(Press-News.org) UNDER EMBARGO UNTIL 00:01 GMT WEDNESDAY 11 DECEMBER / 19:01 ET TUESDAY 10 DECEMBER 2024
Leading ecologists have devised a new framework to classify how biodiversity credit operators define what a unit of nature is. The new analysis demonstrates the challenges involved with devising a biodiversity credit market to fund nature recovery, and the risks of relying too heavily on ‘offsetting.’
Nature conservation faces an estimated $700 billion annual funding gap, in order to halt and begin to reverse global biodiversity loss. This means there is an urgent need to engage businesses and the financial sector in funding nature recovery.
This has sparked interest in developing a ‘biodiversity credit market’, where companies could purchase nature credits to compensate for their biodiversity impacts. There has been an explosion in the number of actors who are beginning to develop or sell biodiversity credits, however up to now it has been unclear how they are defining what ‘one unit of nature’ means, or how they are making standardised, generalisable measurements of biodiversity.
In a new review published today (11 December) in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, a group of researchers introduce a framework that defines how companies are quantifying biodiversity, detecting positive outcomes, and linking actions to investment. They use this framework to interrogate the various challenges that come with abstracting nature, in all its complexity, to one unit, and to discuss ways in which units of nature could be misleading, or unrepresentative of true biodiversity gains.
The review is particularly special because it is the first in a new series commemorating the work of Professor Dame Georgina Mace, who made foundational contributions to the field of biodiversity measurement to support international conservation policy.
Study senior author Professor EJ Milner-Gulland (Department of Biology, University of Oxford) said: “The world's governments have agreed to halt and reverse biodiversity loss by 2030. This requires wider society, particularly businesses, to pull their weight as well. We can't avoid all impacts of human activity on nature, so we need to be able to compensate for the damage that we cause to nature. Our review demonstrates how challenging it is to do this via a tradeable ‘unit of nature’ and provides guidance on how to ensure biodiversity credits are appropriately designed and used, so that they can support genuine biodiversity recovery.”
Study lead author Dr Hannah Wauchope (University of Edinburgh) said: "Measuring biodiversity outcomes is of increasing interest to policy and financial sectors, but it is phenomenally difficult to reduce something as complex as biodiversity to a single number, meaning there are many risks to developing a market that trades in nature. We wanted to examine how companies were attempting this difficult task."
The framework shows how two broad approaches are being used to reduce the complexity of biodiversity at a site to a single value. The first assigns a numeric value to an area, where a higher number indicates higher biodiversity value. For instance, a site might be measured by a number of metrics such as species richness, tree canopy cover, and abundance of a target species. These numbers would be aggregated to a single value that represents ecosystem health.
The second approach classifies sites according to a binary condition- whether the ecosystem is healthy or not. For instance, the health of the forest could be measured by the presence or absence of indicator species, such as the jaguar.
Credits then measure whether sites have been conserved or restored – either demonstrating that the site has not changed (in the case of conservation), for instance, by showing that an indicator species is still present, or demonstrating that the site has improved (in the case of restoration), for instance, by measuring changes in the numeric value. Finally, credit operators adjust the number of credits they issue based on uncertainties (for example, not selling 20% of measured credits) to act as a buffer.
The researchers use this framework to highlight the various challenges that are faced in trying to represent biodiversity by a single unit. For example, biodiversity has many ways of being valuable, many of which are unmeasurable, and some of which conflict with each other (for example the cultural value of a tree species for local people and its financial value as a timber product). Even for aspects that can be measured, it is difficult to do so accurately, and to aggregate metrics in sensible ways – leaving lots of room for uncertainties or gaming to produce misleading outcomes.
According to the researchers, perhaps the biggest challenge is demonstrating that conservation or restoration outcomes happen as a direct result of investment, rather than some other reason, and ensuring that threats to biodiversity haven’t simply been displaced elsewhere.
Because of these challenges, the researchers caution against using biodiversity credits to offset a company's impacts on the environment, particularly to support "Nature Positive" claims. Instead, companies should prioritise avoiding and reducing impacts on nature as much as possible. Credits are best used as a way for companies to demonstrate that they are making measurable, positive, contributions towards nature recovery, when they cannot do this directly (for instance, by restoring biodiversity on land they own).
Dr Wauchope added: “Biodiversity credit markets can only be positive for biodiversity if they are used with unprecedentedly strict regulation that ensures businesses prioritise avoiding negative impacts in the first place. If biodiversity credits are purchased, it should be to quantify positive contributions rather than as direct offsets.”
Professor Milner-Gulland said: “There may be a role for biodiversity markets in leveraging funding for nature that would otherwise be unreachable, but markets can only ever be one part of the solution for delivering effective and equitable conservation. There will remain an important role for direct investment in nature by the public and private sectors, as well as for regulation to reduce impacts on nature.”
Notes to editors:
For media inquiries and interview requests, contact Dr Hannah Wauchope: hannah.wauchope@gmail.com
The study ‘What is a unit of nature? Measurement challenges in the emerging biodiversity credit market’ will be published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, at 00:01 GMT Wednesday 11 December 2024 / 19:01 ET Tuesday 10 December 2024, at https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2024.2353
To view a copy of the paper before this under embargo, contact Dr Hannah Wauchope: hannah.wauchope@gmail.com
About the University of Oxford
Oxford University has been placed number 1 in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings for the ninth year running, and number 3 in the QS World Rankings 2025. At the heart of this success are the twin-pillars of our ground-breaking research and innovation and our distinctive educational offer.
Oxford is world-famous for research and teaching excellence and home to some of the most talented people from across the globe. Our work helps the lives of millions, solving real-world problems through a huge network of partnerships and collaborations. The breadth and interdisciplinary nature of our research alongside our personalised approach to teaching sparks imaginative and inventive insights and solutions.
Through its research commercialisation arm, Oxford University Innovation, Oxford is the highest university patent filer in the UK and is ranked first in the UK for university spinouts, having created more than 200 new companies since 1988. Over a third of these companies have been created in the past three years. The university is a catalyst for prosperity in Oxfordshire and the United Kingdom, contributing £15.7 billion to the UK economy in 2018/19, and supports more than 28,000 full time jobs.
The Department of Biology is a University of Oxford department within the Maths, Physical, and Life Sciences Division. It utilises academic strength in a broad range of bioscience disciplines to tackle global challenges such as food security, biodiversity loss, climate change and global pandemics. It also helps to train and equip the biologists of the future through holistic undergraduate and graduate courses. For more information visit www.biology.ox.ac.uk.
END
What is a unit of nature? New framework shows the challenges involved with establishing a biodiversity credit market
2024-12-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
NYCEDC and NYU Tandon launch applications for new digital game design incubator
2024-12-10
New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC), in conjunction with NYU Tandon School of Engineering, has officially opened and launched applications for New York City’s new digital game design incubator—the Game Design Future Lab (GDFL)—within NYU Tandon Future Labs, a startup incubator network operator founded 15 years ago with initial funding from NYCEDC. The Game Design Future Lab taps into New York City’s growing digital game development industry and aims to enable developer growth and success through personalized and strategic mentorship, industry-specific and fundamental ...
Soda taxes don’t just affect sales. They help change people’s minds.
2024-12-10
It wasn’t that long ago when cigarettes and soda were go-to convenience store vices, glamorized in movies and marketed toward, well, everyone.
Then, lawmakers and voters raised taxes on cigarettes, and millions of dollars went into public education campaigns about smoking’s harms. Decades of news coverage chronicled how addictive and dangerous cigarettes were and the enormous steps companies took to hide the risks and hook more users. The result: a radical shift in social norms that made it less acceptable to smoke and ...
Early restrictive vs liberal oxygen for trauma patients
2024-12-10
About The Study: In adult trauma patients, an early restrictive oxygen strategy compared with a liberal oxygen strategy initiated in the prehospital setting or on trauma center admission for 8 hours did not significantly reduce death and/or major respiratory complications within 30 days.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Jacob Steinmetz, MD, PhD, email jacob.steinmetz@regionh.dk.
To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website at this link https://media.jamanetwork.com/
(doi:10.1001/jama.2024.25786)
Editor’s Note: Please see the article for additional information, ...
Enabling AI to explain its predictions in plain language
2024-12-10
CAMBRIDGE, MA – Machine-learning models can make mistakes and be difficult to use, so scientists have developed explanation methods to help users understand when and how they should trust a model’s predictions.
These explanations are often complex, however, perhaps containing information about hundreds of model features. And they are sometimes presented as multifaceted visualizations that can be difficult for users who lack machine-learning expertise to fully comprehend.
To help people make sense of AI explanations, MIT researchers used large language models (LLMs) to transform plot-based explanations into plain language.
They developed ...
A greener, cleaner way to extract cobalt from ‘junk’ materials
2024-12-10
Siddarth Kara’s bestseller, “Cobalt Red: How the Blood of Congo Powers Our Lives,” focuses on problems surrounding the sourcing of cobalt, a critical component of lithium-ion batteries that power many technologies central to modern life, from mobile phones and pacemakers to electric vehicles.
“Perhaps many of us have read how lithium-ion batteries are vital for energy storage technologies,” says Eric Schelter, the Hirschmann-Makineni Professor of Chemistry at the University of Pennsylvania. “But how material that make up such batteries are sourced can be concerning and problematic, both ethically and environmentally.”
Schelter ...
Better environmental performance boosts profits and cuts costs
2024-12-10
Fukuoka, Japan—Sustainable practices in business are more than just an ethical responsibility; they make sound financial sense. Researchers from Kyushu University, in a study published on December 10, 2024, in Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, reveal that companies with better environmental performance and transparent disclosures can lower costs and boost profits.
Investors are increasingly recognizing companies' contributions toward carbon neutrality, driving the growth of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) investing. To support this trend, the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) has provided an industry-specific framework ...
Making self-driving cars safer, less accident prone
2024-12-10
Self-driving cars rely on artificial intelligence to predict where nearby cars will go. But when those predictions don’t match reality, that discrepancy can potentially lead to crashes and less safe roadways.
That’s why a recent study from the University of Georgia developed a new AI model to make self-driving cars safer.
This study introduces an AI model for self-driving cars, designed to predict the movement of nearby traffic and incorporate innovative features for planning safe vehicle movements.
"The planned trajectory of the self-driving car may turn out to collide with the actual trajectory of another vehicle.” —Qianwen Li, College ...
Rethinking the quantum chip
2024-12-10
Researchers at the UChicago Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering (UChicago PME) have realized a new design for a superconducting quantum processor, aiming at a potential architecture for the large-scale, durable devices the quantum revolution demands.
Unlike the typical quantum chip design that lays the information-processing qubits onto a 2-D grid, the team from the Cleland Lab has designed a modular quantum processor comprising a reconfigurable router as a central hub. This enables any two qubits to connect and entangle, where in the ...
When does waiting stop being worth it?
2024-12-10
You’re standing at a bus stop, waiting for a ride that seems like it will never come. At first, you’re hopeful that it will be here any second. But as the minutes laggardly drag on, doubt creeps in. Should you keep waiting, or is it smarter to start walking or call for a ride?
“It’s a classic dilemma. “Do you persist with the belief that the bus is on its way, or do you cut your losses and move on to something else?” asks Joe Kable, a psychologist in the School of Arts ...
Nationwide study looks at when and where EV owners use public charging stations
2024-12-10
AUSTIN, TX, Dec 10, 2024 – Electric Vehicles (EVs) represent a promising mode of transportation that can help the United States reduce its carbon emissions. But barriers such as the high cost of installing and using EV Charging Stations (EVCS), their limitations in supplying emerging demand, and their uneven distribution throughout the country limit access for many Americans.
Researchers at the University of Maryland are using supercomputers and machine learning methods to analyze a full year of real-time data collected from individual EV charging ports at more than 50,000 publicly available stations throughout the country. The primary focus of the study is ...