(Press-News.org)
Nativity—characterized by place of birth, duration of residence in the host country, citizenship and immigration status—greatly influences the health of foreign-born individuals in the United States (U.S.). Despite this, many national health surveys omit questions about these dimensions of nativity, particularly immigration status. This omission limits the ability to assess health disparities across diverse immigrant subgroups and develop evidence-based policies and targeted interventions.
To navigate this limitation, researchers rely on proxy measures or imputations to determine immigration status. These proxies, including country of birth, occupation and a lack of a social security number, could be inaccurate and lead to biases. For example, some U.S. citizens and permanent residents also do not have social security numbers. Thus, using this as a proxy for identifying undocumented individuals could be misleading.
These challenges could be avoided if questions about immigrant status were asked directly. However, a few concerns persist: stigmatizing questions, lower response rates, invalid responses and deportation or prosecution if data is acquired by law enforcement or immigration authorities.
A research team led by Professor Fatma E. Marouf from Texas A&M University School of Law conducted a study that was published in the American Journal of Public Health on December 4, 2024 to address these complexities. They presented extensive evidence from various sources to corroborate their argument that objections to asking directly about immigration status lack substantiation and can be mitigated.
Highlighting the study’s rationale, Prof. Marouf says, “We can no longer rely on conventional assumptions that [asking about] undocumented status is too stigmatizing or that such questions will yield lower response rates or invalid answers. These concerns must be rigorously tested and weighed against the knowledge lost—and poor health policy decisions that may be made—as a result of not asking [these questions].”
The analysis revealed that surveys like the National Agricultural Worker Survey, Kaiser Family Foundation/Los Angeles Times Survey of Immigrants, Hispanic Community Health Study/Study of Latinos (HCHS/SOL) and Los Angeles Family and Neighborhood Survey (L.A.FANS) have successfully extracted detailed responses to classify immigration status. These surveys provide response choices such as citizen, unauthorized, temporary protected status and pending visa applications.
Furthermore, questions about immigration status in the National Agricultural Worker Survey and the US Census Bureau’s Survey on Income and Program Participation did not affect response rates. Similarly, only 4.3% of foreign-born respondents in L.A.FANS and less than 3% in HCHS/SOL did not answer immigration-related questions. So, questions about immigration status on health surveys could be less stigmatizing than previously assumed and reduce the dependence on proxies.
Regarding response validity, Prof. Marouf notes, “The Census Bureau analyzed the accuracy of self-reported citizenship on the American Community Survey by comparing responses to administrative records from numerous sources, including [but not limited to] those from the Department of Homeland Security and Social Security. They found that among individuals identified as noncitizens based on the administrative records, 12.21% misreported themselves as citizens.” However, this invalidity percentage is still lower than earlier estimates (23.8% to 34.7%) when the Census Bureau used fewer administrative records for analysis.
To prevent deportation or prosecution, participants’ immigration status and personally identifiable information like name and location can be anonymized. Since complete anonymization is impossible in longitudinal surveys, privacy and confidentiality laws can safeguard immigration status data. For instance, the Confidential Information Protection and Statistical Efficiency Act prevents the use of data collected by the federal government for non-statistical purposes and data disclosure without consent by punishments such as 5 years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000.
These findings counter the objections and provide a framework for National Health Surveys to include questions about immigration status. Researchers also proposed that oversampling the foreign-born population could effectively increase the statistical power to detect significant differences.
Prof. Marouf concludes that, “National health surveys have evolved over the past decades to include questions about mental health, substance use, sexual orientation, and gender identity—topics once assumed to be too stigmatizing to ask about, with possible negative legal consequences. The time has come to obtain more detailed information about immigration status as well as to consistently include the measures of immigration history mentioned so that we can better evaluate the health consequences of immigrant-related policy choices.”
###
The American Public Health Association champions optimal, equitable health and well-being for all. With our broad-based member community and 150-year perspective, we influence federal policy to improve the public’s health. Learn more at www.apha.org.
END
Physicians at the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences in Oklahoma City are leading a national clinical trial to help women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)-related infertility who want to become pregnant.
The trial, called REBALANCE, studies the safety and effectiveness of an investigational device developed by May Health that is designed to restore ovulation disrupted by PCOS. OU Health reproductive endocrinologist Karl Hansen, M.D., Ph.D., chair of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the OU College of Medicine, is leading the trial for ...
An experimental bacteria-derived biopesticide is highly effective in killing malaria-carrying mosquitoes, including those that have developed resistance to chemical pesticides, according to initial field tests led by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
The biopesticide is a powder made from the dead cells of a common soil-dwelling bacterial species. The researchers showed that the biopesticide efficiently kills both ordinary and chemical-pesticide-resistant mosquitoes when included in standard baits. ...
WINSTON-SALEM, N.C. – December 4, 2024 — The Piedmont Triad Regenerative Medicine Engine (PTRME), funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), has announced a groundbreaking investment of $2.5 million in the region’s regenerative medicine industry through its inaugural Ecosystem Building Grant program. This milestone underscores PTRME’s leadership in regenerative medicine and commitment to positioning the Piedmont Triad as a global hub for innovation. Six innovative companies have been awarded grants ...
Images
EAST LANSING, Mich. – As global temperatures rise, it’s imperative that plants can adapt to new and changing conditions.
As global temperatures rise, it’s imperative that plants can adapt to new and changing conditions.
Michigan State University researchers from the Walker lab are looking at ways to give plants an assist. More specifically, their research aims to help plants adapt to changing temperatures by introducing engineered enzymes that will increase plants’ heat tolerance.
“I would say that the main goal of our research is to prepare plants for elevated temperatures because, with climate change, ...
The Gerontological Society of America (GSA) — the country’s largest interdisciplinary organization devoted to the field of aging — is proud to acknowledge the work of 34 outstanding individuals through its prestigious awards program.
GSA salutes outstanding research, recognizes distinguished leadership in teaching and service, and fosters new ideas through a host of awards. Nominated by their peers, the recipients’ achievements serve as milestones in the history and development of gerontology.
The awardees were honored at various ...
1. NIMS has established and begun operating a new testing facility to evaluate the mechanical properties of materials exposed to low-temperature hydrogen environments. This facility can create hydrogen conditions across a broader range of temperatures and pressures than any other facility of its kind in the world. It is designed to assess the properties of materials when in contact with low-temperature gaseous or liquefied hydrogen, with the goal of developing cost-effective materials for hydrogen supply chains. This approach is expected to reduce the cost of producing and operating ...
A team of researchers has beaten its own record for the fastest swimming soft robot, drawing inspiration from manta rays to improve their ability to control the robot’s movement in the water.
“Two years ago, we demonstrated an aquatic soft robot that was able to reach average speeds of 3.74 body lengths per second,” says Jie Yin, corresponding author of a paper on the work and an associate professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering at North Carolina State University. “We have improved on that design. Our new soft robot is more energy efficient and reaches a speed of 6.8 body lengths per second. In addition, the previous model could only swim on the surface ...
A new long-term study that has documented the lives of a diverse sample of children over the past three decades shows that the majority of gun carriers began to carry in adulthood, not adolescence. These two groups — which the authors call “adult-onset carriers” if they began carrying after 21 years of age and “adolescent-onset carriers” if their carrying started prior to 21 years of age — have very different patterns in exposure to violence prior to carrying, persistence in carrying, and in actual gun usage.
In “Dual Pathways of ...
"Dog is man's best friend" may be an ancient cliché, but when that friendship began is a longstanding question among scientists.
A new study led by a University of Arizona researcher is one step closer to an answer on how Indigenous people in the Americas interacted with early dogs and wolves.
The study, published today in the journal Science Advances and based on archaeological remains from Alaska, shows that people and the ancestors of today's dogs began forming close relationships as early as 12,000 years ago – ...
Around a third (32%) of people who grew up in Chicago have carried a concealed firearm on the city streets at least once by the time they turn 40 years old, according to a major study of gun usage taking in a quarter of a century of data.
Urban sociologists behind the research argue that such carry rates are likely to be similar across many other major US cities.
The research suggests that almost half of men (48%) have carried a concealed gun by the age of 40, compared to just 16% of women.*
The study, published in Science Advances, is one of the few to track gun usage in the same US population ...
