(Press-News.org) The World Health Organization (WHO) says that it is adhering to standard protocol in pursuing its transgender health guideline, but the process has been criticised for lacking transparency and an association with WPATH - an organisation that supports the “gender affirming” approach, including hormones and surgery, for all ages - and is under fire for meddling with its own guideline development.
In The BMJ today, freelance journalist Jennifer Block investigates these concerns and the questions they raise about how evidence based the panel’s recommendations would be.
Earlier this year, documents emerged showing that two members of WHO’s guideline committee, in their capacity as executives of WPATH, had attempted to interfere with an independent evidence review commissioned from Johns Hopkins University for WPATH’s 2022 guideline, explains Block.
In emails seen by The BMJ, Karen Robinson, Johns Hopkins research lead, refers to submitting “reports of reviews (dozens!)” to WPATH, but says “we have been having issues with this sponsor trying to restrict our ability to publish.”
WPATH denied prohibiting the team from publishing, but documents reveal there was concern among guideline authors that independent appraisals of the evidence would put them “in an untenable position” to protect affirming interventions from legislative restriction in minors.
Despite these revelations, the two members remain on WHO’s committee.
This is especially troubling to Zhenya Abbruzzese, cofounder of the Society for Evidence Based Gender Medicine (SEGM). “If WHO continues to ignore the evidence that two of its guideline development group members led a recent effort to suppress evidence related to treatments in this area,” she says, “it may harm WHO’s reputation in other areas of medicine, where its clinical guidance is sorely needed.”
WHO defended the makeup of its guideline group as well as its process, telling The BMJ it conducts “careful reviews on conflicts of interest” and that guideline development group members “act in their own expert capacity.”
Documents also reveal that, as WPATH’s guidelines were nearing publication, the organisation was under external pressure from high up in the US government to remove minimum age recommendations for gender related hormones and surgeries, writes Block.
At first, WPATH declined to make the change because it would subvert its “consensus based” methodology. But when the American Academy of Pediatrics threatened to denounce the guidelines if this change wasn’t made, WPATH removed the ages entirely.
After the dispute between Johns Hopkins and WPATH just one review was published. It found the strength of the evidence “low” in determining the effect of hormonal treatment on anxiety, depression, and quality of life, but it nevertheless concluded that such treatment “promotes the health and wellbeing of transgender people.”
Gordon Guyatt at McMaster University says, “All guidelines should be based on systematic reviews of the relevant evidence.” Furthermore, he says, “well conducted science that benefits the general community” should be available to all, so “it’s mysterious why Johns Hopkins didn’t publish” all the reviews it conducted, and it’s “problematic” that WPATH would “attempt to block publication.”
Even if the reviews were disseminated on preprint servers, says Carl Heneghan, director of the University of Oxford’s Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, “there are no excuses in this modern era for not making your data or your particular systematic review available.”
[Ends]
END
The BMJ investigates dispute over US group’s involvement in WHO’s trans health guideline
Guideline panel links to World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) raise questions about bias
2024-10-30
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Personal info and privacy control may be key to better visits with AI doctors
2024-10-30
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Artificial intelligence (AI) may one day play a larger role in medicine than the online symptom checkers available today. But these “AI doctors” may need to get more personal than human doctors to increase patient satisfaction, according to a study led by researchers at Penn State. They found that the more social information an AI doctor recalls about patients, the higher the patients’ satisfaction, but only if they were offered privacy control.
The research team published their findings in the journal Communication Research.
“We tend to think of AI doctors as machines ...
NIH study demonstrates long-term benefits of weight-loss surgery in young people
2024-10-30
What: Young people with severe obesity who underwent weight-loss surgery at age 19 or younger continued to see sustained weight loss and resolution of common obesity-related comorbidities 10 years later, according to results from a large clinical study funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
Study participants with an average age of 17 underwent gastric bypass or sleeve gastrectomy weight-loss surgery. After 10 years, participants sustained an average of 20% reduction in body mass index (BMI), 55% reduction of type 2 diabetes, 57% reduction of hypertension, and 54% reduction of abnormal cholesterol. Both gastric ...
Sustained remission of diabetes and other obesity-related conditions found a decade after weight loss surgery in adolescence
2024-10-30
Ten years after undergoing bariatric surgery as teens, over half of study participants demonstrated not only sustained weight loss, but also resolution of obesity-related conditions, such as type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and high cholesterol, according to the report published in the New England Journal of Medicine.
“Our study presents impressive outcomes of the longest follow-up of weight loss surgery during adolescence, which validates bariatric surgery as a safe and effective long-term obesity management strategy,” said lead author Justin Ryder, PhD, Vice Chair of Research for the Department ...
Low-level lead poisoning is still pervasive in the US and globally
2024-10-30
Chronic, low-level lead poisoning is a major risk factor for cardiovascular disease in adults and cognitive deficits in children, even at levels previously thought to be safe, according to a new paper by Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, Simon Fraser University in Canada, and Harvard Medical School, and Boston Children’s Hospital. Low-level lead poisoning is a risk factor for preterm Birth, cognitive deficits and attention deficit–hyperactivity disorder, (ADHD), as well as increased blood pressure and reduced heart rate variability. The findings ...
How researchers can maximize biological insights using animal-tracking devices
2024-10-30
Biologgers allow us to see with unprecedented precision how animals move and behave in the wild. But that's only part of the picture, according to a UC Santa Cruz ecologist renowned for using biologging data to tell the deeper story about the lives of marine mammals in a changing world.
In a new opinion piece published on October 30 in Trends in Ecology and Evolution, researchers present a framework intended to underscore the value of biologging data for testing important questions about the natural world. They urge that now is the time to build upon "discovery-based science," where observations are presented ...
Research shows new method helps doctors safely remove dangerous heart infections without surgery
2024-10-30
ROCHESTER, Minn. — Doctors at Mayo Clinic used a new catheter-based approach to draw out resistant pockets of infection that settle in the heart, known as right-sided infective endocarditis, without surgery. Unless treated quickly, the walled-off infections can grow, severely damaging heart valves and potentially affecting other organs as well. In a recent study, over 90% of the participants had their infection cleared, and they had lower in-hospital mortality compared to those whose infections remained.
The research is part of a Mayo Clinic-led study ...
Rapid horizontal eye movement can improve stability in people with Parkinson’s
2024-10-30
Rapid side-to-side eye movements can help stabilize posture, avoid falls and maintain balance for people with Parkinson’s disease, just as they can for healthy people. This seemingly counterintuitive conclusion was reached by researchers at São Paulo State University (UNESP) in Brazil and the University of Lille in France in a study supported by FAPESP. An article on the study is published in the journal Biomechanics.
Ten individuals diagnosed with Parkinson’s and 11 neurologically healthy individuals participated in the study. All participants were over 60 and were submitted to tests that ...
Study finds COVID-19 pandemic worsened patient safety measures
2024-10-30
PHILADELPHIA (October 30, 2024) – A new study – published in Nursing Research – has found that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly impacted patient safety indicators in U.S. hospitals. The study, from Penn Nursing’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research (CHOPR), examined data from the National Database of Nursing Quality Indicators to assess trends in nursing-sensitive quality indicators from 2019 to 2022. The prevention of these very distressing, uncomfortable conditions is considered to be under the nurse’s purview and directly influenced by nursing care.
The investigation found that rates of falls, bloodstream infections from ...
Costs still on the rise for drugs for neurological diseases
2024-10-30
MINNEAPOLIS – The amount of money people pay out-of-pocket for branded drugs to treat neurological diseases like multiple sclerosis (MS), Alzheimer’s, and Parkinson’s disease continues to rise, especially for MS drugs, according to a study published in the October 30, 2024, online issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology. The study found that average out-of-pocket costs for drugs for MS increased by 217% over a nine-year period.
Costs have dropped for medications where generic versions have been introduced.
“In some ...
Large herbivores have lived in Yellowstone National Park for more than 2,000 years
2024-10-30
Large herbivores like bison or elk have continuously lived in the Yellowstone National Park region for about 2,300 years according to a new analysis of chemicals preserved in lake sediments. John Wendt of Oklahoma State University, U.S., and colleagues present these findings in the open-access journal PLOS ONE on October 30, 2024.
The near-extinction of bison in North America in the 19th and 20th centuries was a major ecological catastrophe and little is known about where and how these animals lived before European colonization. In the new study, researchers attempted to determine the dominant large herbivores that lived in the northern Yellowstone National Park ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Firms that read more perform better
Tightly tied waist cord of saree underskirt may pose cancer risk, warn doctors
10% of children in high-burden tuberculosis settings may develop the disease by age 10
Health experts push for the elimination of a ‘remarkably harmful toxin’
University of Tennessee, Lockheed Martin expand Master Research Agreement
Testing thousands of RNA enzymes helps find first ‘twister ribozyme’ in mammals
Groundbreaking study provides new evidence of when Earth was slushy
International survey of more than 1600 biomedical researchers on the perceived causes of irreproducibility of research results
Integrating data from different experimental approaches into one model is challenging – this study presents a community-based, full-scale in silico model of the rat hippocampal CA1 region that integra
SwRI awarded grant to characterize Las Moras Springs watershed
Water overuse in MATOPIBA could mean failure to meet up to 40% of local demand for crop irrigation
An extra year of education does not protect against brain aging
Researchers from Uppsala and Magdeburg obtain an ERC Synergy Grant to advance cancer immunotherapy
Deaf male mosquitoes don’t mate
Recognizing traumatic brain injury as a chronic condition fosters better care over the survivor’s lifetime
SwRI’s Dr. James Walker receives Distinguished Scientist Award from Hypervelocity Impact Society
A mother’s health problems pose a risk to her children
Ensuring a bright future for diamond electronics and sensors
The American Pediatric Society selects Dr. Maria Trent as the Recipient of the 2025 David G. Nichols Health Equity Award
The first 3D view of the formation and evolution of globular clusters
Towards a hydrogen-powered future: highly sensitive hydrogen detection system
Scanning synaptic receptors: A game-changer for understanding psychiatric disorders
High-quality nanomechanical resonators with built-in piezoelectricity
ERC Synergy Grants for 57 teams tackling major scientific challenges
Nordic research team receives €13 million to explore medieval book culture
The origin of writing in Mesopotamia is tied to designs engraved on ancient cylinder seals
Explaining science through dance
Pioneering neuroendocrinologist's century of discovery launches major scientific tribute series
Gendered bilingualism in post-colonial Korea
Structural safety monitoring of buildings with color variations
[Press-News.org] The BMJ investigates dispute over US group’s involvement in WHO’s trans health guidelineGuideline panel links to World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) raise questions about bias