PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Minnesota Court Decision Leaves Construction Company Unpaid for Completed Work

When a developer goes bankrupt, a subcontractor may not necessarily receive full payment from a city for completed work on public improvements.

2011-02-02
February 02, 2011 (Press-News.org) A recent decision from the Minnesota Court of Appeals has held that a construction company may not receive full payment from a city for the company's work on a completed construction project. The dispute arose out of a failed residential subdivision project, a scenario likely to be repeated in the wake of the housing boom and bust. The decision therefore may have important implications for construction law and commercial real estate.

Development Agreement

In early 2007, Percheron Properties, a developer, received approval from the City of Avon, Minnesota, to build a new housing subdivision. Percheron owned the land on which the subdivision was to take place. As a part of the project, the City of Avon was responsible for public improvements such as water and sewer extensions, streets, and sidewalks. Percheron agreed that special assessments would be assessed against the property to finance the public improvements, that Percheron would pay the assessments as they came due, and that Percheron would post collateral equal to 50% of the total cost of the improvements to secure its obligation to pay the assessments as they came due.

Nodland Construction submitted the winning bid, of approximately $4.5 million, to complete the public improvements for the City of Avon. The contract between Nodland and the City of Avon stated that the city would retain five percent of its progress payments until final acceptance of Nodland's work. However, because Percheron could not provide the required collateral to secure future payment of the special assessments, the entire project was in danger of being cancelled, including Nodland's contract. As a result, Nodland entered into a separate agreement to allow the retainage to be increased from 5% to 10%, with the 10% retainage being treated as security for the assessments.

However, there was a disagreement between the various contract documents as to how the additional 5% retainage was to be handled. The development agreement stated that if Nodland challenged the City of Avon's right to use the retained funds as assessment security, "this form of security shall no longer be approved" and Percheron must immediately substitute other security.

Completed Construction

Nodland completed its work on the project, and the work was approved by the City of Avon. In January 2009, Nodland requested final payment, including the 10% retained amount. However, while the project was progressing, Percheron had experienced financial difficulties (due, at least in part, to the decline in real estate values between planning of the project and inception of construction), and had fallen behind in its payments of the special assessments to the City of Avon. As a result, the City of Avon refused to turn over the 10% retainage to Nodland.

In response, Nodland objected to and challenged the City of Avon's use of the retained amount as assessment security. The City of Avon then demanded that Percheron provide substitute security, but Percheron failed to do so.

Percheron ultimately went out of business. As a result, Nodland essentially was left paying for assessments owed to the City of Avon by Percheron.

Nodland ultimately sued the City of Avon to compel release of the retainage. Nodland was successful at the trial court level. The City of Avon appealed that result.

Court of Appeals Decision

The Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed the trial court, holding that the City of Avon could treat the retainage as an absolute guaranty by Nodland of Percheron's obligations to pay the special assessments. If Percheron were to provide substitute security, the City of Avon would then have to release the retainage. But because Percheron had defaulted, the City was not obligated to release the retainage to Nodland. And, as a result, while Nodland may have a claim against Percheron for default, Nodland could not recover against the City of Avon.

The Court of Appeals thus directed Nodland to seek damages from Percheron, not the City of Avon. But Percheron is out of business, and Nodland has little or no chance of ever recovering any money from Percheron. Thus, even though Nodland performed its work properly, it could suffer a loss of more than $450,000 on the project.

Implications of the Decision

The dispute between Nodland and the City of Avon highlights the risks associated with large development projects, and especially with municipal projects. The insolvency of Percheron has led to large losses by both the City of Avon and Nodland, innocent parties to the development. The City of Avon may be able to recover some or most of its special assessments from future purchasers of property in the subdivision, but it is unlikely that Nodland will ever be paid any of its retainage. The specific "moral" of the story may be to beware of ever guaranteeing or securing payments by another party. But the larger lesson to be taken away from Nodland's misfortune is that one should always make certain that all important contracts are reviewed by counsel before execution.

If you are involved in a real estate development dispute, contact an attorney experienced in construction law and business litigation to discuss your legal options.

Article provided by Patrick Burns & Associates
Visit us at www.patrickburnslaw.com


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

NHTSA Study Reveals Effectiveness of Antilock Brake Technology

2011-02-02
Because they weigh up to 80,000 pounds, when tractor trailers and other heavy trucks are involved in accidents, the consequences are likely to be serious. Any actions that help to reduce the number of truck accidents will help improve the overall safety of the roads and reduce the frequency of serious injuries. In an effort to reduce truck accidents, federal regulations have required all newly manufactured semi-trailers and trucks to have Antilock Braking Systems (ABS) since 1998. However, it was not clear how effective this requirement had been in reducing truck accidents ...

Safety Concerns of Government Planes and Helicopters

2011-02-02
Most would think government aircraft are some of the safest in the country. As it turns out, this is likely not the case. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) said the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which regulates airlines, lacks the authority to regulate the safety of aircraft operated by state and local governments or other federal agencies. The NTSB chairman, Deborah Hersman, said such aircraft are safety "orphans" with no body responsible for their safety. Tragic Accident The NTSB made its stunning finding after recently completing its investigation ...

Sharing the Road: Tips to Stay Safe on North Carolina Highways

2011-02-02
The number of motorcycle riders has increased in recent years and it is easy to see why: motorcycles are fun to ride, less expensive than cars and more fuel efficient. Unfortunately, riding a motorcycle can also be a risky activity, particularly on crowded highways. According to recent statistics, when an accident occurs, motorcyclists are three times more likely to be injured and five times more likely to be killed than those driving automobiles. If you have been injured or have lost a loved one in a motorcycle accident, contact a North Carolina motorcycle accident attorney ...

Atlanta Moving Company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Highlights Flexibility During Moving Off-Season

Atlanta Moving Company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Highlights Flexibility During Moving Off-Season
2011-02-02
Atlanta moving company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage recognizes the benefits for potential movers during the wintertime, the off-season for moving companies. The flexibility afforded by moving over the winter is an attractive alternative for many over the busier summertime months. When most families choose a time to move, school schedules play a major factor. Moving during the summer avoids the hassle of removing children from school, and the summertime is often more conducive to taking time off from work as well. Because the summer is the peak season for the moving ...

Smyrna Georgia Hotel Near Cobb Energy Performing Arts Centre Provides Accommodations to Fans at Clay Aiken in Concert

2011-02-02
Hampton Inn & Suites Atlanta Galleria Hotel, an affordable Smyrna Georgia hotel, is the perfect place for fan to stay who are traveling in town for Clay Aiken's Tried & True Tour. Aiken will take the stage at Cobb Performing Arts Centre at 8:00pm on February 16, 2011. He will perform songs off his newest and fifth studio album, "Tried & True," featuring classic songs including "Unchained Melody," "Suspicious Minds," "Can't Take My Eye's Off You," and "Mack the Knife". First made famous in 2003 on the hit TV show American Idol where he was runner up, Clay Aiken is a singer, ...

Monroe North Carolina Hotel Offers Lodging to Upcoming Musical Production at Wingate University

Monroe North Carolina Hotel Offers Lodging to Upcoming Musical Production at Wingate University
2011-02-02
Super 8 Monroe North Carolina Hotel offers affordable accommodations to families and friends attending Wingate University's upcoming musical production of 'Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very bad Day'. The play will take place 7:00pm on February 11 and at 3:00pm on February 12, 2011. Wingate University, which is a private residential liberal arts university, is only 5 miles of this Monroe NC hotel. The musical 'Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very bad Day' is based on the 1972 children's book. In the story Alexander wakes up with gum in ...

Gaffney Hotel Near Limestone College Offers Lodging to Guests Attending the Theatre Production of 'Almost, Maine'

2011-02-02
Hampton Inn Gaffney Hotel offers convenient lodging to guests attending Limestone College's theater production of 'Almost, Maine.' The show will be held February 24 through 26, 2011 at Limestone Theatre Center. Limestone College, a four year Christian, non-denominational college, is located only miles from this Gaffney South Carolina hotel. Almost, Maine is an American comedy that tells the story of couples that fall in and out of love. It is comprised of nearly a dozen two-character vignettes that explore the joys and perils of romance. The story takes place on a star-filled ...

Atlanta Perimeter Hotel Offers Nearby Lodging to the Theatre Production of Peter Pan at Pemberton Place

Atlanta Perimeter Hotel Offers Nearby Lodging to the Theatre Production of Peter Pan at Pemberton Place
2011-02-02
ATLANTA, GA, February 02, 2011 /24-7PressRelease/ -- Holiday Inn Express & Suites Atlanta Perimeter Hotel (North) near Dunwoody, GA offers convenient accommodations to guests attending the production of JM Barrie's Peter Pan. The show will take place Pemberton Place. Located adjacent to World of Coca Cola in downtown Atlanta, Pemberton Place is a state-of-the-art circular theatre tent constructed to reach 100 feet high and providing over 1200 tiered seats. Atlanta audiences can enjoy Peter Pan, which is playing now through March 20, 2011. This production tells the classic ...

Hartsfield Hotel Announces Offering Guests 20% Savings on Rates with Any Weekend Stay

2011-02-02
The Hampton Inn & Suites Atlanta Airport Hotel (North, I-85) is offering 20% savings on Best Available Rates to guests. Now through December 31, 2011 if travelers book any weekend (at any participating Hampton Inn property) they will receive this special savings. As always, guest accommodations include: - Free hot continental breakfast - Complimentary high-speed Internet access - Clean and fresh Hampton bed TM "Perfect for business and leisure travelers, the Hampton Inn & Suites is the ideal place to stay in the area," explain Kelli-Ann Gordon, the Atl Airport hotel's ...

Amusement Management Partners (AMP) Announces Steve Honeycutt as General Manager of Magic Springs

2011-02-02
Amusement Management Partners LLC (AMP) announced today that Steve Honeycutt has joined the team as General Manager of Magic Springs & Crystal Falls in Hot Springs, AR. A theme park industry veteran with more than 34 years experience, Steve joins the Magic Springs team from Elitch Gardens theme park where he served as General Manager. Previously, Honeycutt worked for industry leading operators, including; Kings Entertainment, Anheuser-Busch, and Hershend Family Entertainment Group. "Steve Honeycutt brings a solid history of management, especially in the area of park ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Scientists unlock secrets behind flowering of the king of fruits

Texas A&M researchers illuminate the mysteries of icy ocean worlds

Prosthetic material could help reduce infections from intravenous catheters

Can the heart heal itself? New study says it can

Microscopic discovery in cancer cells could have a big impact

Rice researchers take ‘significant leap forward’ with quantum simulation of molecular electron transfer

Breakthrough new material brings affordable, sustainable future within grasp

How everyday activities inside your home can generate energy

Inequality weakens local governance and public satisfaction, study finds

Uncovering key molecular factors behind malaria’s deadliest strain

UC Davis researchers help decode the cause of aggressive breast cancer in women of color

Researchers discovered replication hubs for human norovirus

SNU researchers develop the world’s most sensitive flexible strain sensor

Tiny, wireless antennas use light to monitor cellular communication

Neutrality has played a pivotal, but under-examined, role in international relations, new research shows

Study reveals right whales live 130 years — or more

Researchers reveal how human eyelashes promote water drainage

Pollinators most vulnerable to rising global temperatures are flies, study shows

DFG to fund eight new research units

Modern AI systems have achieved Turing's vision, but not exactly how he hoped

Quantum walk computing unlocks new potential in quantum science and technology

Construction materials and household items are a part of a long-term carbon sink called the “technosphere”

First demonstration of quantum teleportation over busy Internet cables

Disparities and gaps in breast cancer screening for women ages 40 to 49

US tobacco 21 policies and potential mortality reductions by state

AI-driven approach reveals hidden hazards of chemical mixtures in rivers

Older age linked to increased complications after breast reconstruction

ESA and NASA satellites deliver first joint picture of Greenland Ice Sheet melting

Early detection model for pancreatic necrosis improves patient outcomes

Poor vascular health accelerates brain ageing

[Press-News.org] Minnesota Court Decision Leaves Construction Company Unpaid for Completed Work
When a developer goes bankrupt, a subcontractor may not necessarily receive full payment from a city for completed work on public improvements.