(Press-News.org) [Strasbourg, 14 May 2025] The “How Equitable Is It?” tool, designed to assess the equity of scholarly communication models, has been officially launched today in its updated version following a comprehensive review of community feedback. Originally introduced as a beta version in September 2024 at the OASPA conference, this refined version of the tool incorporates significant improvements based on input from across the scholarly publishing ecosystem.
Developed by a multi-stakeholder Working Group, comprising librarians, library consortia representatives, funders and publishers, and convened by cOAlition S, Jisc and PLOS, the tool aims to provide a framework for evaluating scholarly communication models and arrangements on the axis of equity.
Key enhancements
The revised tool offers enhanced guidance for users and clearer definitions of equity indicators, across the seven core assessment criteria:
Access to Read
Publishing immediate Open Access
Maximizing participation
Re-use rights
Pricing and fee transparency
Promoting and encouraging open research practices: data and code
Promoting and encouraging open research practices: preprints and open peer review
Community-driven improvements
From September 2024 through January 2025, the Working Group collected extensive feedback from stakeholders who tested the beta version. This collaborative approach ensured that the tool's updated version addresses practical challenges faced by institutions, library consortia, funders, and publishers in evaluating equity within scholarly communication models and arrangements.
The tool, which was inspired by the “How Open Is It?” framework, is targeted at institutions, library consortia, funders and publishers, i.e. the stakeholders either investing or receiving funds for publishing services. It offers users the opportunity to rate scholarly communication models and arrangements across seven criteria:
Robert Kiley, Head of Strategy at cOAlition S and co-Chair of the Working Group, stated: “We are grateful to everyone who provided feedback during the testing period. Their insights have been instrumental in refining this tool to better serve stakeholders in making informed decisions when investing or receiving funds for publishing services while seeking equity”.
Roheena Anand, Executive Director of Global Publishing Development & Sales at PLOS, added: "With this updated release, we're delivering on our promise to create a practical tool that reflects diverse stakeholder perspectives. The refinements made based on community feedback have strengthened the tool's ability to assess equity across different publishing models and arrangements."
Anna Vernon, Head of Research Licensing at Jisc, commented: "We've been using the “How Equitable Is It?” tool to understand how agreements can broaden participation in scholarly publishing. The clearer framework of the updated version will further allow institutions to make more nuanced assessments of how their resources can best support equitable knowledge dissemination."
How the tool works
Based on the above-mentioned criteria, the “How Equitable Is It?” tool prompts users to consider to what extent the model (and associated funding flow) they are assessing facilitates (or restricts) equitable participation in knowledge sharing. Users score each criterion on a scale from "least equitable" to "most equitable," receiving an overall equity score upon completion, along with a summary of their responses.
Rather than prescribing outcomes, the tool empowers users to exercise their judgment in rating models against equitable criteria, with no pre-populated data shaping evaluations.
The "How Equitable Is It?" tool is available at https://coalitions.typeform.com/Equity-Tool. A detailed description of the revised criteria and their definitions can be accessed at: Framework_criteria_definitions.pdf
Future development
The Working Group remains committed to the ongoing development of the tool, with plans to gather implementation case studies and establish a community of practice around equity assessment in scholarly communication. Users of the tool are encouraged to share their experiences at info@coalition-s.org. The Group will review this feedback and publish annual updates as appropriate.
Contact information
Maria Karatzia
cOAlition S, Communication Officer
E-mail: maria.karatzia@coalition-s.org
David Knutson
Head of Communications, PLOS
dknutson@plos.org
END
Updated version of the "How Equitable Is It?" tool for assessing equity in scholarly communication models
2025-05-14
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
McGill researchers lead project to reform youth mental health care in Canada
2025-05-14
New data from a national project led by McGill University researchers shows that redesigning youth mental health services can significantly cut wait times and connect more young people to care.
The ACCESS Open Minds project was launched in 2014 to address gaps in access to quality mental health care, especially for Indigenous, remote and underserved communities. Findings published in Jama Psychiatry provide the first assessment of the program’s outcomes across Canada.
“We focused on transforming existing programs in clinics, schools and youth centres to make them more accessible, youth-friendly and culturally appropriate,” said ...
ESMT Berlin research shows private ownership boosts hospital performance
2025-05-14
New research by ESMT Berlin and the Halle Institute for Economic Research (IWH) shows that private equity (PE) acquisitions lead to substantial operational efficiency gains in hospitals, challenging common public concerns. The study reveals that hospitals acquired by PE firms significantly reduce costs and administrative staff without increasing closure rates or harming patient care.
The paper “Private Equity in the Hospital Industry” is co-authored by Merih Sevilir (ESMT and Halle Institute for Economic Research), Janet Gao (McDonough School of Business, Georgetown), and Yongseok Kim (Freeman School of Business, ...
The risk of death or complications from broken heart syndrome was high from 2016 to 2020
2025-05-14
Research Highlights:
The risk of death or complications from the stress-related heart condition associated with stressful events, such as the death of a loved one — called Takotsubo cardiomyopathy or broken heart syndrome — was high and unchanged from 2016 to 2020, according to data from a national study that included nearly 200,000 U.S. adults.
Takotsubo cardiomyopathy was found to be more common in women in this analysis. However, men with the condition were twice as likely to die.
The rate of complications, such as heart failure, atrial fibrillation, ...
Does adapting to a warmer climate have drawbacks?
2025-05-14
Global warming is already very tough for animals in the wild, but it may be toughest for creatures like fish, whose body temperatures are controlled by the water temperatures around them.
Fish have to evolve to handle higher water temperatures, if they can’t move to areas with colder water. But what if adapting to warmer water has other unwanted consequences?
In a new publication in Nature Climate Change, researchers looked at zebrafish that they had specially bred over 7 generations to tolerate ...
Team develops digital lab for data- and robot-driven materials science
2025-05-14
Researchers at the University of Tokyo and their collaborators have developed a digital laboratory system that fully automates the material synthesis and the structural and physical property evaluation of thin-film samples. With the digital laboratory, or dLab, the team can autonomously synthesize thin-film samples and measure their material properties. The system demonstrates advanced automatic and autonomous material synthesis for data- and robot-driven materials science.
The current research is published in the journal Digital Discovery.
Machine learning, robotics and data are deemed vital to the discovery of ...
Got data? Breastfeeding device measures babies’ milk intake in real time
2025-05-14
While breastfeeding has many benefits for a mother and her baby, it has one major drawback: It’s incredibly difficult to know how much milk the baby is consuming.
To take the guesswork out of breastfeeding, an interdisciplinary team of engineers, neonatologists and pediatricians at Northwestern University has developed a new wearable device that can provide clinical-grade, continuous monitoring of breast milk consumption.
The unobtrusive device softly and comfortably wraps around the breast ...
Novel technology enables better understanding of complex biological samples
2025-05-14
Osaka, Japan – Tissues consist of a heterogenous mixture of different cell types, complicating our understanding of their biological functions and studies of disease. Now, a multi-institutional team led by The University of Osaka has developed and provided proof-of-concept of a new technology to visualize the distribution of components within a single cell, paving the way for a much greater understanding of disease in complex biological samples.
t-SPESI (tapping-mode scanning probe electrospray ionization) is a technique that allows analysis of the spatial layout of molecules in a sample. Multiple micro-samples of different regions of ...
Autistic people communicate just as effectively as others, study finds
2025-05-14
There is no significant difference in the effectiveness of how autistic and non-autistic people communicate, according to a new study, challenging the stereotype that autistic people struggle to connect with others.
The findings suggest that social difficulties often faced by autistic people are more about differences in how autistic and non-autistic people communicate, rather than a lack of social ability in autistic individuals, experts say.
Researchers hope the results of the study will help reduce the stigma surrounding autism, and lead to more effective ...
Alaska: Ancient cave sediments provide new climate clues
2025-05-14
Paul Wilcox, a geologist at the University of Innsbruck, has discovered the first land-based evidence of meltwater pulses from the Cordilleran Ice Sheet during the last ice age about 20,000 years ago. The age of the cave sediments was constrained via optical dating techniques, which is crucial to help piece together the sequence of climate events leading to a warming planet. The results were published in the journal Nature Geoscience.
Around 20,000 years ago, the Cordilleran Ice Sheet in western North America reached its maximum extent. This was followed by warming climate conditions, causing the ice-sheet to melt. While it is generally accepted ...
Adult-onset type 1 diabetes increases risk of cardiovascular disease and death
2025-05-14
A new study in the European Heart Journal shows that people who develop type 1 diabetes in adulthood have an increased risk of cardiovascular disease and death, and that those diagnosed later in life do not have a better prognosis than those diagnosed earlier. The study, conducted by researchers at Karolinska Institutet in Sweden, points to smoking, poor glucose control and obesity as the main risk factors.
Type 1 diabetes used to be called childhood diabetes but can start at any time during life. However, research on adult-onset type 1 diabetes is limited. The researchers behind the current study wanted to investigate the ...