PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Educators and parents reveal culture of fear, censorship, and loss of learning opportunities in the wake of Florida policies

A new study finds that “education restriction” policies reduce opportunities and support offered in public schools, even without parents’ knowledge

2024-09-23
(Press-News.org) How can a teacher discuss Jim Crow laws without breaking state law? Should a librarian stop ordering books with LGBTQ+ characters? A new white paper by UC San Diego and NYU researchers reveals the experiences of K-12 educators and parents in Florida grappling with state policies and policy effects restricting access to instruction, books, courses, clubs, professional development, and basic student supports.

Since 2021, Florida has enacted a series of state laws and policies restricting instruction related to race, sexual orientation, and gender identity; targeting student supports, such as pronoun use; expanding review of materials for prohibited content; and actively inviting public challenges to limit educational material on broad bases, including for “age appropriateness” and inclusion of any “sexual conduct.” Thousands of books have been taken from students for vetting and in some cases, permanent removal, including classic works of literature.

“Our data show state policies driving what we call a limitation effect—a cascade of pressures reaching down from the state, to the districts, to educators’ daily interactions with students that limit basic functions of education,” says Mica Pollock, professor of education studies at UC San Diego. “Data showed time use, energy, and money in K-12 systems becoming organized around restricting access to ideas, information, and supports for students in public schools, versus expanding education opportunity for all – often to placate the most restriction-oriented members of government or communities.”

Pollock and her co-author, Hirokazu Yoshikawa, professor of applied psychology at NYU Steinhardt, analyzed the UC San Diego team’s qualitative surveys and interviews of a total of 86 respondents, most of whom were educators and parents, in fall and winter 2023-2024. Both teams also conducted a supplemental review of public and media documents.

Their findings are published in The Limitation Effect: Experiences of State Policy-Driven Education Restriction in Florida’s Public Schools.

Almost every respondent had witnessed an effort at education restriction in their school or district, in one of the following topics: sexual orientation; gender identity; race; critical race theory; diversity, equity, and inclusion; culturally responsive education; African American history; and ethnic studies. More than half reported all eight types of restriction efforts occurring locally, and three-quarters reported at least five types occurring locally.

“To avoid punishment, including the threat of losing their jobs, K-12 system actors were withdrawing core elements that could benefit students across the education system,” says Yoshikawa. “These included books, discussions of race in curriculum and instruction, school messaging of support for LGBTQ students, Gender-Sexuality Alliance clubs, teacher-student support relationships, and also professional development designed to support students more effectively.”

Respondents described K-12 system actors reacting to single state policies and state policies combined, including broad vetting for “inappropriate” materials. Data showed myriad examples of reduced learning and professional opportunities, like the following:

As required and pressured vetting expanded, teachers boxed up or stopped using entire classroom libraries to avoid punishment. Teachers avoided books with any content on “LGBTQ+” and “racism” with concerns that they might be unauthorized. Some students lost online access to public libraries and online book collections via their schools. Teachers decided not to discuss aspects of US racial history in class. Signs or markers denoting safe spaces for LGBTQ+ populations were removed. LGBTQ+ supportive clubs were cancelled, or attendance was chilled. All students in systems were denied access to a pilot of AP African American Studies; some were also denied AP Psychology. Professional development on supporting students with disabilities was limited given restrictions on discussing “bias.” Many parents were unaware of the restrictive efforts happening in their children’s schools and classrooms. “As seen in these data, K-12 system actors pressured by specific and multiple state policies were reducing education opportunity both to sub-groups of students and to all students, an outcome we call collective harm,” says Pollock. “Some educators were spending paid employee time seeking different lessons that did not mention ‘Black Lives Matter.’ Already-purchased books went unused or were discarded; some districts spent hundreds of thousands of public dollars re-reviewing and removing books.”

​​“The likely effects on students include the loss of learning and well-being that accompanies rich and diverse materials and comprehensive dialogue about our society and its diversity. Additionally, shared civic life can suffer when students fail to build skills for analyzing our nation, or lack opportunities to understand and value their peers’ identity,” says Yoshikawa. “With the cumulative impact of these policies on top of existing stressors, many educators and even parents reported wanting to leave Florida or public education entirely.”

"Our study offers troubling examples to spark further inquiry, and it sounds the alarm about how K-12 system actors pressured by state restriction policy can reduce education opportunity, both to sub-groups of students and in education systems writ large,” says Pollock. “We believe that the opportunities shown restricted in this study should worry any American across political lines.”

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Energy inefficiency and inability to downsize pose even bigger threat to low-income pensioners than loss of Winter Fuel Payments, Cambridge study suggests

2024-09-23
The UK Government’s policy to scrap Winter Fuel Payments could disproportionately affect low-income pensioners in England, new analysis suggests. But the same study argues that the energy inefficiency of homes and challenges involved in downsizing will have an even more harmful effect this winter.   The study, published in Energy Research and Social Science, was completed shortly before the Winter Fuel Payment vote was taken, by researchers from the University of Cambridge and Delft University of Technology (TU Delft). The researchers raise particular concerns about the impact of the policy on pensioners with annual incomes of between ...

Innovative model provides valuable insights into prostate cancer spread

Innovative model provides valuable insights into prostate cancer spread
2024-09-23
A new preclinical model using CRISPR, an advanced technology that allows scientists to cut and edit genes, has given Weill Cornell Medicine researchers and their colleagues a deeper insight into how prostate cancer spreads or metastasizes. In the study, published Sept. 23 in Cancer Discovery, scientists charted the complicated routes prostate cancer metastatic cells take as they travel through the body. “Using virtual maps, we can reveal the hidden highways of metastases, one day guiding us towards novel therapies that could act as roadblocks for cancer,” ...

NIH awards $27M to establish new network of genomics-enabled learning health systems

NIH awards $27M to establish new network of genomics-enabled learning health systems
2024-09-23
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) is awarding $5.4 million in first-year funding to establish a new program that supports the integration of genomics into learning health systems. Present in many hospitals across the United States, learning health systems are a type of clinical practice that bridges research and patient care. These systems use a variety of methods to continually analyze patient data. Clinicians then use the results of those analyses to refine practices and improve future care. The new Genomics-enabled Learning Health System (gLHS) Network aims ...

People prefer to work with higher-paid colleagues

2024-09-23
When given the choice, people prefer to collaborate on work projects with higher-paid colleagues, but they want to hire subordinates with a lower pay history than theirs, according to research published by the American Psychological Association.  The research, published in the journal American Psychologist, aimed to explore how a trend toward increasing pay transparency in the business world may affect workers’ behavior. “I've long been interested in the ways in which slight -- and not-so-slight -- differences in salaries can generate strong ...

Deeper corals may help shallow reefs recover in the Florida keys

Deeper corals may help shallow reefs recover in the Florida keys
2024-09-23
Since the 1970s, coral reefs in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS) have experienced catastrophic declines in coral cover, with as much as a 50% reduction between 1998 and 2011 alone. Although coral reefs within the FKNMS have been heavily studied, research in the mesophotic zone, which extends from about 100 to 500 feet deep, has historically been more limited in this region.  Mesophotic coral ecosystems have the potential to be buffered from anthropogenic stressors due to their depth and/or relative isolation from ...

Why saying you’ll ‘never retire’ may be a warning sign

2024-09-23
COLUMBUS, Ohio – Americans who say they expect to “never retire” are more likely than others to score low on a measure of financial knowledge, a new study shows.   In a national survey, 20% of those who missed all three financial knowledge questions said they expected they would never retire, compared to 12% who answered all questions correctly, who said they’d likely work well past retirement age.   The study also found that those who were overconfident in their financial knowledge (and those whose low levels of confidence ...

Study reveals high rates of seafood mislabeling and ambiguous market names in Calgary, Alberta, highlighting species of conservation concern

Study reveals high rates of seafood mislabeling and ambiguous market names in Calgary, Alberta, highlighting species of conservation concern
2024-09-23
A new peer-reviewed study published in PeerJ Life and Environment has uncovered alarming levels of seafood mislabeling and the use of ambiguous market names in Calgary's seafood market, often concealing species of conservation concern. This research marks the first Canadian study to investigate both invertebrate and finfish mislabeling and the implications of unclear market names. The study, titled "Mislabeled and Ambiguous Market Names in Invertebrate and Finfish Seafood Conceal Species of Conservation ...

COVID-19 hits older adults hardest; which ones want the updated vaccine?

COVID-19 hits older adults hardest; which ones want the updated vaccine?
2024-09-23
The newly updated COVID-19 vaccine just arrived in pharmacies and clinics nationwide, and a new poll suggests nearly half of people age 50 and older plan to get it. But some older adults with high risk of severe illness appear unlikely to seek the vaccine, and interest varies widely by age group, education level, race and ethnicity, and other factors, the poll shows. In all, 45% of people age 50 and older say they’re likely to get the updated vaccine, according to the new findings from the University of Michigan’s National Poll on Healthy Aging. The data come from polling done in August 2024, just before the new vaccine was released but ...

Mental health issues are a common phenomenon in elite sport

2024-09-23
Nearly three-quarters of Dutch elite athletes and forty percent of their coaches report sport-related distress. This is one of the findings from a study conducted by Amsterdam UMC together with NOC*NSF, the organisation which represents the Dutch Olympic Committee and the Dutch Sport Federation, published today in BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine.   The most common mental health problem among athletes and coaches is report sport-related distress (73% and 41%, respectively). Unfavorable alcohol consumption that can negatively affect sports performance is also common (52% and 53%). In athletes, ...

New insights into intellectual disability genetics emerge at Mount Sinai

2024-09-23
New York City (Sep 24, 2024) – Researchers at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai have published a pivotal study in Nature Genetics (DOI: 10.1038/s41588-024-01917-1) that sheds light on a novel genetic variant associated with intellectual capacities and educational outcomes. This discovery offers new insights into intellectual disability diagnostics and potential therapeutic avenues. The study reveals the significant impact of tandem repeats—sequences of DNA where a pattern of nucleotides is repeated multiple times in a head-to-tail manner on a chromosome—on intellectual functioning.  "The ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Premenstrual symptoms linked to increased risk of cardiovascular disease

Newly discovered remains of ancient river landscapes control ice flow in East Antarctica

Newly discovered interstellar object 'may be oldest comet ever seen'

Animal-inspired AI robot learns to navigate unfamiliar terrain

Underserved youth less likely to visit emergency department for concussion in Ontario, study finds

‘Molecular shield’ placed in the nose may soon treat common hay fever trigger

Beetles under climate stress lay larger male eggs: Wolbachia infection drives adaptive reproduction strategy in response to rising temperature and CO₂

Groundbreaking quantum study puts wave-particle duality to work

Weekly injection could be life changing for Parkinson’s patients

Toxic metals linked to impaired growth in infants in Guatemala

Being consistently physically active in adulthood linked to 30–40% lower risk of death

Nerve pain drug gabapentin linked to increased dementia, cognitive impairment risks

Children’s social care involvement common to nearly third of UK mums who died during perinatal period

‘Support, not judgement’: Study explores links between children’s social care involvement and maternal deaths

Ethnic minority and poorer children more likely to die in intensive care

Major progress in fertility preservation after treatment for cancer of the lymphatic system

Fewer complications after additional ultrasound in pregnant women who feel less fetal movement

Environmental impact of common pesticides seriously underestimated

The Milky Way could be teeming with more satellite galaxies than previously thought

New study reveals surprising reproductive secrets of a cricket-hunting parasitoid fly

Media Tip Sheet: Symposia at ESA2025

NSF CAREER Award will power UVA engineer’s research to improve drug purification

Tiny parasitoid flies show how early-life competition shapes adult success

New coating for glass promises energy-saving windows

Green spaces boost children’s cognitive skills and strengthen family well-being

Ancient trees dying faster than expected in Eastern Oregon

Study findings help hone precision of proven CVD risk tool

Most patients with advanced melanoma who received pre-surgical immunotherapy remain alive and disease free four years later

Introducing BioEmu: A generative AI Model that enables high-speed and accurate prediction of protein structural ensembles

Replacing mutated microglia with healthy microglia halts progression of genetic neurological disease in mice and humans

[Press-News.org] Educators and parents reveal culture of fear, censorship, and loss of learning opportunities in the wake of Florida policies
A new study finds that “education restriction” policies reduce opportunities and support offered in public schools, even without parents’ knowledge