PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Why common climate messaging often backfires – and how to fix it

A new study finds many Americans misjudge the relative climate impact of dozens of behaviors. Interventions focused solely on personal behavior can reduce willingness to engage in collective climate action.

2025-06-10
(Press-News.org) In brief:

Climate behavior gap: Most Americans overrate the climate impact of actions like recycling and underrate high-impact choices like skipping long flights or eating less meat, a new study finds.

Spillover risk: Interventions that focus only on personal behavior can reduce willingness to engage in collective climate action, such as voting or protesting.

What works: Active learning boosts climate literacy and commitment to impactful lifestyle changes – but must be paired with strategies that also support collective action.

Many Americans misjudge which personal behaviors have the biggest impact on carbon emissions, researchers have found. But efforts to improve climate literacy that focus too narrowly on individual actions may inadvertently dampen public support for collective solutions.

The findings, published June 9 in PNAS Nexus, indicate that people tended to overestimate the climate benefits of familiar actions like recycling and switching light bulbs, while underestimating the impact of avoiding one long flight a year or eating less beef.

“People are very misinformed around how their actions can translate into actual impact in terms of reducing carbon,” said senior study author Madalina Vlasceanu, an assistant professor of environmental social sciences in the Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability. “We think, ‘I have to recycle this and it will help the planet.’ It’s less likely you will hear that if you fly less, that’s the best you can possibly do, lifestyle-wise.”

The results are based on a study of nearly 4,000 people in the U.S. recruited to participate in an online survey. Participants in an “active learning” group were asked to rate the relative effectiveness of 21 different individual-level behaviors on a sliding scale and received immediate feedback. “We compared the actions to each other – not tons of carbon. That’s something nobody understands. It’s so abstract, you’ll forget it immediately,” Vlasceanu said.

A second group of participants passively received information about the relative mitigation potential of the same behaviors without the prediction step. In the control group, participants received no information. Participants in all groups rated their commitment to the 21 individual behaviors and five additional system-level behaviors, such as voting for pro-climate candidates, as well as the ease of adopting these behaviors. 

Unintended consequences After the interventions, people in both the active learning and passive groups expressed greater commitment to high-impact lifestyle changes like eating lower-carbon meats such as poultry. “Participants found this can be really easy to do, and has one of the highest impacts that has been actually documented,” Vlasceanu said. Those who began the exercise with the greatest misperceptions showed the largest shifts in commitments.

But the interventions also produced a worrying side effect. When the content focused solely on personal behaviors, participants became less likely to commit to climate-related collective actions like voting or joining public demonstrations.

“These interventions also decreased commitment to collective action, where you’re really trying to influence some sort of policy, and this is a problem,” Vlasceanu said. 

Personal vs. public action The findings point to a persistent tension in climate communication efforts: how to encourage effective individual behavior without undermining broader societal engagement. “Now we have to go back and understand how we would better design these interventions so we don’t have those negative spillovers,” she said.

Although collective actions are harder to quantify in terms of carbon impact, one 2021 analysis estimated that a single vote in a recent national election in Canada could be more than 20 times as effective as skipping a long flight – one of the most impactful lifestyle changes scientists have evaluated.

“If you extrapolate from that, you can conclude that all the collective actions are way more effective than all the lifestyle changes you can do, although this still remains to be empirically quantified,” Vlasceanu said.

The study also highlighted a difference in what motivates people to act in their personal lives versus in public. “People will engage in lifestyle changes when they think it’s easy to do. It’s less important to them if it’s effective,” she said. “For collective action, it is more important to people that the action they engage in will actually result in a meaningful change.”

Vlasceanu and co-authors including Danielle Goldwert of New York University collected data in early 2024, with participants averaging 40 years old. Roughly half identified as Democrats, 22% as Republicans, and 26% as independent or other. “Democrats were more sensitive to incorporating what they learned into their behaviors compared to Republicans,” Vlasceanu said.

Insights about the human mind She emphasized that the goal of the research was not advocacy but discovery. “Our job as academics is not to be activists or fight for a particular cause,” she said. “These are research questions we scientifically care about that uncover essential processes about the human mind.”

The work is part of a broader research program investigating how scalable, low-cost interventions can affect behavior. “We pick the context in which we apply these investigations such that they are societally relevant,” Vlasceanu said. 

Climate change offers a unique learning opportunity, she said, because it can only be solved through choices and changes involving large numbers of people working together. “If we understand how the mind works in this context, then we can document ways in which practitioners, policymakers – people whose job it is to address this crisis – can most effectively address it,” she said. 

Future experiments may compare literacy-based strategies with emotional appeals or personal storytelling to determine which approaches most effectively boost both individual and collective engagement.

“In order to meaningfully address climate change, experts have agreed that we will need lifestyle change and collective action. Both of these have to work together,” Vlasceanu said. “This is a critical part of the pathway to net zero.”

This research was supported by a National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship awarded to Danielle Goldwert. END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

New study offers detailed look at winter flooding in California’s central valley

2025-06-10
California’s Central Valley — one of the nation's most critical agricultural regions and home to over 1.3 million people — is prone to flooding. Mapping the extent of winter floods has been challenging for experts, however, because clouds can obscure the view of satellites. Recent efforts to improve satellite flood mapping have been incorporated into a new study that offers insight into where winter flooding is occurring and inform how floodwaters can be used to replenish depleted aquifers.  The research, published June 4 in ...

Rice University students win top prize in global design contest with cutting-edge haptic wristband

2025-06-10
Rice University student engineers have earned top international honors for a novel device that could redefine how humans interact with virtual environments. Their project, a wearable haptic wristband, claimed first place in the IEEE Circuits and Systems Society (CASS) Student Design Competition held in London May 27. The team, known as WRIST (short for Wearable Radial Interface for Sensory hapTic feedback),includes students from mechanical engineering and electrical and computer engineering. Their winning ...

A repurposed FDA-approved drug shows promise in killing antibiotic resistant bacteria

2025-06-10
A new study from Emory University addresses the growing global crisis of antibiotic-resistant infections. Many of these drug-resistant bacteria are spread through hospitals, and there are few antibiotics available for treatment. The study, published in PNAS, looks at a particular bacterium called Acinetobacter baumannii, which is highly infectious, spread mostly in hospitals and typically infects immunocompromised patients. The researchers employed an entirely new strategy to identify weaknesses specific to resistant bacteria and then target these weaknesses with an alternate drug. They found that fendiline, a drug that acts as a calcium channel blocker and ...

How youth teach environmental educators through intergenerational learning

2025-06-10
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — How educators acquire and implement learnings from their students can play a critical role in environmental education, according to a new study from researchers in the Penn State Department of Recreation, Park, and Tourism Management. The researchers found a role reversal between teachers and students, as environmental educators reported improvement in teaching and leadership skills after learning from the existing knowledge and experiences of students in an environmental education program, demonstrating ...

Gilles Martin identifies neurons associated with the suppression of binge drinking

2025-06-10
Among the billions of neurons in the brain, fewer than 500 are responsible for suppressing binge drinking, according to new research by Gilles E. Martin, PhD, associate professor of neurobiology. Published in Nature Neuroscience, these findings provide insights into binge drinking behavior and alcohol dependency that may lead to new therapeutic targets. “It’s really hard to comprehend how only a few neurons can have such a profound effect on behavior,” said Dr Martin, a member of the Brudnick Neuropsychiatric Research Institute at UMass Chan. “This is exciting because we are starting to understand how only a handful of cells are involved in very specific behaviors. ...

Study provides evidence pigs were domesticated from wild boars in South China

2025-06-10
Pigs have long been known, sometimes celebrated, as among the most intelligent of farm animals. Now, a new Dartmouth-led study provides evidence that pigs were first domesticated from wild boars in South China approximately 8,000 years ago. China has long been considered one of the locations for original pig domestication but tracking the initial process has always been challenging. The study is the first to find that pigs were eating humans' cooked foods and waste. The results are reported in the Proceedings of the National Academy ...

Severe neonatal morbidity and all-cause and cause-specific mortality through infancy and late adolescence

2025-06-10
About The Study: Findings from this cohort study suggest that severe neonatal morbidity may be a significant risk factor for childhood mortality. Efforts to prevent severe neonatal morbidity, as well as early identification and long-term follow-up care, may help further reduce mortality.  Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Hillary Graham, MS, email hillary.graham@ki.se. To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website at this link https://media.jamanetwork.com/ (doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2025.1873) Editor’s Note: Please ...

Newborns with health problems are at higher risk of dying into adolescence

2025-06-10
Infants who survive serious health problems in the first few weeks of life have a higher risk of dying during childhood and adolescence compared to children who were healthy as newborns. This is according to a new study from Karolinska Institutet published in the journal JAMA Pediatrics. The study covers over two million babies born in Sweden between 2002 and 2021, about 49,000 (2.4 per cent) of whom had serious health problems in the neonatal period, such as respiratory problems, neurological disorders or severe infections, but survived the first four weeks ...

Announcement of NIMS Award 2025 winners

2025-06-10
The three recipients were recognized for their instrumental roles in developing the perovskite solar cell and for taking key steps toward its practical application. This year’s selection focused on the field of environmental and energy materials, with the aim of honoring exceptional achievements pertaining to “energy-related materials and technologies that pave the way toward a sustainable society”. In addition to pioneering the research field of perovskite solar cells, the awardees were responsible for incorporating a critical element, the solid-state hole transport layer, which led to a dramatic improvement of the cell’s stability and ...

Methane leaks from dormant oil and gas wells in Canada are seven times worse than thought, McGill study suggests

2025-06-10
Methane emissions from Canada’s non-producing oil and gas wells appear to be seven times higher than government estimates, according to a new study led by researchers at McGill University. The findings spotlight a major gap in the country’s official greenhouse gas inventory and raise urgent questions about how methane leaks are monitored, reported and managed. “Non-producing wells are one of the most uncertain sources of methane emissions in Canada,” said Mary Kang, Associate Professor of Civil Engineering at McGill ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

From blood sugar to brain relief: GLP-1 therapy slashes migraine frequency

Variability in heart rate during sleep may reveal early signs of stroke, depression or cognitive dysfunction, new study shows

New method to study catalysts could lead to better batteries

Current Molecular Pharmacology impact factor rises to 2.9, achieving Q2 ranking in the Pharmacology & Pharmacy category in 2024 JCR

More time with loved ones for cancer patients spared radiation treatment

New methods speed diagnosis of rare genetic disease

Genetics of cardiomyopathy risk in cancer survivors differ by age of onset

Autism inpatient collection releases genetic, phenotypic data for more than 1,500 children with autism

Targeting fusion protein’s role in childhood leukemia produces striking results

Clear understanding of social connections propels strivers up the social ladder

New research reveals why acute and chronic pain are so different – and what might make pain last

Stable cooling fostered life, rapid warming brought death: scientists use high-resolution fusuline data reveal evolutionary responses to cooling and warming

New research casts doubt on ancient drying of northern Africa’s climate

Study identifies umbilical cord blood biomarkers of early onset sepsis in preterm newborns

AI development: seeking consistency in logical structures

Want better sleep for your tween? Start with their screens

Cancer burden in neighborhoods with greater racial diversity and environmental burden

Alzheimer disease in breast cancer survivors

New method revolutionizes beta-blocker production process

Mechanism behind life-threatening cancer drug side-effect revealed

Weighted vests might help older adults meet weight loss goals, but solution for corresponding bone loss still elusive

Scientists find new way to predict how bowel cancer drugs will stop working – paving the way for smarter treatments

Breast cancer patients’ microbiome may hold key to avoiding damaging heart side-effects of cancer therapies

Exercise-induced protein revives aging muscles and bones

American College of Cardiology issues guidance on weight management drugs

Understanding the effect of bedding on thermal insulation during sleep

Cosmic signal from the very early universe will help astronomers detect the first stars

With AI, researchers find increasing immune evasion in H5N1

Study finds hidden effects of wildfires on water systems

Airborne fungal spores may help predict COVID-19 & flu surges

[Press-News.org] Why common climate messaging often backfires – and how to fix it
A new study finds many Americans misjudge the relative climate impact of dozens of behaviors. Interventions focused solely on personal behavior can reduce willingness to engage in collective climate action.