(Press-News.org) Toronto - The plumber has just left after fixing that leaky basement pipe. Ping – a phone alert asks you to rate their service. Hmm -- if it wasn’t an outright terrible job, do you give them three, four or five stars? New research from the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management shows that a multi-point system like that is prone to subtle, often unconscious, racial bias -- yet with significant financial consequences for non-white workers.
Using data from a real-life online home maintenance matching service, researchers showed white workers got higher average ratings than non-white workers. They also got top marks 86.9% of the time compared to only 83.4% of the time for workers who weren’t white.
Those ratings cut into workers’ earnings. Under the service’s pay system, lower average ratings reduced the slice of total revenue a worker made from subsequent jobs. Under a five-point system, non-white workers ended up with 91 cents for every dollar earned by white workers, the researchers estimated.
“While the objective difference, on average, between white and non-white worker ratings is very small, it matters because of the impact it has on income, highlighting the importance of structure and organizational design for racial equality at work,” said Katherine DeCelles, a professor of organizational behaviour at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management who was among the four-member research team.
Unlike overt racism, where a customer might refuse to work with a non-white contractor, subtle racism tends to be harder to pin down and can be expressed even when a person doesn’t believe they’re being racist.
A home repair service might not be able to change people’s attitudes, but the researchers found that when the service being studied switched to a two-choice system – customers were only asked if they would use the contractor again, thumbs-up or thumbs-down -- racial gaps in who got top ratings virtually disappeared. And new workers who joined after the switch saw no racial differences in earnings for the same job.
Follow-up experiments using online participants and artificial scenarios again showed reduced racial disparities in two-point performance ratings among participants with subtle racial bias. Participants also told the researchers that their opinions and biases were less likely to influence their performance evaluations when there were only two options.
“People can more clearly evaluate whether someone’s work was good versus not, instead of ‘how good was it?’ which is relatively more subjective and ambiguous – that’s where we’d expect a larger problem with racial bias in evaluations,” said Prof. DeCelles.
Given that rating systems are increasingly common in many digital platform-based services, the researchers recommend keeping them simple and focusing evaluators on whether something was good or bad to avoid the influence of bias. Platforms can also regularly audit their systems to identify systematic variations in evaluations that may be bias-related and give customers other ways to provide more detailed feedback on top of the basic evaluation, without consequences for worker pay, suggested Prof. DeCelles.
Prof. DeCelles collaborated on the research with Demetrius Humes, a PhD student in organizational behaviour and human research management at the Rotman Schook, Tristan Botelho of Yale University and Sora Jun of Rice University. It was published earlier this year in the journal Nature.
Bringing together high-impact faculty research and thought leadership on one searchable platform, the Rotman Insights Hub offers articles, podcasts, opinions, books and videos representing the latest in management thinking and providing insights into the key issues facing business and society. Visit www.rotman.utoronto.ca/insightshub.
The Rotman School of Management is part of the University of Toronto, a global centre of research and teaching excellence at the heart of Canada’s commercial capital. Rotman is a catalyst for transformative learning, insights and public engagement, bringing together diverse views and initiatives around a defining purpose: to create value for business and society. For more information, visit www.rotman.utoronto.ca.
-30-
For more information:
Ken McGuffin
Manager, Media Relations
Rotman School of Management
University of Toronto
E-mail:mcguffin@rotman.utoronto.ca
END
Switch to two-point rating scales to reduce racism in performance reviews, research suggests
2025-05-09
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: May 9, 2025
2025-05-09
Reston, VA (May 9, 2025)—New research has been published ahead-of-print by The Journal of Nuclear Medicine (JNM). JNM is published by the Society of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, an international scientific and medical organization dedicated to advancing nuclear medicine, molecular imaging, and theranostics—precision medicine that allows diagnosis and treatment to be tailored to individual patients in order to achieve the best possible outcomes.
Summaries of the newly published research articles are provided below.
New Brain Imaging Tool Targets Key Enzyme in Mental Health
Scientists have developed a promising new PET imaging compound, 11C-ZTP-1, to visualize ...
Stability solution brings unique form of carbon closer to practical application
2025-05-09
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Carbyne, a one-dimensional chain of carbon atoms, is incredibly strong for being so thin, making it an intriguing possibility for use in next-generation electronics, but its extreme instability causing it to bend and snap on itself made it nearly impossible to produce at all, let alone produce enough of it for advanced studies. Now, an international team of researchers, including from Penn State, may have a solution.
The research team has enclosed carbyne in single-walled carbon nanotubes — tiny, tube-shaped ...
New research illustrates the relationship between moral outrage on social media and activism
2025-05-09
A new study published in Social Psychological and Personality Science examines how expressions of moral outrage on social media are linked to online activism, specifically petition signing behavior.
A research team led by Dr. Stefan Leach from Lancaster University analyzed over 1.2 million posts on X (formerly Twitter) containing links to nearly 25,000 petitions on Change.org. The findings reveal a surprising disconnect: while expressions of moral outrage significantly increase a post's virality (likes and reposts), they ...
New enzyme capable of cleaving cellulose should revolutionize biofuel production
2025-05-09
The deconstruction of cellulose is essential for the conversion of biomass into fuels and chemicals. But cellulose, the most abundant renewable polymer on the planet, is extremely recalcitrant to biological depolymerization. Although composed entirely of glucose units, its crystalline microfibrillar structure and association with lignin and hemicelluloses in plant cell walls make it highly resistant to degradation. As a result, its degradation in nature is slow and requires complex enzymatic systems. The deconstruction ...
Krebs von den Lungen-6 as a biomarker for distinguishing between interstitial lung disease and interstitial lung abnormalities based on computed tomography findings
2025-05-09
Background: Krebs von den Lungen-6 (KL-6), predominantly expressed by type II alveolar cells, is linked to the prognosis and severity of interstitial lung disease (ILD). This investigation sought to explore the relationship between KL-6 concentrations and the presence of ILD versus interstitial lung abnormalities (ILA).
Methods: This single-center retrospective study included 147 patients who were suspected of ILD and underwent KL-6 testing between October 2022 and March 2023. Epidemiological and clinical details of the patients, including the outcomes of pulmonary function tests and computed tomography findings, were retrospectively extracted from electronic medical records.
Results: The ...
Chimpanzee groups drum with distinct rhythms
2025-05-09
New research from a team of cognitive scientists and evolutionary biologists finds that chimpanzees drum rhythmically, using regular spacing between drum hits. Their results, publishing in the Cell Press journal Current Biology on May 9, show that eastern and western chimpanzees—two distinct subspecies—drum with distinguishable rhythms. The researchers say these findings suggest that the building blocks of human musicality arose in a common ancestor of chimpanzees and humans.
“Based on our previous work, we expected that western chimpanzees would use more hits and drum more ...
Wasp mums use remarkable memory when feeding offspring
2025-05-09
Wasp mothers have stunning brainpower when it comes to feeding their young, new research shows.
Digger wasps make a short burrow for each egg, stocking it with food and returning a few days later to provide more.
The study reveals that mother wasps can remember the locations of up to nine separate nests at once, rarely making mistakes despite the fact nests are dug in bare sand containing hundreds belonging to other females.
Mothers feed their young in age order, adjusting the order if one dies, and they can even delay feeding offspring that had ...
Americans’ use of illicit opioids is higher than previously reported
2025-05-09
More Americans use illicit opioids such as fentanyl than previously estimated, highlighting the need for better methods to understand the depths of the opioid crisis, according to a new study.
A survey of American adults found that 11% reported illicit opioid use within the past 12 months and 7.5% reported use of illicitly produced fentanyl during the same period, rates that are more than 20 times higher than estimates from a large federal study that annually asks Americans about their use of illicit drugs.
Researchers say the findings add to the evidence that government counts may significantly underestimate illicit drug use and suggest ...
Estimates of illicit opioid use in the U.S.
2025-05-09
About The Study: In this national survey of 1,515 adults conducted in June 2024, 166 respondents (11.0%) reported illicit opioid use and 114 (7.5%) reported illicitly manufactured fentanyl use within the past 12 months. These rates are much higher than previously reported estimates. The findings highlight the need for more timely and accurate data to inform policy and intervention strategies. Enhanced data collection efforts are essential for understanding and mitigating the opioid crisis.
Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, David Powell, PhD, email dpowell@rand.org.
To ...
Effectiveness and safety of RSV vaccine for U.S. adults age 60 or older
2025-05-09
About The Study: Vaccine effectiveness (VE) for the respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) protein subunit vaccine in this case-control study was similar to the VE in clinical trials. The VE for immunocompromised patients was mildly (overall) to moderately (for stem cell transplant recipients) diminished. Risk of immune thrombocytopenic purpura after vaccination was not elevated, but the risk of Guilain-Barré syndrome was statistically significantly elevated in patients who received the RSVPreF vaccine but not in those who received RSVPreF+AS01 vaccine, although the risk was small. These observations should inform clinicians’ choices ...