(Press-News.org) New commentary published in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine warns that current risk-based regulatory approaches to Artificial Intelligence (AI) in healthcare fall short in protecting patients, potentially leading to over- and undertreatment as well as discrimination against patient groups.
The authors found that while AI and machine learning systems can enhance clinical accuracy, concerns remain over their inherent inaccuracy, opacity, and potential for bias which are not adequately addressed by the current regulatory efforts introduced by the European Union’s AI Act.
Passed in 2025, the AI Act categorises medical AI as "high risk" and introduces strict controls on providers and deployers. But the authors argue this risk-based framework overlooks three critical issues: individual patient preferences, systemic and long-term effects of AI implementation, and the disempowerment of patients in regulatory processes.
“Patients have different values when it comes to accuracy, bias, or the role AI plays in their care,” said lead author Thomas Ploug, Professor of Data and AI Ethics at Aalborg University, Denmark. “Regulation must move beyond system-level safety and account for individual rights and participation.”
The authors call for the introduction of patient rights relating to AI-generated diagnosis or treatment planning, including the right to:
request an explanation;
give or withdraw consent;
seek a second opinion; and
refuse diagnosis or screening based on publicly available data without consent.
They warn that without urgent engagement from healthcare stakeholders - including clinicians, regulators, and patient groups - these rights risk being left behind in the rapid evolution of AI in healthcare.
“AI is transforming healthcare, but it must not do so at the expense of patient autonomy and trust,” said Professor Ploug. “It is time to define the rights that will protect and empower patients in an AI-driven health system.”
END
AI in healthcare needs patient-centred regulation to avoid discrimination – new commentary
2025-06-26
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
A good soak in a hot tub might beat a sauna for health benefits
2025-06-25
Hot tubs and saunas can both soothe aching muscles and provide welcome warmth, but hot tubs might offer greater health benefits.
That’s the takeaway from a new study done by researchers in the Bowerman Sports Science Center at the University of Oregon, which compared the physiological effects of soaking in a hot tub to sitting in a traditional dry heat sauna or a more modern far-infrared sauna.
By raising core body temperatures, soaking in hot water can help lower blood pressure, stimulate the immune system and, over time, improve the body’s ...
Surgery plus speech therapy linked to improved language after stroke
2025-06-25
Combining neck surgery with intensive speech therapy is associated with greater improvements in a person's ability to communicate after a stroke than intensive speech therapy alone, finds a clinical trial published by The BMJ today.
The results show improvements immediately after surgery without any long-term severe adverse events or lasting discomfort, as well as reported improvements in quality of life and post-stoke depression over six months.
Stroke is the most common cause of aphasia (problems with communication, including speaking, understanding others, reading and writing). More than 60% of patients are ...
GP performance pay fails to drive lasting changes in quality of care
2025-06-25
Introducing performance related pay for UK general practices initially improved quality of care, but did not seem to provide lasting improvements beyond that expected by previous trends, finds a study published by The BMJ today.
And initial gains in quality seemed to reverse when financial incentives were withdrawn, say the researchers.
The UK Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) pay-for-performance programme was introduced across the NHS in 2004 to reward general practices for providing high quality care across a range of disease indicators ...
Focusing on weight loss alone for obesity may do more harm than good
2025-06-25
Focusing solely on achieving weight loss for people with a high body mass index (BMI) may do more harm than good, argue experts in The BMJ today.
Dr Juan Franco and colleagues say, on average, people with high weight will not be able to sustain a clinically relevant weight loss with lifestyle interventions, while the potential harms of weight loss interventions, including the reinforcement of weight stigma, are still unclear.
They stress that a healthy lifestyle has important benefits, but that weight alone might not give an adequate picture of someone’s health, and say doctors should provide high quality, evidence based care reflecting individual preferences ...
In sub-Saharan Africa, 1 in 6 cancer medications found to be defective
2025-06-25
Serious quality defects were found in a significant number of cancer medications from sub-Saharan Africa, according to new research from the University of Notre Dame.
For the study published in The Lancet Global Health, researchers collected different cancer medications from Cameroon, Ethiopia, Kenya and Malawi and evaluated whether each drug met regulatory standards. Researchers considered a variety of factors, including appearance, packaging, labeling and, most importantly, the assay value.
The assay value is the quantity of active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) found in each drug. To meet safety standards, most products should be within a ...
Newborns require better care to improve survival and long-term health
2025-06-25
More effective platforms for drug and medical device development and better cross sector engagement are urgently required to prevent the ‘unacceptably high’ newborn death rate, according to a global report.
The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health Commission on the future of neonatology report found this field of medicine faced significant challenges across leadership, collaboration, regulation and funding, which were hindering better health outcomes for newborns.
The Lancet Commission was created to consider these challenges and design a roadmap to accelerate research and development ...
EMBARGOED: New study shows almost half of hospital patients in Malawi and Tanzania have multiple health conditions
2025-06-25
The Multilink Consortium, a NIHR-funded partnership between the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, the Malawi-Liverpool-Wellcome Programme, Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences and Kilimanjaro Christian Medical University College, has published the first-of-its-kind research in sub-Saharan Africa to examine the scale and impact of ‘multimorbidity’ in patients admitted acutely to hospital. Multimorbidity refers to the presence of two or more chronic diseases.
Researchers discovered that of 1007 ...
People with symptoms of chronic lung disease in Kenya face ‘catastrophic’ health costs
2025-06-25
A quarter of people seeking care for symptoms of chronic respiratory diseases in Kenya may incur ‘catastrophic’ health costs, new research published in The Lancet Global Health has found.
A study of almost 300 adults accessing treatment for respiratory symptoms across five health facilities in Meru County, Kenya, found that over a quarter (26%) had ‘catastrophic health expenditure’ (CHE, defined as over 10% of their household’s monthly outgoings) relating to their illness and seeking care.
The severe economic burden included ...
Sylvester Cancer Tip Sheet - June 2025
2025-06-25
JUNE 2025 TIP SHEET
Alcohol & Cancer
Sobering Truth: Alcohol-Fueled Cancer Deaths Rising Across U.S. (Video Available)
Sylvester researchers have become the first to look at trends in alcohol-linked cancer mortality across the U.S. Their findings, presented last month at ASCO 2025, found that alcohol-related cancer deaths nationwide nearly doubled between 1990 and 2021. Moreover, the highest burden fell on men over 55, whose alcohol-linked cancer mortality rose by more than 1% a year between 2007 and 2021. “That’s a big and concerning rise,” said Chinmay Jani, M.D., Sylvester hematology and oncology ...
UC Davis and Proteus Space to launch first-ever dynamic digital twin into space
2025-06-25
The Center for Space Exploration Research at the University of California, Davis, has partnered with Proteus Space to launch a US government-sponsored satellite into space with a custom AI-enabled payload in a brand-new, first-ever rapid design-to-deployment small satellite.
The team will launch the satellite and payload in October 2025 from Vanderberg, CA. From the time the project was fully approved, the design and launch will occur within an unprecedented 13 months. (The normal pace for small satellites is often measured in years.)
The UC Davis-designed ...