PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Why AI can’t understand a flower the way humans do

AI needs to touch, feel and smell to have a sense of the world

2025-06-04
(Press-News.org) Embargoed until 5:00 a.m. ET, Wednesday June 4, 2025

Even with all its training and computer power, an artificial intelligence (AI) tool like ChatGPT can’t represent the concept of a flower the way a human does, according to a new study.

 

That’s because the large language models (LLMs) that power AI assistants are based usually on language alone, and sometimes with images.

 

“A large language model can’t smell a rose, touch the petals of a daisy or walk through a field of wildflowers,” said Qihui Xu, lead author of the study and postdoctoral researcher in psychology at The Ohio State University.

 

“Without those sensory and motor experiences, it can’t truly represent what a flower is in all its richness. The same is true of some other human concepts.”

 

The study was published this week in the journal Nature Human Behaviour.

 

Xu said the findings have implications for how AI and humans relate to each other.

 

“If AI construes the world in fundamentally different way from humans, it could affect how it interacts with us,” she said.

 

Xu and her colleagues compared humans and LLMs in their knowledge representation of 4,442 words – everything from “flower” and “hoof” to “humorous” and “swing.”

 

They compared the similarity of representations between humans and two state-of-the-art LLM families from OpenAI (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) and Google (PaLM and Gemini).

 

Humans and LLMs were tested on two measures.  One, called the Glasgow Norms, ask for ratings of words on nine dimensions, such as arousal, concreteness and imageability. For example, the measure asks for ratings of how emotionally arousing a flower is, and how much one can mentally visualize a flower (or how imageable it is).

 

The other measure, called Lancaster Norms, examined how concepts of words are related to sensory information (such as touch, hearing, smell, vision) and motor information, which are involved with actions – such as what humans do through contacts with the mouth, hand, arm and torso.

 

For example, the measure asks for ratings on how much one experiences flowers by smelling, and how much one experiences flowers using actions from the torso.

 

The goal was to see how the LLMs and humans were aligned in their ratings of the words. In one analysis, the researchers examined how much humans and AI were correlated on concepts.  For example, do the LLMs and humans agree that some concepts have higher emotional arousal than others?

 

In a second analysis, researchers investigated how humans compared to LLMs on deciding how different dimensions may jointly contribute to a word’s overall conceptual representation and how different words are interconnected.

 

For example, the concepts of pasta and roses might both receive high ratings for how much they involve the sense of smell. However, pasta is considered more similar to noodles than to roses – at least for humans – not just because of its smell, but also its visual appearance and taste.

 

Overall, the LLMs did very well compared to humans in representing words that didn’t have any connection to the senses and to motor actions. But when it came to words that have connections to things we see, taste or interact with using our body, that’s where AI failed to capture human concepts.

 

“From the intense aroma of a flower, the vivid silky touch when we caress petals, to the profound joy evoked, human representation of ‘flower’ binds these diverse experiences and interactions into a coherent category,” the researchers say in the paper.

 

The issue is that most LLMs are dependent on language, and “language by itself can’t fully recover conceptual representation in all its richness,” Xu said.

 

Even though LLMs can approximate some human concepts, particularly when they don’t involve senses or motor actions, this kind of learning is not efficient.

 

“They obtain what they know by consuming vast amounts of text – orders of magnitude larger than what a human is exposed to in their entire lifetimes – and still can’t quite capture some concepts the way humans do,” Xu said.

 

“The human experience is far richer than words alone can hold.”

 

But Xu noted that LLMs are continually improving and it’s likely they will get better at capturing human concepts. The study did find that LLMs that are trained with images as well as text did do better than text-only models in representing concepts related to vision.

 

And when future LLMs are augmented with sensor data and robotics, they may be able to actively make inferences about and act upon the physical world, she said.

 

Co-authors on the study were Yingying Peng, Ping Li and Minghua Wu of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University; Samuel Nastase of Princeton University; and Martin Chodorow of the City University of New York.

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Top scientists call for permanent ban on high seas exploitation

2025-06-04
Extractive activity in international waters - including fishing, seabed mining, and oil and gas exploitation - should be banned forever, according to top scientists. The high seas, the vast international waters beyond national jurisdiction, remain largely unprotected and are increasingly threatened. Writing in the journal Nature, Professor Callum Roberts and co-authors argue that stopping all extractive activity in international waters would prevent irreversible damage to marine biodiversity, the climate, and ocean equity. This would ...

A new blood-based epigenetic clock for aging focuses on intrinsic capacity

2025-06-04
A team of international researchers has developed a new biological age “clock” that estimates how well someone is aging, not just how “old” they or their various organs might be. The IC Clock, which is described in a study in Nature Aging, measures intrinsic capacity (IC), the sum of six key functions that determine healthy aging: mobility, cognition, mental health, vision, hearing and nutrition/vitality. “Maintaining function during the aging process is what matters to older adults. Function should inform medical care instead of focusing on getting patients to some disease-free state,” said senior ...

Creating ice layer by layer: the secret mechanisms of ice formation revealed

2025-06-04
Tokyo, Japan – Water is everywhere and comes in many forms: snow, sleet, hail, hoarfrost… However, despite water being so commonplace, scientists still do not fully understand the predominant physical process that occurs when water transforms from liquid to solid. Now, in an article recently published in the Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, researchers from the Institute of Industrial Science, The University of Tokyo, have carried out a series of molecular-scale simulations to uncover why ice forms ...

Life from oceans to savannas explained with one single rule

2025-06-04
A simple rule that seems to govern how life is organised on Earth is described in a new study published today (Wednesday, 4 June) in Nature Ecology & Evolution. The research team led, by Umeå University and involving the University of Reading, believe this rule helps explain why species are spread the way they are across the planet. The discovery will help to understand life on Earth – including how ecosystems respond to global environmental changes. The rule is simple: in every region on Earth, most species cluster together in small 'hotspot' areas, then gradually spread outward with fewer and fewer species able to survive farther away from these ...

From mixed to matched: new marker pinpoints therapeutically relevant stem cell–derived islets

2025-06-04
Over 500 million people worldwide suffer from diabetes—a disease that contributes to major complications such as stroke, kidney failure, cancer, and Alzheimer’s disease. At the heart of this condition lies the dysfunction of pancreatic islets, the mini-organs called organoids responsible for regulating blood sugar, in both autoimmune type 1 diabetes and stress-induced type 2 diabetes. Replacing these damaged islets with lab-grown, functional islets represents a promising therapeutic strategy. However, the lack of reliable markers to identify truly functional, stem cell–derived islets has hindered the consistent production needed for clinical application. In ...

A giant planet around a tiny star: A discovery that challenges planet formation theories

2025-06-04
The host star, TOI-6894, is a red dwarf with only 20% the mass of the Sun, typical of the most common stars in our galaxy. Until now, such low-mass stars were not thought capable of forming or retaining giant planets. But as published today in Nature Astronomy, the unmistakable signature of a giant planet — TOI-6894b — has been detected in orbit around this tiny star. This exceptional system was first identified in data from NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS), as part of a large search for giant planets around small stars, led by Dr. Edward Bryant from UCL’s ...

One single rule helps explain life from ocean depths to open savannas

2025-06-04
A new study published in Nature Ecology & Evolution has found a simple rule that seems to govern how life is organised on Earth. The researchers believe this rule helps explain why species are spread the way they are across the planet. The discovery will help to understand life on Earth – including how ecosystems respond to global environmental changes. At first glance, Earth seems like a collection of wildly different worlds. Each region has its own species and environmental conditions. Yet, beneath this variety, ...

Can early exposure to dogs lessen genetic susceptibility to eczema?

2025-06-04
New research published in Allergy indicates that certain environmental exposures may affect a child’s risk of developing atopic eczema, a condition characterized by dry, itchy, and inflamed skin. In other words, although some people may be genetically predisposed to eczema, certain environmental factors may increase or decrease that risk. For the study, investigators analyzed data from 16 European studies to test for interactions between the 24 most significant eczema-associated genetic variants and 18 early-life environmental factors. They applied their findings to an additional 10 studies and used lab modelling tests to assess their results. The ...

Are stress and resilience factors among gender and sexual minority adolescents related to sleep health?

2025-06-04
New research in the Journal of Adolescence found that among LGBTQ+ adolescents in the United States, those who experienced more violence because of their identity or more bullying because of their gender expression had more trouble falling asleep, whereas those who experienced more familial warmth had less trouble falling asleep. Gender-based victimization, family rejection, absence of a gender-sexuality alliance, and not having a trusted adult at school were also related to trouble falling asleep for cisgender sexual minority youth (who identify with the gender they were assigned at birth but who are not heterosexual). For gender minority youth, being able to use the restroom that matched ...

How does a common plant pathogen affect urban trees, and how should it be managed?

2025-06-04
Trees are important to the environmental health of cities through their capacity to improve air quality, provide cooling via shade and transpiration, and foster natural beauty. New research in Plant-Environment Interactions reveals how the widespread plant pathogen Phytophthora affects urban trees, specifically Common Lime trees. Using numerous tree sensors, investigators found that infected trees exhibited reduced water use and stem growth compared with healthy trees, but some still managed to maintain ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Researchers reveal key differences in STING inhibition between humans and mice

Researchers generate lung cells from mouse fibroblasts in just 7 to 10 days

Prizewinner’s research reveals how immune responses to friendly skin microbiota could pave way for novel vaccination responses

Old aerial photos give scientists a new tool to predict sea level rise

20 million for courageous research at ISTA

Ships trigger high and unexpected emissions of the greenhouse gas methane

Optimizing laser irradiation: An in-silico meta-analysis of skin discoloration treatment

Climate crisis could force wild vanilla plants and pollinating insects apart, threatening global supply

Teens report spending 21% of each driving trip looking at their phone

Study explores the ‘social norms’ of distracted driving among teens

Diver-operated microscope brings hidden coral biology into focus

Enhancing the “feel-good” factor of urban vegetation using AI and street view images

A single genetic mutation may have made humans more vulnerable to cancer than chimpanzees

Innovative nanocomposite hydrogel shows promise for cartilage regeneration in osteoarthritis treatment

2025 Guangci Laboratory Medicine Innovation and Development Conference

LabMed Discovery is included in the ICI World Journals database

LabMed Discovery is included in the China Open Access Journal (COAJ) database

Vaccination support program reduces pneumonia-related mortality by 25 percent among the elderly

Over decades, a healthy lifestyle outperforms metformin in preventing onset of Type 2 diabetes

Mental health disorders, malaria, and heart disease most affected by covid pandemic

Green transition will boost UK productivity

Billions voted in 2024, but major new report exposes cracks in global democracy

Researchers find “forever chemicals” impact the developing male brain

Quantum leap in precision sensing across technologies

Upgrading biocrude oil into sustainable aviation fuel using zeolite-supported iron-molybdenum carbide nanocatalysts

For effective science communication, ‘just the facts’ isn’t good enough

RT-EZ: A golden gate assembly toolkit for streamlined genetic engineering of rhodotorula toruloides

Stem Cell Reports announces five new early career editors

Support networks may be the missing link for college students who seek help for excessive drinking

The New England Journal of Medicine shines spotlight on forensic pathology

[Press-News.org] Why AI can’t understand a flower the way humans do
AI needs to touch, feel and smell to have a sense of the world