PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Soldiers can cope with killing

They train for it and they know it's part of the job. But one factor helps veterans cope with the reality of killing in the course of their duties

Soldiers can cope with killing
2025-03-26
(Press-News.org) Taking a person’s life is not automatically harmful to a soldier’s mental well-being if the circumstances justified it, according to a study of more than 14,600 soldiers.

“Killing another person does not in itself seem to be something that goes against human nature, and it doesn’t necessarily harm the mental health of the person who does it,” said Andreas Espetvedt Nordstrand, a Norwegian clinical psychologist.

Commander Nordstrand is the head of research and development at the Institute of Military Psychiatry, Norwegian Armed Forces – Joint Medical Services. In addition, he is an associate professor at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU’s) Department of Psychology.

The results of a new study directly contradict previous theories that taking a person’s life is automatically detrimental to mental health. However, everything depends on the circumstances in which it takes place.

Studied all Lebanon and Afghanistan veterans Nordstrand investigated the mental health of Norwegian veterans after they had completed their military service. He conducted this study with Professor Leif Edward Ottesen Kennair from the same department at NTNU and several other researchers.

These include war veteran Ronny Kristoffersen, who was himself shot in Afghanistan, and former chief psychiatrist of the Norwegian Armed Forces – now known from the Norwegian TV programme Kompani Lauritzen – Jon Reichelt. It is a comprehensive study.

“We studied every Norwegian Armed Forces veteran who had served in Lebanon and Afghanistan, and identified those who have killed in combat,” said Nordstrand.

The study included 10,605 Lebanon veterans and 4053 Afghanistan veterans, although only a small minority had killed someone. The researchers then investigated how the experiences during service had subsequently affected the soldiers’ mental health.

“We looked at PTSD, depression, insomnia, anxiety, alcohol consumption and quality of life,” Nordstrand said.

The results are striking – the difference between veterans from Lebanon and Afghanistan is huge.

The Lebanon veterans suffered more mental health problems “Taking a life in combat was a key factor among the veterans who had served in Lebanon. The veterans who had killed someone in combat were more likely to experience mental health problems, increased alcohol consumption and reduced quality of life later on,” said Nordstrand.

But that was not the case for the veterans who had served in Afghanistan.

“For the Afghanistan veterans, taking a life had no subsequent impact on their mental well-being. We did not identify a trend in any of the variables we investigated,” said Nordstrand.

The researchers checked all the analyses to establish whether other exposure to trauma could explain the findings. The difference between the two veteran populations is striking.

Nordstrand believes the findings reveal something fundamental about human nature.

“There is a widespread belief in society that taking the life of another person goes against human nature, and that this will easily create what psychotraumatology refers to as ‘moral injuries’,” he said.

But that doesn’t appear to be the case.

“Our findings indicate that whether taking a life subsequently has a negative impact on mental health and quality of life is highly context-dependent,” emphasized Nordstrand.

Completely different situations for soldiers in Lebanon and Afghanistan Lebanon and Afghanistan were very different missions, which may account for some of the difference.

In Lebanon, the soldiers’ mission was largely to calm tensions and ensure that peace was maintained. There was a risk of combat, but it was nowhere near as dangerous as in Afghanistan.

In Afghanistan, soldiers were much more likely to encounter combat situations with more aggressive opponents.

“Participating in a peacekeeping operation seems to make soldiers much more vulnerable to the aftermath of killing another person than soldiers involved in combat missions," Nordstrand said.

The expectations of the soldiers and their missions were very different.

"We believe this supports the view that it is primarily violations of group norms and mission guidelines that make actions like killing harmful,” he said.

If the mission entails a high risk of the enemy acting aggressively, there is more leeway and acceptance for taking a life.

The groups are more similar with regard to other traumatic experiences, such as being in life-threatening situations or witnessing something traumatic.

“But the Afghanistan veterans experience fewer problems from being in life-threatening situations, such as participating in combat. This is probably related to training and preparation, which provide mental resilience in high-stress situations and make it less likely that such experiences will negatively impact the soldiers afterwards.

Clear missions that establish norms “We believe the findings show that we must be acutely aware of the rules of engagement, expectations, and the mission guidelines we set when sending soldiers on armed missions," he said.

And it doesn’t just apply to soldiers. The same is probably true for other areas where the government has a role in violence, such as the police.

"These factors collectively create group norms among the soldiers – norms that determine what they perceive as right or wrong. It is these group norms that are either violated or upheld if they find themselves in a situation where they have to kill,” explained Nordstrand.

If soldiers know and experience that it is acceptable to kill when the situation demands it, such experiences rarely become a problem. They are not left with a feeling of having done something wrong. At the same time, killing someone is very far removed from what most people in Norway experience, so soldiers are often particularly careful to ensure that the action occurred within the established group norms.

“The differences between the two groups of veterans in our study enable us to identify what creates protection against and the risk of negative consequences of taking a person’s life. The common factor here is the context in which it occurs. This applies to preparations, both physical and mental, and how society and networks engage with individuals who have killed when they eventually return to Norwegian society.”

Five years of research Nordstrand started this project back in 2020, and although the data quickly provided clear answers, it still took five years for the article to be published.

“This is a sensitive topic, and the findings may be perceived as somewhat taboo. In civilized, humanistic societies, people often dislike the idea that taking a person’s life can be entirely unproblematic for soldiers, as long as it happens within the rules of war," he said. "We therefore took our time and ensured that we had solid evidence for the findings of the study and the interpretations of the results. I had several different statisticians thoroughly verify the findings.” 

Determined by mindset Professor Leif Edward Ottesen Kennair joined the team to incorporate perspectives from anthropology and evolutionary psychology.

“Traditionally, there has been an argument that war is unnatural, that killing is wrong, and that we expect people to be harmed by it, regardless. I have been sceptical of this line of thought,” Kennair said.

He believes the results of the study confirm that the internal group norms, or ‘rules of engagement’, determine the long-term effects.

“The mindset with which soldiers approach a mission determines whether they expect, are prepared for and interpret the intense aspects of the role. If they are in war mode and fully aware of it, they will deal with it completely differently. They experience events and actions differently than if they are unprepared or have a peace mentality,” explained Kennair.

The well-known war veteran Ronny Kristoffersen contributed as a co-author and brought his personal combat experiences into the reflections on the findings.

Important to address “I think it is important to bring evidence-based perspectives on this taboo subject into the public debate,” said Nordstrand.

Nordstrand said this is especially important during today's turbulent times, when many nations are increasing their military capabilities and there seems to be a greater risk of involvement in armed conflicts.

“Soldiers kill, and being able to do that is actually a key part of their job. The findings are a clear call to take both political and collective responsibility when sending soldiers on dangerous missions, ensuring that they do not feel as though they have done something that goes against the norms of the society they are part of,” Nordstrand said.

END

[Attachments] See images for this press release:
Soldiers can cope with killing Soldiers can cope with killing 2 Soldiers can cope with killing 3

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Quantum Leap: NIST selects FAU for new generation of encryption standards

Quantum Leap: NIST selects FAU for new generation of encryption standards
2025-03-26
The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has selected Florida Atlantic University’s Hamming Quasi-Cyclic (HQC) for standardization in its Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) project. After a thorough evaluation process, NIST selected HQC to be part of the new generation of encryption standards, for its ability to meet its criteria for security, efficiency and practical implementation.  HQC is a cryptographic algorithm designed to ensure secure key exchange between two parties, enabling ...

City of Hope-led study demystifies tumor formation’s two-step process — a foundational understanding needed to prevent cancer

City of Hope-led study demystifies tumor formation’s two-step process — a foundational understanding needed to prevent cancer
2025-03-26
LOS ANGELES — Researchers at City of Hope®, one of the largest and most advanced cancer research and treatment organizations in the U.S. with its National Medical Center named top 5 in the nation for cancer by U.S. News & World Report, have found that cell mutations are necessary but not always sufficient for tumors to form. Instead, they suggest that additional risk factors that promote tumor growth, like chronic inflammation, are a key trigger for tumor formation. The study findings, published this month in Cancer Discovery, answer a question that scientists have long asked: Are cell mutations alone ...

We are vastly overestimating the amount of fresh water available for lithium mining, new study finds

We are vastly overestimating the amount of fresh water available for lithium mining, new study finds
2025-03-26
March 26, 2025   We Are Vastly Overestimating the Amount of Fresh Water Available for Lithium Mining, New Study Finds New research led by UMass Amherst hydrologists sounds the alarm over mining practices that have immediate implications for transition to low-carbon economy   AMHERST, Mass. — New research into lithium mining in the “Lithium Triangle” of Chile, Argentina and Bolivia — source of more than half of the world’s lithium resources — shows that the commonly accepted models used ...

If native plants are going to survive climate change, they need our help to move—here’s how to do it safely

2025-03-26
March 26, 2025 AMHERST, Mass. – Many native plants in the U.S. cannot possibly move themselves fast enough to avoid climate-change driven extinction. If these native plants are going to have any chance of surviving into the future, they’ll need human help to move into adjacent areas, a process known as “managed relocation.” And yet, there’s no guarantee that a plant will thrive in a new area. Furthermore, movement of introduced plants, albeit over much larger distances, is exactly how the problem of invasive species began—think of kudzu-choked forests, wetlands taken over by purple ...

Blue pigment improves foundation makeup shades for dark skin

Blue pigment improves foundation makeup shades for dark skin
2025-03-26
SAN DIEGO, March 26, 2025 — On the shelves of makeup counters and drugstores sits an array of foundations in various olive, ivory and fair shades. But for people with darker skin tones, finding the right foundation shade can be a challenge. Dark foundations on the market often fall flat, appearing gray-like once applied on the skin. But now, researchers report a blue cosmetic color additive that gives these foundations the warmth and depth they currently lack. Gabriella Baki, associate professor of pharmaceutics and director of the cosmetic science and formulation design undergraduate program at the University of ...

A safe nuclear battery that could last a lifetime

A safe nuclear battery that could last a lifetime
2025-03-26
SAN DIEGO, March 26, 2025 — Sometimes cell phones die sooner than expected or electric vehicles don’t have enough charge to reach their destination. The rechargeable lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries in these and other devices typically last hours or days between charging. However, with repeated use, batteries degrade and need to be recharged more frequently. Now, researchers are considering radiocarbon as a source for safe, small and affordable nuclear batteries that could last decades or longer without charging.   Su-Il In, a professor at Daegu Gyeongbuk Institute of Science & Technology, will present his results at the spring meeting of the American Chemical ...

Making sturdy, semi-transparent wood with cheap, natural materials

Making sturdy, semi-transparent wood with cheap, natural materials
2025-03-26
SAN DIEGO, March 26, 2025 — Can you imagine a smartphone with a wooden touchscreen? Or a house with wooden windows? Probably not — unless you’ve heard of transparent wood. Made by modifying wood’s natural structure, this material has been proposed as a sturdy, eco-friendly plastic alternative. But wood’s biodegradability is often sacrificed in the process. Researchers are hoping to change that by creating transparent woods from almost entirely natural materials and making them electrically conductive. The researchers will present their results at the spring ...

Adulting is hard on the heart: Teen to young adulthood is a critical time to address risk

2025-03-26
Statement Highlights: By age 18, many adolescents have already developed heart disease risk factors, such as high blood pressure, obesity, high cholesterol or Type 2 diabetes, and a growing number of younger adults are experiencing adverse cardiovascular events.   Numerous social determinants of health and developmental and life changes impact cardiovascular risk as young people progress from their teens to their mid-20s. The statement describes the challenges and opportunities for easing the transition ...

Study shows link between the start of the working day and time preferences

2025-03-26
Those who start work earlier express more discomfort with the seasonal time change. This is the main conclusion of a study that the lecturers at the University of Santiago de Compostela (USC) and the University of Seville (US), Jorge Mira Pérez and José María Martín Olalla, have just published in the journal Chronobiology International, in which they analyse in detail the results of the public consultation organised by the European Commission in 2018 in the then 28 member states, which ...

Scientists discovered chemical oscillations in palladium nanoparticles, paving the way for recycling precious metal catalysts

Scientists discovered  chemical oscillations in palladium nanoparticles, paving the way for recycling precious metal catalysts
2025-03-26
Scientists have for the first time filmed the real-time growth and contraction of Palladium nanoparticles, opening new avenues for utilising and recycling precious metal catalysts. Researchers at the University of Nottingham’s School of Chemistry used transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to observe the complete lifecycle of palladium nanoparticles in a liquid environment, from nucleation through growth to dissolution, with the entire cycle repeating multiple times. This study has been published today in Nanoscale. One of the most important applications of metal nanoparticles is in catalysis, which forms a backbone of chemical industries. Dr Jesum Alves ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Nuclear monitoring system suggests landslide cut off internet in west Africa

PNNL scientist elected AAAS fellow

American College of Cardiology recognizes five JACC Rocket Fuel Consultants

American College of Cardiology, Association of Black Cardiologists recognize three Merck Research Fellowship awardees

JACC to recognize 2025 Simon Dack Award recipients, Elite Reviewers

American College of Cardiology honors two recipients with the William A. Zoghbi Global Research Initiative Award

JACC recognizes five recipients of the William W. Parmley Young Author Achievement Award

Mass General Brigham researchers identify mutations that can lead to resistance to some chemotherapies

JACC journals honor 10 young researchers

Jefferson Lab Director Kimberly Sawyer named to CoVaBIZ Magazine’s 150 Most Influential People List

The world according to mosquitoes: USU ecologists lead AI-based effort to identify disease vectors

Drexel researchers develop new DNA test for personalized treatment of bacterial vaginosis

Keith T. Flaherty, MD, FAACR, elected as American Association for Cancer Research President-Elect for 2025-2026

Brownie points for ChatGPT’s food analysis skills

The Giants Foundation provide 12 schools with CPR resources to improve cardiac emergency outcomes

Why scientists are worried about weasels

American College of Cardiology recognizes 21 Distinguished Award recipients

American College of Cardiology recognizes three recipients of the Hani Najm Global Scholar Award Observership Program

DNA helps electronics to leave flatland

Studying cardiac cells in space to repair heart damage on Earth

Studies evaluate the health effects of bioactive compounds obtained from plants

Howard University physicist revisits the computational limits of life and Schrödinger’s essential question in the era of quantum computing

Navigating a US bioscience career despite anticipated cuts in funding for biomedicine

How the failure of two dams amplified the Derna Flood tragedy

Oral contraceptives and smoking impact steroid hormone levels in healthy adults

C-Path’s predictive safety testing consortium advances a transformative test to detect drug induced liver injury

Green solvent innovation: high-speed doctor-blading boosts organic solar cell efficiency

C-Path announces successful conclusion of the ECOA: getting better together initiative

Brain channels ‘stopped in time’ reveal chemical flow that enables learning and thinking

PET imaging confirms direct involvement of dopamine in cognitive flexibility

[Press-News.org] Soldiers can cope with killing
They train for it and they know it's part of the job. But one factor helps veterans cope with the reality of killing in the course of their duties