Verified users on social media networks drive polarization and the formation of echo chambers
2024-10-22
(Press-News.org) When X (formerly Twitter) changed its verification system in 2022, many foresaw its potential to impact the spread of political opinions on the platform. In a modeling study publishing October 22 in the Cell Press journal iScience, researchers show that having verified users whose posts are prioritized by the platform’s algorithms can result in increased polarization and trigger the formation of echo chambers. Because X’s new verification system allows almost anybody to become verified, this side effect could be taken advantage of by users wishing to manipulate others’ opinions, the researchers say.
“Our findings confirm that ideologues and verified users play a crucial role in shaping the flow of information and opinions within the social network,” says first author Henrique Ferraz de Arruda (@hfarruda), a computer scientist at George Mason University. “When verified people post things, it can reach more people, which allows them to have a significant impact on the formation and reinforcement of echo chambers.”
Though many people speculated that X’s verification system might have ramifications, its actual impact hasn’t been studied in depth—in part because the platform no longer allows researchers to access its data. For this reason, the researchers used a computational model simulating how people post and receive messages on social media platforms to investigate how having a larger number of verified users might impact polarization and the formation of echo chambers. Within the model, they tweaked the number of verified users and also varied how stubborn these individuals were in their opinions.
They showed that verified users can actually facilitate consensus on the platform if they are not stubborn in their opinions. However, if verified users are “ideologues” with entrenched opinions that they hope to disseminate, their presence can drive polarization. When verified user ideologues held extreme views, their presence triggered the formation of echo chambers in addition to driving polarization. In contrast, the presence of verified centrist ideologues decreased polarization, while the presence of stubborn but unverified centrists drove polarization without triggering echo chambers.
“We found that even centrist ideologues, who may appear as a moderating force on the surface, can have a significant impact on the opinion dynamics when in enough numbers,” says Arruda.
These differences were driven because of changing connections within the network—essentially, how users followed or unfollowed others within the network.
“When the number of ideologues in the network becomes sufficiently large, regardless of whether they exhibit centrist or extremist behavior, we observed that a significant portion of the messages exchanged in the network are either sent to or received from these influential users,” says Arruda. “This suggests that, when social network algorithms prioritize visibility over content control, the users may be able to reach others to reinforce their opinions in groups, which could entrench echo chamber structures.”
Though the study was based on X’s framework, the researchers say that the results are probably also relevant to other social media platforms. They say that social media companies should be aware of the possible impact they have on political polarization and attempt to mitigate this within their algorithms.
Though in some cases social media moguls could be attempting to polarize their networks, Arruda speculates that for other platforms, this “happens as a side effect because they want to make us use the platform more.”
In future research, the team plans to increase the realism of their model by adding features such as news feeds and reposting and to incorporate data from other social media platforms such as Bluesky.
###
This research was supported by the Government of Aragón, Spain and the Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación, Agencia Española de Investigación.
iScience, Ferraz de Arruda et al., “Echo chamber formation sharpened by priority users” https://cell.com/iscience/fulltext/S2589-0042(24)02323-X
iScience (@iScience_CP) is an open access journal from Cell Press that provides a platform for original research and interdisciplinary thinking in the life, physical, and earth sciences. The primary criterion for publication in iScience is a significant contribution to a relevant field combined with robust results and underlying methodology. Visit https://www.cell.com/iscience. To receive Cell Press media alerts, contact press@cell.com.
END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2024-10-22
WASHINGTON, Oct. 22, 2024 – Disc golf is a sport growing in popularity, but there hasn’t been much research into the best techniques – until now.
Researcher Zachary Lindsey and his team studied professional and amateur disc golf players in Georgia to analyze the effect of thumb grip on disc-throwing.
“Participants were eager and excited to engage in the study, as there is clearly a thirst for scientific evidence and data to drive progress in the sport so that disc golf enthusiasts can improve their game in recreational and competitive contexts,” ...
2024-10-22
About The Study: In this population-based cohort study including 392,000 mothers and 649,000 offspring, offspring from mothers with an eating disorder history or pre-pregnancy body mass index (BMI) outside normal weight were at higher risk of psychiatric disorders. The results differed somewhat between the 2 exposures with regard to which offspring diagnoses had associations, and effect sizes were typically larger for maternal eating disorders vs BMI. These findings suggest a need to consider these 2 exposures clinically to help prevent offspring mental illness.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Ida A. K. Nilsson, PhD, email ida.nilsson@ki.se.
To ...
2024-10-22
The noses of many mammals, such as dogs, ferrets and cows, feature grooves forming a multitude of polygons. A team from the University of Geneva (UNIGE) has analyzed in detail how these patterns form in the embryo using 3D imaging techniques and computer simulations. The researchers discovered that differential growth of the skin tissue layers leads to the formation of domes, which are mechanically supported by the underlying blood vessels. This work describes for the first time this morphogenetic process, which could help explain the formation of other biological structures ...
2024-10-22
New Haven, Conn. — Whether we’re staring at our phones, the page of a book, or the person across the table, the objects of our focus never stand in isolation; there are always other objects or people in our field of vision. How that visual “clutter” affects visual processing in the brain, however, is not well understood.
In a new study published Oct. 22 in the journal Neuron, Yale researchers show that this clutter alters how information flows in the brain, as does the precise location of that clutter within the wider field of vision. The findings ...
2024-10-22
A difficult-to-describe nanoscale object called the magnetic skyrmion might one day yield new microelectronic devices that can do much more — for example, massive data storage — all while consuming much less power.
But researchers need a more detailed understanding of skyrmions if they are ever to be used reliably in computational devices, including quantum computers. Peter Fischer, a senior researcher at the Department of Energy’s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley ...
2024-10-22
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can spare many patients with rectal cancer from invasive surgery that can carry lifelong side effects, new research indicates.
The findings, from UVA Cancer Center’s Arun Krishnaraj, MD, MPH, and collaborators, indicate that MRI can predict patient outcomes and the risk of the tumor reccurring or spreading for patients who have undergone chemotherapy and radiation.
That information could be extremely useful in determining the best course of treatment and deciding whether a patient can ...
2024-10-22
New Rochelle, NY, October 18, 2024—An invited Guest Editorial entitled “Give Cas a Chance,” by Fyodor Urnov, PhD, Director of Technology & Translation at the Innovative Genomics Institute (IGI), anchors the October 2024 special issue of The CRISPR Journal on “CRISPR Trials.”
As guest editor of the special issue, Dr. Urnov has penned an extraordinary editorial that emphatically defines the magnitude of the crisis in the genome editing arena and offers a path forward. The inherently programmable nature of CRISPR gene editing that makes it ...
2024-10-22
WASHINGTON—Adults with type 2 diabetes on a low-carbohydrate diet may see benefits to their beta-cell function allowing them to better manage their disease and possibly discontinue medication, according to new research published in the Endocrine Society’s Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism.
Beta-cells are endocrine cells in the pancreas that produce and release insulin, the hormone that controls blood sugar levels.
More than 38 million Americans have diabetes, and over 90% of them have ...
2024-10-22
Exposure to higher levels of air pollution as a baby is linked to having a peanut allergy throughout childhood, according to a new study. And policies aimed at tackling poor air quality could potentially reduce the prevalence and persistence of peanut allergies, it stated.
The research, led by Murdoch Children’s Research Institute (MCRI) and the University of Melbourne, found being exposed to higher levels of air pollution from infancy was associated with increased odds of developing a peanut allergy and having the allergy persist across the first 10 years of life. However, the same association was not seen for egg allergy or eczema.
Published ...
2024-10-22
The metaverse, a space where the lines between physical and digital realities blur, is rising among younger populations. As of March, 33% of teens own a virtual reality (VR) device and 13% use it weekly.
With the metaverse offering richer emotional experiences, youth may be particularly vulnerable to significant harm in these immersive spaces, underscoring the need to explore potential risks.
Unfortunately, research of online victimization in the metaverse is sorely lacking. A new study by Florida Atlantic University, in collaboration with the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire, is one of the first to examine the ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Verified users on social media networks drive polarization and the formation of echo chambers
