Standardizing frailty indexes to improve preclinical aging research
“We recommend that investigators carefully consider what aspects of frailty to include in their analyses instead of fully adopting the published scoring systems.”
2025-10-03
(Press-News.org)
“We recommend that investigators carefully consider what aspects of frailty to include in their analyses instead of fully adopting the published scoring systems.”
BUFFALO, NY — October 3, 2025 — A new research perspective was published in Volume 17, Issue 9 of Aging-US on August 26, 2025, titled “Analysis of the current state of frailty indexes and their implementation for aging intervention studies.”
In this work, led by first author Oliver G. Frost from Loughborough University alongside corresponding authors Abdelhadi Rebbaa and Amit Sharma, from the Lifespan Research Institute, the authors explore growing concerns about the lack of standardization in how frailty is measured in rodent aging studies, which may limit the development of effective interventions targeting age-related decline.
Frailty, a key indicator of deteriorating health in older adults, is increasingly assessed in preclinical models using frailty indexes (FIs). These indexes quantify health deficits, such as reduced mobility, cognitive decline, or physical weakness. However, this perspective highlights that FI methodologies vary significantly across studies, from the selection of parameters to the cut-off thresholds used, resulting in inconsistent outcomes that affects reproducibility and translational value.
The authors reviewed 18 rodent studies and found substantial variation in how frailty is defined and measured. Some FIs rely on clinical observations, such as appearance or beahaviour, while others focus on physical performance metrics like grip strength or locomotion. In several cases, applying different FIs to the same group of animals produced contradictory results, underscoring the importance of harmonized protocols.
To illustrate these issues, the researchers applied an 8-item FI to mice of different ages and found that even young mice were sometimes scored as frail, depending on the scoring method and reference values. This finding emphasizes the need for consistent baselines and controlled environments, especially when comparing across studies. The authors recommend using each animal as its own baseline in longitudinal studies, a strategy that enhances reliability without adding significant cost.
“Sex as a biological variable in FIs is an important consideration, as there is a known difference between male and female frailty onset and progression.”
The authors also discuss emerging automated tools, such as video-based open-field testing, which can reduce observer bias and improve reproducibility. In the future, broader health indicators, such as cognition, circadian rhythms, social behavior, and body composition, may further enhance frailty assessments.
Overall, this work underscores the urgent need for standardized, transparent, and reproducible methods for evaluating frailty in preclinical aging studies. Improved consistency in frailty scoring will better inform the development of healthspan-extending therapies and enhance the translational relevance of animal models.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.18632/aging.206307
Corresponding authors: Abdelhadi Rebbaa — rebbaa@gmail.com; Amit Sharma — amit.sharma@sens.org
Keywords: aging, frailty, rodents, frailty index, phenotype
Click here to sign up for free Altmetric alerts about this article.
______
To learn more about the journal, please visit our website at www.Aging-US.com and connect with us on social media at:
Facebook
X
Instagram
YouTube
LinkedIn
Reddit
Bluesky
Pinterest
Spotify, and available wherever you listen to podcasts
Click here to subscribe to Aging publication updates.
For media inquiries, please contact media@impactjournals.com.
END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2025-10-03
Fuel cells are an efficient, clean alternative to traditional fossil-fuel-based energy systems. Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) are especially attractive due to their ability to use multiple fuels, high efficiency and reversibility. Cobalt (Co)-doped rare-earth layered perovskite oxides are attractive cathode materials for low- and medium-temperature SOFCs. They offer excellent electrochemical performance, owing to their high oxygen content and flexible control of oxygen transport.
Yet, electrodes made from these materials demonstrate low long-term stability. Key strategies to ...
2025-10-03
The COVID-19 pandemic affected people worldwide disproportionately, with economically disadvantaged households facing a heavier burden. Children were also affected since schools and classes were closed to contain the virus. Many students, especially from disadvantaged backgrounds, lost their learning environments, and their academic performance suffered. However, the pandemic presented other challenges that may have also affected students, such as parents losing jobs, financial stress at home, and parents not having the option to work from home. So, it is unclear how ...
2025-10-03
Children entering school from culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) families are more likely to face developmental challenges than their peers, according to a large population-based study in Western Australia. Researchers found that nearly one in four CALD children displayed vulnerabilities in at least one key developmental domain, with communication skills and general knowledge showing the largest gaps. These difficulties go beyond the classroom, shaping social integration, self-confidence, and long-term educational opportunities. ...
2025-10-03
The first successful human transplant of a kidney converted from blood type A to universal type O used special enzymes developed at the University of British Columbia to help prevent a mismatch and rejection of the organ.
Published today in Nature Biomedical Engineering, the achievement marks a major step toward helping thousands of patients get kidney transplants sooner.
In a first-in-human experiment, the enzyme-converted kidney was transplanted into a brain-dead recipient with consent from the family, allowing researchers ...
2025-10-03
ITHACA, N.Y. – Birds separated by vast geographic distances and millions of years of evolution share a remarkably similar learned vocal warning to identify parasitic enemies near their nests, an international team of researchers has found.
The results represent the first known example of an animal vocalization that is learned from an innate response shared across multiple species.
The findings, which will publish October 3, 2025 at 5am EST in Nature Ecology and Evolution, provide a glimpse into the role natural ...
2025-10-03
The world’s first vaccine trial against elephant endotheliotropic herpesvirus (EEHV) – a leading cause of death in young Asian elephants – is safe and triggers a strong virus-fighting immune response, according to an international team led by the University of Surrey, in collaboration with Chester Zoo and the Animal and Plant Health Agency.
Published in Nature Communications, the proof‑of‑concept study involved adult elephants at Chester Zoo. No side effects were seen, and the vaccine successfully activated a key part of the immune system that helps fight viruses.
The elephants received a two‑step vaccination: first, a viral vector ...
2025-10-03
Iridoids are a widespread and evolutionarily ancient class of plant secondary metabolites belonging to the terpenes. They occur in thousands of plant species and play an important role in defense and other interactions between plants and their environment. Iridoids are also found in foods such as olives and blueberries, and are believed to have anti-inflammatory properties. They are also essential precursors for many medically important compounds, including the cancer drug vinblastine and the ipecacuanha alkaloids found in the medicinal plants, sage-leaved alangium and ipecac root (see press release Two plant species invent the same ...
2025-10-03
Study highlights:
The new antibiotic, enterololin, attacks and kills only a specific group of disease-causing bugs, which includes the type of E. coli that drives Crohn’s disease.
As such, the antibiotic is a promising new treatment option for people affected by Crohn’s and other IBD-related conditions. These conditions affect thousands of people across Canada and no cure currently exists.
Most antibiotics wipe out everything, including good bacteria. Enterololin, however, works like a scalpel, reducing the opportunity for opportunistic and/or drug-resistant ...
2025-10-03
October 3, 2025—BRONX, NY—Scientists at Montefiore Einstein Comprehensive Cancer Center (MECCC) and Albert Einstein College of Medicine have shown for the first time that glioblastoma—the deadliest form of brain cancer—affects not just the brain but also erodes the skull, alters the makeup of skull marrow, and interferes with the body’s immune response. Drugs intended to inhibit skull-bone loss made the cancer more aggressive, according to results published today in Nature Neuroscience.
“Our discovery that this notoriously hard-to-treat brain cancer interacts with the body’s immune ...
2025-10-03
In the realm of memories, “where” holds special importance. Where did I leave my keys? Where did I eat dinner last night? Where did I first meet that friend? Recalling locations is necessary for daily life, yet spatial memory — which keeps track of “where” — is one of the first cognitive abilities to fade in old age. And deficits earlier in life can be a telltale sign of dementia.
Now, researchers at Stanford Medicine and their colleagues are uncovering what goes awry in older brains when spatial memory falters and whether these changes can be prevented.
In a new study comparing young, ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Standardizing frailty indexes to improve preclinical aging research
“We recommend that investigators carefully consider what aspects of frailty to include in their analyses instead of fully adopting the published scoring systems.”
