(Press-News.org) Americans perceive small juries of content experts as the most legitimate moderators of potentially misleading content on social media, according to a survey, but perceive large, nationally representative or politically balanced juries with minimum knowledge qualifications as comparably legitimate. Social media content moderation policies tend to attract criticism, with some calling for more aggressive removal of harmful and misleading content and others decrying moderation as censorship and accusing expert moderators of being politically biased. Less clear is what the general public would like to see in terms of content moderation. Cameron Martel and colleagues surveyed 3,000 US residents through the survey platform YouGov in the summer of 2023. Each respondent was asked to assess the legitimacy of moderators when they disagreed with their decision about whether a piece of content was harmfully misleading. The nine options presented to respondents included moderation juries composed of professional fact-checkers, professional journalists, or domain experts, as well as juries composed of randomly selected nationally representative non-experts, randomly selected users of the social platform, a politically balanced group of non-experts, a coin flip, the head of the social media company, or a computer algorithm. All expert juries were fixed at a size of 3 members while layperson juries were randomized as sizes of 3 members, 30 members, or 3,000 members. Layperson juries also varied on the level of required qualifications for participation (e.g., minimum news knowledge). Some juries were described as evaluating content independently while others were described as deciding through group discussion. Overall, participants preferred domain experts over non-experts or algorithms. However, large nationally representative or politically balanced juries with some minimal level of qualifications that were described as making decisions through discussion were seen just as favorably as small juries of independent experts. Republicans perceived experts as less legitimate compared to Democrats, but still preferred experts to non-experts when layperson juries were small and had no knowledge qualifications. Respondents were unenthusiastic about the head of social media companies making moderation decisions, rating this option as about as attractive as a coin flip. According to the authors, the results have practical implications for social media platforms and content moderation system regulators who wish to design systems that users will trust.
END
Public opinion on who should do content moderation
2025-05-20
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Accounting for marine ecosystems in China promises greater environmental and economic sustainability
2025-05-20
A Perspective proposes a pathway to improvements in sustainability of marine ecosystems and resources in China. Based on environmental accounting used in China’s terrestrial ecosystems, the approach would implement policy and governance to ensure accountability for sustainable use of marine systems. Laurence J. McCook and colleagues argue that the ecosystem goods and services provided to the nation by oceans and coastal ecosystems—including seagrass beds, salt marshes, coral reefs, and mangrove forests—are ...
Diabetes drug gives hope for new treatment for prostate cancer
2025-05-20
A drug used to treat type 2 diabetes may also be effective in slowing the progression of prostate cancer. This is shown by an international study in which researchers at Umeå University, Sweden, have participated. The researchers have found that drugs that regulate a particular protein have a key role in reducing prostate cancer recurrence among diabetic patients.
"This is a significant discovery. For the first time, we have clinical observations showing that prostate cancer patients with diabetes who received drugs targeting the protein remained relapse-free during the period we followed them," ...
New US dementia cases in decline, but continued rise in people living with the condition
2025-05-20
New cases of dementia in the United States declined from 2015 to 2021, but the number of people living with the condition continued to rise due to population ageing, with nearly 2.9 million traditional Medicare beneficiaries (around 12%) living with a dementia diagnosis in 2021, finds a study published by The BMJ today.
What’s more, a greater burden of dementia was seen in marginalized and low resource communities, highlighting the importance of policy approaches to promote equitable dementia care, say the ...
Doctors group asks National Institutes of Health to investigate Arizona State University for research misconduct
2025-05-20
TEMPE, Ariz. — The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine filed a complaint with the National Institutes of Health’s Office of Laboratory Animal Welfare today, May 19, 2025, asking for an investigation of Arizona State University’s use of animals to study the effects of dietary supplements on adults with Down syndrome.
“Arizona State University cannot justify its use of mice to study a common nutrient that could be easily and ethically studied in consenting human volunteers,” the complaint says. “These uses of animals run afoul of the ...
St. Jude scientist Charles Mullighan elected to the Royal Society of London
2025-05-20
St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital leukemia researcher Charles G. Mullighan, MBBS (Hons), MSc, MD, senior deputy director of the St. Jude Comprehensive Cancer Center, has been elected as a Fellow of the Royal Society of London, the oldest scientific academy in continuous existence.
Mullighan was selected to join the Royal Society for his trailblazing contributions to genomic research, which have advanced the understanding, diagnosis and treatment of acute leukemia, notably childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia ...
1.5°C Paris Climate Agreement target too high for polar ice sheets and sea level rise
2025-05-20
Efforts to limit the global temperature increase to 1.5°C under the Paris Climate Agreement may not go far enough to save the world’s ice sheets, according to a new study.
Research led by Durham University, UK, suggests the target should instead be closer to 1°C to avoid significant losses from the polar ice sheets and prevent a further acceleration in sea level rise.
The team reviewed a wealth of evidence to examine the effect that the 1.5°C target would have on the ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctica, which together store enough ice to raise global sea levels by almost 65 metres.
The mass of ice lost from these ice ...
Scientists discover potential new targets for Alzheimer’s drugs
2025-05-20
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- By combining information from many large datasets, MIT researchers have identified several new potential targets for treating or preventing Alzheimer’s disease.
The study revealed genes and cellular pathways that haven’t been linked to Alzheimer’s before, including one involved in DNA repair. Identifying new drug targets is critical because many of the Alzheimer’s drugs that have been developed to this point haven’t been as successful as hoped.
Working with researchers at Harvard Medical School, the team used data from humans and fruit flies to identify cellular pathways linked to neurodegeneration. ...
Scientists develop new treatment with potential to tackle commonest form of childhood cancer
2025-05-20
A combination of two drugs could improve outcomes and reduce the need for toxic chemotherapy for B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (B-ALL), the commonest cancer in childhood and one that can be particularly difficult to treat in older patients, according to Cambridge scientists.
Although the research has so far only been conducted in cell lines and mice, the team is seeking funding to begin clinical trials in patients shortly.
More than 500 people a year in the UK are diagnosed with B-ALL, many of whom are children, where it makes up 40% of all ...
Technique rapidly measures cells’ density, reflecting health and developmental state
2025-05-20
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Measuring the density of a cell can reveal a great deal about the cell’s state. As cells proliferate, differentiate, or undergo cell death, they may gain or lose water and other molecules, which is revealed by changes in density.
Tracking these tiny changes in cells’ physical state is difficult to do at a large scale, especially with single-cell resolution, but a team of MIT researchers has now found a way to measure cell density quickly and accurately — measuring up to 30,000 cells in a single hour.
The researchers also showed that density ...
Mask users can now breathe easy on two counts
2025-05-20
Tokyo, Japan—The COVID-19 pandemic increased public awareness of the importance of mask use for personal protection. However, when the mesh size of mask fabrics is small enough to capture viruses, which are usually around one hundred nanometers in size, the fabric typically also restricts air flow, resulting in user discomfort. But now, researchers from Japan have found a way to avoid this.
In a study published this month in Materials Advances, researchers from the Institute of Industrial Science, The University of Tokyo have overcome this bottleneck and developed a filter capable of capturing nanoparticles such ...