(Press-News.org) A new study done in more than 14,000 ninth graders in Germany has revealed that students experience grading bias based on their gender, body size, ethnicity and parental socio-economic status. These negative biases stack on each other, meaning that students with multiple intersectional identities get significantly lower grades than their peers regardless of their true abilities. Richard Nennstiel and Sandra Gilgen of the University of Bern and University of Zurich in Switzerland present these findings in the open-access journal PLOS ONE on July 3, 2024.
Secondary school grades can open or close doors to careers later in life. To explore whether students are suffering from bias in their school grades, Nennstiel and Gilgen used data from the National Educational Panel Study in Germany, a study that has tracked seven cohorts of German school children since 2008. They focused on a nationally representative sample of 14,090 students who were in the ninth grade in 2010. Nennstiel and Gilgen compared grades handed by school teachers to results on standardized competence tests to find out whether some students had an advantage over others. The scientists looked at the effects of gender, body mass index (BMI), parent socio-economic status (SES), and ethnic background.
Gender bias was evident in teacher-assigned grades in all subjects except for chemistry. Girls had an advantage in German, math, and biology, while boys benefitted in physics. Higher BMIs were associated with significantly lower grades from teachers in every subject, while students with higher parental SES had higher grades. Minority students received lower grades in all subjects except biology. These disadvantages compounded, meaning that irrespective of true skill and aptitude, a boy with a high BMI from a low-SES, minority background received on average lower grades, than a German-born, low BMI girl from a higher SES.
While these results can’t determine the exact mechanisms behind this bias, they suggest that grading bias is widespread in Germany. The researchers recommend that further studies focus on why students receive biased grades, and how such biases could be tackled in the classroom.
The authors add: “Even after controlling for three different measures of ability and attended school track we find widespread additive intersectional effects of gender, social and ethnic origin as well as body weight on grading.”
#####
In your coverage please use this URL to provide access to the freely available article in PLOS ONE: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0305703
Citation: Nennstiel R, Gilgen S (2024) Does chubby can get lower grades than skinny Sophie? Using an intersectional approach to uncover grading bias in German secondary schools. PLoS ONE 19(7): e0305703. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0305703
Author Countries: Switzerland
Funding: The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.
END
Minority status, social origin, gender, and weight can all count against a German kid’s grades
A study of more than 14,000 German ninth graders shows that bias comes out in a child’s report card
2024-07-03
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Dengue linked to heightened short- and long-term risk of depression in Taiwan
2024-07-03
Analysis of the medical records of nearly 50,000 people who experienced dengue fever in Taiwan suggests that this disease is associated with elevated short- and long-term risk of depression. Hsin-I Shih and colleagues of National Cheng Kung University and National Health Research Institutes, Taiwan present these findings in the open-access journal PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases.
People may develop dengue fever after being bitten by a mosquito carrying the dengue virus. Dengue fever can be mild, but it can also progress ...
Fighting COVID-19 with a cancer drug
2024-07-03
Twelve years ago, cancer researchers at University of California San Diego identified a molecule that helps cancer cells survive by shuttling damaging inflammatory cells into tumor tissue. In new research, they show that the same molecule does the same thing in lung tissue infected with COVID-19 — and that the molecule can be suppressed with a repurposed cancer drug. The work, published in Science Translational Medicine, represents a new approach to preventing irreversible organ damage in infectious diseases like COVID-19 and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA).
The two key players in this scenario are inflammatory cells called myeloid ...
From ‘hit to vial’: Discovery and optimization of a promising vaccine adjuvant
2024-07-03
Many vaccines are only partially effective, have waning efficacy, or do not work well in the very young or the very old. For more than a decade, Ofer Levy, MD, PhD, and David Dowling, PhD, in the Precision Vaccines Program at Boston Children’s Hospital, have tried improving vaccines by adding compounds known as adjuvants to boost vaccine recipients’ immune responses.
Now, under a large Adjuvant Discovery Program contract from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases ...
Why do you keep your house so cold? Science says: Ask your parents
2024-07-03
Childhood home temperature and community connectedness can help predict how U.S. residents set their thermostats, offering new ways to encourage energy conservation and combat climate change, according to a study published July 3 in the open-access journal PLOS Climate by Dritjon Gruda from the National University of Ireland Maynooth and Paul Hanges from the University of Maryland.
Half of U.S. households’ annual electricity use goes to heating and cooling, but less than half of homeowners tweak their thermostats to save energy ...
Texas A&M center receives $7.6 million grant to promote research in environmental health
2024-07-03
The Texas A&M Center for Environmental Health (TiCER), a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) Environmental Health Sciences Core Center, will be returning to the Texas A&M School of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences (VMBS) with a $7.6 million grant for the center’s new funding cycle.
Under the new leadership of Dr. Weston Porter, a VMBS professor in the Department of Veterinary Physiology and Pharmacology, the center will promote research in four areas of environmental health — climate ...
Deep machine-learning speeds assessment of fruit fly heart aging and disease, a model for human disease
2024-07-03
BIRMINGHAM, Ala. – Drosophila — commonly known as fruit flies — are a valuable model for human heart pathophysiology, including cardiac aging and cardiomyopathy. However, a choke point in evaluating fruit fly hearts is the need for human intervention to measure the heart at moments of its largest expansion or its greatest contraction, measurements that allow calculations of cardiac dynamics.
Researchers at the University of Alabama at Birmingham now show a way to significantly cut the time needed ...
U.S. Department of Energy issues request for proposals for contractor to manage and operate Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility
2024-07-03
Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced the issuance of a Request for Proposals (RFPs) for the competitive selection of a management and operating contractor for the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (TJNAF).
TJNAF is a DOE national laboratory and DOE-sponsored Federally Funded Research and Development Center that has a mission focused on delivering breakthrough science and technology in nuclear physics.
DOE expects to award the contract before the current agreement with Jefferson Science Associates, LLC expires on May 31, 2025, allowing for an anticipated three-month transition. DOE expects the selected ...
Survivorship standards help address the distinct needs of adult cancer survivors
2024-07-03
Key Takeaways
More people are surviving cancer than ever before and living longer. This growing population of adult cancer survivors requires distinct survivorship services focused on long-term well-being.
Survey study demonstrates the value of American College of Surgeons’ survivorship accreditation standards, though specialized services in fertility and sexual health are less accessible.
CHICAGO — With the number of adult cancer survivors in the United States expected to reach 23 million by 2032,* the long-term needs of this ...
Mighty floods of the Nile River during warmer and wetter climates
2024-07-03
Summary
Global warming as well as recent droughts and floods threaten large populations along the Nile Valley. Understanding how such a large river will respond to an invigorated hydrological cycle is therefore a pressing issue. Insights can be gained by studying past periods with wetter and warmer conditions, such as the North African Humid Period eleven to six thousand years ago. A research team of the German Research Centre for Geosciences GFZ, led by Cécile Blanchet, together with colleagues ...
Popular prescription weight loss drugs linked to uncommon blinding condition
2024-07-03
A new study led by investigators from Mass Eye and Ear found that patients prescribed semaglutide (as Ozempic or Wegovy) for diabetes or weight loss had a higher risk of having a potentially blinding eye condition called NAION than similar patients who had not been prescribed these drugs.
Notably, the study found people with diabetes who had been prescribed semaglutide by their physician and then filled the prescription were more than four times more likely to be diagnosed with NAION. Those who were overweight or had obesity and prescribed this drug were more than seven times more likely to get the diagnosis.
The study, which ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Stopping pancreatic cancer spread using benzaldehyde
Pusan National University study reveals engineered bacterial vesicles to combat antimicrobial resistance
Africa needs more large firms, not more entrepreneurs, for economic growth
Clues in the claws: finger length may reveal sexual preferences in rats
World-unique method enables simulation of error-correctable quantum computers
Scientists uncover immune cells that help prostate cancer resist treatment — and reveal a way to stop them
Cellulose instead of crude oil: team with participation of Graz University of Technology develops sustainable foams
New fossils from Earth’s most famous extinction show climate tipping point was crossed
AI predicts patients likely to die of sudden cardiac arrest
Double detonation: New image shows remains of star destroyed by pair of explosions
Gene therapy restored hearing in deaf patients
Survey finds Trump losing favor, Newsom gaining
Religion, politics and war drive urban wildlife evolution
Peeking inside AI brains: Machines learn like us
A map for single-atom catalysts
What about tritiated water release from Fukushima? Ocean model simulations provide an objective scientific knowledge on the long-term tritium distribution
Growing crisis of communicable disease in Canada in tandem with US cuts
Women get better at managing their anger as they age
Illegal shark product trade evident in Australia and New Zealand
New search tool brings 21% better accuracy for robotics developers
New model extracts sentence-level proof to verify events, boosting fact-checking accuracy for journalists, legal teams, and policymakers
Efficient carbon integration of CO₂ in propane aromatization over acidic zeolites
FPGA-accelerated AI for demultiplexing multimode fiber towards next-generation communications
Vitamin D3 nanoemulsion significantly improves core symptoms in children with autism: A clinical trial
Microfluidic point-of-care device accurately measures bilirubin in blood serum: A pilot study
Amygdalin shows strong binding and stabilizing effects on HER2 receptor: A computational study for breast cancer therapy
Bond behavior of FRP bars in concrete under reversed cyclic loading: an experimental study
Milky Way-like galaxy M83 consumes high-speed clouds
Study: What we learned from record-breaking 2021 heat wave and what we can expect in the future
Transforming treatment outcomes for people with OCD
[Press-News.org] Minority status, social origin, gender, and weight can all count against a German kid’s gradesA study of more than 14,000 German ninth graders shows that bias comes out in a child’s report card