecting their valuable knowledge and skills from opportunistic appropriation and ensure effective use of their deployed resources.
Firms need to build the “right” functional capability to yield the most benefit from innovation collaborations. For instance, a firm needs to invest in building marketing capabilities if it is driven by high differentiation and consider more arms-length arrangements such as joint development agreements with suppliers. In contrast, firms driven by efficiency considerations are better off developing their technological capabilities when considering a joint venture.
Firms must resist blindly copying the practices of other firms, regardless of the appearance of “industry best practices.” Considering the firm’s positioning strategy along with its capabilities is crucial to designing effective contracts. Thus, blanket prescriptions for one or the other types of contracts (e.g., joint ventures during downturns) may be misdirected.
Full article and author contact information available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/00222429231222269
About the Journal of Marketing
The Journal of Marketing develops and disseminates knowledge about real-world marketing questions useful to scholars, educators, managers, policy makers, consumers, and other societal stakeholders around the world. Published by the American Marketing Association since its founding in 1936, JM has played a significant role in shaping the content and boundaries of the marketing discipline. Shrihari (Hari) Sridhar (Joe Foster ’56 Chair in Business Leadership, Professor of Marketing at Mays Business School, Texas A&M University) serves as the current Editor in Chief.
https://www.ama.org/jm
About the American Marketing Association (AMA)
As the largest chapter-based marketing association in the world, the AMA is trusted by marketing and sales professionals to help them discover what is coming next in the industry. The AMA has a community of local chapters in more than 70 cities and 350 college campuses throughout North America. The AMA is home to award-winning content, PCM® professional certification, premiere academic journals, and industry-leading training events and conferences.
https://www.ama.org
END
The dangers of misaligned product co-development contracts—and how they can derail innovation in high-tech firms
News from the Journal of Marketing
2024-03-05
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New publication highlights urgency of parasitic wasp release to save native bird
2024-03-05
DENVER/March 5, 2024 – Researchers with the University of Minnesota, funded by Morris Animal Foundation, hope to release highly-specialized parasitic wasps to serve as a biological control method to save Darwin’s finches from a dire threat: the invasive avian vampire fly, Philornis downsi.
This species has been devastating finch populations on the Galapagos Islands by laying eggs in their nests, with the emerging larvae harming the nestlings.
To protect these iconic birds and other endemic species impacted by the fly, ...
Tiny worms tolerate chornobyl radiation
2024-03-05
The 1986 disaster at the Chornobyl nuclear power plant transformed the surrounding area into the most radioactive landscape on Earth. Humans were evacuated, but many plants and animals continue to live in the region, despite the high levels of radiation that persist nearly four decades later.
A new study led by researchers at New York University finds that exposure to chronic radiation from Chornobyl has not damaged the genomes of microscopic worms living there today—which doesn’t mean that the region is safe, the scientists caution, but suggests that these worms are exceptionally resilient.
In ...
Restoration of degraded areas in semi-arid region contributes to ‘return’ of soil microorganisms, study shows
2024-03-05
Strategies deployed for the restoration of degraded land have had promising results in Brazil’s semi-arid region, improving the microbial properties of the soil and contributing to a return of native ecosystem services. The techniques include removal of cattle or restriction of their access to specific areas of pasture; cultivation of cover crops; and terracing to control erosion. Recovery of soil microbial properties maintains biodiversity and raises crop yields, contributing to agricultural ...
New research details negative consumer impacts of BLM support on major companies and brands
2024-03-05
INFORMS Journal Marketing Science New Study Key Takeaways:
Brands that supported BLM on social media during the height of the movement suffered negative impacts on social media.
Negative impacts were felt from both Democratic and Republican consumers.
The ‘bandwagon effect’ was one of the more significant factors.
Some brands with more historical prosocial posting on social media and socially oriented missions suffer less from the negative effects and may even benefit from supporting ...
Having self-control leads to power
2024-03-05
Out-of-control behavior by CEOs and other powerful people constantly makes headlines – so much so that some might consider impulsivity a pathway to power. New research from the UC San Diego Rady School of Management and Texas A&M University finds that having self-control is often what leads to power.
In a paper published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, researchers find that showing self-control influences how powerful an individual is perceived to be by their peers, as well as how much power they are granted by those peers. In a series of seven experiments with roughly 3,500 participants, both students ...
Endocrine Society elects Lange as 2025-2026 President
2024-03-05
WASHINGTON—Endocrine Society members elected Carol Lange, Ph.D., of the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, Minn., as its 2025-2026 President. She will serve as President-Elect for a year beginning in June 2024 before becoming President in June 2025.
Lange is a Professor of Medicine and Molecular Pharmacology and Therapeutics, holds the Tickle Family Land Grant Endowed Chair of Breast Cancer Research, and is the Associate Director for Basic Science and the Director of the Molecular, Genetic, and Cellular Targets of Cancer Training Program at the University of Minnesota Masonic ...
March issues of APA journals cover new insights into treatments for anxiety, depression, substance use disorder, ADHD and more
2024-03-05
WASHINGTON, D.C., March 5, 2024 — The latest issues of two American Psychiatric Association journals, The American Journal of Psychiatry and Psychiatric Services are now available online.
The March issue of The American Journal of Psychiatry features studies that focus on new insights into treatments across the lifespan. Highlights include:
Normalization of Fronto-Parietal Activation by Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy in Unmedicated Pediatric Patients With Anxiety Disorders. (AJP Deputy Editor ...
Does iron accumulate in brain after concussions?
2024-03-05
EMBARGOED FOR RELEASE UNTIL 4 P.M. ET, TUESDAY, MARCH 5, 2024
MINNEAPOLIS – People who have headaches after experiencing concussions may also be more likely to have higher levels of iron in areas of the brain, which is a sign of injury to brain cells, according to a preliminary study released today, March 5, 2024, that will be presented at the American Academy of Neurology’s 76th Annual Meeting taking place April 13–18, 2024, in person in Denver and online.
“These results suggest that iron accumulation in the brain can be used as a biomarker for concussion and post-traumatic ...
Salk Professor Terrence Sejnowski wins Brain Prize
2024-03-05
LA JOLLA—(March 5, 2024) Salk Institute Professor Terrence Sejnowski will receive the 2024 Brain Prize for “pioneering the field of computational and theoretical neuroscience, making seminal contributions to our understanding of the brain, and paving the way for the development of brain-inspired artificial intelligence,” the Lundbeck Foundation announced today.
Sejnowski shares the prize—the world’s top recognition in neuroscience, totaling 10 million DKK (approximately $1.5 million)—with Larry Abbott of Columbia University and Haim Sompolinsky of Harvard University and Hebrew ...
A call for standardization of controls in lifespan studies
2024-03-05
“[...] we posit that the majority of results in biology of aging may be irrelevant to the fundamental aim of this field and must be acknowledged appropriately.”
BUFFALO, NY- March 5, 2024 – A new research perspective was published in Aging (listed by MEDLINE/PubMed as "Aging (Albany NY)" and "Aging-US" by Web of Science) Volume 16, Issue 4, entitled, “On standardization of controls in lifespan studies.”
In this new paper, researchers Olga Spiridonova, Dmitrii Kriukov, Nikolai Nemirovich-Danchenko, and Leonid Peshkin from Harvard Medical ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
High protein or Trp diet increases the risk of cancer-associated venous thromboembolism
Risk of a second cancer after early breast cancer is low
Genetic key to why immune responses differ between men and women
Discovery could lead to new treatments for life-threatening allergic reactions
CRF announces TCT 2025 late-breaking clinical trials and science
Ancient DNA reveals farming spread through migration, locals slow to adopt it
Researchers turn mouse scalp transparent to image brain development
New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
Wheat that makes its own fertilizer
Certain communities of pond plants may increase greenhouse gases
Hormone therapy type matters for memory performance after menopause
Stroke risk highest among Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander people
Scientists reveal warped protoplanetary discs, reshaping ideas about how planets form
Be it feast or famine, orangutans adapt with flexible diets
Insomnia patients report better sleep when taking cannabis-based medical products
Intrusive distracting thoughts may be associated with anxiety and linked to lower well-being, and occur more often when alone than in company
New crocodile-relative “hypercarnivore” from prehistoric Patagonia was 11.5ft long and weighed 250kg
“Unhappiness hump” in aging may have disappeared worldwide
Breathwork can induce altered states of consciousness linked with changes in brain blood flow
New research makes first broad-spectrum antiviral
Good sleep quality might be key for better mental wellbeing in young adults
One step closer to improving ER+ breast cancer patients’ response to therapy
Scientists reveal the first structure of the complete botulinum neurotoxin complex
Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia researchers link dietary fats to more severe form of asthma
Rising temperatures intensify "supercell thunderstorms" in Europe
New Hebrew SeniorLife affordable senior housing building achieves Phius Certification
Overworked brain cells may burn out in Parkinson’s disease
One in seven bariatric surgery patients turn to new weight loss drugs
A nonsurgical path to treating pelvic organ prolapse
Electrons reveal their handedness in attosecond flashes
[Press-News.org] The dangers of misaligned product co-development contracts—and how they can derail innovation in high-tech firmsNews from the Journal of Marketing